- 1 - !" "## $%& $'#() *$( + ! " # $" % & " Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '($ " # )' ")") # * $+"), '$ '$ + -")" ))))- '$ ' '))))- )))))- # . . / # # " 0123445361271859:573;31<2::05=>7;?5<:*@9*<A19:1*< 3<7*8758*@25<:5<9573:57)' ")")4322571<46 325* $+"),BC:05776 5221*<2#>7;53:363B>83;1 - 3 - @*8 B85A1:C D:05 8136 *>8:E F0585BC :05 8136 *>8: 9*<A19:57 :05 399>2573445663<: @*8 :05 *@@5<952 4><1203B65 ><75859:1*<2'$'$*@3<759:1*<+*@ 9: " 05 3B817;57 @39:2 *@ :05 9325 12 :03: *< " ) "), B5:F55< )".))-)".') 4 ? 3: 5F 3;03A5<783 *6*<C363B>83;1A19:1?- B51<;3?1<*8;1863;573B*>: ) C5382 93?5 :* :05 20*4 *@ 399>257 :* B>C 90*9*63:52 @*8 2 - ::03::1?5:05399>2579366570581<2175:0520*4*< :05485:5G:*@;1A1<;90*9*63:52BC*B258A1<;:03:<*B*7CF585 <538:0520*4 05853@:58:05399>25725G>366C3B>257058BC 485221<;B8532:3<7B>::*9H2@*891B6C 05A19:1?BC29853?1<; 1<2175 :05 20*4 @566 7*F< 3:58 :05 ?*:058 *@ A19:1? 1 5 " B8*>;0: 058 :* :05 0*>25 3<7 *< 5<I>18C :05 A19:1? 1<@*8?57:0539:*@399>257 22>902056*7;57:059*?4631<: B5@*85 :05 8524*<75<:-*6195 32 458 G " F0190 F32 85;12:5857 BC + 1< 81?5 * +"), 32 458 G + >B25I>5<:6C :05 8524*<75<:-*6195 9*<7>9:57 :05 1<A52:1;3:1*<3<763179038;52055:3;31<2::05399>257@*8:05 @*8:05*@@5<9524><1203B65><75859:1*<2'$'$*@ 3<759:1*<2+3<7)*@ 9:B5@*85:05 8136*>8: - 4 - ' * 48*A5 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: :05 399>257 B5@*85 :05 8136 *>8: :05 48*259>:1*< 1< :*:36 5G3?1<57 , F1:<52252322 :*,3<7?38H57+7*9>?5<:232G2 :* + 05 399>257 <51:058 5G3?1<57 3<C F1:<522 *< 012 B5036@ <*8?38H573<C7*9>?5<:2 $ < 322522?5<: *@*836 3<77*9>?5<:38C5A175<95 :05 8136 *>8: 9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 @*8 :05 *@@5<952 4><1203B65><75859:1*<2'$'$*@3<759:1*<+*@ 9: 3<7 25<:5<957 01? :* ><758;* 81;*8*>2 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@ C5382 3<7 :* 43C 3 @1<5 *@ 2 ))))- 1< 75@3>6: *@ 43C?5<: *@ @1<5 :* ><758;* 21?465 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@ ?*<:02 @*8 :05 *@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1*< '$ *@ 8F 59:1*< + *@ 9: 5362*25<:5<957:*><758;*81;*8*>21?4812*<?5<:@*83 4581*7 *@'C5382 3<7 :* 43C 3 @1<5 *@ '))))- 1< 75@3>6: *@ 43C?5<:*@@1<5:*><758;*21?4651?4812*<?5<:@*834581*7 *@ C538 @*8 :05 *@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1*< '$ *@ >8:058 71859:57 :03: 366 :05 25<:5<952 20366 8>< 9*<9>885<:6C 052317=>7;?5<:12903665<;57BC:05399>257 1<:012344536 - 5 - 5387 