- 1 - !"# $%& !" !#$#% & ' ( !#%%% Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !#$#% & ' ( ) ( * +!, %%# % , *( !" "#%# * #%## * $$$ , * ( , * -, - 3 - ./0123.4./05.167859.4:7023.;.2<2<75.09 ./05.1 11<2<75/4 7=.05>.52 1=76/2. <9 1<0.62.1272/?.572<6.:7023.0.9;751.52!2/2. 3<9 ;.2<2<75 <9 :<4.1 9..?<5@ 23. :7447A<5@ 0.4<.:9 ! " # $ % ! & '( $ ) " # ( ( * +, $ ) - ) #./ )*0 11.2 ( 00! ( ) 1 ( / ) +, #333 4( 5 60 ) 5 $ % ! $+! -7 0 ( $$ $ ($ $ 5 8 $ !9 .2<2<75.09 64/<> 27 B. 23. 4.@/4 3.<09 7: 75. 0<3<=/93/0/5/;;/ /52/@< 3. B0723.0 7: 9/<1 3<=/93/0/5/;;/0<<11/;;/ 73<=/4<5@/;;//52/@< :<4.1/98<2<57 %$7523.:<4.7:23.0<56<;/4 - 4 - .5<70 <=<4 ,81@. /51 , /4/B80/@< :70 ;/02<2<75 /51 9.;/0/2.;799.99<7580<5@23.;.51.56C7:23.98<29/<1 <11/;;/ 1<.1 /51 3<9 4.@/4 0.;0.9.52/2<=.9 6/>. 75 0.67017A.=.023.98<2:<4.1BC23.9/<1;.09756/>.27 B. 1<9><99.1 675:<0><5@ 23. 70/4 ;/02<2<75 7: 23. 1.:.51/529 3. ;4/<52<::9 63/44.5@.1 23. 9/<1 D81@>.52 /51 1.60.. <5 7$ % 75 23. :<4. 7: 23. /B780 7802 /4/B80/@<3.47A.0/;;.44/2.7802/:2.03./0<5@ 23.>/22.01<9><99.123./;;./4675:<0><5@23.D81@>.52 /51 1.60.. 7: 23. 20</4 7802 3. 9/<1 3<=/93/0/5/;;/ 1<.175%%#<./:2.0;/99<5@7:23.D81@>.52<5 7$ %4./=<5@B.3<513<9A<:.1/8@32.0/51975 # 3<9B.<5@23.92/2.7:/::/<09;.2<2<75.079 /51<.23.A<:./519757:23.9/<13<=/93/0/5/;;/ :<4.1/5/;;4<6/2<752723.7>><99<75.0<2C70;70/2<75 /4/B80/@<:70>82/2<5@23.<05/>.9D7<524CA<230.@/0127 23.3789.;07;.02CB./0<5@70;70/2<757!"3/=<5@ $$$9<28/2.1/20/3/>;80 /4/B80/@< 66701<5@4C 23.<0 5/>.9 A.0. .52.0.1 D7<524C <5 !?3/2/ :70 23. C./0 - 5 - %#!% 2 <9 :8023.0 6752.51.1 23/2 .=.5 2378@3 ;.2<2<75.0 7 /51 3<9 8564.9 /0. <5 ;799.99<75 7: 23.<0 0.9;.62<=.93/0.9/9;.070/4;/02<2<7523.9/>.A/9572 >82/2.1<523.<2C80=.C0.67019/5123.3789.;07;.02C A/992/51<5@D7<524C<523.5/>.97:0<3<=/93/0/5/;;/ 0<<11/;;//510</63/;;/A3<63<9.=<1.52:07>23. <.41 77? <998.1 BC 23. <2C 80=.C ::<6. .2<2<75.0 79/51 /:2.0 @.22<5@ 23.5/>.9>82/2.1 <5 23.<2C 70;70/2<750.67019>7=.1/5/;;4<6/2<7575%$%# 27 23. 99<92/52 <0.6270 7: /51 .67019 <2C 80=.C /4/B80/@< :70 >82/2<5@ 23.<0 5/>.9 D7<524C <5 23. <2C 80=.C 0.67019 A<23 0.@/01 27 3789. B./0<5@ 70;70/2<75 7!" 3/=<5@ ;4<523 /0./ 7: "#%# 9E >209 272/44C >./980<5@ #%## 9E >209 9<28/2.1 /2 0/3/>;80 /4/B80/@< 3. <2C 80=.C ::<6. <998.1 / 4.22.0 <59;.62.1 23. ;07;.02C 6751862.1 / 980=.C <5 23. ;0.9.56.7:;.2<2<75.092<9/49798B><22.123/29<92.07: ;.2<2<75.0 7 3/9 <5 :/62 .