Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2026 DAILYLAW 9394 (PNJ)
SAT NARAIN v. K V MULTI HEALTHPEX PVT LTD AND OTHERS
RSA/2809/2025 · 2026-01-29
Virinder Aggarwal
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 9394 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 9394 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!" # $%&'&'( )* $+ !$%$,%- .
%*'&'( /0$)# # $%1''( ! "#$ %%%% 1 2 3 ' 4 53 # &' ## $( )$ * ( )( +" ( )( ( ) ++ ( ) , * ( ) ++ ( ) , -( )$ - ( ) , ./) %%%% GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 4 ) ! #5 # 6 ) , & ) # ) 7, & , 8 9:() #, 5 ),) #5 - ) 55 ' , ( ) , 5# 6 #5 ) ( ) , ) , 6 ) ( & # , ) ) ' , 6 ) ) 5'( , 5 ' # ( ) ,, ) )' ) , ) , & (,)5 , , ) & ) ,' ) , 5 ) ,& ( 5 ) 5()) ( ) )) ,5 ,); )5' ,, (,) ) ) ' ) ,) , , 6 )
, 5 ( #) 5 , 5 & , 5 < 4 / , & ) , # 5# 6 #5 ) &' * . 4 # ) 7, & , 8 9:& &' , = 0 5# 6 #5 ) 32. 2 3 &' > )( $ &', # , * $ ? )',, 5 4 * ( 6 #5 ) 2 2 &' * ! #(7! > :( ( ) &' / ,, GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 + # ) ' ) #$ ) ? , ) , 5 6 ) 4 $ ) # ) ) , # ,& * & $& ##' & ,)' 3 4 & &' ,,+ # ) , ) ) ? ,( #6 #5 ) . 22@( &' ## $( * ! #(! > ( ( $ ' ( #( & ( ( , ( & # # ,
,, 4 ,,+ ) ,,) 6 #5 ) & & # 5 3 A ( ,, ', ) =@00( ' ) ) 21 22&' * ) B,, ) ( & 5# 6 #5 ) , . 22@( +$ #( & ( , )& # # , ,,( & & C ( ,, + ) , 5 6 ) # , ( # ( # ( ' ) 5 # 5, 5 #(5 ## #( , #( #( $ )5& # ) & # , (&' , ' # $ #, # =@00 = )) )' () , ,, !"# GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 $ %%&' "# ( ) * !$+, ' '
!"# -. / / $!&! $! 01 $002 * !!% ' 34 5 6 / 1,$ $0 0 $00! 7 8 + 5 ,1$ $1 $ $00, * ,!, 2 / +,0+ 0% 0 $00,
* ,!21 5 ,1$& $1 $ $00,
* ,!,, 9 ( : / +0;%1 ' ( 9 . ( $+ $ $00% : / +0;%1 ) ' / 7 ( ( '- $ "< / ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
'( ' !
" # ( =7 :6> / ? ( 4 ' ( ( ( ( ' ? ) @ ) . 7 ( ' A 0 D ) ,55 ( , 3, ) $ ) ? ' ) #
323 2 $ 5 $( $ (, &, , , = @) ) 5 , ,,($ ) ' (' B ' , & 7 ' $ %%& ' "# '. ' : / *3 : "
" / .
( $+ $ $00% ' 0+ 0+ %%1 7 ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
' ' ( / !$
'311$ 9 ' B' 7 ' ' 9' -.
' ( ( ( ( ( , & ' ( ' (' ' '"# ( ' ' ' ' ' 9' ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 ' ' C A 1 C ) ( ,, , ) $ 5 &5 &' , = 0( $ 5 , $ ? )' ,, 5 ($ ( ( &6) 5& $ 5 $ )# )' D 5 ) ) , #) ) ( * 5 ( , , '( ) ( #' ) 6 ) ( ) ' E5 ) ' )) #', 5 , $ #
. ( D $+ $ $00% ' / * 3 : "
" / ' C ( EF
$ ( . ( ( ( ' EF
2 ( (EF
+ E F
!
'( EF
GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
, (C. C . EF
& ( ( EF
1 - @ D ) ' E , (& $ )) ,( , ( 5 #, ' ) ) & , ) # A $ # , ') ) ) ,
) ( 4 * ) ) , ,
F ,,( ) # , $ #, # 9 ( ' : ' ( ( : 7 ' (G . ( $+ $ $00% ' / * 3 : "
" / ' 7 0! 0, $00 ' 3 : 3 '( ,%&& . ( $+ $ $00% .
