Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55141 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER NEKRTC v. GYANAPPA AND OTHERS
MFA/200976/2020 · 2026-02-05
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55141 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55141 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# $$
%&' () $$
%&' $$ *
%&' $$ +
%&' $$ +,
%&' $$
%&'
(
)
! "! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
!#
$
!%
&
'
()*$+
)
+
"* &
()*$+
'
& ()*$+
"#!*
"*#$$
%
&
()*$+
"#*! "*#$$
'
$, !+#!+! )
%
%"
'
!#+!+!+
- 3 -
)!+*
'
(
)
&
'
()*$+
'
+
"(* &
()*$!$
! ()*$+
"
'
& ()*$!)
"(#!*
"(*#$$
$
& ()*$!)
"(#!*
"(*#$$
- 4 -
)
"! !#
%
!%
&
'
()*$+
!, !*+!+! " $
%"
'
!#+!+!+
'
)!+*
*(
)
)% &
'
()*$+
'
+
- 5 -
"(* &
()*$!$
! ()*$+
"
'
&
"(#!*
"(*#$$
$
& ()*$!)
"(#!*
"(*#$$
)
!%
!*
&
'
()*$+
!, *!!+! " $
%"
'
!#+!+!+
'
$!+*
- 6 -
+
(
)
)%
! !%
"
!*
&
'
()*$+
$
+
"* &
()*$+
)
'
& ()*$+
"#!*
"*#$$
- 7 -
& ()*$+
"#*! "*#$$
'
", !+#!+! $ )
%"
'
!#+!+!+
$!+*
'
+,(
)
)! ! !%
- 8 -
"
!$
$
!+
)
*
&
'
()*$+
+
"(* &
()*$+
%
'
& ()*$+
"#!*
"*#$$
*
& ()*$+
"#*! "*#$$
'
), !+#!+! %
*
%"
- 9 -
'
!#+!+!+
!+*
'
(
)
)! &
'
()*$+
'
+
"(* &
()*$!$
! ()*$+
"
'
& ()*$!)
"(#!*
"(*#$$
$
- 10 -
& ()*$!)
"(#!*
"(*#$$
)
!%
!$
%
!+
*
*
&
'
()*$+
!, +*+!!+!! " *
%"
'
!#+!+!+
'
!+*
'
- 11 -
-'
#
./0/ 122/130 14/ 1450567 89: 8; :./ <8==86 '9>7=/6: 16>?14>>1:/>!#+!+!+56 80$!+*)!+* 16> !+* 86 :./ ;53/ 8; >>3 50:45<: 16> /005860 '9>7/16>
1:15<.941?14>567<8=2/601:586 ! : 50 :./ <10/ 8; :./ <315=16:0 :.1: :./ <315=16:0 ?/4/ :41@/33567 56 1 41<:84 16> 4153/4 A/14567 8("(#*! 16>("(*#$$4/02/<:5@/3B86!#!+%16>?./6:./ 015> 41<:84 16> 4153/4 4/1<./> 6/14 9>713 53317/ 1: :.1:
:5=/ :./ >45@/4 8; :./
A90 A/14567 8("(* <1=/;48=822805:/05>/16>>10./>:8:./41<:8416>4153/4 16>861<<896:8;:./01=/:./41<:8416>4153/4:94:3/>16> 10 09<.
