- 1 - ! " #$! %$& ! " #$%&'&( ) * + ! , ' ++ ! #$(((' ! ! #$%&'(' #$%&'(' & #! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$%&'(' $ " #$%&'(' " #$%&'(' ) *! ' , - ! (- ($ #! , *, *, *, " ! (- ($(''($ * #, ./ 0 12324545675895:2;<=412324545672>?1@::27A57A412 2B42>7C274 6>;2> ;@42; (''($ 3@882; <= 412 >28367;274 6 2B42>757A 412 324545672> 9>6C @5?1D> 584>5?446+D;@:@A5E5::@A2F+D;@:@A5584!5G@=@7@A@> - 3 - H5412992?49>6C(''($46(('(96>@32>56;69 C67418 129@?4869412?@82@>2@8D7;2> 24545672> 58 @ 32>C@7274 >285;274 69 5>I@3D> !5::@A2 584>5?4 @5?1D> 2 58 57E6:E2; 57 @A>5?D:4D>@: @E6?@4567 6H757A @ 8C@:: 352?2 69 :@7; 2 58 @ C@>>52; C@7>285;57AH541158H592@7;?15:;>27458?6742742;<= :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672> 41@4 412 ?1@>A28 5C3:5?@42; @A@5784 412 324545672> @>2 9@:82 <@82:288 H5416D4 @7= 8D<84@745@: C@42>5@: H15?1 H6D:; :2@; 46 ?67E5?4567 12 324545672> H@8 57545@::= @>>@=2; @8 672 69 412 @??D82; 57 >5C2 6 (( 57 32?5@: @82 *, 6%'' (( >5C2 6'' (' 57 6-$J (' H12>257412324545672>?@C246<2@?FD5442;578@5;?@828 76412> ?@82 57 >5C2 6J (& 58 327;57A 4>5@: 4 58 @:86 ?6742742; 41@4 57 4158 ?@82 @:86 324545672> H@8 D772?288@>5:= ;>@AA2; 5746 <D4 H@8 764 57E6:E2; 57 @7= 8D?1?>5C2@812585776?274 - 4 - 158 <257A 412 84@42 69 @99@5>8 >28367;274 68&@7;4@K57A764269412366><@?KA>6D7;69412 324545672> 57 6>;2> 46 6E2>>2@?1 412 @?FD544@: 6>;2>8 3@882;579@E6D>69412324545672>@7;412>2<257A764@7= ?>2;5<:2 C@42>5@: 1@8 3>23@>2; @ >236>4 824457A 96>41 A272>@: @7; 6C75<D8 @::2A@45678 H5416D4 412>2 <257A @7= 832?595?6E2>4@?48@A@5784412324545672>@82;67H15?1 >28367;274 6 96>H@>;2; @ >236>4 46 >28367;274 6& >2?6CC27;57A 412 2B42>7C274 69 324545672> 28367;274 6&67>2?253469412>236>4>2FD2842;>28367;274646 57545@42 @?4567 3D>8D@74 46 412 >236>4 8D<C5442; <= >28367;274 6 @82; 67 H15?1 >28367;274 6 412 ?6C324274 @D416>54= A64 588D2; 816H ?@D82 7645?2 ;@42; ''(($ 4 58 ?67427;2; <= :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672>41@476>236>496>H@>;2;<=>28367;27466> 3>23@>2; <= >28367;274 6& 86 @::2A2; H@8 8274 @:67A H541412816H?@D827645?246412324545672>2E2>412:288 412324545672>95:2;158;24@5:2;6<G2?45678464128@5;816H ?