Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55061 (KAR)
BALAPPA @ AMATEPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201599/2025 · 2026-02-02
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55061 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55061 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$% %
$
& &'() & (
*
! "
#
$
%& &
! '(
%& & &'()
* &
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'(
"
# %+
&%$
%
% #$
%#*$
,-
(
% %
% -
(
% %%
#$ #$ ) * #$ % !(
#$#.$#/$#0$#$#1!2$%
,,
%
%
* 3
3 4 &
56/ 789696:; 6/ <6=8>?;>8. 8@96:; :< 52.296A2 2B2.6C ?.2C/52 2;5692 ( /88C6;B 9: D?2/5 958 7.:@88>6;B/2B26;/9958789696:;8./
2@@?/8>:/9:6;
7=:,-
( 2.6/6;B :?9 :< .6E8 :-
( .8B6/98.8> FA 5:.27?. :=6@8 9296:; <:. 958 :<<8;@8/ 7?;6/52F=8 ?;>8. 8@96:;/ #$ #$ ) . 0 8@96:; #$ :< 52.296A2 A2A2 2;5692 ( G<:. H958
- 3 -
(I2;>8@96:;/#$#.$#$#/$#$#0$#$#1! 2$:<@58>?=8>2/98/2;>@58>?=8> .6F8/#.818;96:;
:< 9.:@6968/$ @9 ,, G<:. F.8169A H958 #
$ @9JI78;>6;B:;958<6=8:<6/9.6@92;>8//6:;/?>B829 2>B6. 58 2F.6>B8> <2@9/ :< 958 @2/8 2.8 9529 .8/7:;>8;9:<6=8>7.61298@:E7=26;9?;>8.8@96:;
:< ( F8<:.8 958 6/9.6@9 2;> 8//6:;/ ?>B8 2>B6. 2B26;/9 /6K 2@@?/8> 78./:;/ :; (( FA 2..2A6;B 958/8 789696:;8./ 2/ 2@@?/8> :/ 2;> 6;
:
(96/2==8B8>6;958@:E7=26;99529958=2;> F82.6;B A:(
E82/?.6;B - 2@.8/ B?;92/ 02/ /:=> 9: 588E277268 <2958.!6;!=20 :<.8/7:;>8;9:
FA 69/ :.6B6;2= :0;8. 6;B2772 18. /6;@8 .8/7:;>8;9 : 2;> 58. <2E6=A E8EF8./ 08.8 6; 7: p. 8 6:;
:0818. 958.8 02/ 2 @616= >6/7?98 F89088; 958 06<8 :< 6;B2772 2;> .8/7:;>8;9 : 6; 8B?=2. %6./9 7782= F8<:.8956/:?.9
- 4 -
56;B/ /9::> 95?/ :; ( 058; .8/7:;>8;9:2;>58.<2E6=AE8EF8./08.80:.C6;B6; 9586.2B.6@?=9?.2==2;>2//9298>292F:?93(7E 958 2@@?/8> 78./:;/ 6;@=?>6;B 958/8 789696:;8./ FA <:.E6;B 2; ?;=20<?= 2//8EF=A 9.8/72//8> 6;9: 958 =2;> 2;> D?8/96:;8> .8/7:;>8;9 : 2/ 9: 05A /58 02/ 8;B2B8> 6; 2B.6@?=9?.2= 0:.C 6; 958 /26> =2;> /6;@8 958 /2E8 F8=:;B/ 9: 958E ?.6;B 958 2=98.@296:; 2@@?/8> :2//2?=98>.8/7:;>8;9:2;>2@@?/8>:/2;> 2F?/8> 58. FA E8;96:;6;B 58. @2/98 2;> 2=/: 958A E2>8 2; 2998E79 9: :?9.2B8 58. E:>8/9A / /?@5 /58 277.:2@58> 958 :=6@8 9: =:>B8 958 @:E7=26;9 2B26;/9 958E:0818.958/2E802/;:9.8@8618>2;>.8B6/98.8> FA 958 :=6@8 ?F/8D?8;9=A /58 =:>B8> 958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 6; :
( 2/ /9298> 58 =82.;8> 2B6/9.298 2<98. .8B6/98.6;B 958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 .8<8..8> 958 E2998. 9: 958 L?.6/>6@96:;2= :=6@8 68 .8/7:;>8;9 :!:=6@8 <:. 6;18/96B296:; ?;>8. 8@96:;
-#$ :< . ) #$ :< ( @@:.>6;B=A
- 5 -
.8/7:;>8;9 :!:=6@8 .8B6/98.8> 958 @2/8 6; .6E8 :-
( <:. 958 :<<8;@8/ 7?;6/52F=8 ?;>8. 8@96:;/ ,#$,#$,#$,#$#$)#$ 2;> #$ . 0 8@96:; ,( :< ( 2;> 8@96:;/ #$#.$#$#/$#$#0$#$#B$2;>#$#1!2$:<
#$ @9 2;> 6;18/96B298> 958 E2998. 2;> =26> @52.B8 /58892B26;/9958/8789696:;8./2/2@@?/8>:/9:<:. 958 :<<8;@8/ 7?;6/52F=8 ?;>8.