:./ 56=1:/0 8; :./ 41<:84 16> 4153/4 61=/3B .5@1221 9357/==1 16> 1331==1 090:156/> 56C945/0 16> :./4/1;:/4 09<<9=A/> :8 56C945/0
/6</ :./54 3/713 4/24/0/6:1:5@/0 .1@/ ;53/> :./ 1;84/015> 4/02/<:5@/
<10/0 A/;84/:./45A96130//D567<8=2/601:586
- 12 -
" ;:/4 0/4@5</ 8; 68:5</ 4/0286>/6: 80 16> ! 56 :./ <315=2/:5:5860/6:/4/>122/1416</16>4/0286>/6: 80" 16> $ ?/4/ 231</> /E(214:/ : 50 :./ <10/ 8; :./ 4/0286>/6: F 842841:586 :.1: :./ 133/7/> 1<<5>/6: 8<<944/> 86 1<<896: 8; :./410.16>6/7357/6:>45@5678;:./>45@/48;:./41<:8416> 4153/4 16> :./4/;84/ 0897.: ;84 >50=50013 8; :./ <315= 2/:5:5860 $ 684>/4:8/0:1A350.:./54<10/<315=16:056133:./<10/0 .1@//E1=56/>:.4//?5:6/00/010!16>"16> 248>9</>"$>8<9=/6:0?.5<.14/=14D/>10E0:8"$ /0286>/6:F
842841:586.10/E1=56/>:./>45@/48;:./A90 10 16> 248>9</> # >8<9=/6:0 ?.5<. ?/4/ =14D/> 10 E0:8#./45A96131;:/4<8605>/4567:./=1:/451386 4/<84>AB5:0'9>7=/6:16>?14>>1:/>!#+!+!+1?14>/> <8=2/601:586 8; 0*)!$++( 56
8$!+!+ 0!$++++( 56 8)!+!+ 16> 0!$++++( 56
8!+!+ ?5:. 56:/4/0: 1: G 2/4 1669= ;48= :./ >1:/ 8; <315= 2/:5:586 :533 >/2805: //3567 17745/@/> AB :./ 1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 10 561>/H91:/ :./ <315=16:0 .1@/
- 13 -
24/;/44/>
80!+++!+!+ !++$#!+! 16> !++%++!+! ) //356717745/@/>AB:./8A0/4@1:586=1>/AB:./ 10 :8 351A535:B :./ 4/0286>/6: F
842841:586 24/;/44/>
80!++#%!+!+!++*!+!16>!++*"!+! /14> =: 4//:5 1:53 /3D96>5 3/146/> <8960/3 122/14567;84:./122/3316:F
842841:58616>45101@141C 1:. 3/146/> <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ <315=16:0 ?.8 14/ 122/3316:04/0286>/6:056:./0/122/130 % :50<86:/6>/>AB:./3/146/><8960/3;84:./122/3316:F 842841:586 :.1: :./ 45A9613 .10 <8==5::/> 16 /4484 56 ;10:/6567 351A535:B 86 :./ >45@/4 8; :./ A90 56 H9/0:586 >/025:/ :./ ;1<: :.1: :./ >45@/4 8; :./ 41<:84 16> 4153/4 >48@/ :./ 01=/561410.16>6/7357/6:=166/416><86:45A9:/>:8?14>0 :./133/7/>1<<5>/6:16>1<<84>5673B0897.:;8456:/4;/4/6</8;
:.50
894::50;94:./41479/>AB:./3/146/><8960/3:.1::./ 56=1:/0 ?/4/ :./ 2100/67/40 56 :./ 41<:84 16> 4153/4 16> :./4/;84/0897.:;8456:/4;/4/6</10;1410351A535:B50<86</46/>
- 14 -
* /4 <86:41 45 101@141C 1:. 3/146/> <8960/3 ;84 :./<315=16:056@5:/>:./1::/6:5868;:./
894::8:./0D/:<. 248>9</>1:E"16><86:/6>/>:.1::./1<<5>/6:8<<944/>86 1<<896:8;083/6/7357/6</86214:8;:./>45@/48;:./A9056 H9/0:586 16> 1<<84>5673B <896:/4/> :./ 1479=/6:0 1>@16</> AB :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 ;84 :./ 122/3316: F
842841:586 /146/><8960/31308=1>/09A=50058600//D567/6.16</=/6: 8;<8=2/601:586:8:./<315=16:0 # 1@567 ./14> :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ 214:5/086<14/;93<8605>/41:5868;:./;56>5674/<84>/>AB:./ 45A9613 ?893> 56>5<1:/ :.1: 86 !#!+% .5@1221 9357/==1 16> 1331==1 ?/4/ :41@/33567 56 :./ 41<:84 16> 4153/4 A/14567 8("(#*!
