Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55119 (KAR)

SURESH DESAI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/202070/2025 · 2026-02-04

Rajesh Rai K

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$$ # %& %'() &%( * !" " # $ ! %"&' ( ) # $ $ ! " " ' ( ) $ * "# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " $ " $ + $ $ !"!" $ ,- $ $$ ! $ "!"& $ !"!" $ + + $ $ ) #) %"!" $) $ + . . /) ) 01, 23141567 89-1-1:5 1, ;179< =5<93 92-1:5 " :; 0636-1>6 6?631@ =36@,06 6501-6 "!"& -: A=6,0 -09 83:299<15?, 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593,622=,9< :, 65< " 15 : %"!" 631,15? :=- :; 3149 :"!" 39?1,-939< B>-09 7646--1:7129;:3-09:;;95298=51,06B79=5<9392-1:5 !:;"!"&895<15?:5-09;179:; <<1-1:567 1,-312- 65<9,,1:5,)=<?9#1C6>68=36 " 09 ;62-=67 46-31D :; -09 26,9 1, -06- 39,8:5<95- :" <1->667=76,:5:; ,0:@67=76;179<62:487615-B9;:39 39,8:5<95- ::7129 ! !""!" -06- 01, <9296,9< ;6-093 - 3 - ,0:@6 E6, E:3@15? 15 6>156?971 =?63 $62-:3> F- -< ;3:4 86,- >963, 5963 7646--1 09 <9296,9< E6, 39,1<9< 15 6 395-9< 0:=,9 5963 -: ;62-:3> 65< :;-95 39,8:5<95- :" =,9< -: F1,1- -09 0:=,9 :; <9296,9< =315?,=20F1,1-,-09<9296,9<<1,27:,9<-:39,8:5<95-:" -06--0989-1-1:593,B915?-09656?9365<951:3959367 656?9339,892-1F97>:;-09,61<2:4865>15,1,-9<01,;6-093 -: E:3@ :F93-149 :3 -: A=1- -09 C:B =9 -: -09 ,649 01, ;6-093E95--:<9839,,1:565<9D839,,9<01,<9,139-:2:441- ,=121<9B9;:3939,8:5<95-:" & 5 ! !""!" 6- 6B:=- !.!! 64 39,8:5<95- :"39291F9<680:592677;3:4:596,6F636C6-06-01,;6-093 3946159< 6B,95- ;:3 E:3@ ;3:4 & <6>, 449<16-97> 39,8:5<95- :" 3=,09< -: -09 0:=,9 E0939 01, ;6-093 E6, 39,1<15? 65< ;:=5< -06- 01, ;6-093 06< 2:441--9< ,=121<9 B> 065?15?-:-093::;:;0:=,9 595A=13>E1-0-092:7796?=9,:; <9296,9< 15 -09 ;62-:3> 39,8:5<95- :" 2649 -:@5:E-06- <=9 -: -09 0636,,495--:3-=39 :; -09 89-1-1:593, 01, ;6-093 2:441--9<,=121<9-67,:39F9679<-06--0989-1-1:593,1,,=9< ,0:E 26=,9 5:-129, -: 01, ;6-093 :5 !&!""!"& 65< - 4 - "!!"!" 5 -09 68839095,1:5 -06- 09 E:=7< B9 394:F9< ;3:4C:B-09<9296,9<2:441--9<,=121<9 ,,=2039,8:5<95- :" 7:<?9< -09 2:487615- B9;:39 39,8:5<95- ::7129 :5 ! !""!" 5-09,-395?-0:;,61<2:487615-$2649-:B9 39?1,-939<6?615,--0989-1-1:593,622=,9<153149:"!" ;:3-096;:39,61<:;;9529=B,9A=95-7>-0939,8:5<95-:7129 2:5<=2-9< -09 15F9,-1?6-1:5 65< 761< 2063?9 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593, ;:3 -09 6;:39495-1:59< :;;9529 22:3<15?7> -09 796359<6?1,-36-9-::@2:?51G6529:;-0926,965<2:441--9< -09 26,9 -: -09 9,,1:5, :=3- ??319F9< B> -09 ,649 -09 89-1-1:593,839;9339<-01,89-1-1:5-:A=6,0-0983:299<15?, 963< 796359< 2:=5,97 ;:3 -09 89-1-1:593, 65< 796359< 1?0 :=3- :F935495- 796<93 ;:3 -09 39,8:5<95- -6-9 ' 96359< 2:=5,97 ;:3 -09 89-1-1:593, B> 391-936-15? -0989-1-1:56F93495-,83146317>2:5-95-9<-06-;:3-09,0:E 26=,9 5:-129, 1,,=9< B> -09 89-1-1:593, -: -09 <9296,9< -09 <9296,9<06,?1F9563987>68:7:?>79--93,-:-0989-1-1:593,:5 - 5 - "!"!" ,-6-15? -06- 09 06, 2:441--9< 41,-6@9 B> 2:5,=415? 672:0:7 E0179 09 E6, 15 <=-> 65< 67,: =5<93-6@95 5:--:15<=7?915,=2062-5,=202132=4,-6529,622:3<15?