@D82 7645?2 588D2; <= >28367;274 6 6H2E2> @942> - 5 - 27FD5>=674123>6?22;57A8412C@442>H@8?67?:D;2;<= 3@8857A@72B42>7C2746>;2>67(''($ & 4 58 412 E212C274 ?674274567 69 :2@>72; ?6D782:96>412324545672>41@45C3DA72;6>;2>3@882;<= >28367;274 6 2B2>?5857A 2B4>@6>;57@>= GD>58;5?4567 @7; C2@8D>2E56:@4284123>57?53:2699D7;@C274@:>5A1469412 324545672> AD@>@7422; D7;2> >45?:2 'J*',*;, 69 412 678454D4567 69 7;5@ 4 58 9D>412> ?6742742; 41@4 412 >28367;2748 1@E2 764 96::6H2; ;D2 3>6?2;D>2 @8 ?6742C3:@42; D7;2> 412 +@>7@4@K@ 6:5?2 ?4 'J *12>257@942> >292>>2; 46 @8 .412 + ?4/, 725412> 412 3>57?53:28697@4D>@:GD845?276>412GD8469>2@867@<:27288 @>296::6H2; $ D>412> 54 58 ?67427;2; 41@4 412 >28367;274 658764GD845952;57158@?4692B42>7C27469324545672> 46 +D;@:@A5 E5::@A2 69 !5G@=@7@A@>@ 584>5?4 @8 412 324545672>5841286:2<>2@;2@>72>691589@C5:=412>2<=412 8@C2 @?48 ?674>@>= 46 >45?:2 ' 69 412 678454D4567 69 7;5@7E52H69412D7>2@867@<:26>;2>H15?158@><54>@>= - 6 - @7; 412>2 58 :@?K 69 C@42>5@:8 @7; @:86 @ 767 832@K57A 6>;2>324545672>58<296>241586D>4822K57A46>2E6K2@7; FD@81 412 2B42>7C274 6>;2> 3@882; <= 412 >28367;274 6 4 58 9D>412> ?6742742; <= :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672>41@44125C3DA72;6>;2>585::2A@:32>E2>82@7; ?@3>5?56D8 @7; 58 E56:@45E2 69 412 9D7;@C274@: >5A14 AD@>@7422; D7;2> >45?:2 'J *',*;, 69 412 678454D4567 69 7;5@ 12 6>;2> 32> 82 58 32>E2>82 @8 412>2 58 767 @33:5?@4567 69 GD;5?56D8 @7; 57;2327;274 C57; H5416D4 412>2 <257A @7= ?6A274 C@42>5@: 96> 57E6K57A 412 2B42>7C274 @A@5784 412 324545672> 9>6C 672 3:@?2 46 412 6412> 4 58 @:86 E212C274:= ?6742742; 41@4 412 >28367;274 6 1@8 9@5:2; @7; 5A76>2; 46 :66K 5746 412 @?FD544@: 6>;2>8 3@882; <= 412 6D>4 57 9@E6D> 69 412 324545672>458@:869D>412>?6742742;41@4412>28367;274 61@8<2274@K27@H@=6>579:D27?2;<=412>236>48274 <=4125>?:27832?46>696:5?2@7;1@815C82:99@5:2;46 96>C @7 5742::5A5<:2 6357567 67 412 <@858 69 @7= 4@7A5<:2 - 7 - C@42>5@: 6> ?6A274 H547288 46 @>>5E2 @4 @ ?67?:D8567 69 2B42>7C27469412324545672>12?6D782:9D>412>?67427;8 41@4 3@84 ?>5C57@: ?@828 >2A5842>2; @A@5784 412 324545672> H6D:; 764 <2 @ ?@D82 6> >2@867 46 2B42>7 412 324545672> 9>6C6723:@?2464126412>C6>28696>412>2@86741@457 4H6 69 412 ?@828 412 324545672> 1@8 <227 @?FD5442; 69 @:: ?1@>A28 7;2> 412 ?5>?DC84@7?28 :2@>72; ?6D782: 3>@=8 41@4 4158 32454567 <2 @::6H2; @7; 412 5C3DA72; 6>;2> 69 2B42>7C274<2FD@812; - 2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672> >2:528 D367 412 GD;AC274 69 ?6#6>;57@42 27?1 69 4158 6D>4 57 6(%-J ($ @7; @:86 412 GD;AC274 69 67/<:2 32B 6D>457412?