C ' = ( & ' ( ( ( ( ' ' ( ,%&& A GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
@ 46 #5 ) &' 4 * ( & #)
()5 &,, 5 &' A * 4, 5( ) )
, #( )( #5 ( 5 F , G ) ( & # 9 . ' : 3 :9/;:3;0%$0$2 / #H* 4 6 F A:9/;:3;,$0$2 "< #H* 4 6 F A ' ( ( .
( ' : ' ( ' ( ' ' '( A @ # ) )
, #( & ,) #(
&' * & $( & #5 ,' , $ 6 ) ( + )
) '6 ) , * &' # 2 4 $ + 6 ) , * # ) #( ' # ) # ) )
6 #5 ) &' * & $ D 5 '5 ($, 5 $
# ) 5 H )) #'( $ + GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
.
&' , # ) &5 4( , (& 5 6 ) & , #5 ) &' )
# ) 2 C ) #(6 ) ( ,' , 5 6 ) , ? # , 5 ( * ) 5 ), ) 5 ) ,* & $ ( $ ) $ '
? ( 5& &6) 5 ) ( )( ) #) ' & )) (,,) ( #' , C ) , ) & # & $ #,) &5 (+ # $ # , ( ' 5 & # ) ( ) )
, # &' * & $4 ) & &6) 5 ) ) 5 ) ' , , 5 # I ( . ( ('. ( '( ' (' . ' .
GJ # ) ,) ( $ ,$ 6& ' () , & ) . , 6&* )( @1 ) 22** , ) # ) &5 6 #5 , 5* ) , GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 !"#$$ % #&'( , $ &'6 #5 ) ,( !"#) ## % *#' % % !"!!#! % )! ' # $ $ , 6 #5 ( ? ,$ ? & , 5 < C #) ) , #( ) , ) ( $ ) &5 ( * & $# ' )) # F ,, , ) , ($ $ ' + # , ) )5 ) 5# , ) $ ,,) # )' , ) ( , ( ? ' ) &' ) , C # # $ ) 5 , &( ' 5 #& ) , # &' &' ) 3 ,4 , , ')( , ( ) , & , ) ()? # # , , 5 ,'& &' 5 6 ) < C , ) & * & $) 55 5 , , 5 #6 #5 ) . 22@ 5 # 232= 22 )) # ) ())
) 5) , &' ! $ 5 $ $ ( # ) ( ) ? '( # ) $ , ) ,5 # C GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 6 #5 ) . 22@($ &'; &'! $ ) #( ( ( &' , ' < ) , &5 * & $ # $ ) ) & + , & $K 5 #($ ) ) #( ' , $ &(5) & ' )) , 5 '$ $( ? 5 ) ) '& , 5 , # C # ) . 22@( # , ' & #& # ! () & ) ') # 5 &? ) # &' ,,($ 5 ' ,! ) ) 5 #4( # * & $ # ) # $ )( ,,)( 5 5 5 &) )+ ) # , ' << B 5 ( 5 ' ) 5# 6 #5 ) ,, ,
5 , 5 ,$ # ( , ( & ( 5 $ ) . C &( ) , ) ) , # &'* & $ 5 # &(#' &( , ) ) ) ) , ) C ) & * ($ 6 , ) ( , & ) , & ) ( )) & ( GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 $ F ) ' , 5 # # #, 5 $,' F ,, . 4 , ,' &5 ( ) ) ) )5 , G& 5* + ,, - . +/ 0 1 / / !"## # % 2!" 3 +/ ( . !"#2 2 % #)$( $ ) , ( ) # ,& , ) ( & #) ) , , ) & )) )' B # , ) # &'* & $( # ,5 # 5 ($ 5# 6 #5 ) $ #,, 5 4 A * (
5 ) , ) #() 5 '5 , F ,, ) , & ) 4 * G , # # ( ) # == =1 , 5# 6 #5 ( ) , $ ,, ( 9; ( (/ % 5 3 = 9 ' 5 9 ,& 9 ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 3 ' ,& I ' 9 J 7 ( !7 ( = ( '( J '
' B ! 3 ' ,1 6 : C ,& / -. ' 3( '/ -. 9 ' = ( ' ' B 7 ' +0 %%1 A C 5 ,) , , , ,,$ ,,) # )' , # C ) ( G& * ( ) , 4 GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
- +/ . % !"!2 51 % !!$'( , $ $ F ' C$ ' / + 311$ .
A A ( % % +/
% 5 !"!2 2
+ &&*(* & 96 % +/ !""7 ' % #22: ' 9 1 D$2G #7/< CC '< (' /
1!& ?D"!,,++5-1+$K 6 : 6 : ( (B 7 ' (' ( 9 ' ( !*/ 9 ' ' '( L L ' ( ' . C( L6 L GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
' - 0$ ' 9 ' .
