Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55071 (KAR)
KANAKAREDDY v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200376/2025 · 2026-01-13
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55071 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55071 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!! $%%
&'
(&) *
!! "
!! # ! " $
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
$
!! $ &&
' !! !! $
!!! !!! !! !! &"! (
"
!! #
"
"
- 3 -
!! $
" $
# "
"
% (
"
' !! "
" $
$ "
!! !! !! #
- 4 -
!! $
! (
!! $
"!! " #
#
"!! % "(
! #
' (
"!! "
- 5 -
$ "
!! #
!! "
" #
!! $
!! #
# !! - 6 -
% ! !! "
'
$ (
!! "
!!" %
"
! #
"
- 7 -
" !! %
!!! # !! % (
"!! !! ' "
$
" '
- 8 -
" " $
"
!! " #
! $
!! $
# !! "!! #
% "
! !!! !! #
- 9 -
'
" #
#$ "
!! # "
"!! " $
# !! !! # "
!! #
!! )!! *" ! +
&
" !! &
"" *
! #+
- 10 -
!! $ &
)! *" !!&
, +
& *+
&*!+ ! $$ $ ! " -"
& + !! ##
#
" ! "! & $
&!&
&&!" %*+*.+ '*+ '*+ '*+ *+ *+ '*+ *+ *+ $'*+ *+ *+ $'*+ $*+ % ( '$
& " *+*/+ *+*0+ *+*1+*.+ *+*2+
& *!+ $! &
&
-"
&
!! &
( 3
- 11 -
3
4"
!$
5.0 677869 .0 :.98; <=;8/ 8>?.@= *+ @:
>58;<98 60?8 6=; >58;<98 /.A8 *!/828=?.@= @:
?/@>.?.80+>?''*:@/05@/?B6=;*! +>?C+:@/ D/6=?@:6=?.>.76?@/EA6.9.=/.F8@$@:</2.569 !@9.>8 ?6?.@= :@/ ?58 @::8=>80 7<=.056A98 <=;8/ 8>?.@=0 %*+*.+'*+'*+'*+*+*+'*+ *+ *+ $'*+ *+ *+ $'*+ $*+ % /86; 1.?5 8>?.@= '$ @: " 6=; <=;8/ 8>?.@= *+*/+ *+*0+ *+*1+*.+ *+*2+ @:
6=;*! +F8=;F8=?>?$7/808=?9E78=;.=D@= ?58 :.98 @: ;;.?.@=69 .0?/.>? 6=; 800.@=0 <;D8 6.>5</0.??.=D6?.=;56=</
58 :6>?<69 F6?/.G @: ?58 >608 .0 ?56? @=8 F6/8056@.;;6776699..8/807@=;8=?@9@;D8;
?58>@F796.=?A8:@/8/807@=;8=?@7@9.>86998D.=D?56? 58 @=8 6=D6FF6 ./F696 6=H<=6?5 ./<76==6 56=?6FF6 </D6776 6/.E6FF6 6=; 6F805 6/8
- 12 -
A89@=D0?@>58;<98;60?86=;?58E6/8?58/80.;8=?0@:
6??.D<;;6 2.996D8 .= .=;56=</ 69<I 58 6778996=?0 6>><08; 6/8 690@ ?58 /80.;8=?0 @: 06F8 2.996D8 6=; ?58E 6/8 =@? ?58 F8FA8/0 @: >58;<98; 60?8 @/ >58;<98;
/.A858/81606;.07<?8A8?188= </D677615@.0?58 :6?58/.=961 @: >@F796.=6=?
