Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55167 (KAR)

SHARANAMMA AND ORS v. KARNAMMA AND ORS

RFA/200070/2021 · 2026-01-06

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" !"# $ % & ' !"# # $ !"# $ $$ !"# % Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ !"# $$ !"# & ' ( ) !"### # $ !"$* $ % ' !"# - 3 - % % !"### & '+$) '+% + + ,( % + "*$#*# (#*( ' + + + + ' - ./0 - ' - 4 - " - 121/0./345$%./0(6.71289103685.::1.9 ;6.991/<8/< 361 =0<>1/3 ./0 1;?11 0.310 "*$#*# :.5510 @A 361 91.?/10 1/84? 8789 =0<1 ./0 + 6833.:=?8/4(#*( # 61 :.?3815 56.99 61/;124?36 @1 ?121??10 34 .5 361A B1?1 .??.A10 @124?1 361 ?8.9 4=?3 61 .::199./35 61?18/ B1?1 0121/0./3 45 $ % ./0 ( B6891 361 ?15:4/01/35B1?1:9.8/38224534$./00121/0./34# $8 61 5=83 8/ 4(#*( B.5 28910 24? :.?38384/ ./0 51:.?.31 :45515584/ 42 361 :9.8/38225C 36 56.?1 1.;6 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 61 :9.8/38225 ;9.8>1036.3:9.8/38224534$./00121/0./345./0 #.?13610.=<631?5429.318::.//.1<56133A121/0./3 45$ ./0 .?1 361 54/5 42 0121/0./3 4 121/0./3 4%85361B821420121/0./34$./00121/0./34(85 361B821420121/0./34 - 5 - 88 61 :9.8/38225 ;9.8>10 36.3 3618? :?101;1554? ?8 8::.//. 1<56133A B64 B.5 361D.?36. 42 361E48/3 2.>89A 0810 8/3153.31 91.78/< @168/0 361> ./0 0121/0./3 45./0#.568591<.9618?561?124?1361A;4/31/010 36.3 361A B1?1 1/383910 34 ./ =/0878010 56.?1 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91:?4:1?3815 8883B.52=?361?;4/31/01036.30121/0./34 6.0 ;4/3?.;310 . 51;4/0 >.??8.<1 B836 ./4361? B4>./ 61:9.8/38225./00121/0./34#B1?1<871/8/>.??8.<1 ./0 B1?1 ?15808/< 1951B61?1 .D8/< .07./3.<1 42 3685 0121/0./345./0$<433619./0@1.?8/<=?71A4,$ >1.5=?8/< " .;?15 #* <=/3.5 ./0 " .;?15 , <=/3.5 3?./521??10 34 3618? /.>15 61/ 361 :9.8/38225 ;9.8>10 3618? 56.?1 361 0121/0./35 ?12=510 34 :.?38384/ 361 :?4:1?3815./0361?124?1361:9.8/38225B1?1.078510342891 .5=8324?:.?38384/ %8 61 5=83 B.5 ;4/315310 @A 0121/0./3 4 B64 .0>83310 361 ?19.384/568: 42 361 :9.8/38225 .5 B199 .5 - 6 - 361 4361? 0121/0./35 4B171? 561 01/810 36.3 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 B1?1 ./;153?.9 ./0 E48/3 2.>89A :?4:1?38158/3616./0542361:9.8/3822561;9.8>1036.3 .3 361 38>1 42 61? >.??8.<1 83 B.5 01;8010 @A .99 61? 58531?5 36.3 561 B4=90 ?15801 8/ 361 ./;153?.9 64=51 34 ;4/38/=1 361 98/1.<1 42 8::.//. 1<56133A ./0 36.3 61? 6=5@./0 B.5 @?4=<63 8/ .5 . 899.34> 54/F8/F9.B / 36.3 ;.:.;83A 561 ./0 61? 6=5@./0 6.0 >./.<10 361 5=83 5;610=91:?4:1?3815 88 61 2=?361? ;9.8>10 36.3 0=?8/< 361 982138>1 42 61?2.361?.5:1?685?1G=153./0B836361;4/51/342361 :9.8/38225./0121/0./34#3615=835;610=91:?4:1?3815 B1?1 3?./521??10 34 361 /.>15 42 0121/0./3 45 ./0$ ./0 ;4??15:4/08/< >=3.384/ 1/3?815 B1?1 @?4=<63 8/ 4*,,#F,$ 61 .954 ;9.8>10 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 ?1>.8/10 5891/3 171/ .231? 