- 1 - !!" #$%% $ & &'() &( )* $ $ $ + ) * ! ! " "# ! $%&% '( ! ) ! " Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! %"& ! &" ! * "" ( "'" "'" ! ! !! &% %(%"(% # ( ! #& ("(%'%' '# ( !( ! ! ! ! ! ) * $'&'&! $%''+& ! ! " "# , ! $%&% '( ! ) ! " ! &" ! - 3 - %"& ! * "" ( " "'" ! ! !! &% % (%"(% # ( ! #&("( %'%' '# ( !( ! ! ! ! ! ) * (& "$ $&( "' * $%& "( ! ! " "# ! $%&% '( ! ) ! " ! %"& ! &" ! * "" ( "'" "'" ! ! !! - 4 - &% % (%" (% # ( ! #& ("( %' %' '# ( ! ( ! ! ! ! ! +) * - (& "$ $&( "' *$%& "" ! ! " "# ! $%&% '( ! ) ! " ! &" ! %"& ! * "" ( " "'" ! ! !! &% % (%"(% # ( ! #&("( %'%' '# ( !( ! ! - 5 - ! ! ! ! , , . /010 203434561 780 94:0; <6;08 0=3456 %"& 59 /78734>7 7?784@ <87@1/7 76/437 "'"( 35 A<71/ 3/0 285=00;46?1 7?74613 3/0 20343456081 7==<10; 51" % 76; 46 5 "" ( "'" 784146? 5<3 59 84B0 5 "'"80?413080;C>5B065:4=07:7C<87?443> 958 3/0 59906=01 2<641/7C:0 <6;08 0=34561 #& ("( %'%' '#807;D43/0=3456 #5976;0=34561( 76;595D8>85/4C43456=3 # E958C80F43>G3/0 =3HI 206;46? 56 3/0 94:0 $;;434567: 4F4: <;?0 76; !7:7C<87?4 " /0 97=3<7: B7384J 59 3/0 =710 41 3/73 801256;063 5" 46 3/010 203434561 B78840; 560 @/4:01/ 407==<10;5 56 ('("'"(33/034B059B78847?0 3/0278063159801256;0635"?7F0'35:7159?5:;&' - 6 - 35:715914:F0876;=71/591 %''''' $71;5D8>9308 3/0 B78847?0 801256;063 5" 137830; 35 8014;0 =58;47::> 7:56? D43/ /08 /<1C76; 76; 46$:7D1 958 7 20845; 59 & B563/1 /08079308 3/010 20343456081 7:56? D43/ /08 /<1C76; 7==<10;5 137830;/7871146?801256;0635" 9587;;434567:;5D8>563/028030J33/733/0>/7F0;0C359 1"''''''' $ <0 35 4635:087C:0 /78711B063 B030; 5<3C>7==<10;5 76;46$:7D1801256;0635"90::14=@ 76;56'%' "'" 63/73;7>7==<10;5 :093/0873 /082780637:/5B0/0807930856'#' "'"D/061/0 803<860; 35 /08 B7384B5647: /5B0 7:: 3/010 7==<10; 20343456081 801387460; /08 985B 0630846? 3/0 B7384B5647:/5B076;46138<=30;/083/73491/0417C:035 C846?7;;434567:;5D8>56:>3/063/0>D4:::03/083506308 3/0B7384B5647:/5B011<=/:093D43/6553/08523456 1/0803<860;35/082780637:/5B0 ( 730856'"'""'"1/056=07?746F41430;/08 B7384B5647: /5B0 7:56? D43/ /08 2780631 3 3/73 34B0 7:: 3/0 7==<10; 2081561 C> 46134?7346? 7==<10; 5 - 7 - 24=@0; <2 A<7880: D43/ 801256;063 5" 76; 3/080C> 7==<10; 5 7117<:30; /08 76; 53/08 7==<10; 5<387?0; /08B5;013>76;954130;:4903/807335/0806=0:093D43/ 65 53/08523456 1/0 56=0 7?746803<860; 35 /082780637: /5<10 76; 137830; 8014;46? 7:56? D43/ /08 2780631 <C10A<063:> 1/0 :5;?0; 7 =5B2:7463 C09580 801256;063 5 $5:4=0 56 '%'"'" /0 17B0 D71 80?413080; 46 84B0 5 "'" 7308 801256;063 5 K5:4=0 46F0134?730;3/0=71076;:74;=/78?01/0037?746137::3/0 7==<10; 46=:<;46? 3/010 20343456081 C> 7887>46? 