- 1 - ! "# "#$ #!! % &'%(!)*'+%) , ! " # $ % & % ' ( ' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ! #) " ' *+!" ' #,* % ' ' - % !" #.#* ##... (( ( .# $ *(!" !" $ % ' % '$ ' /' % % 012 /' % % - 3 - # ! /' % %" 345 066708 45 94872 :; <37 =>1?4=<72 0==@572 =308871A41A <37 B@2AC71< 20<72 ##... 012 >D27D >9 571<71=7 20<72 ##... 605572 :; <37 >1-:87 224<4>108 7554>15 %@2A7 0< 080:@D0A4 41 67=408 057 !" >#.#* =>1?4=<41A 34C 9>D <37 >9971=75 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>15 (( 012 *(!"!1" >9 <37 124017108>27!37D74109<7DD797DD72<>05E<37-9>D 53>D<"0127=<4>1(>9<37 =<.#;<37>D27D >9 571<71=7 37 F05 571<71=72 <> @127DA> D4A>D>@5 4C6D45>1C71<9>D067D4>2>9<71;70D501260;09417>9 5....G9>D<37>9971=76@14530:87@127D7=<4>1(( >9012<>@127DA>D4A>D>@54C6D45>1C71<9>D8497012 60;09417>9 5....G9>D<37>9971=76@14530:87@127D 7=<4>1(>9<37 =<.#D702F4<37=<4>1*( !"!1" >9 1 2790@8< >9 60;C71< >9 9417 <37 0==@572 F05 <> 9@D<37D @127DA> 54C6874C6D45>1C71< 9>D 0 67D4>2 - 4 - >9 <F> ;70D5 9>D 70=3 =>1?4=<72 >9971=7 37 D408 >@D< >D27D72<30<<37571<71=7553088D@1=>1=@DD71<8; 37=057>9<376D>57=@<4>145<30<<3790<37D>9 <37 ?4=<4C 419>DC72 <37 6>84=7 >1 ..#.#* <30< 345 20@A3<7D F05 C45541A 541=7 ..#.#* 37D709<7D <37 D756>1271<G6>84=7 D7A45<7D72 D4C7 >.#* 9>D <37 >9971=75 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1 ( ((G >9 <37 012 <>>H @6 <37 41?75<4A0<4>1 37 ?4=<4C A4D8 012 <37 0==@572F7D7<D0=72012<37D709<7D<375<0<7C71<5>9<37 D787?01<F4<175575F7D7D7=>D272D787?01<C030I0D5F7D7 2D0F1<370==@57205F78805<37?4=<4CF7D75@:B7=<72<> C724=08 7J0C410<4>1 012 <37 0A7 >9 <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 F05 05=7D<04172 >1 <37 :0545 >9 <37 5=3>>8 D7=>D25 0<7D 0 =30DA7 5377< F05 8042 9>D <37 >9971=75 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>15(((! "*(>9<37012@127D7=<4>15 +(012>9<37 =<.#>6475>9<37=30DA7 5377<F7D79@D145372<><370==@572 - 5 - 37 D408 >@D< =30DA72 <37 0==@572 9>D <37 >9971=756@14530:87@127D7=<4>15((012*(!"!1">9 <37 012 7=<4>1 ( >9 <37 =< .# 37 0==@57268702721><A@48<;012=804C72<>:7<D472 + 1 5@66>D< >9 <37 =30DA75 <37 6D>57=@<4>1 7J0C4172 <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 05 $G#) <37 90<37D >9 <37 ?4=<4C=>C6804101<05$G)0F4<1755F3>3025771<37 ?4=<4CF4<3<370==@57205$G)<37 5545<01<'05<7DF3> 455@72 <37 :4D<3 =7D<494=0<7 245=8>541A <37 0A7 >9 <37 0==@57205$G+)<37>994=408F4<1755F3>D7A45<7D72D4C7 >.#*05$G)<372>=<>DF3>7J0C4172<370==@572 05$G()<37 5545<01<1A4177DF3>6D760D72<375H7<=3 >9<37680=7F37D7<37?4=<4CA4D8F058>2A7241<373>@57 >9<370==@57205$G*)<37 5545<01<70=37DF3>455@72 <37 =7D<494=0<7 7?4271=41A <37 0A7 >9 <37 ?4=<4C 05 $G) <37 2>=<>D F3> 7J0C4172 <37 ?4=<4C 05 $G,) <37 56>< F4<175575 05 $G#. 