Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55183 (KAR)

HANUMANTHI @ TIMMAVVA W/O LATE HANUMANTHA @ HANUMANTRAYA AND ORS v. HANUMAYYA S/O LANKAYYA AND ANR

MFA/200123/2021 · 2026-01-31

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #! $$ %&' () $$ %&' ( ) ! " ! " # Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ % % # ! $% #& !! " ! " ' ( ) ! * + , !& !&%%%- !! " &$# ! &$# ' ( +. - ) + + () + + - 3 - * # * -- + +$& ( ) ! ( ) / & ! " ! "/ &$# # $ % - 4 - % # &$ &# !! " ! "/ &$# ! * + !&%%%-!! " &$# ( + . +. $ +#. ) + + () + * # -- + * 0 * - 5 - ! 123245524634728962:;14662<=9<=>12?@:=A2<>4<: 4B47::4>2:#9<C--C<>128962 C8 >12 C>C7 ;;9:2<> 649A3 79D@<46 4> 49;1@7 (12729<48>27 7282772: >C 43 0 79D@<460) 4B47:9<= ;CA52<34>9C<>C>12;649A4<>3 +C7 >12 34E2 C8 D72F9>G >12 547>923 9< >12 4552463 31466 D2 7282772: >C 9< >27A3 C8 >1297 3>4>@3 4<: 74<E9<=D28C72>12 79D@<46 >93>12;432C8>12;649A4<>3>14>:2;2432:H 4<@A4<>44<@A4<>74G4B43>121@3D4<:C8;649A4<> C < - >12 :2;2432: B1962 BC7E9<= 43 4 ;624<27 9< 419<:74 4I 59;E&@5 F219;62 D2479<= C!& %%%-4<:C<4;;C@<>C874314<:<2=69=2<>:79F9<=4<: >@7>62 C8 >12 C8 >12 48C72A2<>9C<2: F219;62 >12 4662=2: 4;;9:2<> C;;@772: C< >12 7C4: 3 4 723@6> C8 >12 34A2 :2;2432: & 4<@A4<>4 4<@A4<>74G4 3@;;@AD2: >C - 6 - >12 9<?@7923 2<;2 >12 ;649A4<>3 14F2 57282772: C--322E9<=;CA52<34>9C< # < 327F9;2 C8 <C>9;2 >12 7235C<:2<>3 2<>272: 4552474<;2CB2F277235C<:2<>C143<C>;C<>23>2: >12 A4>>27 C< A279>3 4<: 7235C<:2<> C & <3@74<;2 CA54<G143>4E2<@54352;989;5624>14>>12:2;2432: B43 <C> 4 ;624<27 9< >12 6C77G 9< J@23>9C< 4<: B43 4 =74>@9>C@3 54332<=27 9< >12 F219;62 9< J@23>9C< ;;C7:9<=6G3C@=1>8C7:93A93346C8>12;649A52>9>9C< $ < C7:27 >C 57CF2 >1297 ;432 C<2 B9><233 B43 2I4A9<2: C< D21468 C8 >12 ;649A4<> 43 4<: =C> A47E2: :C;@A2<>3 4<: >12 34A2 B272 A47E2: 43 I3 >C < >12 C>127 14<: >BC B9><23323 B272 2I4A9<2:C<D21468C8>127235C<:2<>343 4<: 4<:57C:@;2:$:C;@A2<>34<:>1234A2B272A47E2:43 I3>C$ 12 79D@<4648>27;C<39:279<=>12A4>27946 C<72;C7:DG9>3?@:=A2<>4<:4B47::4>2:# 4B47:2: ;CA52<34>9C< C8 3& B9>1 9<>2723> 4> >1274>2C8%K5274<<@A87CA>12:4>2C8;649A52>9>9C< - 7 - >966 9> 72469L4>9C< +2269<= 4==792F2: DG 9<4:2J@4>2 ;CA52<34>9C< 43 4B47:2: DG >12 79D@<46 >12 ;649A4<>3 14F2 57282772: + C 322E9<= 2<14<;2A2<>C8;CA52<34>9C<4<:C<>12C>12714<:>12 <3@74<;2 CA54<G 143 57282772: + C% ;14662<=9<= 9>3 694D969>G 43 B266 43 C< J@4<>@A C8 ;CA52<34>9C< % 79 @D1431 46645@7 >12 6247<2: ;C@<326 4552479<= 8C7 <3@74<;2 CA54<G ;C<>2<:2: >14> >12 79D@<46 143 ;CAA9>>2: 4< 277C7 9< 843>2<9<= >12 694D969>G C< >12 :79F27 C8 >12 C882<:9<= F219;62 4<: 8@7>127 9<:2A<9892: >12 ;CA52<34>9C< >C D2 54G4D62 DG >12 7235C<:2<>& <3@74<;2CA54<G:2359>2>1284;>>14>43 >12 :2;2432: B43 4 =74>@9>C@3 54332<=27 4<: B43 <C> BC7E9<= 43 ;624<27 9< >12 C882<:9<= F219;62 4<: <C :C;@A2<>314F2D22<57C:@;2:B9>172=47:>C>1234A2 4;;C7:9<=6G123C@=1>8C79<>278272<;2C8>193C@7> >93 463C 47=@2: >14> >12 4B47: C8 ;CA52<34>9C< 93 C< >12 19=12739:2B19;172J@972:>CD272:@;2:9<>193455246 - 8 - 79 1474<4=C@:4 4>96 >12 6247<2: ;C@<326 4552479<= 8C7 >12 ;649A4<>3 3C@=1> 8C7 2<14<;2A2<>C8;CA52<34>9C< < >12 69=1> C8 >12 3@DA9339C< A4:2 DG >12 6247<2: ;C@<326 4552479<= 8C7 >12 547>923 4<: DG 6CCE9<= 9<>C>12A4>27946C<72;C7:BC@6:9<:9;4>2>14>>127293<C :935@>2 43 >C >12 :24>1 C8 :2;2432: & 4<@A4<>4 4<@A4<>74G4 C< 4;;C@<> C8 >12 7C4: >74889; 4;;9:2<> C< -B196212B43>74F2669<=9<419<:744I59;E& @5F219;62D2479<=C!&%%%-27@346C8>12;147=2 3122>57C:@;2:4>I%A4E239>;6247>14>>12:2;2432: B434;CC6924<:B43>74F2669<=9<>12F219;629<J@23>9C< < >14> F92B C8 >12 A4>>27 >4E9<= 9<>C ;C<39:274>9C< >12 :2;6474>9C<C864BA4:2DG>12C<0D62@572A2C@7>9< >12;432C8 !"# $%725C7>2:9<##& '() *+ 4<: 9< >12 ;432 C8 $ !"#$% , -$% $725C7>2:9< '.) ( / 4A C8 >12 F92B >14> >12 <3@74<;2 - 9 - CA54<G 93 >C 34>938G >12 ;649A C8 >12 ;649A4<>3 4<: >127248>2772;CF27>1234A287CA>12CB<27C8>12F219;62 9< J@23>9C< 39<;2 >12 :2;2432: B43 >74F2669<= 43 4 =74>@9>C@354332<=27 - <3C847 43 2<14<;2A2<> C8 ;CA52<34>9C< 93 ;C<;27<2:>12:2;2432:B434=2:4DC@>G2473624F9<= D219<:39I:252<:4<>3 124;;9:2<>93C8>12G247 4<:>12728C729<;CA2C8>12:2;2432:143>CD2>4E2<4> 3$& 527 AC<>1 8>27 4556G9<= >12 4557C5794>2 A@6>956927C8%43527>12:2;6474>9C<C864BA4:2DG>12 C<0D62 @572A2 C@7> 9< >12 ;432 C8 ( 0 0 12! $ ! $ ,725C7>2:9<'*)( // 4<: 463C DG 4::9<= #K 43 >12 8@>@72 57C352;>3 C8 >12 :2;2432: 9< F92B C8 >12 ?@:=A2<> C8 >12 C<0D62 @572A2 C@7> 9< >12 ;432 C8 $ !"# $%0 3"($,725C7>2:9<'/ ) / ( 4, AC<>16G 9<;CA2 C8 >12 :2;2432: BC@6: D2 3#$& G :2:@;>9<= $>1 >CB47:3 5273C<46 2I52<323 C8 >12 :2;2432: ;CA52<34>9C< >CB47:3 6C33 C8 - 10 - :252<:2<;G BC@6: D2 3#%& (3#$II%I$>1) 4E9<= 9<>C ;C<39:274>9C< >14> >1272 472 39I :252<:4<>3 >12 6C33 C8 ;C<3C7>9@A BC@6: D2 3#& (3#I%) 3$& 24;1 93 4B47:2: >CB47:3 6C33 C8 23>4>2 4<: 8@<2746 2I52<323 ;;C7:9<=6G>12J@4<>@AC8;CA52<34>9C<72J@972:>CD2 724332332:438C66CB3 *+,- ./01 C33C8:252<:2<;G 3#%& C33C86CF24<:4882;>9C< 3#& CB47:38@<27462I52<323 3$& C33C823>4>2 3$& C>46 2334B47:2:DG 79D@<46 <14<;2A2<> 3##%& 3& -"2"( 1@3 >12 ;649A4<>3 472 2<>9>62: 8C7 2<14<;2: ;CA52<34>9C<C8-"2"(B9>19<>2723>4>>1274>2 C8%K5274<<@A <>12723@6> 5433>128C66CB9<= - 11 - 124552463472466CB2:9<547> 12 4552664<>3;649A4<>3 472 2<>9>62: 8C7 2<14<;2: ;CA52<34>9C< C8 -"2"( B9>19<>2723>4>>1274>2C8%K5274<<@A87CA >12:4>2C852>9>9C<>966>12:4>2C872469L4>9C< 12 4552664<> & <3@74<;2 CA54<G 93 :972;>2: >C :25C39> >12 ;CA52<34>9C< 4AC@<> B9>19< 39I B22E387CA>12:4>2C872;295>C8;27>9892:;C5G C8 >193 ?@:=A2<> 4<: >127248>27 72;CF27 >12 34A287CA>12CB<27C8>12F219;629<J@23>9C< 124AC@<>9<:25C39>984<GD2>74<3A9>>2:>C >12 79D@<46 ,( %' ! 93>C6C !