Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55131 (KAR)
THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (TECH) v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/204181/2025 · 2026-02-03
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55131 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55131 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" ##$
%&'! !#
() *
+
()
"
()
*
! "
"
! #$%&'( )
! '
"
"
! ! ! #$*((('
+
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! " #$%&'('
! #&%
! " #$%&'('
&
,
' -
#$%&'(
$
,
-
! "#$%'(
*
. !%
" #$%&'+/
! . !*%
%
. !*
0%
- 3 -
" #$%&'+/ )
! "
" '1
*%
++*
++
, . ! &('('%
('(+(++
! +
-#
, . ! &(/'++
+'(+(++
! +
-#'
, . ! &('('
('(+(++
! +
-#+
, . ! &('(''
+'(/+(++
! +
-#
, . ! &(/'+&
+'(+(++
! +
-#&
, . ! . .! ". #&%.+(++# +. #( ($(+(+ ! $
''( '*/.' &* *&.'
! "
-#! , . #
! +/('+(+$
! ,. .'+$ '+& '+
- 4 -
'++ '+(.+(+#+&
-#
+*
#
23! "
"
! #$%&'(
! '
"
"
! ! ! #$*((('
+
! " #$%&'('
! #&%
! " #$%&'('
- 5 -
&
,
' -
#$%&'(
$
. !$%
! . *#'#+/%'.'+"
"
"
"! #$*
! "
" '1
$
++*
++
, . #
! &'$(+% +'''+(++ ! +
-#
, . ! +/('+(+$! ! ,. .'+'.+(+#+&.*
-#
"*
- 6 -
#
23! "
"
! #$%&'(
! '
"
"
! ! ! #$*((('
+
! " #$%&'('
! #&%
! " #$%&'('
&
,
' -
#$%&'(
$
,
-
- 7 -
! "#$%'(
*
! . !*%
" #$%&'+/
! "
" '1
*
++*
++
, . ! &'$(+* +'''+(++ ! +
-# ! , . ! +/('+(+$! ! ,. .'+'
'+*.+(+#+&. -#
4! - 8 -
5676869:9:;<7=>6?:@6ABC956869:9:;<6>D5;:7956
=9:;<=@:E5D=C7F95;>:9C;?<A:=
+ 56 >:9 69:9:;< ;+(&'%'.+(+$ :7 ?:@6A 766G:<E9;HF=75956I;<J6>7:;<;>A6>7A=96A('(+(++ B6=>:<E
;&('('% +'(+(++ B6=>:<E
;&(/'++ ('(+(++ B6=>:<E
;&('(' +'(/+(++ B6=>:<E
;&('('' =<A +'(+(++ B6=>:<E ;&(/'+& J:A6 <<6KF>67'9;&>6786I9:J6@C8=776ABC>678;<A6<9
;+.956 68F9C ;LL:77:;<6> HF=75.769 =7:A6 956 =D=>A 8>;I66A:<E7 A=96A ($(+(+ B6=>:<E
;
. .! ". #&%.+(++#+.#( J:A6 <<6KF>6#!8=776ABC>678;<A6<9 ;$.95686I:=@
=<A IHF:7:9:;< ??:I6> =<A ;L8696<9 F95;>:9C ?;>
=<A IHF:7:9:;< =<A9;769=7:A6956=>B:9>=@=D=>AA=96A +/('+(+$ B6=>:<E
;
,.