012 $G##) $G# F05 <37 1?75<4A0<41A 994=7D F3> 41?75<4A0<72 <37 =057 41 60D<) $3487$G#F05<3701=30;0<7?78>6C71<994=7DF3> - 6 - 455@72<37H0<307J<D0=<>9<373>@57>9<370==@572)$G #+ F05 <37 C><37D >9 <37 0==@572 F3> <@D172 3>5<487) 012$G# F05<371?75<4A0<41A994=7D JG# <>JG #*C0DH729>D<376D>57=@<4>1 375<0<7C71<5>9<37F4<175575F7D7D702>?7D <> <37 0==@572 F3> 271472 <37 50C7 1 5@66>D< >9 345 27971=7<370==@572 7J0C4172345 :D><37D05 $G#<37 >F17D >9 <37 174A3:>@D41A 8012 05 $G 012 0 ?4880A7D F3> 3782 0 601=30;0< <> 57<<87 <37 24997D71=75 :7<F771 <3790C48;>9<37?4=<4C012<3790C48;>9<370==@57205 $G012<37;C0DH72JG#<>JG#. ( 0572>1<37>D080122>=@C71<0D;7?4271=7>1 D7=>D2 <37 D408 >@D< 3782 <30< <37 6D>57=@<4>1 302 6D>?72<30<>1..#.#*F371<37?4=<4CA4D8302A>17 <>37D8012<370==@572H4210667237DF4<3<3741<71<4>1 <> =>C678 37D <> C0DD; 34C 0A0415< 37D F488 012 <37D7:; =>CC4<<72 01 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1 (( >9 37D408>@D<9@D<37D3782<30<<376D>57=@<4>1302 - 7 - 6D>?72<30<<370==@57209<7DH42106641A<37C41>D?4=<4C A4D8D7670<728;D067237D9D>C..#.#*<>,.#.#* 012 <37D7:; =>CC4<<72 01 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1*(!"!1">9<37<085>3782<30<<37?4=<4C A4D8 F05 0 C41>D 0A72 #* ;70D5 012 <30< <37 0=< >9 <37 0==@572 0C>@1<72 <> 0AAD0?0<72 6717<D0<4?7 57J@08 0550@8< 012 371=7 37 =>CC4<<72 01 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D7=<4>1(>9<37 =<.#37D408>@D< <3@5=>1?4=<72<370==@5729>D<3709>D75042>9971=75012 571<71=72 34C <> @127DA> 54C687 012 D4A>D>@5 4C6D45>1C71<05D797DD720:>?7D7567=<4?78; * 741A 0AAD47?72 :; <37 5042 B@2AC71< >9 =>1?4=<4>1012<37>D27D>9571<71=7<370==@57245:79>D7 <345>@D< 37 870D172 =>@1578 9>D <37 0==@572 5@:C4<<72 <30< <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 F05 7J0C4172 05 $G# 7 =>1<7125 <30< 37D =3479 7J0C410<4>1 F05 60D<8; D7=>D272 >1 - 8 - #.,.#* 012 <37 @:84= D>57=@<>D 5>@A3< <4C7 9>D 9@D<37D7J0C410<4>1G41G=3479<3>@A3<37D7F051>D705>1 <>2>5> , 7=>1<7125<30<>1.##.#*<37?4=<4CA4D8 F05 0A041 D7=08872 012 9@D<37D =3479 7J0C410<4>1 F05 D7=>D2727=>1<7125<30<>1#.,.#*<37?4=<4CA4D8 3025<0<72<30<537302A>17F4<3<370==@572?>8@1<0D48; >F7?7D >1 .##.#* 537 =301A72 37D ?7D54>1 012 =804C72<30<537F059>D=72<>A>08>1AF4<3<370==@572 7=>1<7125<30<:7<F771#.,.#*<>.##.#*$G #F059>D=72<>A4?7090857<75<4C>1; #. 