- 1 - !!" # $% % $% !%&! ## '&( ) ! " ## $ ## %## & ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( )# * # $$+ * *! # # $$ ) #, # *!! %# & ###$- * +# ' $$ .&'$# ## $ ) # ) # ## ## $ $ ) /)) /)) - 3 - % &# /))' 01 234564789 04:1 ;531< 8059 4==143 2043317>57> 801 ?@<>6178 47< 4A4B< <481< =4991< 57 C DE 801 <<585C743 175CB 5:53 )@<>1 47< 5<4BF;CB90CB8GB5D@743HI911J57>17047216178C; 2C6=179485C7 01 234564789 4B1 801 31>43 015B9 C; <121491< 6J4BA0C<51<574BC4<4225<178C7 A017 801 C;;17<57> :105231 <4901< 4>45798 056 1721 801E ;531< 23456 =18585C7 D1;CB1 801 B5D@743 2345657> 2C6=179485C7 C; 9! * ;BC6 801 CA71B 47< 579@B1B C; 801 C;;17<57> :105231 47< 2C7817< 8048 6J4B A494>1<!E14B947<A494=4B871B576J4B47<C79 47< A49 14B757> 9 * =1B 477@6 ;BC6 2C665995C7 4>172E 47< 9! * 8C 9 * =1B477@6;BC6>B52@38@B1 01 579@B1B 2C781981< 801 23456 =18585C7 47< <1751< 801 4225<178 49 A133 49 801 57:C3:16178 C; 801 - 4 - C;;17<57> :105231 8 439C <1751< 589 354D5358E 8C =4E 801 2C6=179485C7 01 23456478 A49 1K46571< 49 # 47< K9#8C#A1B164BJ1<A587199A491K46571<49 # 491< C7 801 CB43 47< <C2@61784BE 1:5<1721 801 B5D@743 013< 8048 801 4225<178 A49 <@1 8C 801 B490 47< 71>35>178<B5:57>DE801<B5:1BC;801C;;17<57>:1052318 439C013<8048801<121491<A494>1<!E14B9488018561 C; 4225<178 47< 95721 801B1 A49 7C 428@43 =BCC; C; 801 572C6114B71<DE801<121491<582C795<1B1<8017C85C743 572C61 C; 801 <121491< 48 9! * =1B 6C780 47< 4A4B<1<801;C33CA57>2C6=179485C7 C99C;<1=17<172E 9 * C99C;198481 9! * $@71B431K=17919 9! * C99C;2C79CB85@6 9 * C843 9 * 01 B5D@743 <5B1281< 801 579@B1B 8C =4E 801 2C6=179485C7 43C7> A580 5781B19848 L=1B477@6 ;BC6 801<481C;23456=18585C78533801<481C;B14359485C7157> - 5 - 4>>B51:1<DE801M@478@6C;2C6=179485C74A4B<1<801 2345647894B1D1;CB1801C@B8 ! 01 314B71< 2C@7913 ;CB 801 234564789 2C7817<1< 8048 801 <121491< A49 4 =4B871B 57 6J4B B4<1B9 47< A49 <B4A57> 477@43 B16@71B485C7 C; 9!. * 1 2C7817<9 8048 K9# 8C # 4B1 801 572C6184K1K8B4289C;6J4B47<C79A052090CA98048 801<121491<A49=45<49@6C;9!. *=1B477@6 499434BE 1801B1;CB12C7817<98048801B5D@743C@>08 8C 04:1 2C795<1B1< 801 572C61 C; 801 <121491< 49 9!. * =1B 477@6 47< 7C8 49 9 * 1 439C 2C7817<9 8048 801 B5D@743 ;4531< 8C 4A4B< 3C99 C; =4B17843 2C79CB85@6 8C 801 2053<B17 C; 801 <121491< 47< ;535432C79CB85@68C8016C801B47<;4801BC;801<121491< 1801B1;CB12C7817<980488012C6=179485C74A4B<1<DE 801B5D@743D11704721< 801 314B71< 2C@7913 ;CB 801 579@B1B 9@D6589 8048 801 234564789 04:1 64BJ1< K9# 8C # A05204B1801B18@B79;531<DE6J4B47<C79A0520594 - 6 - =BC=B5184BE 2C721B7 C; 0464B4C 1 2C7817<9 8048 0464B4C 59 801 ;4801B C; 801 <121491< 6J4B 47< 58 05>03E 56=BCD4D31 8048 801 <121491< A49 D157> =45< 47 477@439434BE 1439C2C7817<98048K9#8C#<C7C8 2C784578019434BE =45< 8C 801 <121491< D@8 801 946159 90CA757801984816178C;=BC;5847<3C99A0520597C847 4@8017852481< <C2@6178 47< 801B1;CB1 2477C8 D1 B1351< @=C7 1439C2C7817<98048801234564789C@>088C04:1 =3421<C7B12CB<801B18@B79;531<DE801<121491<6J4B 8C 1984D3590 8048 01 A49 D157> =45< 4 E14B3E 9434BE C; 9!. * =1B 477@6 1 80@9 2C7817<9 8048 801 B5D@743 59 ?