- 1 - ! "#$$ # %& %'() &%( * !" # $ % % & " Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( ) * +"," ! (* +",$ ' ( % )- ) * ) $, ) (* " ,) ( * ) " $( " "*) )) ,""( * &" #$"( * "(* "$ & $ ) ) ) % %) )% ) . . / % % - 3 - 012 34515167 12 8194:;7:4< 4=5167 " , 68 0><>51?> >@><1A ;<>A20> >7015> 244A17@ 56 B;>20 504 3<6=44:17@2>@>1725504345151674<2>==;24: 6256"17 6 " " ><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4 6" $ <4@1254<4:D?;<E10>9691=4 5>5167347:17@67504819468 1E19%;:@4>7:%)>5>2A186<50468847=423;7120>D94 ;7:4< 4=51672 ," "( * &($* " "( * "(* "$<F 4=5167&680><>51?> ?>?> >7015> G86< D<4E15? 504 H IJ >7: 4=51672 >7: $68 6F<? <601D15167=5&!G86<D<4E15?H504=5IJ 048>=5;>9C>5<1K68504=>241250>5345151674< 6+>99>33>C><<14:<42367:475 6 67 $ 5 504 51C4 68 C><<1>@4 504 3><4752 68 <42367:475 6 @>E4 2#"+ =>20 >967@ F150 569>2 68 @69: >7: 06;24069:><51=94256504345151674<2854<504C><<1>@4 <42367:475 6 L6174: 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 >7: 504 345151674<2 966A4: >854< 04< 3<634<9? 86< > 34<16: 68 674 ?4>< 04<4>854< >==;24: 6 >::1=54: 56 D>: E1=42 >7: - 4 - ;24: 56 0><>22 <42367:475 6 D650 30?21=>99? >7: C475>99?D?:4C>7:17@>::15167>9:6F<?682+ 06;@05042>1:>234=5F>21786<C4:D?<42367:475 6 56 >==;24: 62 >7: 14 504 17+9>F2 504? 17254>: >:E1217@ 5041< 267+>==;24: 6 17251@>54: 01C >7: >D;24: <42367:475 6 >7: >926 0><>224: 04< C475>99? >54<504?>9950<6F704<6;58<6C504C>5<1C671>906C4 2 2;=0 204 25><54: 56 <421:4 >5 04< 3><475>9 06;24 017@2 2566: 50;2 67 $ >5 >D6;5 ". 3C >==;24: 62 56 " 5<423>224: 504 3><475>9 06C4 68 <42367:475 6 >7: 31=A4: ;3 B;><<49 F150 <42367:475 6 D? :4C>7:17@ 2+ :6F<? >7: >22>;954: 04<22;=020496:@4:504=6C39>175D486<4<42367:475 6M691=467 , $>@>1725504345151674<204 2>C4 F>2 <4@1254<4: 17 <1C4 6" $ :>54: , $86<50468847=423;7120>D94;7:4< 4=51672," &($* "( * #$ "$ " "( * "(* <F 4=5167 & 68 >7: 4=51672 >7: $ 68 =5 ;D24B;4759?<42367:475 6M691=417E4251@>54: - 5 - 504 =>24 >7: 9>1: =0><@4 20445 >@>1725 81E4 >==;24: 34<2672 14 504 345151674<2 ==6<:17@9? 94><74: >@125<>54566A=6@71N>7=46850468847=42@@<14E4:D? 5042>C4504345151674<2><4D486<450126;<5 4><: 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<2 >7: 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6E4<7C475 94>:4< 86< <42367:475 6>7:94><74:=6;724986<<42367:475 6 $ 4><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<2 D? <4154<>517@ 504 @<6;7:2 ;<@4: 17 504 34515167 3<>?2 56 >996F50434515167 " 94><74:=6;724986<<42367:475 6 >7: 94><74:1@06;<56E4<7C475 94>:4<633624: 504 34515167>7:3<>?56:12C12250434515167 ! 0>E4@1E47C?>7K16;2=6721:4<>5167D65067 504 2;DC1221672 C>:4 D? 504 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51E4 3><5142 >7: 504 :6=;C4752 C>:4 >E>19>D94 67 <4=6<: - 6 - # 2 =6;9: D4 @>504<4: 8<6C <4=6<:2 504 <49>51672013 D45F447 345151674<2 >7: <42367:475 6 12 76517:123;54734<;2>968504=6C39>175>E4<C47521512 25>54:D?<42367:475 6 50>5>550451C468C><<1>@4 04< 3><4752 0>: @1E47 =>20 68 2#"+ 569>2 @69: >967@F15006;24069:><51=94204<4>854<506;@0204F>2 <421:17@=6<:1>99?17504C>5<1C671>906C486<>34<16:68 674 ?4>< 9>54< 04< 0;2D>7: 25><54: 56 0><>22 04< D650 30?21=>99? >7: C475>99? 