7 9@D<37D =>1<7125 <30< $G# 302 276>572 <30< <37 5<0<7C71< >9 <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 F05 D7=>D272 @127D 7=<4>1#(+>9<37>27>9D4C4108D>=72@D7>F7?7D <3750425<0<7C71<F051><C0DH72:79>D7<37D408>@D< 012 45 085> 1>< 60D< >9 <37 =30DA7 5377< 7 <37D79>D7 =>1<7125<30<<37=057>9<376D>57=@<4>1F05840:87<>:7 <3D>F1>@<0<<37<3D753>82 - 9 - ## 79@D<37D=>1<7125<30<<37?4=<4CA4D84137D =D>55G7J0C410<4>1276>572<30<5373025<@2472@6<>(<3 <0120D2012<30<05>1<3720<7>937D276>54<4>1:79>D7 <37 >@D< 1417 ;70D5 302 806572 9D>C <37 20<7 537 2D>6672 >@< >9 5=3>>8 7 =>1<7125 <30< 49 <345 0567=< 45 <0H71 41<> 0==>@1< <37 ?4=<4C =011>< :7 <D70<72 05 0 C41>D 012 <37D79>D7 37D =804C <30< 537 F05 :>D1 >1 ##.*...=011><:7:7847?72 # 7085>5@:C4<5<30<<37?4=<4CA4D8=804C72<30< 5373020==>C601472<370==@572<>3453>@57F37D7537 F05 57J@088; 7J68>4<72 7 =>1<7125 <30< <37D709<7D <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 302 B>4172 <37 0==@572 012 <37; F71< <> '@C:04 7 9@D<37D =>1<7125 <30< <37D7 0D7 57?7D08 2>=@C71<5 C0DH72 :; <37 0==@572 F34=3 75<0:8453 <37 D780<4>15346 :7<F771 <37 0==@572 012 <37 ?4=<4C 012 <37D79>D7 <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 302 B>4172 <37 =>C601; >9 <37 0==@572 >1 37D >F1 7 085> 5@:C4<5 <30< <37D7 F05 1> =870D 7?4271=7 >9 D7=71< 57J@08 41<7D=>@D57 F34=3 45 7?4271<9D>C<377?4271=7>9$G,3@537=>1<7125<30< - 10 - <374C6@A172B@2AC71<012>D27D>9571<71=7>9<37D408 >@D< 45 F4<3>@< 01; :0545 012 <30< <37 >9971=75 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>15 (( 012 *(!"!1" >9 <37 0D71>< C027 >@< 7 9@D<37D 5@:C4<5 <30< 541=7 <37D7 45 1>7?4271=7<>75<0:8453<30<<37?4=<4CA4D8F050=348205 2794172@127D<37 =<.#<37D408>@D<=>@82 1>< 30?7 =>1?4=<72 >D 571<71=72 <37 0==@572 9>D 01 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1 ( >9 <37 =< .# 37D79>D7 37 6D0;5 <30< <37 4C6@A172 B@2AC71< 012 >D27D >9 =>1?4=<4>1 605572 :; <37 D408 >@D< :7 57< 05427012<370==@572:70=K@4<<72>9<37>9971=75 # 7D =>1<D0 <37 870D172 224<4>108 <0<7 @:84= D>57=@<>D5@:C4<<72<30<<377?4271=7>9$G012JG ,F>@82=870D8;75<0:8453<3720<7>9:4D<3>9<37?4=<4C05 ##.*...79@D<37D5@:C4<5<30<<37C724=08=7D<494=0<7 0< JG#. 085> =>DD>:>D0<75 <37 5042 90=< 3@5 37 =>1<7125 <30< <37 ?4=<4C F05 0 C41>D >1 <37 20<7 >9 <37 41=4271< 7 5@:C4<5 <30< <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 302 =870D8; 276>572<30<4<F05<370==@572F3>9>D=7237D<>A><> - 11 - 345 3>@57 0A0415< 37D F453 7 9@D<37D 5@:C4<5 <30< <37 ?4=<4CA4D8567=494=088;276>572:79>D7<37>@D<<30<4<F05 <37 0==@572 F3> 9>D=4:8; 302 57J@08 41<7D=>@D57 F4<3 37D 0A0415< 37D F453 7 <3@5 =>1<7125 <30< <37 >9971=75 6@14530:87@127D7=<4>1(>9<37 =<0127=<4>1 *(!"