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 :05 3445663<: 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 8524*<75<: * -:3:5 3<7 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 8524*<75<:* " 438: @8*? >8;1<; 25A5836 9*<:5<:1*< 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 :05 3445663<: 481?3816C 9*<:5<757 :03: :05 =>7;?5<: ><758 :012 344536 2>@@582 @8*? 458A5821:C 3<7 1665;361:C21<95:05 8136*>8:@3165734485913:5:055A175<951<3 81;0: 4582459:1A5 99*871<; :* 01? :05 399>257 F32 <*: 8><<1<;348*A121*<362:*85F058590*9*63:529*>67B5B*>;0: : 032 9*?5 *< 859*87 :03: :05 399>257 F32 8><<1<; 3 G58*G 20*43<7<*I>52:1*<*@ A121:1<;320*4*@399>257:*B>C 90*9*63:52 22>90:05;5<5212*@:0593251:256@127*>B:@>6 ( 5 362* 9*<:5<757 :03: :0585 385 ?3:58136 71298543<91521<:055A175<95*@ -A19:1?2 "3<7$-058 4385<:2 1< 852459: *@ :05 1<9175<: 99*871<; :* :05 6538<57 9*><256 -A19:1?0322:3:57:03:205037;*<5:*20*4*@ 399>2573<7F05<:05399>257?*652:57205@5667*F<1<:05 20*4 >:32458 ":05A19:1?F5<::*:0520*4*@399>257 3<7717<*:85:>8<@*834581*7*@)-?1<>:52322>90205 F5<: <538 :05 20*4 3: :03: :1?5 F32 29853?1<; 1<2175 - 6 - :05 20*4 3<7 @566 7*F< 3:58 205 B8*>;0: 058 :* 0*?5 >8:058 $ 032 93:5;*819366C 37?1::57 :03: :0585 385 852175<:136 0*>25 38*><7 :05 20*4 3<7 1< @8*<: *@ :05 20*4 :0585 12 3 8*37 3<7 ?3<C A5019652 385 46C1<; *< :05 8*37 99*871<; :* :05 653<57 9*><256 :05 9*?4631<3<: 6*7;57 :05 @36259*?4631<:@*8:058532*<:03::05399>25775<157:*65<7 :05;8*958152*<98571:B3212:*:059*?4631<3<: 052532459:2 *@:05?3::58F585<*:48*4586C34485913:57BC:05 8136*>8: 99*871<;6C05483C2:*366*F:05344536BC25::1<;32175:05 1?4>;<57=>7;?5<:432257BC:05 8136*>8: + 6538<57 9*<:5<757 :03: :05 8136 *>8: 3@:58 ?5:19>6*>26C 5G3?1<1<; :05 5A175<95 *< 859*87 81;0:6C 9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 1< 3 F566 8532*<57 =>7;?5<: F0190 7*52 <*: 9366 @*8 3<C 1<:58@585<95 3: :05 03<72 *@ :012 *>8: 5 9*<:5<757 :03: :05 5A175<95 *@ -A19:1? 93:5;*819366C52:3B612057:03::05399>2570383225705825G>366C BC ?*652:1<; 058 >8:058 :05 5A175<95 *@ 965386C 9*88*B*83:52 :05 :52:1?*<C *@ 2 " 3<7 $ 1 5 ?*:058 3<7 @3:058*@A19:1? 058512<*8532*<@*8 F0*3;573B*>: )C5382*6790167:*?3H5@36253665;3:1*<3;31<2::05399>257 - 7 - *85*A58 :05F1:<522@*824*:?303J38-G $2>44*8:57 :05 9325 *@ 48*259>:1*< 032 754*257 :03: :05 399>257 F32 8><<1<; 3 H183<1 20*4 >8:058 :05 3;5 *@ :05 A19:1? 