8@96:;/ #$ #$ ) .82> 0695 8@96:; #$ :< ( 2;> 8@96:;/ #$#.$ #$#/$ #$#0$ #$#1!2$ :<
#$@9FA>.:776;B958:958.2@@?/8>@@:.>6;B=A958 =82.;8> 78@62= ?>B8 9::C @:B;6M2;@8 :< 958 :<<8;@8/ BB.6818>FA958/2E8956/789696:;6/<6=8>9:D?2/5958 7.:@88>6;B/
82.> =82.;8> @:?;/8= <:. 958 789696:;8./ =82.;8> @:?;/8= <:. .8/7:;>8;9 : 2;> =82.;8> 6B5 :?.9:18.;E8;9=82>8.<:..8/7:;>8;9:!9298
- 6 -
72.9 <.:E ?.B6;B /818.2= @:;98;96:;/ =82.;8> @:?;/8= <:. 958 789696:;8./ @:;98;>8> 9529 958.8 6/ 2;
6;:.>6;298 >8=2A :< , >2A/ 6; =:>B6;B 958 @:E7=26;9 %?.958.696//78@6<6@2==A/9298>6;958@:E7=26;99529958.8 6/ 2 @616= >6/7?98 78;>6;B F89088; 958 789696:;8./ 2;> .8/7:;>8;9:F8<:.8956/:?.96;8B?=2.%6./97782= 72.9 <.:E 9529 2/ 78. 958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 958/8 2@@?/8> 78./:;/ 2//2?=98> 2;> :?9.2B8> 958 E:>8/9A :< .8/7:;>8;9::0818..8/7:;>8;9:':=6@85218 =26> @52.B8 /5889 :;=A 2B26;/9 958/8 95.88 789696:;8./ ;
/?@5 @6.@?E/92;@8/ 69 6/ @=82. 9529 :?9 :< 18;B82;@8 .8/7:;>8;9 : <6=8> 2 <2=/8 @:E7=26;9 2B26;/9 958/8 789696:;8./FAE6/?/6;B9587.:16/6:;/:< #$@9 @@:.>6;B=A587.2A/9:2==:0958789696:;
-
=82.;8>@:?;/8=<:..8/7:;>8;9:
1858E8;9=A @:;98;>8> 9529 95:?B5 .8/7:;>8;9 : 52/ 277.:2@58>958L?.6/>6@96:;2=:=6@8 6EE8>6298=A2<98.958 6;@6>8;9958/26>:=6@85218<26=8>9:.8B6/98.958@2/8FA .8@8616;B58.@:E7=26;92//?@5/5802698><:.278.6:>
- 7 -
:<,>2A/2;>=298./58<6=8>9587.61298@:E7=26;958 2=/: @:;98;>8> 9529 958 /9298E8;9 :< 069;8//8/ @298B:.6@2==A 8/92F=6/58/ 958 @:EE6//6:; :< 958 :<<8;@8/
58 .8/7:;>8;9 : ' :=6@8 2=/: <6=8> 2 2== 8926= 8B6/98.9:/?F/92;9629895297.8/8;96;9582==8B8>/7:9:;
958 >298 :< 6;@6>8;9 8;@8 2<98. >8926=8> 6;18/96B296:;
.8/7:;>8;9 : ' :=6@8 5218 =26> 958 @52.B8 /5889 2B26;/9958/8789696:;8./;/?@5@6.@?E/92;@8/587.2A/ 9:>6/E6//958789696:;
) 82.;8> 6B5 :?.9 :18.;E8;9 =82>8. 27782.6;B<:..8/7:;>8;9:!9298:77:/8>958789696:;
/9296;B 9529 958.8 2.8 /78@6<6@ 2==8B296:;/ 2B26;/9 958/8 789696:;8./6;9587.61298@:E7=26;92;>2=/:6;958@52.B8 /5889 E298.62=/ @@:.>6;B=A 58 7.2A/ 9: >6/E6// 958 789696:;
