- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %&' %()* '%) + ! "# !!$ !$ % $ ! !$ "# $ &$ &$# & %# $$ & '( )* &$ & + $$"$ & & && *'**' %(& & $$% * )* & !!$ & & % , Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , - $ ! ./0 12/3/456 789/9/:4 /0 ;/68< =4<82 819/:4 :; .5259/>5 5?52/@ =25@0.5 54./95 )* 088@/4? 9: A=50. 9.8 72:188</4?0 5?5/409 9.8 789/9/:482 511=08< :) /4 :'( )* 2/38 :* )*# 28?/09828< B> !:<8@56 :6/18 959/:4;:29.8:;;841807=4/0.5B68=4<82 819/:40* ' ** ** ' 2 C 819/:4 ( :; 72808496> 784</4?:49.8;/68:;<<6/D/6=<?854< & .:257=259 5<?/2;:2B28D/9>E9.82/56:=29# .8 ;519=56 3592/F :; 9.8 1508 /0 9.59 :4 )G))* 59 5B:=9 ),*) 73 5 7:6/9/156 2566> C50 1:4<=198< 4852 !:<8@56 "/665?8 9 9.59 9/38 5 7:6/9/156 1650. 15=08< B89C884 9.8 C:2@820 :; .5259/>5 54595 529> 54< 4</54 59/:456 :4?2800 % % 9: %) 54< %* /87:6/18:;;/1820C828:49.8B54<:B509<=9>95B:=9),)) 7348529.86:156 $-0.:=0859!:<8@56"/665?89.84</54 59/:456:4?28007529>C:2@820522/D8<56:4?C/9.9.8/2)9: D8./1680 B> 0.:=9/4? 06:?540 .:=?. %7:6/18 :;;/182 5<D/08< 9.83 4:9 9: /4<=6?8 /4 0=1. 5190 9.8> 1:49/4=8< 9.8 - 3 - 0538 4 9.8 3854C./68 511=08< :0 9: * 522/D8< 54< 095298<7869/4?09:48059D8./1680:1:492:69.80/9=59/:49.8 7:6/18:;;/182054<095;;0/8%%9:%)54<%* =08<9.83/6<;:2189:</0782089.812:C<=2/4?9.81650.9.8 511=08< :B092=198< 7:6/18 :;;/1820 9: 782;:23 9.8/2 <=9/80 54< 78698<09:480:49.83B>C./1.%0=095/48</4H=2>:49.8 B51@7:29/:4 :; ./0 .85< 54< %G:4 ./0 68;9 9./?. 54< 9.8 7:6/18 D8./1680 C828 <535?8< .8285;982 & 1538 9: B8 28?/09828< 5?5/409 9.8 789/9/:482 54< :9.820 B508< :4 9.8 1:3765/49 :; % /8 :; =4505?/ /2168 54< 0=B08A=8496> /4D809/?59/:4 C50 1:4<=198< 54< 1.52?8 0.889 .50B88465/<5?5/4099.8789/9/:48254<:9.820B>5225>/4? 9./0 789/9/:482 50 511=08< :) 54< 9.8 685248< 5?/092598 9::@ 1:?4/I5418 :; :;;84180 ??2/8D8< B> 9.8 0538 9.8 789/9/:482/0B8;:289./0:=29 * 852<685248<1:=4086;:29.8789/9/:48254<685248< /?.:=29:D8243849685<82;:29.82807:4<849 9598 7529 ;2:3 =2?/4? 08D8256 1:49849/:40 685248< 1:=4086 ;:2 9.8 789/9/:482 .50 1:4984<8< 9.59 9.8 5668?8< /41/<849C505?2:=71650.B89C8849C:7:6/9/1567529/80<=89: - 4 - 7:6/9/1562/D562>.8789/9/:482B8/4?9.8383B82:;:4?2800 7529><=89:7:6/9/1562/D562>.8C50/376/1598</49.85668?8< 12/388560:1:4984<8<9.598F18799.87:6/18:;;/18209.828 /04::9.828>8C/948009:9.85668?8</41/<849.8095983849:; 9.8 5668?8< 8>8C/9480080 281:2<8< 5;982 65708 :; <5>0 ;2:3 9.8 <598 :; /41/<849 0 0=1. 3=1. 128<8418 1544:9 B8 59951.8<9:9.8/20959838498560:1:4984<8<9.598F18799.8 :34/B=0 5668?59/:4 9.828 /0 4: 0=1. 0781/;/1 5668?59/:4 ;:29.1:3/4? :4 281:2< 5?5/409 9./0 789/9/:482 11:2</4?6> 725>09:566:C9.8789/9/:4 685248<:77:08<9.8789/9/:454< 725>09:</03/009.80538 G .5D8?