361 01.36 42 ?8 8::.//. 1<56133A 61?124?1 561 ;4/31/010 36.3 361A .?1 8/ 1H;9=5871 :45515584/ 42 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 ./0 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 B1?1 4=5310 2?4> 361 5=83 5;610=91 - 7 - :?4:1?3815.5361A/18361?78583103617899.<1/4?1H1?;8510 E48/3 4? ;4/53?=;3871 :45515584/ 471? 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 .510 4/ 36151 ;4/31/384/5 361 ?8.9 4=?3 2?.>1036124994B8/<855=15 61361? 361 :9.8/38225 :?4710 36.3 361 5=83 5;610=91:?4:1?3815.?1./;153?.9:?4:1?381542 361>519715./00121/0./354./0#I # 61361? 361 :9.8/38225 :?471 36.3 361?1 85 . ;.=5142.;384/343615=83I $ 61361? 361 0121/0./3 4 :?4715 36.3 361 5=83 42 361 :9.8/3822 85 @.0 4? /4/ 8/;9=584/ 42 3614361?:?4:1?3815I % 61361? 361 0121/0./3 4 :?4715 36.3 361 5=8385@.??10@A98>83.384/I 61361?361:9.8/38225.?11/38391024?:.?38384/ ./0 51:.?.31 :45515584/ 42 $36 56.?1 1.;6 36 56.?1 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 .5 :?.A10I ( 61361?361:9.8/38225.?11/38391024?361?19812 .5:?.A1024?I 6.34?01?4?01;?11I - 8 - ( / 5=::4?3 42 361 .71?>1/35 42 361 :9.8/3 :9.8/3822 4$ B.5 1H.>8/10 .5 F ./0 561 >.?D10 04;=>1/35.3HF34,B68;6.?1361?1;4?0542?8<635 42 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 121/0./3 4 B.5 1H.>8/10 .5 F ./0 561 >.?D10 .3 HF 34 F# 61.9541H.>8/103B44361?B83/15515.5 F#./0 F $ .5104/3614?.9./004;=>1/3.?A17801/;14/ ?1;4?0361?8.94=?3619036.3361:9.8/382256.0:?4710 36.33615=835;610=91:?4:1?3815B1?1./;153?.9:?4:1?3815 ./0 36.3 361A .94/< B836 0121/0./3 45 ./0 $ B1?1 1/383910 34 ./ =/0878010 56.?1 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?38154/51G=1/39A361?8.94=?301;?1103615=83 8/ :.?3 ./0 6190 36.3 :9.8/3822 45 34 $ .?1 1/383910 34 $36 56.?1 1.;6 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 B6891 0121/0./345./0#.?11/383910343656.?11.;68/ 3615=835;610=910:?4:1?38154B171?8301/810361?19812 42>15/1:?42835 - 9 - " 18/< .<<?81710 @A 361 5.80 E=0<>1/3 ./0 01;?110121/0./345$34(6.71289103685.::1.9 , 1.?/10 ;4=/519 24? 361 0121/0./35 5=@>83310 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 .?1 .99 0.=<631?5 B64 B1?1 <871/ 8/ >.??8.<1 ./0 36.3 361A /171? 1H1?;8510 ./A 04>8/84/ 4? ;4/3?49471?3615=835;610=91:?4:1?38151;4/31/0536.3 361/.>15420121/0./345./0$B1?11/31?108/361 ?171/=1?1;4?05@.5104/361;4/51/342361:9.8/38225./0 0121/0./3 4# 1 361?124?1 ;4/31/05 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 .?14=53102?4>3615=835;610=91:?4:1?3815.5361A6.71 /171? 1H1?;8510 ./A ?8<63 38391 4? 8/31?153 8/ 361 5=83 5;610=91:?4:1?3815 * 1.?/10 ;4=/519 24? 361 :9.8/38225 4/ 361 4361? 6./0;4/31/0536.3361G=15384/424=531?0415/43.?851 .5 361 :9.8/38225 1H1?;8510 5A>@498; :45515584/ 471? 361 5=835;610=91:?4:1?3815544/.231?36101.36428::.