-: -09796359<2:=5,97-0989-1-1:593,6395:E6>39,8:5,1B79;:3 -09,=121<67<96-0:;<9296,9<65<-09>06F95:-<31F95014-: 2:441- ,=121<9 22:3<15?7> 09 ,=B41-, -06- -09 2:5-15=6-1:5 :; 83:299<15?, 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593, 1, 6B=,9 :; 83:29,, :; :=3-65<836>,-:677:E-0989-1-1:5 796359< :88:,9< -09 836>93 B> 2:5-95<15? -06- 5:E -09 2063?9 ,099- 1, ;179< 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593, 65< ,-6-9495- :; E1-59,,9, 639 392:3<9< 5 ,=20 2132=4,-6529, -09 83:299<15?, 2655:- B9 A=6,09< 65< 622:3<15?7>836>,-:<1,41,,-0989-1-1:5 06F9?1F954>65D1:=,2:5,1<936-1:5B:-0:5-09 ,=B41,,1:5, 46<9 B> -09 796359< 2:=5,97 ;:3 -09 39,892-1F9 863-19,65<-09<:2=495-,46<96F6176B79:5392:3< % , 2:=7< B9 ?6-0939< ;3:4 392:3<, 1- 1, 5:- 15 <1,8=-9 -06- -09 89-1-1:593, 1,,=9< ,0:E 26=,9 5:-129, -: -09 <9296,9< :5 -E: :226,1:5, 19 !&!""!"& 65< "!!"!" - 6 - ;:3-0941,2:5<=2-:;<9296,9<<=315?-09<=->0:=3,$:3-09 ,649 -09 <9296,9< 06, ?1F95 6 3987>68:7:?> 79--93, -: -09 89-1-1:593, :5 "!"!" ,-6-15? -06- 09 06, 2:441--9< 41,-6@9 B> 2:5,=415? 672:0:7 E0179 09 E6, 15 <=-> 65< 67,: =5<93-6@95 5:- -: 15<=7?9 15 ,=20 62- 5 893=,67 :; -09 ,-6-9495-:;+-:+9D298-1,,=6529:;,0:E26=,9 5:-129, B> -09,9 89-1-1:593, 6B,:7=-97> 5: :-093 :F93- 62- 15,-1?6-1:5 :3 0636,,495- ,61< -: 06F9 B995 ?1F95 B> -09,9 89-1-1:593,6,,-6-9<B>-094 ! ,65:;;12167<=->;:3-0941,2:5<=2-:;<9296,9< -09> 06F9 1,,=9< -09 ,0:E 26=,9 5:-129, <41--9<7> -09 <9296,9<06,2:441--9<,=121<96;-93<6>,;3:4-09<6-9:; 1,,=6529:;-09,92:5<,0:E26=,95:-1295-094965-14909 06,398719<;:3-09,0:E26=,95:-1295,=202132=4,-6529,1- 2:=7< 5:- B9 839,=49< -06- -09 89-1-1:593, 06F9 <31F95 -09 <9296,9< -: 2:441- ,=121<9 09 :5/B79 89D :=3- 15 -09 26,9 :; 398:3-9< 15 097< 15 8636?3680 :," 65< "" 6, =5<93. - 7 - ! " # $ % & # " $% " # " # ' & # % ' #% # &#% "# #% % % % % #% # % &# #" " #" % # ' # # " - 8 - &#% % % &# # %% # # # ( " " # ' % % )"#% * # + ( , " # # - $&#% . * # % % # % # /"% ( # ( ## ## " # ## ## % # , ## - 9 - # $ 0# # /"% # ( # " " # + ( # :77:26-15?-09;15<15?,:;-09:5HB79 89D:=3-15 -096B:F926,9-:-09;62-,65<2132=4,-6529,:;-01,:=3- 64 :; -09 2:5,1<939< F19E -06- -09 89-1-1:593, B915? -09 :;;12167,:;-092:4865>06F9<1,2063?9<-0913:;;12167<=->B> 1,,=15? ,0:E 26,9 5:-129, E0120 1-,97; <: 5:- 6--362- -09 15?39<195-,:;92-1:5!:;:39:F93-0983:D141->:; -096779?9<62-:;89-1-1:593,65<-09,=121<67<96-0:;<9296,9< 1, -:: 7:5? 19 <6>, 5 ,=20 2132=4,-6529, 9F95 1; -09 95-139 6779?6-1:5, 15 -09 $ 2:487615- 65< -09 2063?9 ,099- 46-93167,:5392:3<-6@95:51-,;629F67=967,:-09,649<: 5:- # 2:5,-1-=-9 65 :;;9529 2063?9 ,099-9< 6?615,- -0989-1-1:593, " 5 -06- F19E :; -09 46--93 -09 2:5-15=6-1:5 :; 83:299<15?, 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593, 1, 5:-015? B=- 6B=,9 :; 83:29,,:;:=3- 22:3<15?7>83:299<-:86,,-09;:77:E15?* - 10 - 1 0989-1-1:51, 11 09 83:299<15?, 6?615,- -09 89-1-1:593,622=,9< :, 65< " 15 : %"!" 631,15? :=- :; 3149 :"!"39?1,-939<B>-09 7646--1:7129 ;:3-09:;;95298=51,06B79=5<9392-1:5! :; "!"& 895<15? :5 -09 ;179 :; <<1-1:567 1,-312- 65< 9,,1:5, )=<?9 #1C6>68=361,0939B>A=6,09< < %$( $ 1,-:.7:.