- 1 - ! "#"$ %#!! ! !!&& '!( ) ! !! ""#$%! & !' ( $! ) ( "$ ! !)!** ""$+*! *! , ' ! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - -"++"*! #! + ! ' ( ! ! ""*.*! & ' $/ !! ' *( # .( ) *+ $* *+*" ) ' !$+*+$% ) ! ) ' 0 ! !! # $! 123 455647 23 58696886: ;< =16 5742>=299 2> ?!$+*+$% ?> =16 9276 ?9 =16 48>4=4@4 )4A9 82;B>47 - 3 - 474;B84C2 2D232?> 4= 474;B84C2 9?8 31?8= E=16 =82;B>47F( G14776>C2>C =16 8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" H16862> =16 82;B>47 477?H6: =16 I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>= ?!$ 4>: :23I2336:=163B2=1?7:2>C=14==165742>=29923>?=6>=2=76:=? G?>=2>B6 43 4 B=4H4772 49=68 =16 6J528< ?9 =16 ?8:68 :4=6: *.!+!*+*K54336:;<=16G?I56=6>=?48:! *! 676D4>=94G=39?84:LB:2G4=2?>?9=123455647486 =14==1648C414M484= 147294= 8 416I4>414I4= 774 724 B>>2( 47@16: G742I3 =? ;6 4> 2>3=2=B=2?> 14D2>C G68=42> 58?568=263!16 5742>=299 2>3=2=B=2?> 23 8658636>=6: ;< 2=3 4LL4:4 4312> 4>: B=4H4772 - <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82?!B8=BM4B4:826684314B4:828632:6>=?9 474;B84C2! 16 5742>=299 143 9276: 3B2= 366@2>C :6G7484=2?> H2=1 G?>36AB6>=247 867269 ?9 56856=B47 4>: I4>:4=?8< 2>LB>G=2?> 2> 86356G= ?9 =16 3B2= 58?568=263 4C42>3= =16 :696>:4>=3! = 23 4D6886: 4= 5484C8451 ?!K ?9 =16 5742>= =14=<6:141B3=494B4:8223>?=?>7<4B=4H4772?9=16 5742>=299F3 2>3=2=B=2?> ;B= 473? 4 4LL4:4 4312> G742I2>C 2>1682=4;76 82C1= 2> 86356G= ?9 =16 3G16:B76: 58?568=< I6>=2?>6:2>=165742>=!B82>C=1656>:6>G<?9=163B2==16 - 4 - :696>:4>= ?! $ 143 9276: I6I? :4=6: *K!+%!*+*" 3=4=2>C =14= =16 <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 H1? 143 ;66> 455?2>=6: ;< =16 =4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 4>C47?86 43 B=4H4772 H43 9?8 4 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 4>: 34I6 H43 G?>G7B:6:;<6997BJ?9=2I6?>*!+!*+*"4>:=16869?86=16 342: <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 G4>>?= ;6 568I2==6: =? G?>=2>B6 =16 58?G66:2>C3 2> =16 3B2= 4>: 143 =16869?86 3?BC1=9?8:23I23347?9=163B2=! #! 16 342: I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>= ?! $ H43 ?55?36:;<=165742>=299!1682;B>4749=68G?>32:682>C=16 I4=68247 ?> 86G?8: ;< 2=3 ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" 477?H6: =16 I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>= ?! $ 4>: 43 3BG1 :23I2336: =16 3B2= 9276: ;< =16 5742>=299 2>3=2=B=2?> ?> =16 C8?B>: =14= =16 <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 H1? 143 8658636>=6: =16 5742>=2992>3=2=B=2?>23>?I?864B=4H4772?9=16>3=2=B=2?> 43 =16 34I6 H43 G?>G7B:6: ;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6! 6672>C 4CC826D6: ;< =16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" =16 5742>=29914358696886:=123455647! - 5 - K! 648: 82! 4G12> ! 414L4> 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= 82! I66=@BI48 63154>:6 7648>6: 6>2?8 ?B>367 4556482>C ?> ;61479 ?9 82! 8B>@BI48 I48CB>:4554 9?8 8635?>:6>= ?!