@8269 ' % 1@E212@>;:2@>72;?6D782:96>412324545672> @7; :2@>72; ;;54567@: 6E2>7C274 ;E6?@42 96> 412 >28367;274#4@42@7;32>D82;4125C3DA72;6>;2> 1 ( 7:572JJ - 8 - J 7?@>29D:32>D8@:695C3DA72;6>;2>54588227 41@4412>258767@33:5?@456769C57;@7;86@:86412>258 76 >236>4 27?:682; 69 >28367;274 68& @7; 46 >28367;2746@85458764@772B2;@:67AH541412816H ?@D827645?2A5E2746412324545672>12>28367;2748@>2 >2FD5>2;46?6785;2>4122B42>7C27457412:2442>@7;835>54 694123>6E58567D7;2>2?4567$69412+?4@8@7= 8D?1 6>;2> H15?1 58 3@882; 2B42>757A @ 32>867 9>6C 672 3:@?246@76412>H5416D43>632>C@42>5@:@7;3>28DC34567 @7; @33:5?@4567 69 C57; H5:: ?2>4@57:= :2@; 46E56:@456769 412 9D7;@C274@: >5A14 A>@742; D7;2> >45?:2 'J *',*;, 69 412 678454D4567 69 7;5@ 412>2<= 412 9>22 C6E2C274 69 412 324545672> 58 >284>5?42; 4 58 @:86 72?288@>= 96> 412 >28367;274 @D416>5452846>2?6>;@8D<G2?45E28@4589@?4567 @8?6742C3:@42;D7;2>2?4567$69412+?454H6D:; ?2>4@57:=<267412<@85869412C@42>5@:83:@?2;<296>2412 ?6C324274 @D416>54= 7 412 3>28274 ?@82 67 1@7; 54 @332@>8 41@4 @<86:D42:= 76 C@42>5@: @7; 76 ;58?D88567 58 412>2 H541 >2A@>; 46 412 41>2@4 6> 57GD>= 41@4 58 - 9 - ?6742C3:@42;6>32>?25E2;<=412?6C324274@D416>54=46 3D<:5? 32@?2 @7; 4>@7FD5:54= 2>2:= <2?@D82 69 412 2B58427?2 69 @ ?>5C57@: ?@82 H6D:; 764 :2@; 46 41>2@4 46 3D<:5?32@?2@7;4>@7FD5:54=12@D416>54=H6D:;1@E246 C@K26D4@A66;?@82<@82;678D<G2?45E2@33>2?5@456769 412C@42>5@:841@4412324545672>H6D:;?2>4@57:=57E6:E257 @?45E54528 H15?1 H6D:; ?@D82 41>2@4 46 3D<:5? 32@?2 @7; 4>@7FD5:54= @E57A A672 41>6DA1 412 C@42>5@:8 ;6 764 957;@7=8D?1C@42>5@:81@E57A<227C@;2@E@5:@<:2<=412 ?6C324274 @D416>54= 67/<:2 32B 6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69 *D3>@,@43@>@A>@3168'@7;'$1@812:; @896::6H8 ! " " # $ %&#'# & ( " (&& % $$ & & # & ) * &" - 10 - & ( +(( , &# % $ & " (& #- *# & " - ( . % $ - & ) &"/ & # - # & " &#&& ) # ( / " # - *# #" #(" # - ) # ) &" # ' " - # & +(( $& '#" & " $ #. && ' ) ) #0 - 11 - '( 12 >2@8678 @885A72; <= 412 ?6C324274 @D416>54=@>2@8D7;2> !" #$%&'()$ *!+,! "#$%&'(# ,- -- , (.!+, !/(*! 01 $ 2 1 3 1 !" 45 67 -!84-2 1!3 9 .:;2 1 !. < = ->- -+ ?@A B<" $ - #!C = D- 5 !.! 5* $-E% ; ! B!FG- !F-E HI*D" $ (G- 45, - 6 -! J=- $=E21 )2!3 A1$!"KLMN-%>'- 5 1 1 ! -.1 O; P ;Q < 1 K R" * 5* -S!" 1 .M 1 3 T : B;* 1! $1 U V! $1 WW ,1 !C- G<-J - % B" ! G.