- 1 - ! " ## $%& '( ## ) $%& ## ** $%& ## + $%& ' ( ! " # $ %# & %'' $ %#() *(' )% ) % ' Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' %# ( % !% " )% %# ('+ #%% ' ''%% & ( (% % *"& ( # %( % $% % % % % ,' ' % %%#$% % # '' , )' ( %# ( % " % ( (( ) (() & " )% %# & % % ' %'' $ %#() *(' )% ) % % " %' #%& - 3 - ( (% % *"& ( # % % $% % % % % ,' ' # '*' , % %%#$% % **' ( %# ( % " % ( (( ) (() & " )% %# & - ## % ' %'' $ %#() *(' )% ) % % " %' #%& ( (% % *"& ( # % % $% % % % % ,' ' # '' , - 4 - % %%#$% % +' ( %# ( % " % ( (( ) (() & " )% %# & ' %'' $ %#() *(' )% ) % % " # $ %# (& ( (% % *"& ( # % % $% % % % % ,' ' # '' , % %%#$% % - 5 - ( %% $% %#% % .$% /01234/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/;013</: ' ( 8' *' ' ( 8' *,,' ' 062 ( 8' ' ' 01/ ><5/2 ?@ 34/ 81;8103<86 0=0<6:3 34/ 78AA86 B92=A/63 062 0C012 203/2 ,' ' <6 # 8:'*' , '' , 062 '' ,8634/><5/8>34/ 22<3<8605/6<81<D<5$92=/ 062 03 0<7491 74055/6=<6= 34/ 5<0?<5<3@ 062 ( 8' ' ' ' <: ><5/2 ?@ 34/ 750<A063 0=0<6:3 34/ B92=A/63 <6 # 8'' , ://E<6= /64067/A/63 8> 78A;/6:03<86 * 4/ 1/5/D063 >073: >81 02B92<703<86 8> 34/:/ 0;;/05: 01/ 3403 34/ 750<A063: <6 # 8:'*' , '' , 062 '' , C/1/ 310D/55<6= <6 0 107381 062 10<5/1?/01<6=8) *,'062) * ,86 0:E<92=05 1802 86 ',' 062 03 3403 3<A/ - 6 - 1/:;862/63 834/ 21<D/1 8> 34/ 9: ?/01<6= 8) *( 218D/ <3 <6 0 10:4 062 6/=5<=/63 A066/1 06220:4/20=0<6:334/3107381062310<5/1062860778963 8> 34/ :0A/ 34/ 3107381 062 310<5/1 39135/2 062 0: :974 34/ 750<A063: <6 34/ 0>81/A/63<86/2 70:/: :9:30<6/2 =1</D89: <6B91</: 77812<6=5@ 34/ 750<A063: 40D/ ;1/>/11/2 0>81/A/63<86/2 750<A ;/3<3<86: ://E<6= 78A;/6:03<86 6 :/1D<7/ 8> 683<7/ 1/:;862/63 8' 81;810<386/63/1/20;;/01067/062><5/22/30<5/2C1<33/6 :303/A/63 2/6@<6= 34/ 0D/1A/63: A02/ <6 34/ 750<A ;/3<3<86: 6812/138/:30?5<:434/<170:/34/750<A063:<6 055341//70:/:/F0A<6/2>891C<36/::/:0: :38062 =83A01E/22879A/63:0:F:38634/834/1 4062 1/:;862/2 8' 40: /F0A<6/2 <3: C<36/:: 0: 062=83A01E/286/2879A/630:F - 7 - 4/ 1<?9605 0>3/1 786:<2/1<6= 34/A03/1<05 86 1/7812?@B92=A/630620C012203/2 ,' ' 0558C/2 34/ 750<A ;/3<3<86: <6 ;013 062 0C012/2 78A;/6:03<86 38 34/ 750<A063: 4852<6= 3403 1/:;862/63 8' ?/<6= 34/ <6:91/18>34/8>>/62<6=?9:<:2<1/73/238:03<:>@34/750<A 8>34/750<A063: (//5<6=0==1</D/2?@><F<6=34//63<1/5<0?<5<3@86 34/21<D/18>34/?9:1/:;862/638'81;8103<86?/>81/ 34/ 1<?9605 40: ;1/>/11/2 ( 8:' *' ' ' *,,' '062' ' ' 4/1/0:34/750<A063<6 # 8'' , 40: ><5/2 ( 8' ' 8> ' ' ://E<6=/64067/A/638>78A;/6:03<86 A3 1//3< 03<5 /5E962< 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6=>8134/81;8103<867863/62/2340334/1<?9605 40:78AA<33/206/1181<6>0:3/6<6=34//63<1/5<0?<5<3@86 34/21<D/18>34/?9:<6G9/:3<862/:;<3/34/21<D/18>34/ 3107381062310<5/140:05:878631<?93/238C012:34/055/=/2 077<2/63 062 34/ :0<2 0:;/73 40: ?//6 <=681/2 ?@ 34/ 1<?96050620::974:89=43>81<63/1>/1/67/8>34<:8913 - 8 - 3 <: 05:8 01=9/2 ?@ A3 1//3< 03<5 /5E962< 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 81;8103<86 3403 34/ 103/ 8> <63/1/:3 0C012/2 ?@ 34/ 1<?9605 <: 86 34/ 4<=4/1 :<2/ C4<74 1/G9<1/: 38 ?/ <63/1>/1/2 C<34 <6 34/:/ 0;;/05: 6 1/:;/738>34//64067/A/638>78A;/6:03<8638?/A02/ <6 ( 8' ' ' ' <: 7867/16/2 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 81;8103<86 01=9/2 3403 34/ 0C012 8> 78A;/6:03<86 <:86 34/ 4<=4/1:<2/ C4<74 1/G9<1/:38 ?