3/0B 71 7==<10; 51" % 76; ==58;46?:> 3/0 :07860; 7?4138730 355@ =5?64L76=0 59 3/0 59906=01 06=0 3/0 20343456081 7==<10;51"%76;780C095803/415<83 40 46 84B467: 0343456 5"'"'## "'"%$7==<10; 5" 84B467: 0343456 5"'" '( "'"%$7==<10; 5 84B467: 0343456 5"'" '" "'"%$7==<10; 5% 76; 84B467: 0343456 5"'" ' "'"%$7==<10; 5 35 A<71/ 3/0 285=00;46?17?746133/0B - 8 - 078; :07860; =5<610: 958 3/0 20343456081 15 7:15 :07860; ;;434567: 3730 <C:4= 8510=<358 958 801256;063 5 K 3730 76; :07860; =5<610: 958 801256;0635"467::3/0203434561 % 07860;=5<610:9583/020343456081467::3/010 203434561C>8043087346?3/0?85<6;1<8?0;463/0203434561 =56306;0;3/737==<10;5418014;46?7306?7:<8<76; 7==<10;5176;%7808014;46?7346?71<?<8711<=/ 3/0>7806531/7846?3/0=5BB568559D43/7==<10;51 35(61<=/=48=<B1376=013/07::0?7345617?746133/0B 7805B64C<17::0?734561463/0=5B2:746376;53/08=/78?0 1/003 B730847:1 ==58;46?:> /0 287>1 35 7::5D 3/0 203434561 :07860;=5<610:958801256;0635" 76; :07860; ;;: 522510; 3/0 203434561 76; =56306;0;3/733/5<?/7==<10;5176;%7808014;46? 73 46?71<?<8 7==<10; 5 C046? 3/0 141308 59 7==<10; 5 41 8014;46? 46 /08 2780631 /5<10 7:56? D43/ 7==<10; 51 35 (46 3/01/780;8559 7:56? D43/ /08 156 D/541 - 9 - 7;B4330;467=/55:737:7C<87?4/0>7:15=56306;0; 3/73 801256;063 5" 41 807;> 35 M546 3/0 B7384B5647: /5B0 C<3 56:> C0=7<10 59 7==<10; 51" 35 1/0 41 <67C:0 35 =56346<0 /08 B78437: 80:734561/42 D43/ 7==<10; 5 ==58;46?:>3/0>287>35;41B4113/0203434561 + /7F0?4F06B>76J45<1=5614;0873456C53/56 3/0 1<CB4114561 B7;0 C> 3/0 :07860; =5<610: 958 3/0 80120=34F0278340176;3/0063480=/78?01/003B730847:1 & 1 =5<:; C0 ?73/080; 985B 80=58;1 3/0 80:734561/42 C03D006 801256;063 5" 76; 3/010 203434560814165346;412<303417:1565346;412<303/73 793083/0B78847?0597==<10;5 D43/801256;0635" 3/0>C53/137830;8014;46?463/0B7384B5647:/5B063/0 174; B7384B5647: /5B0 7==<10; 5" 40 2034345608 46 84B467:03434565"'"'## "'"%76;7==<10;5(D080 8014;46?/5<?/4341=56306;0;C>:07860;=5<610:9583/0 20343456081 3/73 7==<10; 5 41 8014;46? 7:56? D43/ 7==<10; 5% 73 46?71<?<8 3/0 =/78?0 1/003 B730847:1 80F07: 3/73 1/0 /71 7:15 0A<7::> 27834=42730; 46 3/0 - 10 - /78711B06335801256;0635"7:56?D43/7==<10;51 35( # 5805F084341=56306;0;C>:07860;=5<610:958 3/0801256;0631 3/73 7==<10; 5 41 8014;46? 7:56? D43/ /08 2780631 46 /08 2780637: /5B0 76; /08 156 41 7:15 137>46? 73 7:7C<87?4 /0 13730B063 59 B730847: D43601101463/0=/78?01/003=:078:>80F07:13/737==<10; 51 35 /787110; 801256;063 5" 76; 4BB0;4730:> 79308 14J B563/1 1/0 D71 3/85D6 5<3 985B 3/0 B7384B5647: /5B0 /5<?/ 1/0 3840; 35 M546 3/0 B7384B5647: /5B0 7==<10; 51" 35 780 653 7::5D46? /0835=56346<03/0B78437:80:734561/42D43/7==<10;5 $ /<1C76;61<=/=48=<B1376=046B>=5614;080;5246456 3/080780 B730847:12:7=0;463/0=/78?01/003 7?746137==<10;51 35 ' 5D0F08 4615978 71 7==<10; 51% 76; 780 =56=0860;407==<10;5%/<1C76;597==<10;541 8014;46? 73 46?7<1?