- 1 - !" "## $% &$' ( ! " " #$%$!& & & #$%$&!$ " !' &""( ! &&) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !*# ! " " + & ( &&$ !&$&&$ " ""&,* $&$!& "&& ! & # " !,%, " )&&$ " " # ! " " - - . " /01 233425 01 60547 8974: 4;<0=9 !*! =6 </4 ;/47854721<41297</4;/478547:0>41:4?49<0=9=6 <:=;0<041 ;< !,%, @6=: 1/=:< A</4 ;<BC :427 D0</ 4;<0=9 $&% =6 /2:2<0E2 2F2:0G 8:2G1/2 29/0<2 && @6=: 1/=:< A</4 BC <= H821/ </4 3:=;44709F1 09 35 = !&$&&$ 2:0109F =8< =6 :0I4 = )&&$ :4F01<4:47 >E 8912F0 =50;4 <2<0=9 27F0: 6=: </4 =6649;41 38901/2>54 8974: 4;<0=91 &,* $& $!& =6 /2:2<0E2 E2E2 29/0<2 && @6=: 1/=:< A</4 BC2974;<0=9! : ! 1 & ?#2 =6</4 - 3 - ;< 3:4149<5E 349709F =9 </4 6054 =6 01<:0;< J 4110=9187F427F0: & /462;<825I2<:0K=6</4;21401</2<</489;54 =6</4;=I3520929</21:4F01<4:472;2142F2091<</44574: >:=</4:62</4:297=</4:62I05EI4I>4:1=6</423345529<# 2;;8147 6=: </4 =6649;4 38901/2>54 8974: 4;<0=91 )) ))()):427D0</4;<0=9!*,=62974;<0=91 ! K? ! K00 & ? =6 ;<09</4E42: &$ /41207;214;2I4<=>4<:0470935 = *&! >46=:4</401<:0;<J4110=9187F427F0:02972;H80<<47 </42;;8147?074=:74:72<47!% * &&* /09F1 1<==7 </81 =9 !* $ &&$ D/49 </4 ;=I3520929< 297 /01 D064 D4:4 09 /=814 </4 23345529<# 2;;8147 2554F475E <:41321147 </4 /=814 >E /=5709F 2 ;/=334: 297 2>8147 </4 ;=I3520929< >E I49<0=909F /01 ;21<4 297 251= <:047 <= 211285< </4 ;=I3520929< 297 /01 D064 /=D4?4: </4E 41;2347 1 18;/ </4E 60547 </4 ;=I35209< =9 !* $ &&$ 2147 =9 </4 1207 ;=I35209< - 4 - " D21:4F01<4:4709:0I4= )&&$=9</412I472E 6=: </4 26=:4I49<0=947 =6649;41 /4:426<4: </4 9?41<0F2<09F 660;4: ;=I354<47 </4 09?41<0F2<0=9 297 5207 </4 ;/2:F4#1/44< 2F2091< </4 23345529< 6=: </4 26=:4I49<0=947 =6649;41 297 </4 34;025 87F4 <==G ;=F90L29;4 =6 </4 26=:4I49<0=947 =6649;41 2F2091< </4 23345529<#2;;8147 FF:04?47 >E </4 12I4 </4 23345529< 60547 </4 3:4149< 233425 >E ;/25549F09F </4 ;=F90L29;4 =:74:72<47& ( &&$297251=2F2091<</4;=9<0982<0=9 =6</43:=;44709F1 * 42:7542:947;=891456=:</423345529<297</4 542:947 0F/ =8:< =?4:9I49< 54274: 6=: :413=9749<# <2<4 =<0;4<=:413=9749<= &/45718660;049<?074=8:< =:74:72<47( ! &&) $ 32:< 6:=I 8:F09F 14?4:25 ;=9<49<0=91 542:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 