( C B - %1 00 F $ A ) , ,,, ) ' & # 6 #5 , G& * # , ) & ) # E & , ) , ) C & ) , ' ) ( , # ) &'* & $ , , ,, & , ) , ) 5 ,' &() ' ) ,$( )) #' A * , & , 5 # $ # , ,,C$ ! ( ) , ,,( , ) # 6 #5 ) K.( $ ) $ &? ' 5 $ $ ) 5 5 &$ ( 5' , 3 , = 0C 5 , ) 5 5 ( , = 0 '# ' ) 5 ) #, 5 ) &'! 1 4 * ( ) ( & , (&' ) )( ? )' ? GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 ') 5 ) ) &'! ( &'(
' &' ) ' 5 ) ( )+ $ # ## ' ' , ) # $ ) ,,)? #( ( ' C , ! ( #$ $ #6 #5 K.( ) 5 5 ) $ & ( # 5 ,) > # )' ,) # (! , ' ,,C ) ($ $ ( , #$ )) )$ ) 1 , )) )! , , ($ )( # ) ()5 ) 5 5 $ &' ' ) '$ ) 5 ' , ) # ) )) # # 6 ) 4 ) )(&' ) ' 5 ) (,, 5 ' # ' , ) # ) &'! , , ,, 1 * ? '( #& & # ,! ( $ ! #$ $ & ,5 5 &'! "#$ ( , 5 ) # #( ' , 5( # '( '( , )& ' , ) # ) &'! ))
, , ,, GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 @ ) , ,,&5 ) ) ) &' A * , ) ' ( ,) #) ) ) ,,) ) )5 ) ,)) ) ) )," !6 $++ !)# ! 7 )%8)0$! ,/!)($ G& * ' ) & 5 5 ) ( 8& $ ) (9 & & 5 '( , ) ) , $ 2+ 3 ' ( LLL LL L B' ' ' ' ( ' 7 ' ( (
H 3(( < /(-:9 H*- = (* * /-: <- * / +
- * < (4< -( 9 /, : 6 - ( : < D: -( : /B HB ( : ( F: *: % 2!
' 7 7 ' <' (' ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 ' B ( A @ ) , ) ( $ ( # <3 <0( ) , & & ' &5 A * ) )') ) , 5) # ## ' ' , ) # ) &'! )) @ B () , ) , # ) &' A * $ ) 5 ) 5 5 ) , ,! # ! 5 '$ $ ( 6 #5 K. &' * ! # , '( $ &'; ) &' #$ ( # , ? ( &' # ! ' , ( ) ? )( # , , ,, ' C$, ) ( B <( , * ,* ) () 5 5 ) ) '& & ,$ ) 5 5 H5 $ $ , ( &5 ( )
& 5 , ) & ) # # ') 5 5 ) C ( ) $) # , G&* .8 9 + 0 % / +/ 5 5 GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 !"#* * + 2*&($ G& * , $ 2, - F $2 B ( ( - F $2 ' ( ( : ( .
(
( : - 2 F $2 B ( ( - 2F $2 ( ( ( ( ( ' %&,( ( : : 7 ' - ( ( - 2 ( ( ( - 2 ( I 2& 9 -. /$00,
2-:-
: +&%G$00,
$-:-
- !0G$00&
+- 3
" (
- 3 " +1G
$00,!/::!,, GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
L - 2E ( ( ( ' ( ( ( . ' ' ( ( ( ' ( ( ;( ( ( ' (( .
'( ( ( ( ' (F ( (' '' ( ( ( 9 ' ( 7 I . ( ( 7 ' ( 9 ( 21 = . ( ' ( ( ( ' 7 ( ' ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
012 2 3
.
C( A ! " ! # = ( ( ( ( ( ' 7 : 9 ( ( ( ( ( 9 ' ( 7 5 7 ( : A @. C )( $ ) 5 5 $) &$ ( ' + # $5 5 &' ! "#$ ( # ) )5 )) , 5 6 #5 4 G& * ) ' ( & ) , $ ) 5 5 ( ) B <( < , * , * ) ) ) ) C 5 ( ) $ & ,5 5 &' H ( , &' ! $ 5 ' 5 & $ $ * ? '( & ) , ' ) ( ? , '5 # &$ 6 #5 ) ,* * ) A $ #$ $ ,( GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 6 #5 ) &' *
! #5& 5 , ' @3 45 $ ) , ! "#$ ' ) '$ ) 5 ' ) , ' &'! "' , ? ) 5 ( ! "#$ + ') 5 ) ($ )( &5 , ,,(5 )+ $ #5 , ' , , , , , ,,&'! ) 55 5 ) #5 2 ) , ( $ () 5 5 &'! "#$ 5 ' ,) + # ) 5 ' ) , ) ) &'! ( ( ,() ' )+ $ #5 , ' , ) ; &, , $&5 ( ,5 5 ) ( &' ' ? # ) 5 ' , ) ( ( &' ) ' 5 ) ( ) # E ' # , ) ,,) , , ,,* ?