//. 1<56133A1361?124?1;4/31/0536.35494/<.53615=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 B1?1 8/61?8310 2?4> 8::.//. - 10 - 1<56133A361:9.8/38225@18/<68591<.9618?5.?11/383910 34./=/087801056.?1 1 .954 5=@>835 36.3 8/ 781B 42 361 9.B 01;9.?10@A3614/C@91:1H4=?38/361;.5142 361:9.8/38225 .?11/38391034./1G=.956.?1.94/<B8360121/0./345 ./0#1361?124?15=@>83536.3361E=0<>1/3./001;?11 :.5510@A361?8.94=?385E=53./0:?4:1?./00415/43 B.??./38/31?21?1/;1 # 1 6.71 ;4/5801?10 361 5=@>85584/5 42 361 91.?/10;4=/51924?0121/0./345./0$34(.5B199.5 36191.?/10;4=/51924?:9.8/382254534$ 16.71.954 :1?=510 361 ?1;4?05 42 361 ?8.9 4=?3 .5 B199 .5 835 E=0<>1/3./001;?11 $ 614/9A:48/336.3.?851524?4=?;4/5801?.384/ 85 B61361? 0121/0./3 4 6.0 :?4710 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 B1?1 4=5310 2?4> 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 ./0 36.3 - 11 - 561 B.5 8/ 1H;9=5871 :45515584/ 42 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 % :1?=5.9 42 361 B?8331/ 53.31>1/3 28910 @A 0121/0./3483519201>4/53?.315@1A4/004=@336.3361 :?4:1?38158/G=15384/B1?14B/10./0:45515510@A?8 8::.//.1<56133A385.954/438/085:=3136.38::.//. 1<56133A 0810 8/3153.31 61 :9.8/38225 ./0 0121/0./3 45 ./0 # .?1 361 2871 0.=<631?5 42 361 5.80 8::.//. 1<56133A 61 ;9.8> 42 0121/0./3 4 36.3 361 ?171/=1 ?1;4?05 B1?1 >=3.310 8/ 361 /.>15 42 0121/0./3 45 ./0 $ @.510 4/ 361 ?1G=153 42 8::.//. 1<56133A ./0 B836 361 ;4/51/3 42 361 :9.8/38225 85 /43 153.@985610 @A ;?108@9117801/;1 2 361 :9.8/38225 6.0 ?198/G=85610 3618? 56.?1 8/ 361 5=835;610=91:?4:1?38158/2.74=?420121/0./3 45 ./0$361A564=906.7104/1548/361>.//1?D/4B/34 9.B 1?11/3?8158/361?171/=1?1;4?058/361/.>1542 0121/0./3 45 ./0 $ 0415 /43 8/08;.31 36.3 - 12 - 361:9.8/382256.0;4/51/310345=;6./.??./<1>1/361 17801/;1 42 F#./0 F$85 .954 :.3;6A ./00415 /43 8/08;.31 64B 361 /.>15 42 0121/0./3 45 ./0 $ B1?1 1/31?10 8/ 361 ?171/=1 ?1;4?05 61?1 85 .954 /4368/< 4/ ?1;4?0 34 564B 36.3 361 :9.8/38225 6.0 171? ;4/51/310 24? 5=;6./.??./<1>1/3 ( /781B423612.;336.30121/0./345./0# 080 /43 085:=31 36.3 361 5=83 5;610=91 :?4:1?3815 B1?1 4B/10./0:45515510@A8::.//.1<56133A.5361D.?36. ./0 36.3 61 0810 8/3153.31 83 85 8/1783.@91 36.3 361 5.80 :?4:1?3815 6.0 34 @1 0878010 .>4/<53 361 5=?7878/< 91<.9 618?5 42 8::.//. 1<56133A /.>19A 361 :9.8/38225 ./0 0121/0./3 45 ./0 # 61 ?8.9 4=?3 6.5 361?124?1 ;4/5801?10 361 2.;35 8/ 361 :?4:1? :1?5:1;3871 ./0 6.5 ?8<639A619036.33619.8/38225.?11/38391034./=/0878010 3656.?18/3615=835;610=91:?4:1?3815 008384/.99A361?185/4>.31?8.934E=5382A36.3 361 :9.8/38225 B1?1 171? 4=5310 2?4> 361 5=83 5;610=91 - 13 - :?4:1?3815 ./0 61/;1 361 :48/3 24? ;4/5801?.384/ 2?.>10 @A=585./5B1?10.;;4?08/<9A " / 781B 42 361 28/08/<5 >1/384/10 .@471 3685 .::1.99.;D5>1?835./0361?124?153./05 (% $& (% $#& 853494#