<8 76; 7==<10; 5 D/5 41 3/0 C853/08597==<10;5 418014;46?7306?7:<8<76;3/0> - 11 - 7806531/7846?3/0=5BB568559/07::0?7345617?74613 3/0B 46 3/0 =/78?0 1/003 780 5B64C<1 7::0?734561 76; D43/5<376>1<=/1<C1376347:B730847: 6 1<=/=48=<B1376=01 3/0 285=00;46?1 =76653 C0=56346<0;7?746137==<10;51%76;71:74;;5D6C> 3/0 56.C:0 20J 5<83 46 3/0 =710 59 ! "#" $ % & '""%( #") ) $ *"8025830; 46 + , -. 73 2787?872/ 5 /0:; 3/73 3/0 5<83 1/5<:; C0 =7809<:46285=00;46?7?746133/0;41376380:734F0146=84B01 208374646?35B7384B5647:;412<30176;;5D8>;073/1/0 80:734F01 59 3/0 /<1C76; 1/5<:; 653 C0 8520;$46 56 3/0 C7141 59 5B64C<1 7::0?734561 <6:011 120=494= 461376=0 59 3/048 46F5:F0B063 46 3/0 =84B0 780 B7;0 5<3 3 41 7:15 1033:0; 25143456 59 :7D 3/73 49 7 20815641 B7;0 35 97=0 7 =84B467: 3847: 56 15B0 ?06087: 76; 1D00246? 7::0?734561 D43/5<3 C846?46? 56 80=58; 76> 120=494= 461376=01 59 =84B467:=56;<=34341653/46?C<37C<1059285=011593/0 5<83 /0 5<831 2510 7 ;<3> 35 1<CM0=3 3/0 7::0?73456 - 12 - :0F0::0;463/0=5B2:74633573/585<?/1=8<346>35946;5<3 D/03/08 3/080 41 76> ?746 59 38<3/ 46 3/0 7::0?734561 58 D/03/08 3/0> 780 B7;0 56:> D43/ 3/0 15:0 5CM0=3 59 46F5:F46? =083746 46;4F4;<7:1 46 7 =84B467: =/78?0 B580 27834=<:78:> D/06 7 28510=<3456 78410 985B 7 B7384B5647: ;412<30 " !<83/083/056HC:0 20J5<83 46 3/0 =71059 "/*)& "% ! 8025830;46 010/0:;46278751"%76;"&71<6;08, ! " # $% & $' - 13 - $' $% ( 2) !*+, # ! ( - . ! *+, # / . " 0 ! ..!*+, # . #- # 1 ( 3411033:0;2514345659:7D3/735<831/7F035 C0=7809<:76;=7<345<146;07:46?D43/=5B2:746376;B<13 37@0 287?B734= 807:43401 4635 =5614;0873456 D/4:0 ;07:46? D43/ B7384B5647: ;412<301 D/080 3/0 7::0?734561 /7F0 35 - 14 - C01=8<3464L0;D43/?8073=78076;=48=<B120=34564658;08 35280F063B41=78847?059M<134=076;7C<1059285=01159 5<83 5D0F08 71 ;41=<110; 3/080 780 B730847:19583/=5B46?4615978717==<10;51 35 /06=03/0285=00;46?17?746133/0B=76653C0A<71/0; /0 =56346<73456 59 285=00;46?1 7?74613 7==<10; 51% 76; 41 653/46? C<3 7C<10 59 285=011 59 5<83 ==58;46?:>285=00;3527113/095::5D46?, 4 84B467: 0343456 5"'"'## "'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10; 5" 76; 84B467: 20343456 5"'" '( "'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10; 5 780$&)&$ 44 84B467: 0343456 5"'" '" "'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10; 5% 76; 84B467: 0343456 5"'" ' "'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10; 5 780 3$ 444 /0 285=00;46?1 7?74613 3/0 20343456081 7==<10; 51% 76; 46 - 15 - 5 "" ( "'"784146?5<35984B0 5 "'"80?413080;C>5B065:4=0 7:7C<87?4 43> 958 3/0 59906=01 2<641/7C:0 <6;08 0=34561 #& ("( %' %' '# 807; D43/ 0=3456 # 59 76; 0=34561 ( 76; 59 5D8> 85/4C43456=3 # 206;46?563/094:0 ;;434567: 4F4: <;?0 76; ! 7:7C<87?441/080C>A<71/0; ,) &%( % 4135, :5,(% $