23345529< 3:0I2:05E ;=9<49<47 </2< =9 34:8125=6</4;=I35209<2?4:I49<10<01;542:</2<262514 ;=I35209< 6=01<47 2F2091< </01 23345529< 09 =:74: <= - 5 - 0I350;2<4 </4 23345529< 8974: </4 3:=?010=91 =6 ;<297251=8974: ) ;;=:709F <= /0I </4 42:504: ;214 60547 >E </4 89;54 =6 </4 ;=I3520929< 2F2091< </4 >:=</4: 297 =</4: 62I05E I4I>4:1 =6 </4 23345529< D21 2;H80<<47 =9 !% * &&* /4:426<4: </01 2554F47 09;0749< D21 ;28147 =9 !* $ &&$ 0 4 26<4: 52314 =6 =94 E42: >1=58<45E </4:4 D21 9= 18;/ :421=9 6=: </4 23345529< <= 49<4: </4 /=814 =6 </4 ;=I3520929< 297 </:42<4947 /0I 6=: /2?09F 60547</442:504:;214 ( 770<0=9255E /4 ;=9<49747 </2< </4 23345529< 01 2 A1;/0L=3/:4902B 32<049< = 18>1<29<02<4 </4 12I4 /4 352;47 2 I470;25 ;4:<060;2<4 72<47 &) % &&$ 011847 >E 1E;/02<:01< ;;=:709F5E /4 18>I0<1 </4:4 01 2 F:=11 I01814 =6 </4 3:=?010=91 =6 34;025 92;<I49< 297 ;=9<0982<0=9 =6 3:=;44709F1 2F2091< </4 23345529< 01 29 2>814 =6 3:=;411 =6 </4 =8:< ;;=:709F5E /4 3:2E1 <= 255=D</4233425 - 6 - % 542:947 0F/ =8:< =?4:9I49< 54274: ?4/4I49<5E =33=147 </4 233425 >E ;=9<49709F </2< </4 ;=I3520929< 297 /01 62I05E I4I>4:1 /2?4 D0<941147</409;0749<</2<</42;;814749<4:47</4/=814 >E /=5709F 2 74275E D423=9 297 </:42<4947 </4 ;=I3520929< D0</ 70:4 ;=914H849;41 297 251= I274 29 2<<4I3<<=211285<</4;=I3520929<297/01D064 =D4?4: </4E 41;2347 6:=I </4 211285< 9 18;/ ;0:;8I1<29;41 </4:401 ;214I274=8<2F2091<</423345529< ;;=:709F5E/43:2E1<=701I011</4233425 , /2?4F0?49IE29K0=81;=91074:2<0=9>=</=9 </4 18>I0110=9 I274 >E </4 542:947 ;=89145 6=: </4 :4134;<0?4 32:<041 1= 251= 34:8147 </4 ;/2:F4 1/44< I2<4:0251 ! 1;=857>4F2</4:476:=I:4;=:71</489;54=6 </4 ;=I3520929< 5=7F47 2 ;=I35209< 2F2091< </4 >:=</4: 297 62I05E I4I>4:1 =6 </4 23345529< =9 &) ! &$ 297 </4 12I4 D21 :4F01<4:47 09 :0I4 = !,&$ 6=: </4 - 7 - =6649;438901/2>548974:4;<0=91)))) ()) :D!*,=62974;<0=9! K? ! K00 & ? =6 ;< /=8F/</41207;214D21<:0472F2091< </4I </4 12I4 D21 2;H80<<47 ?074 M87FI49< 72<47 !% * &&* >E </4 34;025 =8:< ;;=:709F <= </4 ;=I3520929<109;4</489;54=6</4;=I3520929<5=7F47</4 ;=I35209< 2F2091< </4 62I05E I4I>4:1 =6 </4 23345529< </4 23345529< ;=II0<<47 </01 09;0749< =D4?4: </4 3:4149< 09;0749< 01 1207 <= /2?4 =;;8::47 =9 !