12 ><7124>:576C)C53823::05:1?5*@1<9175<:32458:053:5*@ 18:0 958:1@193:5 3: G < 2>90 9189>?2:3<95 :05 5221*<2 *>8: 81;0:6C 34485913:57 :05 5A175<95 3<7 9*<A19:57 :05 399>257 @*8 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: 01? 99*871<;6C 05 483C2 :* 712?122 :05 344536 BC 9*<@18?1<; :05 1?4>;<57 =>7;?5<:432257:05 8136*>8: , 03A5;1A5<?C3<G1*>29*<217583:1*<B*:0*<:05 2>B?1221*<2 ?375 BC :05 6538<57 9*><256 @*8 :05 852459:1A5 438:1523<7458>257:057*9>?5<:2?3753A3163B65B5@*85:012 *>8: ) 2 9*>67 B5 ;3:05857 @8*? 859*872 :* 48*A5 :05 3;5*@:05A19:1?:03:205F32?1<*81 5 3;573B*>:)C5382 3: :05 :1?5 *@ 1<9175<: 3438: @8*? 058 5A175<95 :05 48*259>:1*< 856157 :05 18:0 58:1@193:5 32 458 G F0190 75419:2 :03: 058 3:5 *@ 18:0 12 ) )$ ")) 3<7 :05 1<9175<: F32 9*??1::57 *< " ) "), 32 2>90 1: 12 96538 :03: :05 A19:1?F32)C53823::05:1?5*@1<9175<: 3257*<G 058 - 8 - 290**6 37?1221*< 85;12:58 362* 122>57 32 458 G ( 05 F32 2:>7C1<; 1< F3?1 1A5H3<3<73 90**6 1< $:0 :3<7387 438: @8*? :03: :05 *9:*8- F0* 5G3?1<57 :05 A19:1? 032 *41<57:03:D32458:055<:12::053;5*@:05A19:1?F32+-, C5382E :* :03: 5@@59: 205 122>57 ?571936 958:1@193:5 32 458 G < :05 *:058 03<7 :05 399>257 032 <*: 463957 3<C 7*9>?5<::*85B>::055A175<95*@:053B*A5F1:<522523<7:* 48*A5:03::05A19:1?F32?3=*83::05:1?5*@1<9175<: 5<95 :0548*259>:1*<03248*A57:03::05A19:1?F32?1<*83<73;57 3B*>:,-)C53823::05:1?5*@1<9175<: < 9385@>6 458>236 *@ :05 5A175<95 *@ A19:1?- 205 032 93:5;*819366C 2:3:57 :03: *< :05 73:5 *@ 1<9175<: 205 F322>@@581<;@8*?@5A58:0585@*852059*>67<*:;*:*290**6 3<7 3: 3B*>: " 4 ? 205F5<: :* :05 20*4 *@ 399>257 :* B>C 90*9*63:523::03::1?5:05399>2579366570581<2175:0520*4 3<7?*652:57058 ??5713:56C20529853?573<7@5667*F<BC @5561<;:1857 3:58058?*:0583<7@3:05893?5:05853<7:**H 058 :* 0*>25 3<7 205 <3883:57 :05 1<9175<: :* 058 4385<:2 99*871<;6C :05 9*?4631<: F32 6*7;57 BC 058 ?*:058 0525 32459:2 *@ :05 ?3::58 385 2:3:57 BC :05 A19:1? B5@*85 :05 - 9 - 6538<57 3;12:83:5 1< 058 $ 2:3:5?5<: 32 458 G 05 2:*>:6C75<157:052>;;52:1*<*@:0575@5<95:03::051<9175<: 037 <*: B55< 93>257 05 :52:1?*<C *@ 965386C 9*88*B*83:52 :05 5A175<95 *@ 2 " 3<7 $-058 ?*:058 3<7 @3:058852459:1A56C 05C03A5851:583:57:059*<:5<:2*@G "- 9*?4631<:3<72:3:57:05981?1<3639:*@399>257 99*871<;:* :05? 21<95 717 <*: 85:>8<57 0*>25 @*8 3B*>: )- ?1<>:52 "A121:57<538:0520*43<7@*><7:03::05A19:1? F3298C1<;<538:0520*43<7*<5<I>18C20585A53657:0539: *@399>257 " >8:058 -*9:*8F0*5G3?1<57:05A19:1?362* 2:3:57 :03: :05 A19:1? 