=S1 !F R 1 " FD2!+D"!, BG - G #X, D" D% #X, =Y1 / ;" Z#!7 !. 17 ;.M!K>N-%1O-K. N7$ G -.M 1 O D-1 .M- N' 13 [ O1 /< \5%].!+ 1 B O 17 :7.$ #<(G-4110F7> 1(G- "#7>5 13 @17->#! - G#X5^!1- G#X / D"! Z;" - R% 1 _>^ 2 - R2 13 - 12 - `17ab>'"1 !";I%7< c-E $G 1 !" 411 # (G- "0F7>!1 1!3 d (!" 45 e6f - -.1 B14- B1 .-2!+.!!. !C->- -+ [[ ! B<" K cD"g! < -.1 - ? Z! ! -\1^ (G- =S $%D a(.5!+ 3h '' 12 >2@8678 @885A72; <= 412 ?6C324274 @D416>54= @>2 96> 2B42>7C274 H6D:; 764 <2 8D995?5274 46 2B42>7412324545672>9>6C6723:@?246@76412>@857?@82 412324545672>58?@D857A@7=41>2@46>;@C@A24128@C2 H6D:; 1@E2 46 <2 7645952; 46 412 324545672> 57 412 816H ?@D82 7645?2 @7; 412 >2:2E@74 >236>4 6DA14 46 1@E2<227 A5E27 46 412 324545672> 46 >23:= 46 412 8@5; 816H ?@D82 7645?2 H15?1 1@8 764 <227 ;672 57 412 3>28274 ?@82 67 1@7; 12>296>2 57 C= 6357567 412 8@5; 6>;2> :@?K8 @33:5?@456769C57;@7;8D<G2?45E28@4589@?4567@812:;<= 412 670<:2 32B 6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69 *D3>@, 12 6>;2> 69 2B42>7C274 H@8 3@882; H541 2992?4 9>6C - 13 - (''($46(('(H12>2572B42>7C27432>56;1@8 @:>2@;= ?6C2 46 @7 27; 7 ?@82 @D416>54528 @>2 @33>2127;57A @7= 69 412 @?45678 6> @?45E54528 69 412 324545672> 412= 81@:: 96::6H 412 3>632> 3>6?2;D>2 @8 ?6742C3:@42;D7;2>2?4567$69412+?47?@8269 57E6K57A 8D?1 @ 3>6E58567 412= 81@:: 3>6E5;2 @ 3>632> 6336>4D754=@7;96::6H4123>57?53:28697@4D>@:GD845?2@7; 3>6E5;2@::8D?1C@42>5@:8<296>24@K57A@7=;>@845?8423 7 412 3>28274 ?@82 67 1@7; 412 2B42>7C274 32>56; 1@E57A @:>2@;= ?6C2 46 @7 27; 4158 C2>2:= >2C@578 @7 @?@;2C5? 5742>284 96> 767#96::6H57A 69 412 3>632> 3>6?2;D>2 ?6742C3:@42; D7;2> 412 + ?4 @7; 412 GD;AC27469412670<:232B6D>457412?@8269 *D3>@, 158 6D>4 58 57?:572; 46 816H 57;D:A27?2 57 412 C@442>96>1@E57A76496::6H2;412AD5;2:5728:@5;;6H7<= 412 670<:2 32B 6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69 *D3>@, ??6>;57A:=3@8841296::6H57A - 14 - 5 12H>543245456758 55 12 5C3DA72; 6>;2> ;@42; (''($ 3@882; <= >28367;274 6 E5;2 772BD>2# 58 12>2<= FD@812; 555 6H2E2>5458C@;2?:2@>41@441586>;2>H5:: 764 3>2?:D;2 412 @D416>54528 46 57545@42 @33>63>5@42 3>6?22;57A8 59 54 86 H@>>@748 <D4 H15:2 ;657A 86 >28367;274 @D416>5452881@::96::6H;D23>6?2;D>269:@H57 84>5?4@;12>27?246412GD;AC2746967/<:232B6D>457 412?@8269 '( % & ! 5846':6$' 2 ( 7:572JJ