6=; 6>><08; @'
F6/8056776 0@= @: 5.FF6/6;;8776 .= /8078>? @:
76?516E 986;.=D ?@ ?58./ 96=;0 58 89;8/0 @: ?58 :6F.9E 6=; 2.996D8/0 5628 08??98;?58 06.;;.07<?8@1828/ ?58 6>><08;18/8=@</.05.=D.991.996=;6=.F@0.?E6D6.=0??58 2.>?.F0>@F796.=6=?6=;5.0:6F.9EF8FA8/0 5.=D0 0?@@; ?5<0 @= $%$ 6? 6A@<? 3$ 6F ?58 6>><08; <08; >/.F.=69 :@/>8 6D6.=0? 6=D6FF6 1.?5 6= .=?8=?.@= ?@ @<?/6D8 58/ F@;80?E 6=; 058 160 F6=56=;98; 58 06.; :6>? 160 A/@<D5? ?@ ?58 =@?.>8 @:
89;8/0 6=; ?58E 5628 /80@928; ?58./ ;.07<?8 58/86:?8/ ?586>><08;AE056/.=D?5806.;F8006D80.=0@>.69F8;.6 ?5/@<D5 ?58./ >@FF<=.?E AE ?6/D8?.=D ?58 >60?8 @: ?58 2.>?.F0@=$6?6A@<?$$7F6=6I6/8;;E
- 13 -
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
@F6058I56/ "606=6D@<;6 5.FF6/8;;E ./<76I056 F6/6D@<;6 6=<F6=?56 8;;E 6=; @=8 F/8056776 5628 F6;8 6= 6??8F7? ?@ >@FF.? /678 @: @=8 ./F696 58E690@<08;>/.F.=69:@/>86D6.=0?58/1.?56=.=?8=?.@= ?@ @<?/6D8 58/ F@;80?E 58/86:?8/ ?58E 6006<9?8; ?58
- 14 -
2.>?.F0 6=; >6<08; .=H</.80 AE ?6/D8?.=D ?58 >60?8 @: ?58 >@F796.=6=? >>@/;.=D ?@ ?58 >@F796.=6=? .= ?58 06.;
.=>.;8=? ?58 D@9;8= >56.= 18.D5.=D ?@960 160 9@0? 6=;
?58E 690@ ;6F6D8; ?58 5@<08 @: ?58 2.>?.F0 6?8/ ?58 2.>?.F0 18/8 05.:?8; ?@ ?58 @28/=F8=? @07.?69 .=;56=</ 6=;6>>@/;.=D9E ?58E 9@;D8; ?58 >@F796.=? @= '$6? $3$$ 7F 15.>5 160 /8D.0?8/8;.=/.F8 @$;6?8;'$AE?58</2.569!@9.>8:@/ ?58 6:@/8F8=?.@=8; @::8=>80 >>@/;.=D ?@ ?58 6>><08;6778996=?0 828/ 0.=>8 ?58 ;6?8 @: /8D.0?/6?.@= @: &/807@=;8=?@7@9.>86/8F6I.=D58>?.>6??8F7?0 ?@ 6//80? ?58 6778996=?0 0 0<>5 ?58E 6/8 <=;8/ ?58 677/858=0.@=@:?58./6//80?8=>8?58E677/@6>58;?58 ;;.?.@=69 .0?/.>?6=;800.@=0<;D86.>5</0.??.=D 6? .=;56=</ :@/ D/6=? @: 6=?.>.76?@/E A6.9 .= /9.0>@$ 6=; ?58 06F8 160 /8H8>?8; 2.;8 @/;8/;6?8;$$8=>8?5.0677869
86/; ?58 986/=8; >@<=089 :@/ ?58 6778996=?0 6=; 986/=8; .D5 @</? @28/=F8=? !986;8/ :@/
- 15 -
/807@=;8=? @?6?8 807@=;8=? @ .0 78/0@=699E 7/808=?A8:@/8?58@</? 76/? :/@F </D.=D 0828/69 >@=?8=?.@=0 986/=8;
>@<=089 :@/ ?58 6778996=?0 7/.F6/.9E >@=?8=;8; ?56? ?58 :6908>608560A88=:@.0?8;AE?58>@F796.=6=?0.=>8?58/8 160676?516E;.07<?8A8?188=?1@>@FF<=.?.808690@ >@=?8=?8;?56?6>@<=?8/>@F796.=?560A88=/8D.0?8/8;.= /.F8 @'$ ;6?8; '$ .= /8078>? ?@ ?58 06F8 .=>.;8=?