86< >::15167>9 :6F<? 04 345151674< 62 >7: >==;24: 62 >7: ><4 <421:17@ >967@F150345151674< 6>==;24: 6734<;2>968504 =6C39>175>7:=0><@420445C>54<1>9504<4><4 >994@>5167286<50=6C17@>@>1725>==;24: 6256 , 6F4E4< 17268>< >2 345151674< 62$ >7: ">==;24: 62$ >7: " ><4 =67=4<74: 679? >994@>5167 >@>1725 504C 12 50>5 >854< <42367:475 6 9485 504 C>5<1C671>906C4F047204F>2<421:17@>504<3><475>9 06;2467 $504?>995<423>224:5041<06;24>7: >22>;954: 04< K=435 50>5 76 6504< >994@>5167 12 - 7 - 86<50=6C17@>@>1725345151674< 62$>7:">==;24: 62$ >7: " :C1554:9? 345151674< 6$ 12 <421:17@ 243><>549? >5 >19>3;< 6>: ;<E10>9 6F7 17:0>7;< 45151674< 6" 12 <421:17@ >5 1<47>7:10>99 E199>@4 ;25>@1 >9;A >1=0;<72;=0=1<=;C25>7=417C?=6721:4<4:6317167 504<412 =>24C>:46;5>@>1725345151674< 62 56 >==;24: 62 56 >7: 3<6=44:17@2 >@>1725 504C =>7765D4 B;>204: 6F4E4< >2 >@>1725345151674< 62$ >7: ">==;24: 62$ >7: " ><4 =67=4<74: 4K=435 26C4 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 76 6504< C>54<1>92 ><4 86<50=6C17@ >@>1725504C17504=0><@420445 & 72;=0=1<=;C25>7=4250467/D9434K6;<5 17 504 =>24 68 <436<54: 17 ! "#$ %& >5 3><>@<>30 6! 049: 50>5 504 6;<5 206;9: D4 =><48;9 17 3<6=44:17@ >@>1725 504 :125>75 <49>51E42 17 =<1C42 34<5>1717@ 56 C>5<1C671>9 :123;542 >7: :6F<? :4>502 04 <49>51E42 68 504 0;2D>7: 206;9: 765 D4 <634:+17 67 504 D>212 68 - 8 - 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 ;79422 234=181= 1725>7=4 68 5041< 17E69E4C475 17 504 =<1C4 ><4 C>:4 6;55 12 >926245594: 36215167689>F50>518>34<26712C>:4568>=4>=<1C17>9 5<1>9 67 26C4 @474<>9 >7: 2F44317@ >994@>51672 F1506;5 D<17@17@ 67 <4=6<: >7? 234=181= 1725>7=42 68 =<1C17>9 =67:;=5 15 12 765017@ D;5 >D;24 68 3<6=422 68 504 6;<5 046;<523624>:;5?562;DL4=5504>994@>516794E4994:17 504=6C39>17556>506<6;@02=<;517?56817:6;5F04504< 504<4 12 >7? @>17 68 5<;50 17 504 >994@>51672 6< F04504< 504? ><4 C>:4 679? F150 504 2694 6DL4=5 68 17E69E17@ =4<5>17 17:1E1:;>92 17 > =<1C17>9 =0><@4 C6<4 3><51=;9><9? F047>3<624=;5167><1248<6C>C>5<1C671>9:123;54 );<504<50467ID94 34K6;<5 17 504 =>2468 '( # <436<54:17 )*$$+*)049:173><> 62 ">7: , >2;7:4<. ) - 9 - ! " # $% & $' $' $% ( ,) !*+, # ! ( - . ! *+, # / . " 0 ! ..!*+, # - 10 - . #- # 1 339?17@504>D6E4817:17@268504L;:@C475268 50467ID9434K6;<5565048>=52>7:=1<=;C25>7=4268 5012 =>24 =67517;>5167 68 3<6=44:17@2 >@>1725 345151674< 62$ >7: ">==;24: 62$ >7: " 12 >D;24 68 3<6=422 68 6;<5==6<:17@9?3<6=44:563>2250486996F17@. > 043451516712 - D 04 34515167 17 <4234=5 68 345151674< 62 56 12 >7: 504 3<6=44:17@2 >@>1725504C20>99=67517;4 = 04 34515167 17 <4234=5 68 345151674< 62$ >7:"12 - : 04 3<6=44:17@2 >@>1725 345151674< 62$ >7: ">==;24: 62$ >7: " 17 6 " " ><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4 6" $ <4@1254<4: D? ;<E10>9 691=4 - 11 - 5>5167 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 1E19 %;:@4 >7: %) >5 >2A1 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>D94 ;7:4< 4=51672 ," "( * &($* " "( * "(* "$ <F 4=5167 & 68 0><>51?> ?>?> >7015> >7: 4=51672 >7: $ 68 6F<? <601D15167 =5 &! 12 04<4D? B;>204: +) %$( $ 125 6. 9 6.! .%