- 1 - !"!# $%" " % &'&()*'+& ) , ! " #$ % & ' $ $ & $ $ ( ) ' ( " #$ $&% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & )(!& #%)( &$#'% ' $ $ & $ #% # ' % & & *$ & #% & && $(+#%+#%)#%#,%&$ ' #% & & & - && & & ' . . /$ 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 )( 68 $0><>51?> >@><1A;<>A20>>7015> (B?504345151674<>==;24: 86< @<>75 68 <4@;9>< B>19 17 34=1>9 >24 #% 6 ><1217@6;568<1,46 <4@1254<4: B? 1C>?>3;<> '6,47 691=4 5>5167 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>B94 ;7:4< 4=51672 (+#% +#% )#%#,% 68 $0><>51?>?>?>>7015> (>7:4=51672#9%>7:68 <654=5167 68 019:<47 8<6, 4D;>9 8847=42 =5 #E =5*86<206<5% 048>=5;>9,>5<1D68504=>241250>5504F1=51, 17 5012 =>24 G>2 86;7: ,12217@ 8<6, 504 06;24 68 - 3 - =6,39>17>758<6, ! 854<,>A17@>7>554,3556 5<>=4 04< 504 =6,39>17>75 B417@ 04< 8>504< 96:@4: 504 =6,39>175 B486<4 504 <42367:4753691=4 G01=0 G>2 <4@1254<4:17<1,46 >@>1725;7A76G734<2672 86< 504 68847=4 3;7120>B94 ;7:4< 4=5167 (+#% 68 $ ;B24H;4759? :;<17@ 504 =6;<24 68 17F4251@>5167 504 <42367:4753691=4 ;367 5<>=17@ 504 F1=51, >5 1C>?>3;<> $;2 5>7: 67 ) ! >967@ G150 >==;24: <4=6<:4: 04< 25>54,475 G04<417 204 25>54: 50>5 504 >==;24: 345151674<0>:86<=1B9?5>A4704<>7:A43504<17>96:@4>5 >9>,@;5><4>6>86<>34<16:50<44:>?2>7:=6,,1554: 86<=1B94 24D;>9 1754<=6;<24 67 04< 2 2;=0 504 <42367:4753691=417F6A4:5043<6F1216768;7:4<4=51672 +#%)#%#,%68$ (>7:4=51672#9%>7:68 =5>@>1725504345151674<>==;24: ( 04<4>854< <42367:4753691=4 ><<4254: 504 345151674<672>,4:>?1 4 67 ) ! =67:;=54:504 17F4251@>5167 >7: 9>1: =0><@4 >@>1725 01, 86< 504 >86<4,4751674: 68847=42 B486<4 504 34=1>9 6;<5 $417@ - 4 - >@@<14F4: B? 504 =;256:1>9 17=><=4<>5167 504 345151674< 8194:B>19 >3391=>5167B486<4 504 ::15167>9 4221672 ;:@4 &>25 <>=A 34=1>9 6;<5 1C>?>3;<> 17 <1,17>9 12= 6 !) >7:5042>,4G>2<4C4=54:F1:46<:4< :>54: 47=4501234515167 ) 4><:94><74:=6;724986<504345151674<>7:504 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7,475 94>:4< 86< <42367:475 6 5>54 06;@0 7651=4 12 24<F4: 56 <42367:475 6 04<4,>174:>B2475 3><5 8<6, ;<@17@ 24F4<>9 =6754751672 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1,><19? =6754754: 50>5 6734<;2>968504=6,39>175>F4<,4752:12=9624250>5 504 345151674< >7: F1=51, G4<4 17 96F4 >7: 504 F1=51, F69;75><19?C6174:504=6,3>7?68345151674<>7:504?B650 G4<4 24D;>99? >=51F4 &;<504< >==6<:17@ 56 01, 504 17F4251@>517@ 6881=4< 8>194: 56 39>=4 >7? >;504751=>54: :6=;,475 56 3<6F4 504 >@4 68 504 F1=51, 50>5 204 G>2 ,176<>550451,46817=1:475 4>926=67547:4:50>5504 - 5 - ,4:1=>9 <436<5 :642 765 :12=9624 >7? <4=475 34745<>51F4 24D;>9>=5 ==6<:17@9?043<>?256>996G50434515167 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7,475 94>:4< 633624: 504 B>19 34515167 67 504 @<6;7: 50>5 504 =0><@4 20445 ,>54<1>9 :12=96242 > 04176;2 68847=4 3><5 8<6, 50>5 504 F1=51, 17 04< ( 25>54,475 25>54: >B6;5 50486<=1B9424D;>9>=568504>==;24:6704< ==6<:17@9? 3<>?256:12,122504B>1934515167 + 0>F4@1F47,?