!1">9<37F05=870D8;C027>@< #+ 7 9@D<37D 5@:C4<5 <30< <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 :741A0 C41>D =>@82 1>< 30?7 :771 <0H71 0F0; 9D>C <37 80F9@8 =@5<>2;>937D60D71<5012<30<5@=3010=<F>@820C>@1< <> 01 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1 (( >9 <37 37D79>D737=>1<7125<30<<37D7F055@994=471<7?4271=7 :79>D7 <37 D408 >@D< <> B@5<49; <37 =>1?4=<4>1 >9 <37 0==@572 012 <37 4C6>54<4>1 >9 571<71=7 9>D <37 09>D75042 >9971=757<37D79>D76D0;5<30<<374C6@A172B@2AC71< 012 >D27D >9 =>1?4=<4>1 605572 :; <37 D408 >@D< :7 @63782 - 12 - # 79@D<37D=>1<7125<30<<3>@A3$G,276>572 <30<<37D7F7D71>54A15>9D7=71<57J@0841<7D=>@D5737D 7?4271=7 75<0:845372 <30< <37 ?4=<4C F05 @572 <> 54C480D 57J@08 0=<5 7 <37D79>D7 =>1<7125 <30< <37 ?4=<4C F05 9>D=72 41<> 5@=3 0=<5 :; <37 0==@572 012 <37D79>D7 <37 =>1?4=<4>1>9<370==@5729>D<3709>D75042>9971=7545B@5< 012 6D>67D 012 <30< <37 7?4271=7 :79>D7 <37 D408 >@D< F05 085> 027K@0<7 9>D =>1?4=<4>1 >9 <37 0==@572 9>D <37 09>D75042>9971=75 #( $7 30?7 =>15427D72 <37 5@:C4554>15 C027 :; <37870D172=>@15789>D<370==@57205F78805<37870D172 224<4>108 <0<7 @:84= D>57=@<>D $7 30?7 085> 67D@572 <37 B@2AC71< >9 <37 D408 >@D< 012 <37 7?4271=7 >1 D7=>D237>18;6>41<<30<0D45759>D=>15427D0<4>141<345 06670845L$37<37D<37D7F055@994=471<7?4271=7<>=>1?4=< <370==@5729>D<37>9971=756@14530:87@127D7=<4>1(>9 <37 =< 012 7=<4>15 (( 012 *(!"!1" >9 <37 MN - 13 - #* 37 =<.#45710=<72<>6D><7=<<37 63;54=08 012 C71<08 F788G:741A >9 <37 =3482 012 <37D7:; 715@D7 <37 63;54=08 7C><4>108 41<7887=<@08 012 5>=408 27?78>6C71< >9 <37 =3482 37D79>D7 7?7D; 0=< <30< 45 =060:87 >9 0997=<41A 0 =3482 63;54=088; 5>=4088; >D 7C><4>1088;45<D70<720501>9971=7@127D<37 =< .#$3717?7D02456@<70D457505<>F37<37D<37?4=<4C 45 0 =3482 >D 1>< <37 =< .# 6D75=D4:75 0 6D>=72@D7@127D7=<4>1+>9<37 =<.#F34=3 D7025059>88>F5 !" !#$% & ' ( ) ' ) ( ( - 14 - ( % * + ) ' ( , ( %- # 1 <37 =057 >1 3012 <37 >18; 67D=74?0:87 7?4271=7<>75<0:8453<370A7>9<37?4=<4CA4D8F0505<@2; =7D<494=0<7455@72:;$GF34=34124=0<72<30<:0572>1 <37D7=>D25C041<0417241<375=3>>8<3720<7>9:4D<3>9 <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 F05 ##.*... $G F05 01 5545<01< 70=37D0<<374A37DD4C0D;=3>>837?4=<4CA4D8F3> F057J0C417205$G#567=494=088;276>572<30<537302 5<@2472 >18; @6 <> <37 (<3 <0120D2 37D79>D7 <37 =>C67<71< F4<1755 F>@82 30?7 :771 0 <70=37D 9D>C <37 >F7DD4C0D;=3>>80< 20H4130120 #, 7 <30< 05 4< C0; $G 41 345 =D>55G 7J0C410<4>1 5<0<72 <30< JG, F05 455@72 >18; >1 <37 :0545 >9 <37 02C4554>1 D7A45<7D 012 <30< <37D7 F7D7 1> - 15 - D7=>D255@=305:4D<3=7D<494=0<7B@5<49;41A<3720<7>9:4D<3 71<7D72 41 <37 5=3>>8 D7=>D25 7 085> 276>572 <30< <37 :4D<3 =7D<494=0<7 F05 41 <37 =@5<>2; >9 <37 702 '05<7D >F7?7D 1> 0<<7C6< F05 C027 <> 57=@D7 <37 :4D<3 =7D<494=0<7>9<37?4=<4CA4D837?4=<4CF3>F057J0C4172 05$G#567=494=088;276>572059>88>F5 !"