/D843>54F/:=01:40/<8259/:4B:9.:49.8 0=B3/00/:40 35<8 B> 9.8 685248< 1:=4086 ;:2 9.8 2807819/D8 7529/8054<9.8<:1=384905D5/65B68:4281:2< ' 0 1:=6< B8 ?59.828< ;2:3 281:2<0 9.8 :; 2807:4<849:6/186:<?8<9.8 1:3765/495668?/4?9.59 :4 )G))* 59 5B:=9 ),*) 73 .8 2818/D8< 0781/;/1 /4;:2359/:4 ;2:3 9.8 !:<8@56 :6/18 959/:4 9.59 9.828 C50 5 7:6/9/1561650.B89C8849.8C:2@820:;9C:7:6/9/1567529/80/8 - 5 - 4</54 59/:456 :4?2800 54< .5259/>5 54595 529> .8285;9829.8C:2@820:;B:9.9.87529/80C828A=522868<C/9. 851.:9.82/4;2:49:;9.8.:=08:;6:156 $:;!:<8@56"/665?8 .:=?.1:3765/4549 2807:4<84935<85459983799:168529.8 A=52286 B> 5<D/0/4? 9.8 3:B 9.8> 1:49/4=8< 9.8 0538 54< 095298< 7869/4? 09:480 :4 9.8 1:3765/4549 54< 560: 9.8 7:6/18 D8./1680.83:B1650.84<8<=7C/9.15=0/4?/4H=2/809:9.8 1:3765/454954<:9.827:6/18:;;/1/560<3/998<6>9.828528G 8>8C/94800809:9.8/41/<8494782=056:;9.8/2095983849/9 168526> 28D8560 9.8 7529/1/759/:4 :; 9./0 789/9/:482 4 0=1. 1/21=3095418599./0095?89.872:188</4?01544:9B8A=50.8< 5?5/4099./0789/9/:482:49.8?2:=4<:;D84?85418 .8849/28359982/0:46>595728359=28095?854< 9.8 /4D809/?59/:4 .50 4:9 72:188<8< C/9. 8F1879 0:38 7286/3/452>8;;:2995@84:49.8<598:;28?/09259/:4:;9.81508 .88D/<8418.509:B8?59.828<5;98259.:2:=?./4D809/?59/:4 54<76518<B8;:289.8:=29:49.8B50/0:;C./1.56:48:=29 154 1:38 9: 5 1:416=0/:4 :48 C5> :2 :9.82 :4 9.8 7685 :; 3565;/<80 ; 9.8 5668?59/:40 528 B28;9 :; 92=9. 54< 35<8 356/1/:=09.8/4D809/?59/:4C/6628D8569.8053899./0095?8 - 6 - C.84 9.828 528 :46> 5668?59/:40 54< 2812/3/459/:40 B=9 4: 8D/<8418 9./0 :=29 1544:9 549/1/7598 9.8 280=69 :; 9.8 /4D809/?59/:454<284<82;/4</4?0:49.8A=809/:4:;3565;/<80 :4 9.8 35982/560 59 7280849 5D5/65B68 .828;:28 /9 1544:9 B8 05/< 9.59 9.8 1:3765/49 0.:=6< B8 9.2:C4 :D82B:52< :4 9.8 3828 =40=B09549/598< 7685 :; 3565;/<80 D84 500=3/4? 9.59 9.81:3765/49.50;/68<:4511:=49:;7820:45654/3:0/9>9.59 B> /9086; C/66 4:9 B8 5 ?2:=4< 9: </0152< 9.8 1:3765/49 1:495/4/4? 082/:=0 5668?59/:40 C./1. .5D8 9: B8 98098< 54< C8/?.8< 5;982 9.88D/<8418 /0 1:668198< 50.86< /4 9.8 1508 :; 287:298</4 ( 49.8/40954915089.81.52?80.88935982/560 </016:085 15085?5/4099.8789/9/:482 511=08< ;:2 9.8 :;;84180 C./1. .8 .5< B884 1.52?8 0.8898< 4 0=1.1/21=30954189.80538.509:B898098</45<895/68< 92/568418C/9.:=98F72800/4?54>:7/4/:4:49.8382/90 :; 9.8 1508 0=;;/18 9: .:6< 9.59 9.8 72:188</4?0 5?5/409 9.8 789/9/:482 511=08< :) 1544:9 B8 A=50.8< 59 9./0 - 7 - 095?811:2</4?6>9.8789/9/:4651@0382/9054<9.80538 /0 ) /4189.828528*511=08</416=</4?9./0789/9/:482 /4D:6D8</49.805/<12/389.8685248< 5?/092598/028A=8098< 9:72:188<9.8359982;:292/56B>081=2/4?9.872808418:;566 9.8511=08<599.88526/809C/9./454:=9826/3/9:;)3:49.0 ,* %!) ! $/09:, 6:,