.'+$ '+& '+ '++0'+(.+(+#+&.%/ J:A6 <<6KF>6# 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9 ;.956>B:9>=9;>=<A956AA:9:;<=@68F9C ;LL:77:;<6>
- 9 -
56 >:9 69:9:;< ;+(&'$/.+(+$ :7 ?:@6A 766G:<E 9; HF=75 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6> A=96A +'''+(++ B6=>:<E ;&'$(+% 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9 ;+ J:A6 <<6KF>6# =<A 9; 769 =7:A6 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A A=96A +/('+(+$ B6=>:<E
;
,. .'+'0'+*.+(+#+&.* J:A6<<6KF>6#8=776ABC>678;<A6<9 ;
& 56 >:9 69:9:;< ;+(((%.+(+* :7 ?:@6A 766G:<E 9; HF=75 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6> A=96A +'''+(++ B6=>:<E ;&'$(+* 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9 ;+ J:A6 <<6KF>6# =<A 9; 769 =7:A6 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A A=96A +/('+(+$ B6=>:<E
;
,. .'+'0'+*.+(+#+&. J:A6<<6KF>6#8=776ABC>678;<A6<9 ;
$ 9 :7 956 I;<96<9:;< ;? 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ L9 >F9: ?;> 956 869:9:;<6> 95=9 956 ;J6><L6<9 ;? <A:=95>;FE5:97:<:79>C;?;=A>=<78;>9=<A:E5D=C7 :77F6A <;9:?:I=9:;< B6=>:<E <FLB6> +( F<A6> 6I9:;<=;?956 =9:;<=@:E5D=C7I9'/$*?;>75;>9 2956 I9 ;? '/$*3 ;< (&('+(++ =88;:<9:<E >678;<A6<9
- 10 -
;&=7=I;L8696<9=F95;>:9C?;>=IHF:7:9:;<;?@=<A7?;> 9568>;M6I956?F>956>I;<96<A795=9;<+(%+(++J:A6 <;9:?:I=9:;<B6=>:<E<FLB6>/$&>678;<A6<9 ;$D=7 =88;:<96A :< 956 8@=I6 ;? >678;<A6<9 ;& =7 956 I;L8696<9 =F95;>:9C
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9;<956J6>C<6K9A=C:6;<+&(%+(++>678;<A6<9
;7* 9; % :< >:9 69:9:;< ;+(&'%'.+(+$ =88@:6A ?;> I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956:> @=<A7 B6=>:<E C ;7''( &* =<A * >6786I9:J6@C?;>I;LL6>I:=@F76
* 9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A BC 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ 95=9 ;< +'(/+(++ D:95:< @677 95=< = L;<95 ;? 956 =88@:I=9:;< L=A6 >678;<A6<9 ;+ D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E 956 8>;86> 8>;I6AF>6 8>67I>:B6A F<A6> 956 @=D E>=<96A I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A :< F>J6C ;* ?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76 56>6=?96> ;< +%(/+(++ >678;<A6<9 ;7* =<A =88@:6A ?;> I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A7 B6=>:<E C ;7'*/.' =<A &.' >6786I9:J6@C ?;> I;LL6>I:=@ F76 9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6ABC956@6=><6AI;F<76@95=9=E=:<:<@67795=<= L;<95D:95;F9?;@@;D:<E9568>;86>8>;I6AF>6>678;<A6<9
- 11 -
;+ E>=<96A I;<J6>7:;< ;? 956 @=<A7 :< F>J6C ;7''( =<A &* ?;> I;LL6>I:=@#=E>;#B=76A :<AF79>:67 F76 ;< ('(+(++=<A956@=<A7B6=>:<EC ;7'*/.'=<A&.' ?;>I;LL6>I:=@F76;<+'(+(++
9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 A678:96 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 5=J:<E B66< E>=<96A @677 95=< = L;<95 B6?;>6 8>6@:L:<=>C ;9:?:I=9:;< BF9 =?96> 956 8>;M6I9 :976@?