'(&' , ) , (' ) , 5) # # # ' ' , , 2 ) , , # 5 #(, + , #5 ( ) , )&( $ $ ) & $C )( , &' ,,+ ) GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 6 #5 ) . 22@ &' * ! #( ( ( #& ( $ ) # , ,,( & & 4 ,, + ) =@00( ) 6 #5 ) ( #( ( ,,) # #( # $ ) ? ,&'$' , 5 6 ) # , , 5 # 2 C $ ) ( # ( ,, ( )() # #6 #5 ) &'* ,) 5 6 ) $ ) , ' &$ " #)) ( ,, & &' ) , C , ) ) , ) $ $ $ &' G&* ( +/ : 0 6+ !"!!
+ 3 % &&*($ * , $ ' < .
( ' < 9 ( ' ' 5 : ' 7 A C ),'&5 ( ( 6 #5 ) 5 & ) # ' $' ) )5) & # ( 5' , ( 5 ( ) ) ( && GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 )) 4 ,$ ' ,, 5 &' * +/ 0 % : : / !"!$;00 ;""))2) ( # &' F ,, 5 & $ ) ( ) #, F ,, '5 &() # ) 5 ,, &' # )' , # , 6 #5 ) 5# ) #($ ? )' + ) 5 ) ' ) , ' &' ! C ) )) )5 5 5 ,# ' ' , ) &'! # )' , ) #( &' # # , 5&? ' # # '* ? '( &5 F ,, ,') 5 5 C , $
&' ,,# 5E (55 (5 '(5 ( ! ( ( ! "#$ ( C>*( >B( D (+ # 6 #5 ) . 22@ &' * ! #( ( ) , &'! "#$ ( & # #( ( & # ,, < "' $' , ( ! "#$ # ) ,,) ; @@0( ' GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 ) , , , (! ($ & # # , , ( $ & ,, , ? )) )$ $ , )) 4 $) &' ! (& , ) ' ; ($ , < =( 5'55 5E ($ ) # >, 5 ) 5 , ,,($ , .
3, 6 $ 5 #$ ! ( 5 # ) ,; , D ) ) , ( * ! # ) ; # ) '$ ,, , ? $ , )) > # )' , # 6 #5 ) ( ! "#$ 5 5 ,,)'$ ) 5 ' ,,) &' ! # )' , ) #( $ ) ! $ $ * ? '( 6 #5 ) &' * ! # , ' < 4 F ,,( & # , ( , ) (! ( ( , (& &'6 #5 ) 4' # # 6 #5 ) ) 5 #( ( & # 545 5 &' ! "#$ ) (&(& '5+ , ) 6 ) # #( ( , , ($ $ ) ) $ 6 GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 012 2 3 , ) 4 5 ,,) &' ,)5E 55 $ ) # ( , . 3 , 6 $ 5 $ ! ()) )5 ) , , # 5 , )) # )) , B ) '( ) # &' * ! #( # ,
'( & # , ( ( , ( 6 #5 ) * .2 ,@@1( ) . 22@() & ) #( < , ) , ) ) ( ' # ! "#$ ( $ 5 5 ? ( ' & &' 4' ) , 5 #, 5 5 #) ' K $ ( 5 $ 5 ) '$ ) 5 ' ) # , ) &'! )) #'(' ' , 5) 5 # ' )) ( , # )) F ,, & , ) # , # ) + ) 5 #( ( & # 5C ) )5 )( & * & $) 55 5 , # ' # , &' F ,, &5 & # 6 #5 ) ' # &$ ($ ' ) # * ? '( 7:, &' $ (6 #5 ) GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy
and integrity of this document 012 2 3 &' * & $ ( , &' F ,, 5 . * ? , 6 ) , ) 5 ( # 5 ) ) ( , '( # , ) ) $ ) #( 5 & ,&' ) ' 5 ) C $ ,) ) ( ? $ ) ) ) ( 6 ) &) 5 ' , ) ) 5 ) 3 ) ' , & ' $ ) ) ) , , ) ( , 5 ) & ', ) # , ) # 4 53 '&'( ),!)" $!$* Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No Whether reportable? Yes / No GAURAV SOROT 2026.02.02 16:52 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document