16> ("(*#$$ 16> ?./6:./015>@/.5<3/4/1<./>6/149>71353317/:./>45@/4 8;:./
A90A/14567 8("(*<1=/;48=822805:/ 05>/16>>10./>:8:./41<:8416>4153/416>01=/50/@5>/6: ;48=:./028:216<.161=113867?5:.0D/:<.=12248>9</>1: E"6:.1:@5/?8;:./=1::/41=8;:./@5/?:.1::./ ;56>567 4/<84>/> AB :./ 45A9613 ;10:/6567 :./ 351A535:B 86 :./ >45@/48;:./A9056H9/0:586.10:8A/1<</2:/>./4/;84/
- 15 -
>8 68: ;56> ;84</ 56 :./ 09A=500586 =1>/ AB :./ 3/146/> <8960/3;84:./
842841:586 + 6 08 ;14 10 1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 50 <86</46/> :./ <315=16:056 8$!+*14/:./3/7134/24/0/6:1:5@/010 >/2/6>/6:0 8; >/</10/> .5@1221 ./ 17/ 8; .5@1221 ?10 )*B/1401086:./>1:/8;:./1<<5>/6:./4/;84/:1D56756:8 <8605>/41:586:.1::./1<<5>/6:508;:./B/14!+%102/4:./ 795>/356/08;:./1461:1D1:1://713/4@5</09:.845:B:./ =86:.3B56<8=/8;:./>/</10/>.5@1221500+!)+(B 1223B567 :./ 122482451:/ =93:5235/4 8; # 56 :/4=0 8; :./ '9>7=/6:8;:./86-A3/924/=/
894:56:./<10/8; &
&-
$ $4/284:/>56 # + 16> AB 1>>567 +G :8?14>0 ;9:94/ 24802/<:0 56 @5/? 8; :./ '9>7=/6: 8; :./ 86-A3/ 924/=/
894: 56 :./ <10/ 8; $ &- $ 4/284:/>56 # !>/>9<:567
"4>:8?14>0.502/408613/E2/60/0:./<315=16:014//6:5:3/> ;84<8=2/601:5868;0**++(+!)+I+GE!E#E !":8?14>038008;>/2/6>/6<B./4/14/:.4//>/2/6>/6:0 16> :./4/;84/ 3800 8; <86084:59= 50 >/:/4=56/> 1:
- 16 -
0!++++(0$++++E"./<315=16:014//6:5:3/>;84 0)+++( :8?14>0 3800 8; /0:1:/ 16> 168:./4 0)+++( :8?14>0;96/413/E2/60/0./<315=16:0.1@/56<944/>=/>5<13 /E2/60/0 :8 :./ /E:/6: 8; 0$**)+( <<84>5673B :./ <315=16:0 56 8$!+* 14/ 7416:/> <8=2/601:586 10 68:/>A/38? /1>0 =896: 5692//0 8008;>/2/6>/6<B **++++
8008;/0:1:/ )+++++
8008;<86084:59= !++++++
4160284:1:586J;96/413/E2/60/0 )+++++
/>5<13/E2/60/0 $**)+++ 8:13 +)+++
608;14101?14>8;<8=2/601:58656 8)!+* 50 <86</46/> :./ <315=16:0 :./4/56 14/ :./ 3/713 4/24/0/6:1:5@/0 10 >/2/6>/6:0 8; >/</10/> 9357/==1 9357/==1 ?10 17/> 1A89: $* B/140 10 86 :./ >1:/ 8; :./ 1<<5>/6:1D56756:81<<896::./=86:.3B56<8=/8;>/</10/> 9357/==1 1: 0+!)+( 10 2/4 :./ 795>/356/0 8; :./
- 17 -
1461:1D1 :1:/ /713 /4@5</0 9:.845:B :./4/ 14/ ;894 >/2/6>/6:016>AB1223B5672482/4=93:5235/48;"102/4:./ '9>7=/6:8;:./86-A3/924/=/
894:56:./<10/8; &0924116>AB1>>567!)G:8?14>0;9:94/24802/<:0 10 2/4 :./ '9>7=/6: 56 :./ <10/ 8; $ 09241 >/>9<:567 $:. :8?14>0 ./4 2/408613 /E2/60/0 :./ <315=16:0 14//6:5:3/>;84<8=2/601:5868;0$##+!(+!)+I!)G E!E"E"$:8?14>038008;>/2/6>/6<B./4/14/;894 >/2/6>/6:016>:./4/;84/38008;<86084:59=500++++( 0$++++ E $ ./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/> ;84 0)+++( :8?14>038008;/0:1:/16>168:./40)+++(:8?14>0;96/413 /E2/60/0<<84>5673B:./<315=16:056 8)!+*14/ 7416:/><8=2/601:5861068:/>A/38? /1>0 =896: 5692//0 8008;>/2/6>/6<B $##+!++
8008;/0:1:/ )+++++
8008;<86084:59= ++++++
4160284:1:586J;96/413/E2/60/0 )+++++
8:13
*#+!++
- 18 -
!