5=A B66<<;9:?:6A>678;<A6<9 ;$=776776A956<=9F>6;?956 @=<A7=IHF:>6A?>;L>678;<A6<9 ;7*9;%=7F<A6J6@;86A I;LL6>I:=@@=<A7=<AA696>L:<6A956L=>G69J=@F6;?956 7=L6 =7 7+$&.# 86> 7HF=>6 L696>7 :< >:9 69:9:;<
;+(&'%'.+(+$ =<A 7'&'.# 86>7HF=>6 L696>7 :< >:9 69:9:;<
;7+(&'$/.+(+$ =<A +(((%.+(+* =<A =II;>A:<E@C I;L86<7=9:;< D6>6 =D=>A6A ?;> 956 =IHF:>6A @=<A7 56 7=:A I;L86<7=9:;< =D=>A7 I=L6 9; B6 A:7BF>76A 9; >678;<A6<9 ;7* 9; % :< >:9 69:9:;<
;+(&'%'.+(+$ >678;<A6<9
;$ :< >:9 69:9:;<
;7+(&'$/.+(+$ =<A >678;<A6<9 ;* :< >:9 69:9:;<
- 12 -
+(((%.+(+* =<A 956 =D=>A 8>;I66A:<E7 I=L6 9; B6 8=776A;<($(+(+
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
/ 6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 =7 86> 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 >678;<A6<9 ;7* 9; % L=A6 =88@:I=9:;<7 ?;> I;<J6>7:;< ;<@C =?96> 956 <;9:?:I=9:;< :77F6A ;< (&('+(++ F<A6> 6I9:;< = ;? 956 I9 ;? - 13 -
'/$*9:7?F>956>I;<96<A6A95=9=>B:9>=@=D=>A7I=L69; B68=776A;<+/('+(+$
'(
6=><6A I;F<76@ J656L6<9@C I;<96<A7 95=9 956 I;<J6>7:;<;>A6>7=D=>A8>;I66A:<E7=<A=>B:9>=@=D=>A7 =>6 =@@ D:95;F9 MF>:7A:I9:;< =>B:9>=>C 86>J6>76 =<A =L;F<97 9; 7FBJ6>7:;< ;? 956 >F@6 ;? @=D 9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A95=9956:L8FE<6AI;<J6>7:;<;>A6>78=776ABC >678;<A6<9 ;+ =>6 D:95;F9 MF>:7A:I9:;< =7 :9 5=7 B66< 8=776A =?96> 956 :77F=<I6 ;? <;9:?:I=9:;< F<A6> 6I9:;< = ;? 956 I9 ;? '/$* 7; =@7; D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E AF6 8>;I677;?@=D56@6=><6AI;F<76@?F>956>I;<96<A795=9 :9 :7 =88=>6<9@C I@6=> 95=9 956 F>E6<IC :< D5:I5 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 5=J6 B66< 8=776A D:95:< @677 95=< = L;<95 ;? 956 =88@:I=9:;< 5=J:<E B66< L=A6 D:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<EAF68>;I677=<A8>;I6AF>6;?@=D=<A<;2 3 5=7B66<;B9=:<6A?>;L ;>?>;L9569=96956 6<9:>6 8>;I677 ;? I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 =<A 956 =D=>A7 =>6 @:=B@69;B6769=7:A69:7=@7;I;<96<A6ABC956I;F<76@ 95=9956=D=>A78=776A;<956B=7:7;?9567=:AI;<J6>7:;<
- 14 -
;>A6>7D6>6:<@67795=<;<6L;<958>:;>9;956A=96;?956 8>6@:L:<=>C ;9:?:I=9:;< A696>L:<67 956 ?>=FA 8@=C6A D:95 I;@@F7:;<=<A<6KF7;?956=F95;>:9:679:7I;<96<A6A95=9 >678;<A6<9 ; ;FE59 9; 5=J6 <;9:I6A 95=9 956 I@=:L ;? 956@=<A75=J:<EB66<I;<J6>96A?;>I;LL6>I:=@F76:7<;9 679=B@:756A :< 956 @:E59 ;?
956 I;<J6>7:;< 5=J:<E B66< E>=<96A 7D:?9@C :< @677 95=< ;<6 L;<95 ?>;L 956 A=96 ;? 8>6@:L:<=>C ;9:?:I=9:;<
''
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 >678;<A6<9 ;5=7?=:@6A9;=88@C5:7L:<A9;956?=I97 =<A I:>IFL79=<I67 956 :L8FE<6A I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 B=>7 956 A6J6@;8L6<9 ;? 956 @=<A7 D:95:< &( L696>7 ;? 956 I6<96> ;? ;? 9=96 :E5D=C.
