Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55192 (KAR)

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. RANGAMMA AND ORS

MFA/201506/2021 · 2026-02-03

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $$ %& '( # )* ' ( ! "! " # $% ! &'(! & ) % ! &* # ' % ! & # " !% ! &'! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ! % " $% " ! + ! % " ! $$% ! '*! & $ '+%))' % ", + ! - ) !- # '# ! ! # " $ ))) '%)* " $ *'++% ). $ / % " $ ! ! ! ! " !" $ ! ! ! $ ! % # ! # !! +%)) - 3 - *'++% ). ! $ / )+%)( )*' ( $% ! '(! & ) 0 % ! *! & ' % ! ! & " !% ! '! & ) ! % " $% " ! " ! # ! % " ! $$% ! - 4 - '*! & $ '+%))' % " , ) $ ! ))%'%%% *)) +))+# ! "! " )- # )) ! $ ! ! " $ )')) ! " '%)* " !" $ & & 1 " - 5 - # 23456728234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;4672>346?2= ) 72=2 3>>238= 342 34?=?9@ ;<6 ;A 672 B<5@C296 395 3D345 53625 )')) ?9 ;'%)* ;9 672 A?82 ;A 672 8234925 55?6?;938 29?;4 ?E?8 "<5@2 36 3?:7<4 7242?93A624 42A24425 6; 3= 1;CC?==?;924F# 3D345?9@:;C>29=36?;96;672:83?C396= ' ;4 672 =3G2 ;A H42E?6I 672 >346?2= ?9 672 3>>238 =7388 H2 42A24425 6; ?9 624C= ;A 672?4 =636<= 395 439G?9@H2A;426728234925;CC?==?;924 6?=672:3=2;A672:83?C396=67366727<=H395 ;A :83?C396 ; 395 A36724 ;A :83?C396 ;5) 6; J 34?I3>>3D3=D;4G?9@D?6742=>;95296 ;3=354?E24 ;A H234?9@ 42@?=6436?;9 ;'+%))' 9 ') 672 52:23=25 34?I3>>3 D7?82 54?E?9@ 672 3A;42=3?5 363 E27?:82 ;9 <53@38 ?9@3=<@<4 4;35 92343=H3J?9@3=<@<43953667366?C23643:6;4:3C2 - 6 - A4;C?9@3=<@<43957?66;672E27?:82D7?:7D3= 54?E29HI67252:23=25=342=<86;A672=3C252:23=25 J 34?I3>>3=<=63?925@4?2E;<=?9B<4?2=395=<::<CH256; 672 =3C2 29:2 672 :83?C396= 73E2 >42A24425 ;'%)* H2A;42 672 8234925 ;CC?==?;924 =22G?9@ :;C>29=36?;9 A624 =24E?:2 ;A 9;6?:2 672 42=>;95296= 73E2 2962425 3>>23439:2 395 A?825 5263?825 =6362C296 72 42=>;95296 ; 73= =63625 6736 52:23=25 34?I3>>3 D3=D;4G?9@3=354?E243953::;45?9@8I?6?==636256736 =?9:2672E27?:82?9K<2=6?;9D3=?9=<425D?6742=>;95296 ;) J 9=<439:2 ;C>39I 42=>;95296 ;) 73= 6; ?952C9?AI 672 42=>;95296 ; 9 672 ;6724 7395 42=>;95296 ;) 73= A?825 5263?825 D4?6629 =6362C296 =636?9@673642=>;95296 ;7352964<=625672E27?:826; 67252:23=25 34?I3>>3G9;D?9@A<88ID288673672D3= 9;6 73E?9@ E38?5 395 2AA2:6?E2 54?E?9@ 8?:29:2 6; 54?E2 >346?:<834 :83== ;A E27?:82 395 67242A;42 =;<@76 A;4 5?=C?==38;A672:83?C>26?6?;9 - 7 - + 9;45246;>4;E2672?4:3=2:83?C396 ;D3= 2L3C?9253=$395@;6C34G256295;:<C296=395672 =3C2D242C34G253=L=6; 9672;67247395 67242=>;95296=73E2355<:256722E?529:2;A$395 C34G25 6D; 5;:<C296= 395 672 =3C2 D242 C34G25 3= L= 395 ) 72 8234925 ;CC?