@985;51< 57 4==3E57> 801 7C85C743 572C61 C; 9! * =1B 6C780 47< <181B65757> 801 2C6=179485C7 1721 01 9@D6589 8048 801 2C6=179485C7 4A4B<1<DE801B5D@74359?@9847<=BC=1B . 104:12C795<1B1<9@D65995C79C;801314B71< 2C@7913;CB80123456478947<801314B71<2C@7913;CB801 579@B1B - 7 - =1B@943 C; K9# 8C # 90CA9 801 B18@B7 ;531<DE6J4B47<C7947<801<1234B478234561<804801 A49 801 =BC=B518CB C; 6J4B 47< C79 0C@>0 58 59 61785C71< 57 801 984816178 C; 3C99 47< =BC;589 8048 801 <121491<A49D157>=45<47E14B3E9434BEC;9!. * 801B1 59 7C C801B 6481B543 8C ?@985;E 801 9461 $@B801B6CB1 801 $CB69 ;531< <C 7C8 2CBB19=C7<A580 801;5>@B1961785C71<57801984816178C;=BC;58947<3C99 01B1;CB1 801 2C781785C7 C; 801 234564789 8048 801 <121491<A4914B757>9!. *=1B477@62477C8D1 D1351:1<18048495864E585998481<8048801<121491< A49 013=57> C@8 059 ;4801B 57 801 >BC21BE D@957199 99@657>804801A4949959857>059;4801B57801D@957199 582477C8D1945<804801A4914B757>47C85C743572C61C; 9! *=1B6C78001B1;CB18059C@B82C795<1B958 4==BC=B5481 8C 2C795<1B 801 7C85C743 572C61 C; 801 <121491< 48 4 9@6 C; 9! * =1B E14B 01 B5D@743 2C795<1B57> 801 4>1 C; 801 <121491< 04< B5>083E 4==351< 801 6@385=351B C; GH 9 801 <121491< 04< 31;8 - 8 - D1057<056059A5;1801B12053<B1747<0596C801B 80C; 059 572C61 049 8C D1 <1<@281< 8CA4B<9 059 =1B9C743 47< 35:57>1K=1791974<<585C7 LC;059572C610498CD1 4<<1<8CA4B<93C99C;;@8@B1=BC9=1289C791M@1783E801 2C6=179485C7 <181B6571< DE 801 B5D@743 <191B:19 8C D1 1704721<49@7<1B 9!.! *KN9! * + 01 B5D@743 049 4A4B<1< 9 * 8C 801 A5;1 C; 801 <121491< 8CA4B<9 9=C@943 2C79CB85@6 5J1A591 801 2053<B17 47< =4B1789 C; 801 <121491< 4B1 1785831< 8C 3C99 C; ;53543 47< =4B17843 2C79CB85@6 48 9 * 1420 57 :51A C; 801 ?@<>6178 C; 801 =1K C@B8 57 801 2491 C; 0@9 801 2C6=179485C7 <181B6571< DE 801 B5D@743<191B:198CD11704721<49;C33CA9 1 &' - 9 - C99C;<1=17<172E 9! * C99C;198481 9! * $@71B431K=17919 9! * C99C;2C79CB85@6 9 * C843 9.+ * 7:51AC;8014DC:1801;C33CA57> 5' 014==14359 55' 012C6=179485C7C;9 * 4A4B<1<DE801B5D@743591704721< 8C49@6C;9.+ *A052059 =4E4D31 DE 801 579@B1B 43C7> A580 5781B198C;801B481C;L=1B477@6 ;BC6 801 <481 C; 23456 =18585C7 8533 801<481C;B14359485C7 555' 011704721<2C6=179485C790433D1 <1=C9581< DE 801 579@B1B D1;CB1 801 B5D@743 A58057 <4E9 ;BC6 801 <481C;8059?@<>6178;45357>A0520 8015781B19890433D1204B>1<+L=1B 477@6 ;BC6 801 <481 C; 23456 =18585C78533801<481C;B14359485C7 - 10 - 5:' 01 1K2199 5781B198 =45< 90433 D1 B12C:1B1< ;BC6 801 =1B9C7 B19=C795D31 ;CB 801 <134E 57 <1=C95857>8012C6=179485C7 *+ '%( % *+ '!%&!( % 598C3C