=9:;<=@ :E5D=C 9 :7 ?F>956> I;<96<A6A 95=9 >678;<A6<9 ; I;F@A <;9 5=J6 9>6=96A 956 @=<A7 =7 A6J6@;86A I;LL6>I:=@ @=<A7 :< 956 =B76<I6 ;? =<C 7=<I9:;< 8@=< ?>;L 956 I;L8696<9 =F95;>:9C;>:<956=B76<I6;?8>;;?;?=<CA6J6@;8L6<9;? 956 @=<A7 56>6?;>6 756 I;<96<A7 95=9 956 6<9:>6
- 15 -
A696>L:<=9:;< ;? 956 J=@F6 ;? 956 7;#I=@@6A A6J6@;86A @=<A7=>6=>B:9>=>CD:95;F9=<CB=7:7
'+
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 L6>6@C B6I=F76 =>B:9>=@ 869:9:;<7 ?:@6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> =>6 >6M6I96A;<956E>;F<A;?956CB6:<EB=>>6ABC@:L:9=9:;< 956 7=L6 D:@@ <;9 A68>:J6 956 869:9:;<6> ?>;L I5=@@6<E:<E 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 L=A6 :< = 5=79C L=<<6> D:95 A6@:B6>=96:<96<99;L=G6F<@=D?F@E=:<<7F88;>9;?56> I=767565=78@=I6A>6@:=<I6;<956?;@@;D:<EMFAEL6<971 : ! " #$%
&
'( :: )*+ ,! ! - !* .,!$%
&'
' @6=><6AI;F<76@>:=5=<9675=9:@ =886=>:<E?;>>678;<A6<9 ;7*9;%J656L6<9@CI;<96<A7 95=9 =9 956 ;F9769 956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 D;F@A <;9 B6 L=:<9=:<=B@6 6:956> :< @=D ;> ;< ?=I97 =<A 956 7=L6 A676>J69;B6A:7L:776AD:95;F9A6@J:<E?F>956>;<L6>:97
- 16 -
6 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> 7F88>677:<E 956 L=96>:=@ ?=I97 5=7 =88>;=I56A 95:7 ;F>9 D:95;F9 I@6=< 5=<A7 956>6BC :9 :7 =< =BF76 ;? 8>;I677 ;? @=D
6=><6A I;F<76@?F>956>I;<96<A795=9956I5=@@6<E6:7L=A6BC956 869:9:;<6>9;956;>A6>7;?I;<J6>7:;<=<A956I5=@@6<E69;
956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 :< 95676 869:9:;<7 D5:I5 =E=:< :7 <;9 7F79=:<=B@6 6 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> :7 5=J:<E <; 9; I5=@@6<E6 956 ;>A6>7 ;? I;<J6>7:;< BC I;<96<A:<E 95=9 956 =?;>67=:A @=<A7 =>6 =AM=I6<9 9; 956 J:@@=E6 =<A 956>6 =>6 I;LL6>I:=@ A6J6@;8L6<9 7F>>;F<A:<E 956 @=<A7 9 :7 =@7; I;<96<A6A 95=9956@=<A7=>65=J:<E 8;96<9:=@:9C9567=L6D6>6 I;<J6>96A;<+'(/+(++('(+(++=<A+'(+(+(6 =@7;A6<:6795=9956;>A6>7;?I;<J6>7:;<78=776AD:95;F9 ?;@@;D:<E AF6 8>;I677 ;? @=D =<A 9=G67 F8 = I;<96<9:;< 95=9956;>A6>78=776AF<A6>6I9:;</$;?956"=><=9=G= =<A 6J6<F6 I9 =>6 =L6<=B@6 9; I5=@@6<E6 B6?;>6 956 >:BF<=@ F<A6> 6I9:;< &/I ;? 956 "=><=9=G=
=<A
- 17 -
6J6<F6I9;<95:7E>;F<A=@7;9568>676<9869:9:;<7=>6 @:=B@69;B6A:7L:776A
'&
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> 956 >678;<A6<97 ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 :L8FE<6A =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 A=96A +/('+(+$ D6>6 =@>6=AC I5=@@6<E6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> BC D=C ;?