5218B618;EA2;K6:?/@:;/6>8.296:;F:95:;
958 /?FE6//6:;/ E2>8 FA 958 =82.;8> @:?;/8= <:. 958
- 8 -
.8/78@9618 72.968/ 2;> 78.?/8> 958 >:@?E8;9/ E2>8 2126=2F=8:;.8@:.>
, / @:?=> F8 B2958.8> <.:E @52.B8 /5889 E298.62=/ 2@@:.>6;B 9: .8/7:;>8;9 : 958 2==8B8> 6;@6>8;9 02/ @2?/8> :; ( 058; /58 02/ 8;B2B8> 6; 958 2B.6@?=9?.2= 2@9616968/ 6; 58. <68=> 9 9529 96E8 /6K 2@@?/8> 78./:;/ 9.8/72//8> 6;9: 958 <68=> 2;> D?8/96:;8>58.2;>958.82<98.2//2?=98>58.2;>:?9.2B8>
58. E:>8/9A FA E8;96:;6;B 58. @2/98 >E6998>=A 958 7.61298@:E7=26;902/<6=8>2<98.2=27/8:<,>2A/68:; (( 5:?B5 69 6/ /9298> 6; 958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 9529 2<98. 958 6;@6>8;9 /58 277.:2@58> 958 :=6@8 2;> =:>B8> 958 @:E7=26;9 5:0818. ;: @:E7=26;9 :. >:@?E8;9/ :. /9298E8;9/ 08.8 7=2@8> FA
58. 9:
/?F/92;96298 9529 /58 277.:2@58> 958 :=6@8 2<98. 958 6;@6>8;98K@879/9296;B958/2E86;58.2<<6>2169%?.958.
:;78.?/2=:<958@:E7=26;9218.E8;9/696/@=82.=A/9298> 6; 72.2!) :< 958 @:E7=26;9 9529 958.8 6/ 2 @616= >6/7?98
- 9 -
F89088; 958 06<8 :< =298 6;B2772 2;> .8/7:;>8;9 : 78;>6;BF8<:.8956/:?.96;8B?=2.%6./97782=
( %?.958. :; 78.?/2= :< 958 /9298E8;9 :< .8/7:;>8;9:2;>:958.069;8//8/:E;6F?/2==8B296:;/ 2.8 E2>8 2B26;/9 958/8 789696:;8./ 9529 958A 2=:;B 0695 958:958.2@@?/8>9.8/72//8>6;9:9587.:78.9A2;>E2>8 2998E79 9: 2//2?=9 2;> :?9.2B8 58. E:>8/9A : 0:?;> @8.96<6@2986/7=2@8>FA58.9:/?F/92;962989529>?89:958 2//2?=9/58/?/926;8>6;L?.68/%?.958.95:?B5696//9298> 6;958@:E7=26;995292@@?/8>:/9:-08.87.8/8;929 958/@8;8:<:@@?..8;@8958:958.2@@?/8>2.8;:9@52.B8 /58898> FA .8/7:;>8;9 : ' :=6@8 818.958=8// 958 7.61298@:E7=26;96/;:9/?77:.98>FA958=6/9:<069;8//8/ 2;>>8926=8>2<<6>2169 58:;JF=878K:?.96;958@2/8 :<
.87:.98>6; 58=>9529958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 /52== @:;926; >8926=8> 2<<6>2169 :< 958 @:E7=26;2;9 2;> 2=/: E8;96:;6;B 958 ;29?.8 :< 958
- 10 -
