- 1 - !"!# $%"" % &' &()*'+ &) , ! "# "$$ "$$ $ % & '" $ ! "( "# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " )*" !#) " !&# & " "" )%!#+" ) +"& " " , , " " ", " & ' ' - , , $ ./0123/3/45/06/7289582:2;3/45)46 ) <= 3.2 123/3/452:>;;9028 64: ?:>53 46 <>/7 /5 :/@2 4 8>328 :2?/032:28 <= 3.2 /5?>09?9: 47/;2 >/;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582:2;3/450)%!#+46 >582;3/450>58+46 :432;3/4546./78:25":4@2A9>76625;20;3!64: 0.4:3B;3C# .26>;39>7@>3:/A463.2;>02/03.>33.26>3.2: 46 D/;3/@ 452 >59@>53:>=> >772?28 3.>3 ./0 @/54: 8>9?.32: E>0 @/00/5? 6:4@ ) 632: 02>:;. .2 - 3 - 748?28 > @/00/5? ;4@17>/53 <264:2 3.2 :201458253147/;2 45 .2 0>@2 E>0 :2?/032:28 /5 :/@2 4 64: 3.2 46625;2 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/45 )%!#46 )>?>/50395F54E512:0450 ) .2:2>632: 45 * + 3.2 D/;3/@ >58 >;;9028 E2:2 3:>;28 /5 > 3/5 0.28 >3 $>:/?988> D/77>?2 .2:2>632::2014582534 147/;2:2;4:8283.203>32@253 46 3.2 D/;3/@ E.2:2/5 /3 /0 03>328 3.>3 45 >3 ><493 ' > @ /5 3.2 5/?.3 .49:0 3.2 >;;9028 F/85>1128.2:>583.2:2>632:344F.2:34@>:20.E>:>/5 > <90 >58 3.2:2>632: 3.2= <43. 03>=28 /5 > 3/5 0.28 >3 $>:/?988> 64: > 12:/48 46 8>=0 >58 89:/5? 3.>3 3/@2 3.2>;;9028;4@@/332864:;/<7202A9>7/532:;49:0245.2: 009;.3.2:201458253147/;2/@17/;>3283.2123/3/452:/5 3.2;:/@2<=/5D4F/5?02;3/450)%!#>58+46 >58 02;3/450 >58 + 46 ;3 ;;4:8/5?7= 3.2 :201458253147/;2 >::20328 3.2 123/3/452: >58 1:489;28 ./@<264:23.212;/>749:3>583.2:2<=025334G98/;/>7 ;90348= .2 123/3/452: /0 /5 ;90348= 6:4@ * + - 4 - 9<02H92537=:201458253147/;2/5D203/?>3283.2;>02>58 7>/8 ;.>:?20.223 >?>/503 3.2 >;;9028 64: 3.2 >64:2@253/4528 46625;20 2/5? >??:/2D28 <= 3.2 0>@2 3.2 123/3/452: >11:4>;.28 887 /03:/;3 >58 200/450 ,98?2>/;.9:/33/5?>3/58.>59:>5812;/>7,98?2"4: :/>7 6 .2 >020 582: ;3 /5 :7 /0; 4 +* 64: ?:>53 46 <>/7 E./;. E>0 :2G2;328D/824:82:8>328 2/5?>??:/2D28<= 3.20>@23.2123/3/452:1:262::283./0123/3/45 2>:872>:528;49502764:3.2123/3/452:>583.2 72>:528 /?. 49:3 4D2:5@253 72>82: 64: :201458253 3>32 1>:3 6:4@ 9:?/5? 02D2:>7 ;453253/450 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: 1:/@>:/7= ;45325328 3.>3 45 12:90>7 46 3.2 ;.>:?20.223 >D2:@2530 3.2 D/;3/@ >58 >;;9028E2:2/574D2>580.2D47953>:/7=>;;4@1>5/283.2 >;;9028>58>70403>=2834?23.2:64:>12:/48468>=0 /5 > 3/5 0.28 >3 $>:/?988> D/77>?2 "9:3.2: 3.49?. >5 - 5 - >772?>3/45E>0@>82/53.2;.>:?20.2233.