>B:9>=9:;< 69:9:;< ;7+%.+(+$ =<A +/.+(+$ F<A6> 6I9:;< & ;? 956 I9 ;? '//* B6?;>6 956 >:<I:8=@ :79>:I9FAE6=:I5F>56>B:9>=9:;<69:9:;<7I=L69;
B6 A:7L:776A J:A6 ;>A6> A=96A (''++(+$ =7 B=>>6A BC 956 @=D ;? @:L:9=9:;< 56>6?;>6 56 I;<96<A7 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> 5=J:<E ?=:@6A F<A6> 6I9:;< & ;? 956 I9 ;? '//* I=<<;9 :<J;G6 956 D>:9 MF>:7A:I9:;< F<A6> >9:I@67 ++* =<A++ ;?956;<79:9F9:;< ;?<A:==7 956 7=L6:7 :L86>L:77:B@6
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 F8;< A:7L:77=@ ;? 956 =>B:9>=9:;< 869:9:;<7 ?:@6A F<A6> 6I9:;< & ;? 956 I9 ;? '//* 956 869:9:;<6> 5=7 <;9 B;956>6A9;?:@6=<=886=@F<A6>6I9:;<;?956I9;? '//*
- 18 -
'$ 9:7=@7;I;<96<A6A95=9956869:9:;<6>?:@6A956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 ;<@C D:95 = :<96<9 9; =J;:A A68;7:9;?I;L86<7=9:;<:<9566K6IF9:;<869:9:;<786<A:<E B6?;>6956>:<I:8=@:79>:I9FAE6=:I5F>56>6?;>656 I;<96<A7 95=9 9; I:>IFLJ6<9 =@@ 95676 79=9F9;>C B=>7 ;? @:L:9=9:;< =<A 956 I;<76HF6<I67 ;? <;9 5=J:<E B66< 7FII677?F@ 956 8>676<9 D>:9 869:9:;<7 =>6 ?:@6A D5:I5 :7 6K8>677@C8>;5:B:96ABC7699@6A@=D:<I=96<=;?MFAEL6<97 ;? 956 ;<3B@6 86K ;F>9
6=><6A I;F<76@
?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956>6 :7 <; :@@6E=@:9C :< 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 7; =@7; :< 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9 ;+?=9=@@956869:9:;<6>5=7=<CE>:6J=<I6 D:95>6E=>A9;A:7L:77=@;?956=>B:9>=@869:9:;<79567=L6 D;F@A5=J69;B6I5=@@6<E6A:<956L=<<6>G<;D<9;@=D F<A6>6I9:;<;?956I9;?'//*=J:<E<;9A;<67; 9568>676<9869:9:;<7=>6<;9L=:<9=:<=B@6
'*
6=><6A I;F<76@ ?F>956> I;<96<A7 95=9 956 ;<3B@6 86K ;F>9 :< 956 I=76 ;? /0 #1!! 2* ! ,- 2* $%
&
3 ' 5=7
- 19 -
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
6=><6A I;F<76@ :< 7F88;>9 ;? 5:7 I=76 5=7 =@7; >6@:6AF8;<956?;@@;D:<EMFAEL6<971 : 8 ( ! + 9 2* $%
&': :: 8!16 !9;619 $% & 3':
- 20 -
::: 8 ! !5 <1* $% & ': :J =# !)=5*$% &': J 9;6197</ !8<! )1.$#2
<
': J: 97/ !#!161 2$% &,2<
': J::
8+> /+0! ! <5$ ,2<3'( J::: =# ! = )1.00 $
,2< '
' 56>6?;>6 56 I;<96<A7 95=9 ;< 956 B=7:7 ;? 95676 MFAEL6<97 =<A 956 ?=I97 =<A I:>IFL79=<I67 ;? 956 I=76 D56< 956 869:9:;<6> 5=J:<E ?=:@6A 9; I5=@@6<E6 956 A:7L:77=@ ;>A6> F<A6> 6I9:;< & ;? 956 I9 ;?
'//* 956 8>676<9869:9:;<7D;F@A <;9 7F>J:J6 ?;> I;<7:A6>=9:;< 956 7=L6=>6@:=B@69;B6A:7L:776A
- 21 -
'% =J:<E 56=>A 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> 956 8=>9:67 956 8;:<9 95=9 =>:767 ?;> I;<7:A6>=9:;< :7 =7 9; D56956>9568>676<9869:9:;<7=>6L=:<9=:<=B@6
'/ 9 :7 <;9 :< A:78F96 95=9 956 869:9:;<6> :7 <;D HF679:;<:<E 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 8=776A BC >678;<A6<9
