- 1 - ! "#$$ # %&' %()* '%) + ! " # ! $ %& # '%() # ! ! *($ ! %$( ! ! $$ $$ +' $%$$$ &*, $$ )($$ +' ! ! # #! # ! !! &, () Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! - - .## /01 23404056 01 70839 :693; 3<4056 %$( 57 /=;=40>= =?=;0@ :;=@1/= =6/04= $$ 45 A:=1/ 4/3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; =<<:139 06 5 &*, $$ =;0106? 5:457;0B35$$ $$ ;3?0143;39C>4/358?:BC=D 580<3 0E=>=2:;= 75; 4/3 57736<3 2:601/=C83 :693; 3<4056 &, 57 236906?564/3708357 ;06<02=83605;0F08#:9?3=69# 0E=>=2:;= $ /3 7=<4:=8 B=4;0G 57 4/3 <=13 01 4/=4 ;312569364 5$ 859?39 = <5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364 5 ' 580<3 56 $%$$$ =883?06? 4/=4 56 * $$ 56 4/3 5<<=1056 57 332=F=80 73140F=8 06 4/3 8=43 60?/4 H/36 /3 =69 /01 H073' :6=69=H3;3;34:;606?454/30;/5:13=743;=4436906? 55E==4 4/30; ;06406? ;311104:=439=4=B==690;=5=90E=>=2:;= /3 /=9 @324 * ?;=B1 57 ?589 </=06 57 /01 H073 =69 4H5 =B1:6? B5C083 2/5631 06 4/3 2:;13 57 /01 H073 =43; =4 =C5:4 -2B/32=;@39/01B545;C0@3C3=;06?;3?014;=4056 5'$( '%&$ 5225104345=@33B/5H@=69064/31=09 - 3 - B545;C0@3 /3 @324 /01 H073I1 2:;13 H/0</ <564=061 4/3 =75;31=09F=8:=C831743;2:;</=106?4/34=C8341064/3B390<=8 1/52H/083;34:;606?4/3>H3;3:443;8>1/5<@39=14/32:;13 57 ;312569364 5$I1 H073 H=1 B01106? 36<3 /3 859?39 = <5B28=064C375;34/3;3125693645 ' 580<3=694/31=B3H=1 ;3?0143;39 06 ;0B3 5$$ $$ 9=439 $%$$$ 75; 4/3 =75;3B3640563957736<3:C13A:3648>=743;8=21357$B564/1 234040563;C306?4/3156'06'8=H57;3125693645$0B280<=439 06 4/3 <=13 =883?06? 4/=4 /3 /=9 145836 4/3 2:;13 @324 06 4/3 B545;C0@3 <<5;906?8> ;312569364 5 ' 580<3 =;;31439 4/3 234040563; =69 8=09 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 /0B 75; 4/3 =75;3B36405639 57736<3 =139 56 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 4/3 #:;0190<4056=8 =?014;=43 455@ <5?60D=6<3 57 4/3 57736<3 ??;03F39C>4/31=B34/3234040563;2;373;;394/012340405645 A:=1/4/32;5<33906?1 3=;9 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 234040563; =69 83=;639 0?/5:;45F3;6B364 83=93;75;;3125693645 '4=43 * 3=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; ;3043;=439 4/3 ?;5:691:;?39064/323404056=692;=>145=885H4/323404056 - 4 - % 3=;639 75; ;312569364 5 '4=43 5225139 4/323404056=692;=>145901B0114/31=B3 ) /=F3?0F36B>=6G05:1<561093;=4056C54/564/3 1:CB011056 B=93 C> 4/3 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 ;3123<40F3 2=;4031 =69 4/3 <5B28=064 =F3;B3641 15 =815 </=;?3 1/334 B=43;0=81 & 6 23;:1=8 57 4/3 <5B28=064 =F3;B3641 = F=?:3 =883?=40561 =;3 B=93 06 4/3 <5B28=064 4/=4 H/083 ;312569364 5$=69/01H0734;=F3806?064/30;B545;C0@356 * $$=4 =C5:4 % 2B 4/3> 1452239 4/30; B545;C0@3 06 = 28=<3 <=8839 =@33B /5H@ 45 2:;</=13 B390<0631 104:=439 63=;C> 4/3 ;5=9 =69 =743; 2:;</=13 4/3> 75:69 4/=4 4/3 2:;13 H=1 B01106? H/0</ H=1 /=6?39 45 4/3 /=6983 57 4/30; B545;C0@3 /3;3=743; ;312569364 5$ 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 56 $%$$$ 03 =743; 8=213 57 $ B564/1 =69 4/3;3=743; 4/3 234040563;H=1=;;31439=690B280<=439064/3<;0B3/3</=;?3 1/3342=23;;3F3=814/=44/3234040563;01656354/3;4/=6156' 06'8=H57;3125693645$=694/3;3H=1=B=4;0B560=89012:43 C34H3364/3234040563;=694/39=:?