:@/?58 @::8=>807<=.056A98 <=;8/ 8>?.@=0 '*+'*+'*+*+%*+$'*+ *+/18>?.@='$@:"$6D6.=0?#78/0@=0 .=>9<;.=D?58>@F796.=6=?6=;?582.>?.F0.=?5.0>608
8 :</?58/ >@=?8=;8; ?56? @= 78/<069 @: ?58 >@F796.=?628/F8=?0?5806F8;87.>?0@F=.A<06998D6?.@=0 6D6.=0? 699 ?58 6>><08; 1.?5@<? 796>.=D 6=E F6?8/.69 ?@ 6??/6>? ?58 7/@2.0.@= <=;8/ ?58 " @/ <=;8/ ?58 7/@2.0.@= @: *! + >? ;;.?.@=699E 58 >@=?8=?8; ?56? ;</.=D ?58 >@</08 @: .=280?.D6?.@= .? 160 /828698; ?56? ?582.>?.F0 5628 =@?0<0?6.=8;6=E .=H</.80
- 16 -
606998D8;.=?58>@F796.=?6=;?58E56280<0?6.=8;@=9E 6A/60.@=0 6=; ?58 7@9.>8 5628 =@? 08.K8; ?58 D@9;8= 6/?.>98015.>518/86998D8;9E9@0?.=?58.=>.;8=?56?.?089:
05@10 6 :6908 >@F796.=? 560 A88= :@.0?8; AE ?58 >@F796.=6=?80<AF.?0?56??5.0.06;.07<?8A8?188=?58 ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80 60 0<>5 ?58/8 .0 =@ 0<>5 .=>.;8=? 560 >6<08;>>@/;.=D9E587/6E0?@699@1?58677869
986/=8; .D5 @</? @28/=F8=? 2858F8=?9E @77@08; ?58 7/6E8/ 6=; >@=?8=?8; ?56? ?58 6778996=?0 6/8=@? 8=?.?98; :@/ 6=?.>.76?@/EA6.9 .=2.81@:
?58A6/<=;8/8>?.@=*+@:*! +>?&</?58/ 58 690@ >@=?8=;8; ?56? ?58 >@F796.=6=? .= ?5.0 >608 560 9@;D8;?5.0>@F796.=?6=;0<A08J<8=?9E6:6908>@F796.=? 560A88=9@;D8;AE?586778996=?0=0<>5>./><F0?6=>8 >608 F6;8 @<? 6D6.=0? ?5808 6778996=?0 >>@/;.=D9E587/6E0?@;.0F.00?58677869 # 807@=;8=? @ .0 7/808=? A8:@/8 ?5.0 @</? 6=; 796>8; ?58 75@?@D/6750 @: ?58 .=H</.80 0<0?6.=8; AE
- 17 -
5.F 6=; @?58/ :6F.9E F8FA8/0 6=; 7/6E0 ?@ ;.0F.00 ?58 677869 % 5628D.28=FE6=G.@<0>@=0.;8/6?.@=A@?5@= ?58 0<AF.00.@= F6;8 AE ?58 986/=8; >@<=089 :@/ ?58 /8078>?.28 76/?.80 6=; /807@=;8=? @ 0@ 690@ 78/<08;
?58;@><F8=?0F6;8626.96A98A8:@/8?5.0@</? 0 >@<9; A8 D6?58/8; :/@F /8>@/;0 ?58 >@F796.=6=? 2.>?.F0 6=; ?58 6>><08;6778996=?0 6/8 /80.;.=D .= ?58 06F8 2.996D8 58/8 .0 6 ;.07<?8 78=;.=D A8?188=?58F.=/8078>?@:676?516E&</?58/@=>6/8:<9 78/<069 @: ?58 >@F796.=? 628/F8=?0 .? .0 0?6?8; ?56? @= 0828/69 @>>60.@=0 !6=>56E6?5 18/8 589; ?@ /80@928 ?58 ;.07<?8 A8?188= ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80 >>@/;.=D ?@ ?58 >@F796.=6=? ?58 6778996=?0 .8 # 78/0@=0 6? 6 ?.F8 8=?8/8;?58./5@<086=;F6;86=6??8F7??@@<?/6D8?58 F@;80?E @: @=8 ./F696 6=; 690@ 6006<9?8; ?58F 1.?5 ;86;9E1867@=0@1828/?581@<=;>8/?.:.>6?8;.0>9@080 ?56? ?58E 5628 0<0?6.=8; @=9E 0.F798 .=H</.80 .8
- 18 -
6A/60.@=0 6=; .FF8;.6?89E ;.0>56/D8; :/@F ?58 @07.?69 6:?8/?6I.=D:./0?6.; ' 0/.D5?9E>@=?8=?8;AE?58986/=8;>@<=089:@/ ?586778996=?0?58.=280?.D6?.@=@::.>8/560=@?08.K8;6=E D@9;8= 6/?.>980 @ ;@<A? ?58/8 .0 6 A6/ 7/@2.;8; <=;8/ 8>?.@= *+ @: ?58 *! + >? :@/ D/6=? @: 6=?.>.76?@/EA6.9@1828/?58@=4A9878G@</?.=?58 >608@: /87@/?8; .= .? .0 589; ?56? 699 .=0<9?0 @/ .=?.F.;6?.@=0?@678/0@=1.99=@?A86=@::8=>8<=;8/?58 >? <=9800 0<>5 .=0<9? @/ .=?.F.;6?.@= .0 @= 6>>@<=?