/ <63/1>/1/2C<34<634/:0<20;;/05 , /1 786310 1< 0:0D010B 034 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 750<A0630;;/55063 <6 ( 8' ' ' 'C4<5/<6D<3<6=34/033/63<868>34/8913 38 F* 062 1/>/11<6= 38 34/ :E/374 01=9/2 3403 34/ 7401=/ :4//3 40: ?//6 5/D/55/2 0=0<6:3 34/ 21<D/1 8> 34/ ?9: 062 077812<6=5@ 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 :9?A<33/2 3403 34/ 1<?9605 0>3/1 786:<2/1<6= 34/ A03/1<05 86 1/7812 1<=435@ >0:3/6/2 34/ 5<0?<5<3@ 86 34/ 21<D/1 8> 34/ ?9: 062 34/1/>81/78963/1/234/:9?A<::<86A02/?@34/5/016/2 7896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/81;8103<86 - 9 - 6:8>01 0: /64067/A/63 8> 78A;/6:03<86 <6 ( 8' ' ' '<:7867/16/2<3<:7863/63/2?@34/ 5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/0;;/55063?@<6D<3<6=34/ 033/63<86 8> 34/ 8913 38 F 3403 34/ 78A;/6:03<86 0C012/2?@ 34/ 1<?9605<: A/0=/1 C4<74 1/G9<1/: 38 ?/ /64067/2<634<:0;;/05 0D<6=30E/6683/8>34/:9?A<::<86:A02/?@ 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ ;013</: 062 86 701/>95 786:<2/103<86 8> F:* 38 A0E/: <3 75/01 3403 34/ 21<D/1 8> 34/ ?9: 218D/ 34/ :0A/ <6 0 10:4 062 6/=5<=/63 A066/1 062 20:4/2 0=0<6:3 34/ 3107381 062 310<5/106234/1/>81/34/><62<6=1/7812/2?@34/1<?9605 >0:3/6<6= 34/ /63<1/ 5<0?<5<3@ 86 1/:;862/63 821<D/1 8> 34/ ?9: <: B9:3 062 ;18;/1 C4<74 28 683 7055 >81 <63/1>/1/67/<634/:/0;;/05: ' 6:8>01 0: 34/ 01=9A/63 02D067/2 ?@ 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 81;8103<86 0: 38 34/ 0C012 8> <63/1/:3 <: 7867/16/2 ><62 >817/ <6 34/ :9?A<::<86A02/?@34/5/016/27896:/5340334/103/8> - 10 - <63/1/:3 40: 38 ?/ 0;;5</2 30E<6= <638 786:<2/103<86 34/ ;1/D0<5<6= 06E <63/1/:3 >81 34/ 1/5/D063 ;/1<82 062 34/1/>81/34/1<?960589=433840D/0C012/2<63/1/:303 34/103/8>H;/10669A8634/0C0128>78A;/6:03<86 * 6:8>010:34//64067/A/638>78A;/6:03<86<6 ( 8' ' ' ' "# 8'' ,& <: 7867/16/2 30E<6= <638 786:<2/103<86 34/ C8962 7/13<><703/ 062 34/ 2<:0?<5<3@ 7/13<><703/ <::9/2 ?@ 34/ 31/03<6= 287381 ><62 >817/ <6 34/ :9?A<::<86 A02/ ?@ 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 750<A063 77812<6=5@ 30E<6= <638 786:<2/103<86 34/ >073 3403 34/ 055/=/2 077<2/63 C0: 877911/2 291<6= ' 062 >8558C<6= 34/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 ?@ 34/ )016030E0 303/ /=05 /1D<7/: 93481<3@ 34/ 683<8605 <678A/ 8> 34/ 750<A063 <: 38 ?/ 30E/6 03 : ' ;/1 A8634 3 <: 05:8 38 ?/ 683/2 3403 34/ 1<?960589=433840D/30E/634/2<:0?<5<3@03 H<6:3/02 8>H30E<6=<638786:<2/103<8634/A/2<7051/7812: 77812<6=5@ 34/ 78A;/6:03<86 0C012/2 ?@ 34/ 1<?9605<:1/0::/::/20:962/1 - 11 - 0<6062:9>>/1<6= : /2<705/F;/6:/: : 8::8>>9391//016<6=: ": ' F'F*F H& :,, (9391/A/2<705/F;/6:/: :* 33/62063786D/@067/0626931<3<86 7401=/: :' 8305 /::0C012/2?@1<?9605 ,-.,/010,2 :' :' 3!4! 49: 34/ 0;;/55063 <: /63<35/2 >81 /64067/2 78A;/6:03<86 8> :* C<34 <63/1/:3 03 H ;/1 0669A 634/1/:953;0::34/>8558C<6=812/1 "<& 5534/0;;/05:01/0558C/2<6;013 "<<& 4/0;;/55063<6( 8' ' ' '750<A063 <6 # '' , <: /63<35/2 >81 /64067/2 78A;/6:03<86 8>:* C<34 <63/1/:3 03 H ;/1 0669A >18A 34/ 203/ 8> ;/3<3<86 3<55 1/05<:03<86 "<<<& 4/ 0;;/55063 <6 ( 8:' *' ' ' *,,' ' 062 ' ' '81;8103<86 <: - 12 - 2<1/73/2382/;8:<334/0C0120A8963C<34H <63/1/:3 C<34<6 :<F C//E: >18A 34/ 203/ 8> 1/7/<;38>07/13<></278;@8>34<:B92=A/63 "<D& 4/0A8963<62/;8:<3<>06@?/3106:A<33/238 34/1<?9605>812<:?91:/A/63 5' $& <:3858*