# $ %& '( ))*+,*** - $$ ./ . (01 20 3456 . 9 <37 0:>?7 7?4271=7 45 <0H71 41<> 0==>@1< <371<37?4=<4CF05=7D<0418;:7;>12.;70D5>90A7012 <37D79>D7 F05 1>< 0 =3482 05 2794172 @127D <37 =<.#37C0117D>927<7DC4141A<370A7>90=348241 <370:571=7>901;C0<7D40845056D>?4272@127D7=<4>1 ,+>9<37%@?71487%@5<4=7!0D7012D><7=<4>1>93482D71" =<.#F34=3D7025059>88>F5 - 16 - . / 0 ( ( ( 0 ( ( ' 1 *# ( (% & 0 ( ( ( ( 0 2 ( 2 ( (3 ' 4 0 5 5 ( 5 - 17 - ( ( 0 / ( 0 % *6 (0 ( ( ( %- # 37 6D>57=@<41A 0A71=; 305 904872 <> 05=7D<041 <370A7>9<37=3482:79>D741?>H41A<376D>?454>15>9<37 =<.#27564<7D7670<7271@1=40<4>1>980F:; <345>@D<05F78805<37>1-:87 67J>@D<9D>C<4C7<> <4C7 37 1?75<4A0<41A 994=7D 305 C0418; D78472 @6>1 5=3>>8D7=>D25<>41?>H7<376D>?454>15>9<37 =< .# 37D79>D7 F7 30?7 1> 3754<0<4>1 <> 3>82 <30< <37 6D>57=@<4>1305904872<>6D>?7<30<<37?4=<4CF050=3482 052794172@127D<37 =<.#>157K@71<8;<37 - 18 - >9971=76@14530:87@127D7=<4>1(>9<37 =<90885 980<>14<590=7 1 5> 90D 05 <37 >9971=7 @127D 7=<4>1 (( >9 <37 45 =>1=7D172 <37D7 45 1>7?4271=7<> B@5<49;<30< <37 0==@572 302 H42106672 <37 ?4=<4C 1 <37 =>1<D0D; <37 7?4271=7 >1 D7=>D2 6>41< <> <37 90=< <30< <37 ?4=<4C F71< F4<3 <37 0==@572 ?>8@1<0D48; 345 45 9@D<37D 75<0:845372:;JG#.F34=345087<<7D022D75572:;<37 ?4=<4C <> <37 0==@572 345 45 085> 5@66>D<72 :; <37 7?4271=7>9$G 5D7A0D25<37>9971=7@127D7=<4>1*(!"!1" >94<45<37=057>9<376D>57=@<4>1<30<<37?4=<4CA4D8 F05<0H71:;<370==@572<>3453>@57F37D75375<0;72 9>D170D8;(20;537D7451>7?4271=7>95<D497>D6D><75< >DD7?>8<:;<37?4=<4C 2@D41A37D5<0;F4<3<37 0==@572 1<37=>1<D0D;<377?4271=787241:;<376D>57=@<4>1088 6>41<<><3790=<<30<<37?4=<4C302A>17F4<3<370==@572 >137D>F137D745085>1>279414<77?4271=7<>75<0:8453 - 19 - <30< <37 0==@572 302 D0672 <37 ?4=<4C 08<3>@A3 <37D7 45 7?4271=7 <> 53>F <30< <37 ?4=<4C A4D8 F05 @572 <> 57J@08 0=<5 18755 <37D7 45 7?4271=7 <> 6D>?7 <30< 4< F05 <37 0==@572 F3> F05 D756>154:87 9>D 4< <37 <D408 >@D< =>@82 1><30?73782<30<<370==@572302=>CC4<<7201>9971=7 @127D7=<4>1*(!"!1">9 + 1 <30< ?47F >9 <37 C0<<7D F7 30?7 1> 3754<0<4>1<>3>82<30<<37D7F051>5@994=471<7?4271=7<> =>1?4=< <37 0==@572 9>D <37 >9971=7 6@14530:87 @127D 7=<4>1(>9<37 =<>D7=<4>1((>D*(!"!1">9 >157K@71<8;F7088>F<345 01257<05427<37 B@2AC71< 012 >D27D >9 =>1?4=<4>1 012 <37 >D27D >9 571<71=7605572:;<37<D408>@D<$7<37D7:;0=K@4<<37 0==@572>9<37>9971=756@14530:87@127D7=<4>1(>9<37 =< 012 7=<4>15 (( 012 *(!"!1" >9 >157K@71<8;<370==@5724557<9D77 994=7 45 24D7=<72<> =>CC@14=0<7<345>D27D <> <37 <D408 >@D< 9>D 17=7550D; 0=<4>1 9>D<3F4<3 F4<3>@< - 20 - 41545<41A 01; :>125 994=7 53088 9>D<3F4<3 D7<@D1 <37 D7=>D25>9<37D408>@D< -* %) -* %$) !60D0G#<>" !60D0G<>712" 45<>#8>