608;14101?14>8;<8=2/601:58656 8!+* 50 <86</46/> :./ <315=16:0 :./4/56 14/ :./ 3/713 4/24/0/6:1:5@/010>/2/6>/6:08;>/</10/>1331==1?.8>5/> 1::./17/8;$*B/140>9/:8:./1<<5>/6:56H9/0:5861D567 56:8 1<<896: :./ =86:.3B 56<8=/ 8; >/</10/> 1331==1 1: 0+!)+(102/4:./795>/356/08;:./1461:1D1:1://713 /4@5</0 9:.845:B 16> 10 :./4/ 14/ ;894 >/2/6>/6:0 AB 1223B567 2482/4 =93:5235/4 8; " 10 2/4 :./ '9>7=/6: 8; :./ 86-A3/924/=/
894:56:./<10/8;&09241 16>AB1>>567;9:94/24802/<:0:8:.//E:/6:8;!)G102/4:./ '9>7=/6: 56 :./ <10/ 8; $ 09241 >/>9<:567 $:.:8?14>0./42/408613/E2/60/0:./<315=16:014//6:5:3/> ;84<8=2/601:5868;0$##+!(+!)+I!)GE!E"E
"$ :8?14>0 3800 8; >/2/6>/6<B 56</ :./4/ 14/ ;5@/ >/2/6>/6:0 3800 8; <86084:59= 50 0!+++++( 0$++++ E ) ./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/> ;84 0)+++(:8?14>03800 8;
/0:1:/ 16> 168:./4 0)+++( :8?14>0 ;96/413 /E2/60/0 <<84>5673B :./ <315=16:0 56 8)!+* 14/ 7416:/> <8=2/601:5861068:/>A/38? - 19 -
/1>0 =896: 5692//0
8008;>/2/6>/6<B $##+!++
8008;/0:1:/ )+++++
8008;<86084:59= !+++++++
4160284:1:586J;96/413/E2/60/0 )+++++
8:13
%!#+!++
" 6:./4/093:2100:./;8338?567
5 ./ 50</3316/890 540: 22/13 80!++#%!+!+ !++*!+! 16> !++*"!+! ;53/> AB :./
842841:586 14/ ./4/AB>50=500/> 55 ./<315=16:056 8$!+*14/./3>/6:5:3/> ;84 :8:13 <8=2/601:586 8; 0+)+( 10 171560:
0*)!$++( 1?14>/> AB :./ 45A9613 ?5:. 56:/4/0: 1: G 2/41669=;48=:./>1:/8;<315=2/:5:586:5334/135K1:586 555 ./<315=16:056 8)!+*14/./3>/6:5:3/> ;84 :8:13 <8=2/601:586 8; 0*#+!( 10 171560:
- 20 -
0!$++++(1?14>/>AB:./45A9613?5:.56:/4/0:1:G 2/41669=;48=:./>1:/8;<315=2/:5:586:5334/135K1:586 5@ ./<315=16:056 8!+*14/./3>/6:5:3/> ;84 :8:13 <8=2/601:586 8; 0%!#+!( 10 171560: 0!$++++(1?14>/>AB:./45A9613?5:.56:/4/0:1:G 2/41669=;48=:./>1:/8;<315=2/:5:586:5334/135K1:586 @ 6 133 8:./4 4/02/<:0 :./ '9>7=/6: 16> ?14> 2100/> AB :./ 45A9613 0.133 4/=156 56:1<: <<84>5673B :./ <8==86 '9>7=/6: 16> ?14> >1:/> !#+!+!+ 56
80$!+*)!+*16>!+*86:./;53/8;>>3 50:45<:16>/005860'9>7/16>
1:15<.940.1330:16> =8>5;5/> @5 ./ 1=896: 56 >/2805: 56 80!++#%!+!+ !++*!+! 16> !++*"!+! 0.133 A/ :4160=5::/> :8 :./ <86</46/>
.( %' # 01< 50: 8 3 8 "+