>33.2>;;9028 ;4@@/3328 64:;/<72 02A9>7 >;3 45 3.2 D/;3/@ 54 09;. @28/;>7 :2;4:80 8/0;74020 3.>3 3.2:2 E>0 64:;/<7202A9>7>;3<=3.2>;;9028453.2D/;3/@ 4:24D2: 3.2 1:402;93/45 .>0 543 17>;28 >5= >93.253/;>328 84;9@253 7/F2 </:3. ;2:3/6/;>32 34 1:4D2 3.2 >?2 46 3.2 D/;3/@3.>30.2E>0@/54:>33.23/@246/5;/8253 509;. ;/:;9@03>5;20.21:>=034>774E3.2123/3/45 + 72>:528;49502764::2014582534 4114028 3.2 <>/7 123/3/45 45 3.2 ?:4958 3.>3 3.2 1:402;93/45.>017>;283.2;2:3/6/;>32/00928<=3.2;.447 93.4:/3= 34 1:4D2 3.2 >?2 46 3.2 D/;3/@ 3.>3 0.2 E>0 @/54: >3 3.2 3/@2 46 /5;/8253 >58 03>32@253 46 D/;3/@ 9582: 2;3/45 ) 46 821/;30 3.>3 >;;9028 .>8 ;4@@/3328 64:;/<72 02A9>7 /532:;49:02 45 .2: 25;2 .2 1:>=0348/0@/003.2123/3/45 % 2>:528 /?. 49:3 4D2:5@253 72>82: >704 4114028343.2123/3/45<=09114:3/5?3.2/@19?5284:82: - 6 - .>D2?/D25@=>5A/490;450/82:>3/45<43.45 3.2 09<@/00/450 @>82 <= 3.2 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D21>:3/20>5884;9@2530>D>/7><7245:2;4:8 * 0 ;4978 <2 ?>3.2:28 6:4@ 3.2 ;4@17>/53 >58 43.2::2;4:80 3.2 >;;9028 >58 3.2 D/;3/@ <2745?034 3.2 52/?.<4:/5? D/77>?2 >58 45 3.2 D/;3/@ E>0 64958@/00/5?6:4@3.2.4902463.2;4@17>/5>53 009;. 45 3.2 D2:= 52A3 8>= / 2 45 .2 748?28 > @/00/5? ;4@17>/53 >?>/503 95F54E5 12:0450 9<02H92537= >632: 8>=0 3.2 D/;3/@ >58 3.2 >;;9028 E2:23:>;28/5>3/50.28>3$>:/?988>D/77>?2 512:90>7 463.203>32@253463.2D/;3/@3.20>@2:2D2>703.>33.2 >;;9028 >58 D/;3/@ 3:>D27728 /5 > <90 6:4@ @>:20.E>:> 34 $>:/?988> D/77>?2 8@/33287= 0.2 .>0 543 /564:@28 ><493 3.2 F/85>1 34 >5=<48= .2 @28/;>7 :214:3 46 3.2 D/;3/@>7048/0;740203.>33.2:2/05464:;/<7202A9>7>00>973 453.2D/;3/@ - 7 - "9:3.2: 34 1:4D2 3.2 >?2 46 3.2 D/;3/@ 3.2 1:402;93/45.>017>;283.28@/00/452?/032:>58;.447 2:3/6/;>32 /00928 <= 3.2 2>8@>032: 46 3.2 ;.447 /5 E./;. 3.2 D/;3/@ .>0 0398/28 .2 0>/8 ;2:3/6/;>32 4: :2?/032:/0543>;;4@1>5/28E/3.3.2</:3.;2:3/6/;>32463.2 D/;3/@ 5 12:90>7 46 3.2 /@19?528 4:82: 1>0028 <= 3.2 :/>7 49:3 /3 8/0;74020 3.>3 3.2 D/;3/@ .>0 ?/D25 54 4<G2;3/45 34 >774E 3.2 <>/7 123/3/45 >58 0.2 ;>32?4:/;>77= 03>3283.>33.2=<43.E2:2/574D2 509;.;/:;9@03>5;203.245-<7212A49:3 /5 3.2 ;>02 46 :214:328 /5 .278 /5 1>:> 4 >58>09582:' - 8 - ! " # $ % & ' " ( ) - 9 - $ *+( ) "9:3.2:3.245C<72 12A49:3 /5 3.2 ;>0246 !"! #$:214:328/5%&'( ).2783.>3E.25>E4@25E.4E/77/5?7=25?>?20 /5>745?32:@02A9>7:27>3/450./1E/3.>@>56977=>E>:2 46/305>39:2>58E/3.493>5=;4?2532D/825;2340.4E3.