=.5 @<=.5 / 6759.52 4.22.0 1/2.1 $%"%# B.:70. 23. 99<92/52 <0.6270 7: /51 - 6 - .6701992/2<5@23/293.3/9577BD.62<75:70>82/2<5@23. 5/>.9 7: ;.2<2<75.09 <. B0723.0 /51 >723.0 D7<524C <5 0.9;.627:23.;07;.02C<5E8.92<75 3<9B.<5@23.92/2.7:/::/<090.9;751.527 <592./17:;/99<5@23.701.07:>82/2<75<523.D7<525/>.9 7: ;.2<2<75.09 0.D.62.1 23. /;;4<6/2<75 =<1. 701.0 1/2.1 %%#/99<@5<5@23.0./97523/223.0.<9/67>;4/<52 :<4.1BC75.7:23./;;4<6/5223/2/.@84/0.6751 ;;./4 <9;0.:.00.1/5123.9/>.<9;.51<5@B.:70.23.<@37802 7: /05/2/?/ <5 7%%%" %# @@0<.=.1 BC 23. <5/62<757:23.0.9;751.529<5D7<524C>82/2<5@23.5/>.9 7: ;.2<2<75.0 79 /51 75 23. ;0.><9. 23/2 23.0. <9 / .@84/0 .6751 ;;./4 ;.51<5@ B.:70. 23<9 7802 23. ;0.9.52;.2<2<75<9:<4.1BC23.;.2<2<75.09 ) ./05.1 11<2<75/4 7=.05>.52 1=76/2. 0.;0.9.52<5@ 23.0.9;751.52!2/2. 98B><29 23/2 3.A7841 <592086223.7::<6.092767>;4CA<2323.<0684/0<998.1BC - 7 - 23. 7=.05>.52 7: /05/2/?/ 1/2.1 %% ;/02<684/04C@8<1.4<5.79/51)7:23.9/<1572<:<6/2<759 $ ./05.167859.4:7023.;.2<2<75.090.4<.98;75/ D81@>.527:23.75-B4. ;.F7802<523.6/9.7: 0.;702.1 <5 /51 0.4<.9 75 8558>B.0.1;/0/!<598;;7027:3<96/9. " 5 =<.A 7: 23. :/62 23/2 23. 98<2 :<4.1 BC 23. 8564. 7: 23. ;.2<2<75.0 7 3/9 B..5 1<9><99.1 /51 675:<0>.1 <5 23. .@84/0 ;;./4 >.0. ;.51.56C 7: 23. .@84/0.6751 ;;./46/5572B.23.@07851:700.:89/47: 23. >82/2<75 .520<.9 BC 23. 0.9;751.529 <5 :/=780 7: 23. ;.2<2<75.09 3. 0.9;751.529 /0. B7851 27 :7447A 23. <0684/0 63/5@. 23. >82/2<75 .520<.9 /9 ;.0 23. D81@>.529 7: 23. 7802 /51 <5 :8280. <: /5C 1.6<9<75 <9 /00<=.1 A3<63 63/5@.9 23. .520C 23.5 75 9863 /;;4<6/2<7523.9/>.67841B.6759<1.0.1/2/:8280.;7<52 7:2<>..=.023.4.99:7023.;0.9.5223.0.9;751.529/0. - 8 - B785127:7447A23.<0684/0A3/2<9/=/<4/B4.750.6701/9 7:57A/5123.D81@>.520.51.0.1BC23.7802 % 51.023.6<068>92/56.9;/9923.:7447A<5@ < 3.A0<2;.2<2<75<9/447A.1 << 3. <>;8@5.1 .51709.>.52 1/2.1 %%# <998.1 BC 0.9;751.52 7 /2 55.F80.!, <9 3.0.BCE8/93.1 <<< 3. A0<2 7: >/51/>89 <9 <998.1 1<0.62<5@ 0.9;751.52 7 27 >82/2. 23. 5/>.9 7: ;.2<2<75.09<50.67019A<230.@/01273789. B./0<5@ 70;70/2<75 7!" 3/=<5@ ;4<523 /0./7:"#%#9E>209272/44C>./980<5@ #%## 9E >209 3/=<5@ 7$$$ 9<28/2.1 /2 0/3/>;80 /4/B80/@< A<23<5 / ;.0<717::780A..?9:07>23.1/2.7:0.6.<;27: /67;C7:23<9701.0 '% $& # <92747