==?;924 HI B<5@C296 395;452453625)'))388;D25672:83?C>26?6?;9?9 >346 7;85?9@ 6736 672 :83?C396= 342 296?6825 A;4 :;C>29=36?;9;A=*'++%D?67?96242=6366724362;A ). >24 399<C A4;C 672 5362 ;A 672 3::?5296 6?88 4238?M36?;9 228?9@ 3@@4?2E25 HI 672 8?3H?8?6I 3= 6; >3IC296 ;A :;C>29=36?;9 672 9=<439:2 ;C>39I 73= >42A24425 ;)+%)) 395 ;9 672 ;6724 7395 672 :83?C396= 73E2 >42A24425 4;H ;)*%))) =22G?9@29739:2C296;A:;C>29=36?;9 * 4? 39B3I ";=7? 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@A;46729=<439:2;C>39I34@<2567363=672 52:23=255?59;6>;==2==2AA2:6?E254?E?9@8?:29:26;54?E2 672 E27?:82 ?9 K<2=6?;9 395 67242A;42 672 ?C><@925 - 8 - B<5@C296395;4524>3==25HI6728234925;CC?==?;924 ?= 9;6 C3?963?93H82 6 ?= 38=; 34@<25 HI 672 8234925 :;<9=28 A;4 672 9=<439:2 ;C>39I 6736 672 :83?C396= 73E2A3?8256;>4;E267242836?;9=7?>;A2C>8;IC296;A672 52:23=25D?6742=>;95296 ;39567242A;42=;<@76A;4 ?9624A2429:2;A67?=;<46 C636?8 73963H3? 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 :83?C396= =;<@76 6; B<=6?AI 672 ?C><@925 B<5@C296 395 ;4524 >3==25 HI 672 8234925 ;CC?==?;924 ( 3E?9@ 63G29 9;62 ;A 672 =<HC?==?;9 C352 HI 6728234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;4672>346?2=?6?=9;6?9 5?=><623=6;67252367;A 34?I3>>3;9')D7?82 72 D3= 54?E?9@ 672 E27?:82 H28;9@?9@ 6; 42=>;95296 ;96736E?2D;A672C3662463G?9@?96; :;9=?52436?;9 672 A?95?9@ 42:;4525 HI 672 8234925 ;CC?==?;9243=D2883=42=>;95296 ;73=A?825D4?6629 =6362C296 =636?9@ 6736 672 52:23=25 D3= D;4G?9@ D?67 - 9 - 7?C3=354?E24395D3=>3I?9@=%>24C;9673= =3834I 395 672 =3?5 3=>2:6 73= 6; H2 :;9=?52425 63G?9@ ?96;:;9=?52436?;9672;HB2:6;A672:6?=:;9:249256?= 38=;6;H29;625A4;C672A?95?9@42:;4525HI6728234925 ;CC?==?;924 36 >343@43>7 ; ;A 672 ?C><@925 B<5@C296 6736 672 E27?:82 ?9 K<2=6?;9 ?= ?9=<425 D?67 42=>;95296 ;) 9=<439:2 ;C>39I 395 67242A;42 3= 672 3882@25 3::?5296 ;::<4425 3= ;9 672 5362 ;A 2C>8;IC296 ;A 52:23=25 D?67 42=>;95296 ; 395 672 :83?C >26?6?;9 ?= A?825 <9524 672 >4;E?=?;9= ;A 672 C>8;I22= ;C>29=36?;9 :6 3C ;A 672E?2D6736672 34@<C296=35E39:25HI6728234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;4 6729=<439:2;C>39I:399;6H23::2>625 9=;A343=3D345;A:;C>29=36?;9?=:;9:24925 ;9 :342A<8 :;9=?52436?;9 ;A 672 A?95?9@ 42:;4525 HI 672 ;CC?==?;924 A;4 C>8;I22= ;C>29=36?;9 36 >343@43>7 ) ;A 672 ?C><@925 B<5@C296 C3G2= ?6 :8234 6736 672 3D345 ;A :;C>29=36?;9 ?= B<=6 395 >4;>24 D7?:7 5; 9;6 :388A;4?9624A2429:2?967?=3>>238 - 10 - ::;45?9@8IH;676723>>238=3425?=C?==25 +' %& # ?=6 ;&8 ;&' &