$ 4>: 82! !!47254=277648>6:G?B>3679?8=168635?>:6>=?!*! "! 82! 4G12> ! 414L4> 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 5742>=299 48CB6: =14= =16 82;B>47 143 G?II2==6:4>688?82>:23I2332>C=166>=2863B2=?>I682=3!= 23G?>=6>:6:=14==1?BC1=16AB63=2?>;69?86=1682;B>4743 =? G454G2=< ?9 =16 342: 4LL4:4 4312> 4>: B=4H4772 4>: =16869?86=1682;B>47?BC1=>?==?14D6:23I2336:=163B2= H2=1?B=G?>32:682>C=1694G=B474356G=3?>86G?8:?>I682=3! =23473?48CB6:;<82!4G12>!414L4>7648>6:G?B>367 ;<8696882>C=?=1658?D232?>G?>=42>6:B>:686G=2?>#@(?9 =16 )4@9 G= $.." 16862>49=68 8696886: =? 43 EG=F( H16862> =16 :692>2=2?> 43 =? =16 N5683?> 2>=6863=6: 2> 4 O)4@9PF 2>G7B:63 =16 4LL4:4 4312>! 16869?86 16 G?>=6>:6: =14= =16 82;B>47 ?BC1= =? 14D6 477?H6: <6: 141B3=494B4:82=?;68658636>=6:4344LL4:44312> - 6 - 4>: B=4H4772 9?8 =16 5742>=29903 2>3=2=B=2?> 4>: =16869?86 3?BC1=9?82>=689686>G6?9=123 ?B8=! ! =23473?48CB6:;<=167648>6:G?B>3674556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= ;< 8696882>C =? =16 58?D232?> G?>=42>6: B>:686G=2?>#*(?9=16G=H16862>2=233=4=6:=14=4>< B=4H4772?85683?>2>=6863=6:2>=16)4@9G4>I42>=42>=16 3B2==?58?=6G==162>=6863=?9=162>3=2=B=2?>433BG14>:=? =14=6J=6>==1682;B>471436886:2>4882D2>C4=4G?>G7B32?> =?G7?36=163B2=2=36794>:=16869?863?BC1=9?82>=689686>G6 ?9=163B2=! %! 82! 4G12> ! 414L4> 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= 9B8=168 48CB6: =14= =16 48>4=4@4 =4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 4>C7?86 ;< ?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*"6J=6>:6:=165682?:?9?>6<648?9B=4H4772?9 =164556774>= >3=B=2=2?> <6:141B3=494B4:824>:3BG1 ?=16832I27487<574G6:2>3=2=B=2?>3H1?36=68I23=?6J5286?> ?849=68+$3=BCB3=*+*"4>:=16869?862=23G?>=6>:6:=14= =16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68 54336: ;< =16 =82;B>47 86AB2863 =? ;6 2>=689686:H2=12>=123455647! - 7 - ! 68G?>=8482!I66=@BI4863154>:67648>6: 6>2?8 ?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>= ?!$ ;< 8696882>C =? =16 ?8:68 :4=6: *.!+!*+*K 54336: ;< =16 48>4=4@4 =4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 4>C47?86 4>: G?>=6>:6: =14==165682?:?9B=4H4772 <6:141B3=494B4:82H43 9?845682?:?9?>6<6484>:433BG12>=68I3?9B76"K"( ?9 =16 48>4=4@4 )4@9 B763 16862>49=68 8696886: =? 43 EB763F( =16 342: <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 23 >? I?86 4 B=4H4772 4>: =16869?86 3?BC1= =? LB3=29< =16 2I5BC>6: ?8:6854336:;<=16=82;B>47! .! > 86356G= ?9 =16 G?>=6>=2?>3 84236: ;< =16 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>=43=? =16 ?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*" 54336: ;< =16 1269 J6GB=2D6 992G68 48>4=4@4 =4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 2= 23 G?>=6>:6: ;< =16 7648>6:6>2?8 ?B>3679?8=168635?>:6>=?!$=14=43=16 6>AB28<23;62>C2>2=24=6:4C42>3==16342:<6:141B3=494 B4:82 4>: =16869?86 =16 6J=6>32?> ?9 =16 5682?: 43 568 ?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*" G4>>?