@:
2.>?.F A89@=D0 ?@ >58;<98; 60?8 @/ >58;<98; /.A8 &</?58/ ?58 @=4A98 78G @</? .= ?58 >608 @:
/87@/?8;.= !560589;.=76/6 %60<=;8/3
- 19 -
! " #
$ %
& '
" % &
$ #
" %
" &
" %
" # $ %
" (
)
$ = ?58 .=0?6=? >608 6;F.??8;9E ?58/8 .0 6 >@<=?8/ >@F796.=? :.98; AE ?58 6>><08; .= 15.>5 ?58 >@F796.=6=?6=;2.>?.F06/86>><08;
=>6/8:<978/<069@: ?58/.269>@F796.=?06=;&.?>@<9;A8D6?58/8;?56??58 >6086=;6>@<=?8/>608160:@.0?8;.=2.81@:?58D/@<7 >9605 .= A8?188= ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80 1.?5 /8078>? ?@ ?58 76?516E
- 20 -
= 0<>5 >./><F0?6=>80 ?58 ><0?@;.69 .=?8//@D6?.@= @: ?58 6778996=?0 ;@80 =@? >699 :@/ >>@/;.=D9E1.?5@<?8G7/800.=D6=E@7.=.@=@=?58F8/.?0 @:?58>6080<::.>8?@5@9;?56??586778996=?06>><08;>6= A88=96/D8;@=6=?.>.76?@/EA6.98=>8?58:@99@1.=D,
.58/.F.=6977869.0""# .. 58 @/;8/ ;6?8; $$ 76008; .= /9.0>@$ AE ?58 ;;9 .0?/.>? 6=;800.@=0<;D86.>5</0.??.=D6?.=;56=</ .058/8AE08?60.;8 ...586778996=?06>><08;@0?@##?@# 6/8 ;./8>?8; ?@ A8 8=96/D8; @= A6.9 .= /.F8 @$ /8D.0?8/8; AE </2.569 !@9.>8 ?6?.@= :@/ ?58 @::8=>80 7<=.056A98 <=;8/ 8>?.@=0 %*+*.+ '*+ '*+ '*+ *+ *+ '*+ *+ *+ $'*+ *+ *+ $'*+ $*+
- 21 -
% /86; 1.?5 8>?.@= '$ @: " $ 6=; 8>?.@=0 *+*/+ *+*0+ *+*1+*.+ *+*2+ @:
6=;*! +F8=;F8=?>?$0<AH8>? ?@?58:@99@1.=D>@=;.?.@=03 6+ 58 6778996=?0 05699 8G8><?8 6 78/0@=69 A@=; :@/ 6 0<F @: 0$$$$$86>51.?5?1@0</8?.80:@/ ?58 9.I80<F ?@ ?58 06?.0:6>?.@= @: ?58 H</.0;.>?.@=69@</?, A+ 586778996=?0 05699 67786//8D<96/9E @= 699 ?58 ;6?80 @: 586/.=D A8:@/8 ?58 /.69 @</? <=9800 ?58 /.69 @</? 8G8F7?0 ?58./ 67786/6=>8 :@/ 269.; /860@=0, >+ 58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? ;./8>?9E @/ .=;./8>?9E ?5/86?8= @/ ?6F78/ 1.?5 ?58 7/@08><?.@=1.?=80080,
- 22 -
;+ 58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? .=2@928 .= 0.F.96/@::8=>80.=:<?</8, 8+ 58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? 98628 ?58 H</.0;.>?.@= @: ?58 /.69 @</? 1.?5@<? 78/F.00.@= @: ?58 06.; @</? <=?.9 ?58 >608/8D.0?8/8;6D6.=0??58F.0;.07@08; @:: :+ 58 6778996=?0 05699 F6/I ?58./ 6??8=;6=>8 A8:@/8 ?58 ?6?.@= @<08 ::.>8/ </2.569 !@9.>8 ?6?.@= @= :./0? <=;6E @: 828/E F@=?5 A8?188= $$$ 6F 6=; $$$ 7F ?.99 ?58 >608 /8D.0?8/8; 6D6.=0? ?58F .0 ;.07@08; @::
A8:@/8?58/.69@</? +' &!) ! .0?@39@3 3