;+ =<A 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 88=>6<9@C D56< 956 869:9:;<6> D=7 <;9 7FII677?F@ :< I5=@@6<E:<E 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7 B6?;>6 956 >:<I:8=@ :79>:I9 =<A 677:;<7 FAE6 =:I5F> =<A 5=J:<E <;9 ?:@6A =< =886=@ =7 I;<96L8@=96A F<A6> 6I9:;< ;? 956 I9 ;? '//* <;D 9>C:<E 9;
I5=@@6<E6 956 =D=>A7 =<A 956 I;<J6>7:;< ;>A6>7 :< LC 5FLB@6 ;8:<:;< D;F@A <;9 B6 7F79=:<=B@6 7; =@7; 956 869:9:;<7 ?:@6A BC 956 869:9:;<6> I5=@@6<E:<E 956 =>B:9>=@ =D=>A7D;F@A<;9B6L=:<9=:<=B@6B6?;>695:7;F>9:<D>:9 MF>:7A:I9:;<F<A6>>9:I@67++*=<A++;?956;<79:9F9:;< ;? <A:= 56;<3B@6 86K;F>9 :< 956 I=76;?+ #1!! 7F8>= =9 8=>=E>=85 ;7+ =<A 56@A =7 F<A6>
- 22 -
! " ! 8 ( + 9 2 #$
% &#$ '
( ! ( ) *'
+
"* , ( ! -
"#
. ( ! /)(! ( ! "* (
! ! (!(
! - 23 -
0
( ! '
+
(
! ( )* '
&
+( < 956 I=76 ;? + =?.! 1. # !+4 ,!$% & '7 956 ;<3B@6 86K ;F>9 =9 8=>=E>=85
;7''=<A'+56@A=7F<A6> //! 1 (
! 2 1 1
( ) ' 1 ( ! 2 '
1
- 24 -
( ) '
1 ( ! 2
1
2(
! 2(
/+ ( ) '
1
(
! 2
3
1 14
+' 56 ;<3B@6 86K ;F>9 :< 956 I=76 ;? .19*0. !8+) +02*$ ,2' =98=>=E>=85 ;7&=<A$56@A=7F<A6> #
$( (
( (
. '
5
678 9::;/$*:)
(
)
* 1
(
- 25 -
(
1
,3
! 1
,3 $! < ,
(
! ):= , 4 ;=@7;:<956I=76;?9+6!+!!2* ! " !! 6!16*0.2* ( ,!7 $% &
3' 956 ;<3B@6 F8>6L6 ;F>9=98=>=E>=85 ;7+=<A56@A=7F<A6> * >
1 ? @2@ @
@'
? ?2? ? ? .
"#(AB(C'(
- 26 -
(
? ?2? @ @(
2
? ?2? @
? @' 0
7 (9 ; D
%. &7
! 8
,
6
)A #
& *" 1 5
9 ;
- 27 -
0 9)#'(/#);
C 6
E'A #
< F 9 ;
? @
' A 69 ;
4
++ 56;<3B@686K;F>9:<956I=76;?! +1!2* !/;0+!! 2*$ # '=98=>=E>=85 ;7'&9; '*56@A=7F<A6>
/#' ( ! :G/::#
- 28 -
? @ 2 ? . 1 A+./
' 3
1
3 13
( )2* 3
9 ; 9 ;
3
! %. &9 ; '
9 ;
9 ; C1 3
9 ; '
1 3
( )2*
- 29 -
91; ! 1 ?1 ? ? ? 91; C
& /$' > ( )2*? ? 9 ;
91;
( ! /)+ ,
! + ! ! (
.1
! - 30 -
! > >
.1 ! 1
1
>
2 1
+ =J:<E 56=>A 956 @6=><6A I;F<76@ ?;> B;95 956 8=>9:67=<A5=J:<EI;<7:A6>6A956MFAEL6<97>6@:6ABC956 @6=><6AI;F<76@?;>956869:9:;<6>@6=><6AI;F<76@?;>956 >678;<A6<97 =<A 956 MFAEL6<97>6@:6ABC95:7;F>9:9:7 =88=>6<9@C 766< 95=9 956 8>676<9 869:9:;<7 :< D5=97;6J6> L=<<6>D;F@A<;9B6L=:<9=:<=B@6=7956869:9:;<6>D;F@A <;9B66<9:9@6A9;L=:<9=:<956D>:9869:9:;<7F<A6>>9:I@67 ++* =<A ++ ;? 956 ;<79:9F9:;< ;? <A:= D56< :9 5=7 =@>6=AC 7F??6>6A =< ;>A6> F<A6> 6I9:;< & ;? 956 I9 ;? '//* 6<I6 956 8>676<9 D>:9 869:9:;<7 =>6 <;9 L=:<9=:<=B@6 =7 95676 =>6 B=>>6A BC @=D 7; =@7; 956 8>676<9 D>:9 869:9:;<7 I=<<;9 B6 6<96>9=:<6A 9; I;<7:A6> ;956> 8>=C6>7 ;? 956 869:9:;<7 :6 ;>A6>7 ;? I;<J6>7:;<
- 31 -
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
= 56 >:9 69:9:;<7 =>6 A6J;:A ;?
L6>:9 II;>A:<E@C79=<AA:7L:776A B >A6>6A=II;>A:<E@C !,* ( !#) '
' '