6;@6>8;92;>958>:@?E8;9/9:95298<<8@92;>2=/:958=6/9 :<069;8//8/2;>>:@?E8;9/
; 958 6;/92;9 @2/8 8K@879 18.6<A6;B 2<<6>2169 ;: /?@5 >8926=8> 2<<6>2169 6/ <:.95@:E6;B 2=:;B 0695 958 7.61298@:E7=26;92;>2>E6998>=A;:/?@5=6/9:<069;8//8/ 6/ <6=8> FA .8/7:;>8;9 : 056=8 <6=6;B 958 7.61298 @:E7=26;9 :.8:18. 958 6;@6>8;9 /26> 9: 5218 F88; @2?/8> 6; 958 >6/7?98> <68=> :< 2@@?/8> : 2;> .8/7:;>8;9 : 6; :.>8. 9: 299.2@9 958 7.:16/6:;/ :< 8@96:;#$:<958 #$@99586;@6>8;9E?/9F8 @2?/8> 6; 958 7?F=6@ 7=2@8 2;> 6; 2;A 7=2@8 06956; 958 7?F=6@1680
58 :;JF=8 78K :?.9 6; 958 @2/8 :< ! .87:.98> 6; 58=>6;72.2B.275:/2;>2/ ?;>8.3
- 11 -
! "
! #
$ ! ! $
"
!$
%!$ & ! $!! '"
! ( )! '
"
! ! $
( )
* '$
! $ !+ ,
!+
" - .! -. /
+$ !+ 0
$
$
$ ! . $
'
$! ! 1
- 12 -
)2 0 304 5 (
$)$ +
'
0
$ ! $ ! 0 ! !6 ! $
$ $ ! ! '
$! ! ,
/
!+ /
+ ! $ ! . $
$ 7 ! $
$
$
$ ! ! +
; :18.2== 78.?/2= :< 958 218.E8;9/ 6; 958 @:E7=26;9 2;> 958 /9298E8;9 :< 069;8//8/ 69 @:?=> F8 B2958.8>95296;:.>8.9:B6182@.6E6;2=@:=:?.9:958@616=
- 13 -
>6/7?982.6/6;BF89088;95872.968/2<2=/8@:E7=26;952/ F88;<:6/98>2B26;/9958789696:;8./;:18.2==78.?/2=:< 958E298.62=/:;.8@:.>2E:<958@:;/6>8.8>16809529 @:;96;?296:; :< @.6E6;2= 7.:@88>6;B/ 2B26;/9 958 789696:;8./ 6/ @=82. 2F?/8 :< 7.:@8// :< :?.9 /6;@8 958 /2E86/E2;6<8/9=A<.61:=:?/18K296:?/2;>6;/969?98>0695 958 ?=98.6:. E:9618 <:.
0.8@C6;B 18;B82;@8 58 8;96.8 2==8B296:;6;958%2;>@52.B8/58892@@8798>:;69/<2@8 12=?8818;958;958/2E8>:;:9 @:;/969?98 2; :<<8;@8/ @52.B8 /58898> 2B26;/9 958 789696:;8./
2@@?/8>:/9:@@:.>6;B=A7.:@88>9: 72//958<:==:06;B3
6 58789696:;6/""# 66 58 7.:@88>6;B/ 2B26;/9 958 789696:;8./
2@@?/8> :/ 9:
6;
7=:,-
( 2.6/6;B :?9 :< .6E8 :-
( .8B6/98.8> FA 5:.27?. :=6@8 9296:; <:. 958 :<<8;@8/ 7?;6/52F=8 ?;>8. 8@96:;/ #$ #$). 08@96:;#$:<52.296A2
- 14 -
A2A2 2;5692 ( 2;> 8@96:;/ #$#.$ #$#/$ #$#0$ #$#1!2$ :< @58>?=8> 2/98/ 2;> @58>?=8> .6F8/ #.818;96:; :< 9.:@6968/$ @9 ,, 78;>6;B :; 958 <6=8 :< 6/9.6@9 2;> 8//6:;/ ?>B8 29 2>B6. 6/ 58.8FA D?2/58>
+) &% ( %
*& 6/9:3=:3
!