>7D16;2=6721:4<>5167B65067 504 2;B,1221672 ,>:4 B? 504 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51F43><5142>7:34<;24:504:6=;,4752>F>19>B9467 <4=6<: 2 =6;9: B4 @>504<4: 8<6, 504 =6,39>175 >7: 6504< <4=6<:2 504 F1=51, G>2 ,12217@ 8<6, ! >7:>,12217@=6,39>175G>296:@4:675042>,4:>?B? 04< 8>504< 04<4>854< F1=51, >7: 5012 345151674< G4<4 5<>=4: 67 ) ! >5 1C>?>3;<> $;2 5>7: 7 47H;1<?15G>2<4F4>94:50>5504?B65025>?4:56@4504<>5 - 6 - 6>86<>34<16:6850<44:>?2 :,1554:9?504F1=51,G>2 765 1786<,4: 6< 96:@4: >7? =6,39>175 5199 ) ! 2 <1@059?=6754754:B?50494><74:=6;724986<504345151674< 4D=435 39>=17@ 504 =0669 4<5181=>54 122;4: B? 504 4>:,>254< 68 504 =0669 76 6504< >;504751=>54: :6=;,47520>2B44739>=4:B?5047F4251@>5167881=4<56 3<6F4504>@468F1=51, 06;@0151225>54:17504=0><@4 2044550>5504<4G>2>86<=1B9424D;>9>=5B?504>==;24: 67504F1=51,50425>54,4756804<>7:504=0><@420445 ,>54<1>92 @642 56 206G 50>5 504<4 G>2 > =672472;>9 24D B45G447504F1=51,>7:345151674< ! 512245594:36215167689>GB?50467*B94 34D 6;<517504=>2468 <436<54: 17 50>5 G047 > G6,47 G06 G19917@9? 47@>@42 17 > 967@ 54<, 24D;>9 <49>51672013 G150 > ,>7 8;99?>G><4681527>5;<4>7:G1506;5>7?=6@4754F1:47=4 56 206G 50>5 2;=0 <49>51672013 G>2 17:;=4: B? ,12=67=435167688>=526<8>9243<6,12468,><<1>@4,>:4 - 7 - 17 B>: 8>150 8<6, 504 17=435167 504 ,>7 =>7765 B4 049: @;195?68<>34;7:4<4=5167(+68 04 ,>54<1>92 39>=4: 17 5012 =>24 :12=9624250>5504F1=51,F69;75><19?C6174:504>==;24:>7: 504? 25>?4: 56@4504< 86< > 34<16: 68 50<44 :>?2 >7: 0>: =672472;>924D;>9>=5 6745049422504>@468504F1=51, >7: 04< 25>54,475 ;7:4< 4=5167 ( 68 $ 0>2 56 B4 3<6F4: 504 F4<>=15? 17 > :45>194: 5<1>9 17=4 504 17F4251@>5167 12 =6,39454: >7: =0><@4 20445 0>2 B447 8194:504=;256:1>917=><=4<>516768504345151674<:642765 =>9986< 750>5F14G68504,>554<G1506;54D3<42217@>7? 631716767504,4<15268504=>242;881=456069:50>5504 345151674<>==;24:=>7B4479><@4:67B>19 ==6<:17@9? 3<6=44:563>2250486996G17@. 043451516712 04345151674<>==;24:12:1<4=54:56B4479><@4:67 B>191734=1>9>24#%6 #><1217@6;568 - 8 - <1,46 %<4@1254<4:B?5041C>?>3;<>'6,47 691=45>516786<50468847=423;7120>B94;7:4<4=51672 (+#%+#%)#%#,%68$ (>7:4=51672#9% I68 =52;BC4=55650486996G17@=67:151672. >% 04 345151674< 20>99 4D4=;54 > 34<267>9 B67: 86< > 2;, 68 2 G150 5G6 2;<4514286<50491A42;,565042>5128>=516768 504C;<12:1=5167>96;<5J B% 04345151674<20>99>334><<4@;9><9?67>99 504 :>542 68 04><17@ B486<4 504 <1>9 6;<5 ;79422504 <1>96;<54D4,352012>334><>7=4 86<F>91:<4>2672J =% 04 345151674< 20>99 765 :1<4=59? 6< 17:1<4=59? 50<4>547 6< 5>,34< G150 504 3<624=;5167G15742242J :% 04 345151674< 20>99 765 17F69F4 17 21,19>< 68847=42178;5;<4J 4% 04 345151674< 20>99 765 94>F4 504 C;<12:1=5167 68 504 <1>9 6;<5 G1506;5 34<,122167 68 504 2>1: 6;<5 ;7519 504 =>24 <4@1254<4:>@>172501,12:123624:688 - 9 - 8% 04 345151674< 20>99 ,><A 012 >5547:>7=4 B486<4 504 5>5167 6;24 881=4< 1C>?>3;<> '6,47 691=4 5>5167 1C>?>3;<> 67 81<25 ;7:>? 68 4F4<? ,6750 B45G447 > , >7: 3 , 5199 504 =>24 <4@1254<4: >@>1725 01, 12 :123624: 688 B486<4 504 <1>9 6;<5 -* &" ) " 1256 .96 . .