* $ &&$ 0 4 26<4: 52314=6 =94 E42: 6:=I </4 72<4 =6 2;H80<<25=6 </42;;81470934;025214= *&! !! 770<0=9255E=9;2:468534:8125=6</4;=I35209< 2?4:I49<1 297 251= </4 ;/2:F4#1/44< I2<4:0251 4K;43< =I90>81 2554F2<0=91 I274 2F2091< </4 23345529< 2>1=58<45E 9= 18;/ I2<4:0251 2:4 352;47 <= 3:=?4</2<</423345529<49<4:47</4/=814=6;=I3520929< 297 I274 29 2<<4I3< <= 211285< </4I D0</ ;/=334: 7I0<<475E</409;0749<D21=;;8::47D0</096=8:D2551=6 </4/=814=6;=I3520929<2979=<09</438>50;?04D /4 - 8 - =9.>5434K=8:<09</4;214=6 :43=:<47 09 /4570932:2F:23/=1 !297!*218974:- ! " # $ # ! $ # $ % # & $ # '! $ () ' ! $ # () *'# # + , + ! - . -. / - 9 - + # + 0 $ # # $ # . #$ ' $ # 1 )2 0 304 5 ($ $ # )# + ' 0 $ # $ # 0 $ 6 $ $ # # $ # $ ' $ # , $ $ / + / + # . $ # # 7 # - 10 - # # $ # + !& 770<0=9255E</4I470;25;4:<060;2<43:=78;47>E </4 23345529< :4?4251 </2< </4 23345529< 01 2 N+ O32<049<297<=</2<4664;<</4;4:<060;2<4 D21 011847 >E </4 ;=9;4:947 1E;/02<:01< /4 I2<4:025 D0<9411412:49=94=</4:</29</462I05EI4I>4:1=6</4 ;=I3520929< < 01 14<<547 3=10<0=9 =6 52D </2< 06 </4 ;=I35209< 297 =</4: I2<4:0251 7= 9=< 701;5=14 29E =6649;4 297 </4 12I4 01 60547 =9 2 6:0?=5=81 ?4K2<0=81297>2147=9=33:4110?4</42554F2<0=914<=8< 09 </4 ;=I35209< 7= 9=< ;=91<0<8<4 29 =6649;4 D/0;/ </4 ;=F90L29;4/21<2G49>E</42F01<:2<40<01=3496=:</01 =8:<<=H821/</43:=;44709F1 <019=<</2<2I4<0;85=81 2925E101 =6 </4 ;214 1/=857 >4 7=94 >46=:4 <:025 6 </4 49<0:4 2554F2<0=91 <2G49 =9 :4;=:7 06 </4 12I4 7= 9=< ;=91<0<8<4 29 =6649;4 </49 </01 =8:< /21 </4 3=D4: <= H821/</4;:0I09253:=;44709F109=:74:<=I44<</44971 =6M81<0;4 918;/;0:;8I1<29;412I=6</4;=91074:47 - 11 - ?04D </2< </4 3:4149< 3:=;44709F1 090<02<47 >E </4 ;=I3520929<2F2091<</423345529<7414:?41<=>4H821/47 ;;=:709F5E3:=;447<=3211</46=55=D09F- 0 /4:0I09253342501 00 /4 3:=;44709F1 2F2091< </4 23345529<2;;8147 09 35 = !&$&&$ 2:0109F =8< =6 :0I4 = )&&$ :4F01<4:47 >E 8912F0 =50;4 <2<0=9 27F0: 6=: </4 =6649;41 38901/2>54 8974: 4;<0=91 &,* $& $!& =6 /2:2<0E2 E2E2 29/0<2 && @6=: 1/=:< A</4 BC 297 4;<0=9 ! : ! 1 & ?#2 =6 </4 ;< 3:4149<5E 349709F =9 </4 6054 =6 01<:0;< J 4110=91 87F4 27F0: 01 /4:4>E H821/47 )% $' 01<= -!5= -&! -