= ;6 I4:6 45572G4;76 =? =16 342: B=4H4772 ?9 =16 5742>=299 4556774>= >3=B=2=2?> 4>: 9B8=168 16 G?>=6>:6: =14= =16 1269 992G68 ?9 =16 ?48: - 8 - 31477 =4@6 G486 ?9 =16 9B>G=2?>2>C ?9 =16 5742>=299 4556774>= >3=2=B=2?> 4>: 4GG?8:2>C7< 3?BC1= 9?8 :23I23347 ?9 =16 455647! $+! 82! !!47254=27 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 8635?>:6>=?!* ?48:48CB6:?>32I274872>63?9=167648>6: 6>2?8 ?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>= ?!$ 4>: 2= 23 9B8=168 G?>=6>:6: ;< =16 8635?>:6>= ?!* =14= 2> D26H ?9 6G=2?>#@(?9=16G=4>:B76"K"(?9=16B763=16342: <6:141B3=494B4:82G4>>?=;6:286G=6:=?G?>=2>B643 G486=4@68?9=165742>=299 4556774>=>3=2=B=2?>434B=4H4772 4>:4GG?8:2>C7<3?BC1=9?8:23I23347?9=16455647! $$! > =16 72C1= ?9 =16 3B;I2332?> I4:6 ;< =16 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 548=263 14D6 G4869B77< 6J4I2>6: =16 4D68I6>=3 I4:6 2> =16 5742>= H16862> =16 >3=2=B=2?> 23 48C41 4M84= 147294= B8 416I4> 414I4= B774 724BB>2(47@16: 8658636>=6:;<<6:141B3=494 B4:82! = 5484C8451 ?!K ?9 =16 5742>= C6>647?C< ?9 =16 B=4H4772233=4=6:!=23473?>?=2>:235B=6=14=8635?>:6>= ?!* ?48: 23 6I5?H686: =? 455?2>= B=4H4772 =? =16 - 9 - 5742>=299 4556774>= >3=2=B=2?>! 16 3B2= 2> !!?!$+*+$% 23 9276:;69?86=16=82;B>47366@2>C867269?9:6G7484=2?>=14==16 3B2= 58?568=263 43 :63G82;6: 2> =16 5742>= H686 )4@9 58?568=263 4>: =16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?> 23 4;3?7B=6 ?H>68 ?9 =16342:58?568=263!=23=?;6>?=6:2>=16584<68?!#2>=16 5742>=H16862>=165742>=2991433?BC1=9?8:286G=2?>4C42>3= :696>:4>= ?!*8635?>:6>= ?!* 16862> =? 5B;7231 =16 3B2= 58?568=263 43 )4@9 58?568=263! = 23 9?8=1G?I2>C 98?I =16 H82==6>3=4=6I6>=9276:;<=16:696>:4>=?!$=14==16342: <6:141B3=494B4:821439276:!!?!K.K*++";69?86 =16 ::2=2?>47 2D27 B:C6 4= 477482 366@2>C 2>LB>G=2?> 4>:=16342:3B2=G4I6=?;6:23I2336:!=23>?=2>:235B=6 =14=<6:141B3=494B4:82H43455?2>=6:43B=4H4772 =? =16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?> 9?8 4 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 43 568 ?8:68 :4=6: *.!+!*+*K! 16 =82;B>47 49=68 G?>32:682>C =16 I4=68247 ?> 86G?8: 143 4882D6: 4= 4 G?>G7B32?> =14= 9B>G=2?>2>C?9=16B=4H4772 <6:3141B3=494B4:82G4I6 =?4>6>:;<#+!+!*+*K4>:433BG154336:=162I5BC>6: ?8:68! - 10 - $*! > G4869B7 G?>32:684=2?> ?9 =16 ?8:68 :4=6: *.!+!*+*K 54336: ;< =16 48>4=4@4 =4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 4>C47?86 H16862> B=4H4772 31477 9B>G=2?> 43 568 =16 58?D232?>3 ?9 =16 G= 4>: =16 =6>B86 ?9 =16 <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 G?I6 =? 4> 6>: ;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6! > =123 86C48:7648>6:G?B>3674556482>C9?8=164556774>=8696886: =?4>?8:68:4=6:#+!$+!*+*"54336:;<=16 48>4=4@4=4=6 ?48: ?9 )4@9 H16862> =16 =68I ?9 4>4C2>C ?II2==663B=4H477263H1?36=68I23G?I2>C=?6J5286?8 47864:< 6J5286: ?> ?8 49=68 $3= BCB3= *+*" 23 ;62>C G?>=2>B6: =277 #$!+$!*+*! > =16 342: ?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*"=165682?:?9B=4H47726331477G?