- 1 - ! " # $!! $ %&'%()*' %) + !"#"$%& '(# '# %%' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '%'$&'% ) ) * +,- ./0,0,12 ,- 3,4/5 625/7 /80,12 '# 13 +9790,:9 9;97,<9 679<-+9 92+,09 %( 317 -+170 = > 317 ;7920 13 920,8,.9017: ?9,4 ,2 7,@/ 1%%' 590/5 $"%%' 7/;,-0/7/5 ?: +9+9?95 1A2 14,8/ 317 0+/ 133/28/- .62,-+9?4/ 625/7 /80,12- '% '$& 925 '% 13 +/ 3980694 @907,B 13 0+/ 89-/ ,- 0+90 0+/ 81@.49,2920 29@/4:12/ 1+,0 ,C9:<920+90,4 7/-,5/20 13 +92<67 D,449;/ +9+9?95 946< A9- 7622,2; 9 0/9 ?6-,2/-- 2/97 +92<67 871-- 371@ ' :/97- 925 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 925 +,- 39@,4: @/@?/7- 97/ 7622,2; 8410+ ?6-,2/--,20+/29@/925-0:4/13E0925975410+/20/7F 925 0+/: 94-1 7622,2; 9 8+,0 3625 ,2 0+/ 29@/ 925 -0:4/ - 3 - E 90,:9+,0625F,2928/,20+/29@/13E 90,:9,2928/ 9252D/-0@/2017.1790,12F92594-19E9+9:1;12/: 9D,2;8+/@/F,2+9+9?95371@'%:/97- ( +,2;- -0115 0+6- 0+/ 81@.49,2920 -0970/5 01 5/.1-,0 -$%%%G 12 59,4: ?9-,- ,2 0+/ 9D,2; 8+/@/ ,2071568/5 ?: 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 925 10+/7 9886-/5 ./7-12- 9250+/-9@/A9-/20/7/5,29.9--?11<371@%$%#%% 0,44978+%' +/81@.49,2920,2010945/.1-,0/59-6@ 13-"%%%%%G,20+/9D,2;8+/@/-6?-/H6/204:0+/ ./0,0,12/7 925 10+/7 9886-/5 ./7-12- 39,4/5 01 7/0672 0+/ -9,59@1620 +6-0+/./0,0,12/792510+/7-8+/90/50+/ 81@.49,2920010+/062/13-$%%%%%%G92512/2H6,7: ,0A9-94-17/D/94/50+900+/./0,0,12/79412;A,0+9886-/5 ./7-12- 8+/90/5 10+/7 &' ./7-12- A+1 A/7/ ,2D/-0/5 ,2 0+/ -9,5 9D,2;- 8+/@/ /28/ +/ 415;/5 9 81@.49,20 9;9,2-00+/./0,0,12/79412;A,0+10+/79886-/5./7-12- ' 9-/5 12 0+/ 81@.49,20 0+/ 7/-.125/20G.14,8/ 7/;,-0/7/5 9 89-/ 9;9,2-0 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 925 10+/7- ,2 - 4 - 7,@/ 1%%' 9- -090/5 -6.79 ?: 9779:,2; ./0,0,12/7 9- 9886-/5 1 D/7 -,28/ 0+/ 7/;,-0790,12 13 0+/ 7/-.125/20G.14,8/97/@9<,2;+/80,8900/@.001977/-00+/ ./0,0,12/7 - -68+ 12 0+/ 9..7/+/2-,12 13 977/-0 0+/ ./0,0,12/79..7198+/50+/554,-0I/--,12-65;/ 949?679;,,00,2;90/59@317;792013920,8,.9017:?9,4 ,27,,-81#'%"9412;A,0+ 9886-/51-(925' +/ /--,12- 65;/ ?: .9704: 9441A,2; 0+/ -9,5 ./0,0,12 ;7920/5 920,8,.9017: ?9,4 01 9886-/5 1-( 925 ' 925 7/C/80/5 0+/ ?9,4 ./0,0,12 13 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 ,/ 9886-/5 1/28/0+,-./0,0,12 " /9750+/4/972/58162-/43170+/./0,0,12/7925 4/972/5 ,;+ 1670 1D/72@/20 4/95/7 317 7/-.125/20G 090/ .970 371@ 67;,2; -/D/794 8120/20,12- 4/972/5 8162-/4 317 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 .7,@97,4: 8120/25/5 0+90 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 ,- 0+/ -12 13 9886-/5 1$ 0 0+/ 0,@/ 13 0+/ 944/;/5 ,28,5/20 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 A9- 9;/5 9?160 % :/97- - 5 - 925+/A9-.67-6,2;+,- 1@/;7//670+/7+/+9- 210 90 944 ,2D14D/5 ,2 0+/ 944/;/5 0792-980,12 ,2 92: @922/7 -,28/ 0+/ /20,7/ 8410+ -+1. 