>3 09;.:27>3/450./1E>0/589;28<=@/0;45;213/45466>;304: 6>702 1:4@/02 46 @>::/>?2 @>82 /5 <>8 6>/3. 6:4@ 3.2 /5;213/45 3.2 @>5 ;>5543 <2 .278 ?9/73= 46 :>12 9582: 2;3/45 )%+ 46 .90 /3 /0 ;72>: 3.>3 >;;9028 ;>5 <2 ;45D/;328 64: :>12 457= /6 3.2 49:3 :2>;.20 > ;45;790/45 3.>3 3.2 /53253/45 46 3.2 >;;9028 E>0 @>7>6/82 >58 3.>3 .2 .>8 ;7>58203/52 @43/D20 .2 @>32:/>70 17>;28 /5 3.2 ;>02 >:2 0966/;/253 34 :2G2;3 >58 4D2::972 3.2 6>;39>7 >002:3/45;453>/528/5 3.2;4@17>/533.>3 >;;90>3/450 >:2 6>702 009;.3.2;453/59>3/45461:4;228/5?03:/>7E4978 - 10 - :20973/5>5><902461:4;200463.249:3>58E4978543 02:D2 3.2 2580 46 G903/;2 012;/>77= E.25 /3 /0 ;72>: 3.>3 3.20>@2E4978543;45;7982/53.2;45D/;3/4546>;;9028 ) 25;23.23:93.6975200>58?259/525200463.2 >?21:4461:489;28<=3.21:402;93/45>583.203>32@253 463.2D/;3/@.>034<2320328/5>823>/7283:/>7 /5;23.2 /5D203/?>3/45 /0 >7:2>8= ;4@172328 >58 ;.>:?20.223 .>0 <225 7>/8 >?>/503 3.2 >;;9028 ./0 ;90348/>7 /5;>:;2:>3/45 8420 543 ;>77 64: 25;2 E/3.493 2A1:200/5? >5= 41/5/45 45 3.2 @2:/30 46 3.2 ;>02 0966/;2 34 .478 3.>3 3.2 123/3/452:;>5<2257>:?2845:2?97>:<>/7 ;;4:8/5?7=3.2123/3/45/0 * .2 123/3/452:>;;9028 /0 8/:2;328 34 <2 257>:?2845:2?97>:<>/7/5:/@24 :2?/032:28 <= /5?>09?9: 47/;2 3>3/45 >/;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><729582:2;3/450)%!#+46 >582;3/450 >58 + 46 ;3 09<G2;3 34 3.2 64774E/5? ;458/3/450' - 11 - ># 23/3/452: 0.>77 2A2;932 > 12:045>7 <458 64: > 09@ 46 0 E/3. 3E4 09:23/20 64: 3.2 7/F209@ 34 3.2 0>3/06>;3/45463.2G9:/08/;3/45>749:3( <# .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 >112>: :2?97>:7= 45 >77 3.2 8>320 46 .2>:/5? <264:2 3.2 :/>7 49:3 957200 3.2 :/>7 49:3 2A2@130 ./0 >112>:>5;264:D>7/8:2>0450( ;# .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 543 8/:2;37= 4: /58/:2;37= 3.:2>325 4: 3>@12: E/3. 3.2 1:402;93/45E/3520020( 8# .2123/3/452:0.>77543/5D47D2/50/@/7>: 46625;20/56939:2( 2# .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 543 72>D2 3.2 G9:/08/;3/45 46 3.2 :/>7 49:3 E/3.493 12:@/00/45 46 3.2 0>/8 49:3 953/7 3.2 ;>02 :2?/032:28 >?>/503 ./@ /0 8/014028 466( 6# .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 @>:F ./0 >33258>5;2 <264:2 3.2 3>3/45 4902 66/;2: /5?>09?9:47/;23>3/45>/;.9:4503 958>= 46 2D2:= @453. <23E225 > @ >58 1 @ 3/77 3.2 ;>02 - 12 - :2?/032:28 >?>/503 ./@ /0 8/014028 466 <264:23.2:/>749:3 ?# .2 4<02:D>3/45 @>82 /5 3./0 123/3/45 0.>77543;4@2/53.2E>=463:/>7 -* &") " ' ' 3(:G