032 <3883:57 :05 5<:185 1<9175<: B5@*85 058 0*>;0:0585F585<*1<=>8152*<:054582*<*@:05A19:1? :03:1:256@12<*:3;8*><7:*712B5615A5:05:52:1?*<C*@ 05 *9:*8 032 965386C 754*257 :03: 1< :05 61;0: 48522>85 485221<;1<=>8152?3C<*:*99>8*<:05B*7C 99*871<;:*058 :05 B37 :*>90 2:1?>63:52 :05 25G>36 *8;3<2 :05C ?3C <*: 93>25 1<=>8C B>: 75@1<1:56C 0>8::05 25G>36 @5561<;2 *@ 3?1<*8 90167 438: @8*? :05 3B*A5 5A175<95 -:05 1<7545<75<: F1:<522 @*8 24*: ?303J38 2>44*8:57 :05 9325 *@ 48*259>:1*< - 10 - 3<7 75<157 :05 2>;;52:1*< *@ 75@5<95 :03: 399>257 F32 <*: 8><<1<;:05H183<120*4 ' 5<95*<*A58366458>236*@:055A175<95*<859*87 1< ?C 9*<2175857 A15F :05 48*259>:1*< 032 52:3B612057 :05 ;>16: *@ 399>257 @*8 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: 01? 3<7 :05 8136*>8:03281;0:6C9*<A19:57:05399>257@*8:05*@@5<95205 129038;57 $ *F5A58 :05 8136 *>8: F0165 1?4*21<; 25<:5<95 @*8 :05 *@@5<95 ><758 59:1*< '$ *@ 8F 59:1*< + *@ 9: 1?4*257 :05 ?3G1?>? 25<:5<95 05 6538<57 9*><256@*8:05399>2572>B?1::57:03::05399>25712<*F3;57 3B*>:3B*A5()C53823<72>@@581<;@8*?*673;5316?5<:232 2>90 65<15<: A15F ?3C B5 :3H5< BC :012 *>8: BC 1?4*21<; ?1<1?>?25<:5<95:*:05399>257 4*<9*<217581<;:05@39:23<79189>?2:3<952*@:05 93253<79*<217581<;:0532459::03::051<9175<:93>2571<:05 C538"),:166:*73C:053445663<:12*<B3163<7<*F123;57 3B*>:()C53823<7362*9*<217581<;:0532459::03::0585385 <**:058B373<:59575<:2854*8:573;31<2::053445663<:3? - 11 - *@:059*<2175857A15F:03::0525<:5<951?4*257BC:05 8136 *>8:12613B65:*B5?*71@157 1 0581?1<364453612 11 05 =>7;?5<: *@ 9*<A19:1*< 73:57 )' ")") 432257 1< 46 325 * $+"), *< :05 @165 *@ 6538<57 776 5221*<2 #>7;5 363B>83;1 12 0585BC 9*<@18?57 *F5A58 :05 *8758 *@ 25<:5<95 1?4*257BC:05 8136*>8:12?*71@157 111 05 399>257 12 25<:5<957 :* ><758;* 81;*8*>2 1?4812*<?5<: @*8 3 4581*7 *@ ' C5382 3<7 :* 43C @1<5 *@ 2 ))))- 1< 75@3>6::*><758;*21?4651?4812*<?5<:@*8 34581*7*@*<5C538@*8*@@5<954><1203B65 ><75859:1*<'$*@F59:1*<+*@ 9:")" 1A >8:058 :05 399>257 12 25<:5<957 :* ><758;*81;*8*>21?4812*<?5<:@*834581*7 *<5C5383<7:*43C@1<5*@2 '))))-1< 75@3>6::*><758;*21?4651?4812*<?5<:@*8 3 4581*7 *@ ?*<:02 @*8 :05 *@@5<95 4><1203B65><75859:1*<'$*@ - 12 - A 1<5 3?*><: 1@ 3<C 754*21:57 BC :05 399>25712*875857:*B54317:*:05A19:1? *< 7>5 175<:1@193:1*< 1< 3771:1*< :* :05 9*?45<23:1*< 48*A1757 ><758 59:1*< '( *@8 BC:05 8136*>8: A1 05399>257125<:1:657@*825:*@@><758$"+ *@8 5;12:8C 12 71859:57 :* 25<7 B39H :05 36*<; F1:0 958:1@157 9*4C *@ :012 =>7;?5<: :* :05 9*<958<57 *>8: @*8:0F1:0 ,) $( 12:* .6* .+ .#