>=2>B63B;L6G= =? =16 G?>:2=2?> =14= 2> =16 6D6>= 29 4>< 6>AB28< 23 2> 58?C8633 4>: G?>G7B:6: 4C42>3= 3BG1 4>4C2>C ?II2==663 ?8 B=4H477263 4>: 43 3BG1 =16 ?48: 31477 433BI6 =16 9B>G=2?>2>C?93BG1>3=2=B=2?>43568B76"K"(?9=16B763! = 23 =16 3B;I2332?> ?9 82! !!47254=27 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 :696>:4>= ?!*8635?>:6>= ?!* =14= 4> 6>AB28< 143 ;66> 2>2=24=6: 4C42>3= =16 342: <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 4>: 58?G66:2>C3 486 56>:2>C G?>32:684=2?> - 11 - ;69?86 =16 ?48: 4>: 2> =123 86C48: 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= :2: >?= G?B>=68 =16 3B;I2332?> 43 =? =16 56>:6>G< ?9 =16 6>AB28< 4C42>3= 82! <6: 141 B3=494B4:82!>=14=D26H?9=16I4==684I?9=16D26H =14= =16 342: <6: 141 B3=494 B4:82 23 >? I?86 4 B=4H4772 4>: G4>>?= ;6 568I2==6: =? ;6 G?>=2>B6: =? 8658636>==165742>=299 >3=2=B=2?>43B=4H4772!>=12386C48: ?> G4869B7 6J4I2>4=2?> ?9 =16 92>:2>C 86G?8:6: ;< =16 =82;B>47 43 568 5484C8451 ?3!$$ =? $K 4I ?9 =16 D26H =14==1692>:2>C86G?8:6:;<=16=82;B>4723LB3=4>:58?568 2>3?948 43 1?7:2>C=14= 82! <6: 141 B3=494 B4:8231477 >?= ;6 G?>=2>B6: 43 4 B=4H4772 ?9 =16 5742>=299F3 >3=2=B=2?> ;<6997BJ?9=2I6! $#! ?H6D68 =16 3B2= 23 9276: ;< =16 >3=2=B=2?> 8658636>=6: ;< 2=3 4LL4:4 4312> 4>: B=4H4772! > =14= D26H ?9 =16 I4==68 =16 =82;B>47 143 G?II2==6: 4> 688?8 2> :23I2332>C =16 6>=286 3B2= H16862> =16 3B2= 9276: ;< =16 >3=2=B=2?>3B8D2D63:6352=6=1686;62>CG14>C6?9B=4H4772 ;< =16 )4@9 ?48:! ? =14= 6J=6>= =16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" 54336: ;< =16 =82;B>47 86AB2863 =? ;6 - 12 - 2>=689686:H2=14>:=16869?8692>:9?8G62>=163B;I2332?> I4:6;<=167648>6:G?B>3674556482>C9?8=164556774>=43 =?G?>=2>B4=2?>?9=163B2=9276:2>=16>4I6?9=16>3=2=B=2?>! ?H6D68 2> D26H ?9 =16 455?2>=I6>= ?9 )4@9 992G68 =? 9B>G=2?>43B=4H477243H67743=?G488<?B=:4<=?:4<4994283 ?9=165742>=299F3>3=2=B=2?>4I?9=16D26H=14=2=23?56> 9?8=16342:)4@9992G68455?2>=6:;<=16?48:=?G?>=2>B6 =1658?G66:2>C3;69?86=16=82;B>47=?58?=6G==162>=6863=?9 =165742>=299 >3=2=B=2?>! $K! >=16863B7=5433=169?77?H2>C 2( 1645564723477?H6:2> 548=/ 22( 16 ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" 2> !!?!$+*+$%?>=169276?9=16 48>4=4@4)4@9 82;B>47 474;B8C2 2D232?> 474;B8C2 23 36= 432:643=?:23I2332>C?9=163B2=?9=165742>=299 >3=2=B=2?> 2> 6>=286=< 4>: =1686;< !!?!$+*+$%314773B8D2D69?8G?>32:684=2?>43 - 13 - =? =16 584<68 I4:6 2> =16 3B2=4>:=16 342: 3B2= 143=?;6G?>=2>B6:2>=16>4I6?9=16>3=2=B=2?> I6>=2?>6:2>=16G4B36=2=768658636>=6:;<=16 )4@9992G68/ 222( =23?56>9?8=16683=H1276B=4H4772 <6:141B3=494B4:82=?2I5764:2>=163B2= 43?>6?9=16:696>:4>=3293?:63286343=?=4@6 4D4274;76G?>=6>=2?>39?858?=6G=2>C=162>=6863=?9 =165742>=299 >3=2=B=2?>/ 2D( > D26H ?9 =16 4556484>G6 ?9 =16 548=2634>:=?4D?2:9B8=168:674<2>=16I4==68 =16 548=263 =? =16 3B2= 486 568I2==6: =? 455648 ;69?86 =16 48>4=4@4 =4=6 )4@9 82;B>47 474;B84C22D232?> 474;B84C2?>+*!+*!*+*4= $$!++4!I! !*+ '! !( # ' 23=?!$7?!K*