/43;57;3125693645$6 F03H 57 4/3 9012:43 4/3 234040563;.1 H073 03 9=:?/43; 57 - 5 - ;3125693645$/=170839=<=13=?=06144/3234040563;H/0</ H=1 ;3?0143;39 06 ;0B3 5) $ , /3;3=743; = 90F5;<3 23404056 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; 06 5$ % $ , H=1 70839 =694/31=B3H=1=885H39=694/3B=;;0=?3H=1901158F39 ( 2=;47;5B4/=4/01B54/3;06'8=H=81570839=<=13 =?=0614 /0B 75; 4/3 57736<3 :693; 4/3 2;5F010561 57 <4 H/0</01236906?06;0B35 $$/:10401<83=;4/=406 5;93; 45 /=;=11 4/3 234040563; 5:4 57 F36?3=6<3 4/01 7=813 <5B28=064 /=1 C336 7501439 =?=0614 /0B 3F3;4/38311 ;312569364 5 ' 580<3 /=F3 654 130D39 4/3 B5C083 65; ?589 5;6=B3641 3G<324 =B5:64 57 1% ' =4 4/3 0614=6<3 57 234040563;!:;4/3;4/3065;906=43938=>57B5;34/=6$B564/1 06 859?06? 4/3 <5B28=064 4/=4 455 =743; B01106? ?589 =69 B5C0832/563C>;3125693645$041387<;3=431=95:C4064/3 ?363101574/3<=13 , 4 01 65H H388 1344839 4/=4 4/3 <56406:=4056 57 <;0B06=8 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 =6> 23;156 56 4/3 C=101 57 = 7;0F585:15;F3G=405:1<5B28=0640115B34/06?F3;>13;05:1/01 H5:89 4=;601/ 4/3 0B=?3 57 4/3 23;156 =?=0614 H/5B 7=813 7;0F585:1 =69 F3G=405:1 =883?=40561 =;3 83F3839 /3 56IC83 - 6 - 23G5:;4064/3<=1357 ;325;43906 /3894/=4H/363F3;=6 =<<:139 <5B31 C375;3 4/3 5:;4 06F5@06? 304/3; 4/3 06/3;364 25H3;1 :693; 3<4056 *($ 57 ; 5; 3G4;=5;906=;> E:;0190<4056:693;;40<83$$)57<561404:405645?344/3 !5; <;0B06=8 2;5<33906?1 A:=1/39 3113640=88> 56 4/3 ?;5:69 4/=4 1:</ 2;5<33906?1 =;3 B=6073148> 7;0F585:1 5; F3G=405:1 5; 061404:439H04/4/3:843;05;B540F375;H;3=@06?F36?3=6<34/36 06 1:</ <0;<:B14=6<3 5:;4 5H31 = 9:4> 45 855@ 0645 4/3 ! H04/<=;3=69=804483B5;3<85138>4H088654C3E:14365:?/75; 4/35:;445855@06454/3=F3;B3641B=93064/3! <5B28=064 =8563 75; 4/3 2:;2513 57 =1<3;4=0606? H/34/3; 4/3 63<311=;> 06?;3903641 45 <561404:43 4/3 =883?39 57736<3 =;3 901<85139 5; 654 6 4/3 54/3; /=69 4/3 5:;4 5H31 = 9:4> 45 855@ 0645 B=6>54/3;=4436906? <0;<:B14=6<3 3B3;?06? 7;5B 4/3 ;3<5;9 574/3<=135F3;=69=C5F34/3=F3;B3641=69076339C3H04/ 9:3<=;3=69<0;<:B123<40564;>45;3=906C34H3364/380631 /35:;4H/0833G3;<0106?041E:;0190<4056:693;3<4056*($57 ; 5;;40<83$$)57561404:40566339654;314;0<4041387568> 454/314=?357=<=13C:4013B25H3;39454=@30645=<5:64 4/3 5F3;=88 <0;<:B14=6<31 83=906? 45 4/3 06040=4056 ;3?014;=4056 - 7 - 574/3<=13=1H388=14/3B=43;0=81<5883<439064/3<5:;1357 06F3140?=4056 =B574/3<561093;39F03H4/=43F36074/33640;3 =883?=4056064/3!</=;?31/334=6954/3;95<:B36414=@36 0645 <561093;=4056 56 041 7=<3 F=8:3 65 <=13 /=1 C336 B=93 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; =<<:139 75; 4/3 57736<3 =883?39 =?=0614 /0B36<3<56406:=4056572;5<33906?1=?=0614/0B01=C:1357 2;5<311575:;4<<5;906?8>2;5<339452=114/375885H06?J 0 /32340405601 00 /3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; =<<:139 06 5 &*, $$ =;0106? 5:4 57 ;0B3 5$$ $$ ;3?0143;39 C> 4/3 58?:BC=D 580<3 0E=>=2:;= 75; 4/3 57736<3 2:601/=C83 :693; 3<4056&,57 236906?564/3708357 ;06<02=8 3605; 0F08 #:9?3 =69 # 0E=>=2:;= 01 /3;3C> A:=1/39 ,* %$) $ 0145- 85- -#