Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55048 (KAR)

M/S NINABAI SUGAR P LTD v. THE COMMISSIONER

CCC/200314/2025 · 2026-02-04

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$$ "#$$% %#!! & ! " ## $" # # " # ""%#" &" "& #&# "' " # ( Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ## % ""%# " " ! #"# % ""%## *% % $"" + #"" &"" # # $& #"&)+, " #"""& ")&# "&" "#")&# " & " # " & "" # # & # & # )! ) )+ # #- " ) ) )!) )) . ' . # & " " # " & # # % "% #/ " 012 #/ " - 3 - %#/ " 345 67189:;8 ;9848471 45 <4=92 0==9>41> 171. 67:;=40169 7< 01 7?29? 20892 )! ) )+ ;05592 @A 839 =90?19241>=9B2>9417) ) )!) )) ) 39 67:;=041018 39?941 302 <4=92 7) ) )!) )) <7? 0 24?968471 87 CB053 0 =9889? 20892 ) ) )) @90?41> 7) ).) )) 455B92 @A 839 ?95;712918 7 012 87 24?968 839 ?95;7129187839?94187455B902458016969?84<46089<7? 839 ;?7;7592 <0687?A 41 89?:5 7< 8394? 0;;=4608471 20892 )) ) ! 39=90?19241>=9B2>94189?:57<8397?29? 20892 )! ) )+ 245;7592 7<< 839 D?48 ;9848471 24?96841> 839 ?95;7129185 839?941 87 80E9 0 29645471 71 839 0;;=4608471 <4=92 @A 839 ;98484719?5 20892 )) ) 012 87;0550;;?7;?40897?29?53967:;=0410185B@:4858308 839 50:9 45 178 67:;=492 012 39169 305 <4=92 8345 67189:;8;9848471 - 4 - + 39 =90?192 67B159= <7? 839 67:;=041018 ?9489?0892 839 0@7F9 5B@:4554715 012 5B@:48892 8308 839 67:;=041018 302 57B>38 <7? 839 455B0169 7< 0 24580169 69?84<46089 <7? 9580@=453:918 7< 0 5B>0? <0687?A 012 8308 83950:945178455B92 #7D9F9? 0 67B189? 0<<420F48 45 <4=92 @A 839 =90?192 22484710= 7F9?1:918 2F76089 916=7541> 839?9D483 01 7?29? ;05592 @A 839 "019 "7::4554719? D39?941484558089283088390;;=46084717<83967:;=041018 05 D9== 05 719 5 020>7B20 702=4195 F8 82 4G0A0;B?0D05F9?4<492<7?7F9?=0;;41>7<83924580169012 83084830280E9102964547187?967::912<7?60169==08471 7< 7< 5 020>7B20 702=4195 F8 82 "7189:;7?0197B5=A 839 "019 "7::4554719? 302 022?955920=9889?20892 ! ) )8783929;0?8:9187< 12B58?495 012 "7::9?69 87 6715429? 839 0;;=4608471 7< 83967:;=041018<7?455B01697<02458016969?84<46089845 839?9<7?967189129283088397?29?;05592@A8345"7B?845 - 5 - 67:;=492 012 39169 17 <B?839? 7?29?5 1992@9 ;05592 41 834567189:;8;9848471 39 67:;=041018 302 0;;?706392 8345 "7B?8 599E41> <7? 0 24?968471 87 6715429? 345 ?9;?9591808471 <7? 455B0169 7< 0 6019 24580169 69?84<46089 345 "7B?8 302 245;7592 7<< 839 D?48 ;9848471 012 24?96892 839 6715429?08471 7< 839 0;;=4608471 7< 839 67:;=041018 39 "019 "7::4554719? D37 45 839 67:;98918 0B837?48A 305 F9?4<492012<7B12830883967:;=0410180=719D0591848=92 <7? 0 24580169 69?84<46089 012 839 455B92 41 <0F7B? 7< 5020>7B20702=4195F882537B=2@960169==928 45178E17D1D39839?839"019"7::4554719?3050=?902A 80E91 589;5 <7? 60169==08471 7< 839 @B8 839 "019 "7::4554719? 305 ;=0692 839 ?9CB958 7< 839 67:;=041018 @9<7?9 839 29;0?8:918 7< 12B58?495 012 "7::9?69 <7? 455B0169 7< 0 24580169 69?84<46089 <7? 9580@=453:918 7< 0 19D5B>0?<0687?A H 1 8308 F49D 7< 839 :0889? 8345 67189:;8 ;9848471 2959?F95 87 @9 6=7592 667?241>=A 48 45 - 6 - #7D9F9?839066B5924524?968928780E91969550?A589;5 87 915B?9 8308 839 0;;=4608471 7< 839 67:;=041018 45 6715429?92 41 0667?20169 D483 =0D 05 24?96892 @A 839 =90?19241>=9B2>9417) ) )!) )) 3950:9530==@92719D483410;9?4727<<7B? D99E5<04=41>D346383967:;=0410184508=4@9?8A87599E ?9F4F0=7<834567189:;8;9848471 '( )$* $ '( )$%* $ 4587%=7%)!