925 10+/7 ?6-,2/-- A/7/ 762 ?: +,- 390+/7 88175,2;4: .79:- 01 9441A 0+/ ./0,0,12 & 4/972/5 ,;+ 1670 1D/72@/20 4/95/7 1..1-/- 0+/ ?9,4 ./0,0,12 12 0+/ ;71625 0+90 0+/ ,2D/-0,;90,12 ,- -0,44 625/7 .71;7/-- 925 0+/ 86-015,94 ,20/771;90,12 13 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 ,- 7/H6,7/5 317 7/81D/7: 13 0+/ 944/;/5 9@1620 /28/ +/ .79:- 01 5,-@,-- 0+/ ./0,0,12 # +9D/;,D/2@:92B,16-812-,5/790,12?10+12 0+/ -6?@,--,12 @95/ ?: 0+/ 4/972/5 8162-/4 317 0+/ 7/-./80,D/.970,/--194-1./76-/50+/@90/7,94-9D9,49?4/ 127/8175 J - 81645 ?/ ;90+/7/5 371@ 7/8175- 0+/ 81@.49,20415;/5?:0+/81@.49,29207/D/94-0+90371@0+/ :/97 %% 01 %' +/ +9- ,2D/-0/5 9 -6@ 13 - 6 - -"%%%%%G ,2 0+/ 9D,2;- 8+/@/ ,2071568/5 ?: 9886-/5 1$ A+1 A9- 9 8410+ @/78+920 94-1 7622,2; 9 8+,03625?6-,2/--925,2071568/50+/9D,2;-8+/@/ $% -7,;+04:8120/25/5?:0+/4/972/58162-/4317 0+/ ./0,0,12/7 0+,- ./0,0,12/7G9886-/5 1 ,- 0+/ -12 13 9886-/51$ +/ 7,941670+9-;7920/5920,8,.9017:?9,4 01 9886-/5 1-( 925 ' A+1 97/ 212/ 10+/7 0+92 0+/ :162;/7 ?710+/7 925 @10+/7 13 0+,- ./0,0,12/7 12 0+/ ;71625 0+90 0+/7/ A9- 21 ,2D14D/@/20 13 0+/@ ,2 0+/ 944/;/50792-980,122-68+8,786@-0928/-0+,-./0,0,12/7 ,-94-1/20,04/5317920,8,.9017:?9,4120+/;7162513.97,0: /28/ A,0+160 /B.7/--,2; 92: 1.,2,12 12 0+/ @/7,0- 13 0+/89-/-633,8/01+1450+900+/./0,0,12/7,-/20,04/5317 920,8,.9017:?9,4 $$ +/ 7,@,294 /0,0,12 ,- +/ 7/-.125/20G14,8/97/5,7/80/5017/4/9-/0+/./0,0,12/7,2 0+//D/2013+,-977/-07/;,-0/7/5,27,@/1%%'?: +9+9?95 1A2 14,8/ 090,12 949?679;, 317 133/28/- - 7 - .62,-+9?4/625/7/80,12-'%'$&'%13-6?C/8001 0+/31441A,2;8125,0,12-) $ +/ /0,0,12/7 -+944 9../97 ?/317/ 0+/ 2D/-0,;90,2; 33,8/7A,0+,2$"59:-371@0+/ 590/137/8/,.0130+/81.:130+,-175/7925 -+944 /B/860/ 9 ./7-1294 ?125 317 9 -6@ 13 -$%%%%%G 6.//- 2/ 9<+ 124: A,0+ 0A1 -67/0,/- 317 0+/ 4,</-6@ 01 0+/ -90,-3980,12130+/2D/-0,;90,2; 33,8/7 /0,0,12/7 -+944 7/;64974: 9../97 ?/317/ 0+/ 7,94 1670 A,0+160 39,4 624/-- /B/@.0/5 ?: 0+/ 7,941670317D94,57/9-12- ( /0,0,12/7 -+944 210 09@./7 A,0+ 0+/ .71-/860,12 A,02/--/- 925 +/ -+944 81G1./790/ A,0+ 0+/ .14,8/ 317 ,2D/-0,;90,12 925 9../97 ?/317/ 0+/@ A+/2/D/7 8944/5 6.12 ' +/ ./0,0,12/7 -+944 210 ,2D14D/ ,2 -,@,497 133/28/-,236067/ ,* %!) ! )$ )$'K )