- 1 - !"! #$" " $ %&'(%)*+& '% * , ! "#$#% & ' $ "#$#%$ ( ) &! *+! *$ '! ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &%&# *, &%&# ! ,*&!-! $# $+ #&! $+&! +!+&!#&!#& "&%& * ' +, *, + % &%%, " ! ' . . / 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 *$ 68 &%& 86< ><?75 68 @?19 17 <1-4 6*, &%&# :?54: &A%$&%&# <4>1254<4: @B 504 4C66< 691=4 86< 504 68847=423;7120?@94;7:4< 4=51672,*&!-!$#$+ #&! $+&! +! +&! #&! #& <4?: D150 4=5167+%680?<?51B?B?B? ?7015?&%& 4=51672 ?7:*686D<B<601@15167=5+, 4=51672+?7:%68 <601@1516768019:?<<1?>4=5&%%,?7: 4=51672*?7: ,68504<654=516768019:<478<6- 4E;?98847=42=5 &%&D01=0123<424759B347:17>67504819468::15167?9 - 3 - 125<1=5 ?7: 4221672 ;:>4 " 34=1?9 6;<5 86< ?242 ?5 ?9?@;<?>1 17 ! 34=1?9 ?24 6 &%&# & 04 8?=5;?9 -?5<1E 68 504 =?24 12 50?5 504 C1=51- =6-39?17?75D?2?-176<?7:?==;24:6-4504< 17<F;7?>1 ?7:?8G?93;< ?9;H?9?@;<?>1125<1=5?7: 25?<54:17:;=17>04<56-?<<B01-67504>;12450?50412 96C17>04< 04<4?854<504BD4<424E;?99B?=51C4?54< 04< 3?<4752 =?-4 56 H76D ?@6;5 504 2?-4 ?7: ? 3?7=0?B?5 =67C4B4: D150 5041< 8?-19B -4-@4<2 ==6<:17>9B 5041< -?<<1?>4 D?2 2694-71G4: 67 +%&%&%5128;<504<=?24685043<624=;516750?5?5 504 51-4 68 -?<<1?>4 # 569?2 68 >69: =?20 68 2%%%%% " ?7: 674 -656<=B=94 D?2 >1C47 56 ?==;24: 6 345151674< ?2 ? :6D<B 04<4?854< 504 =6-39?17?75 @4>65547 ? -?94 =019: 7?-49B 1B?720 D06 12 76D ?>4: ?@6;5B4?<25128;<504<?994>4:17504=6-39?17550?5 9?54< ?==;24: 62 56 25?<54: 56 0?<?22 04< @650 30B21=?99B?7:-475?99B?7:504B0?C47653<6C1:4:3<634< - 4 - -4:1=?9?1:?7:866:5604<?7:04<267::15167?99B504B :4-?7:4: ?::15167?9 :6D<B 68 2*%%%%% " ?7: # 569?2 68 >69: 2 2;=0 204 9485 504 -?5<1-671?9 06-4 ?7: 25?<54:56<421:41704<3?<475?906-4 06;>05044886<5 D?2 -?:4 56 245594 504 :123;54 @B 504 8?-19B -4-@4<2 504 2?-4 D475 17 C?17 ?7: ?2 2;=0 504 C1=51- 96:>4: ? =6-39?175 ?>?1725 504 345151674< ?7: 6504<2 D01=0 D?2 <4>1254<4: 17 <1-4 6*, &%&# 86< 504 ?86<4-4751674: 68847=42 ;<17> 504 =6;<24 68 17C4251>?5167 504 <42367:475 " 3691=4 ?<<4254: 504 345151674< ?==;24: 6 67%&%&#?7:4C4<217=450470412 17=;256:B 04 <42367:475"3691=4?854<=6-394517>50417C4251>?51679?1: =0?<>420445?>?1725504345151674<?7:6504<2@486<4504 34=1?96;<5417>?>><14C4:@B5042?-4504345151674< 3<484<<4:?@?1934515167@486<4504::15167?9125<1=5?7: 422167 ;:>4 " 34=1?9 6;<5 86< ?242 ?9?@;<?>1 D01=0 D?2 <4F4=54: @B 6<:4< :?54: %&%&#47=4501234515167 - 5 - 4?<: 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 50494?<74:86<<42367:4756"25?54?7:?926504 94?<74:=6;7249?334?<17>86<<42367:4756& * 3?<5 8<6- ;<>17> 24C4<?9 =6754751672 504 =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< ?==;24: 6 0?2 3<1-?<19B =67547:4: 50?5 ?:-1554:9B 504 345151674< ?7: 504 C1=51- =6-39?17?75 D4<4 17 96C4 ?7: D150 504 =672475 68 8?-19B -4-@4<2 504B @650 >65 -?<<14: 04 ?994>?5167 50?5504C1=51-D?2?-176<?550451-46817=1:475?7:?5 504 51-4 68 -?<<1?>4 12 765 425?@91204: @B 39?=17> -?54<1?9 17 504 =0?<>4 20445 ==6<:17> 56 01- 4E=435 39?=17> 504 2=0669 =4<5181=?54 122;4: @B 504 4?:-?254< 68 504 2=0669 76 6504< ?;504751=?54: :6=;-4752 ?<4 39?=4: @B 504 3<624=;5167 17 504 =0?<>4 20445 7 2;=0 =1<=;-25?7=4 504 68847=4 ;7:4< 504 3<6C121672 68 =5 :642 765 ?55<?=5 ?>?1725 504 345151674<==6<:17>9B043<?B256?996D50434515167 - 6 - # 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< <42367:475 6&C404-4759B633624:504@?193451516767504><6;7: 50?5 345151674< H76D17> 8;99B 504 C1=51- D?2 ? -176< =6--1554: 24E;?9 1754<=6;<24 D150 04< ?7: ?926 -?<<14: 04<?7:504<4?854<204@4>65547?-?94=019:6D504 ?==;24:6-?:404<5694?C4504-?5<1-671?906-4@B 0?<?2217> 04< @650 30B21=?99B ?7: -475?99B 7 2;=0 =1<=;-25?7=42 504 345151674< 12 765 4751594: 86< ><?75 68 @?19 ==6<:17>9B 04 3<?B2 56 :12-122 504 34515167 04 94?<74:?9262;336<54:5041-3;>74:6<:4< , 0?C4>1C47-B?7E16;2=6721:4<?5167@65067 504 2;@-122167 -?:4 @B 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51C4 3?<5142 26 ?926 34<;24: 504 =0?<>4 20445 -?54<1?92 A 2 =6;9: @4 >?504<4: 8<6- =0?<>4 20445 -?54<1?92 ;7:123;54:9B 504 345151674< ?==;24: 6 ?7: 504 C1=51- =6-39?17?75 D4<4 8<6- 504 2?-4 C199?>4 ?7: 504B84991796C4D1504?=06504<?7:504<4?854<@6500?: - 7 - =672472;?9 24E;?9 ?=5 ?54< D150 504 =672475 68 504 8?-19B-4-@4<2504B@650-?<<14:564?=06504<?7:?926 504C1=51-0?:@4>65547?-?94=019:17504B4?<&%&%5 12 504 ?994>?5167 17 504 =0?<>4 20445 50?5 504 C1=51- D?2 -176< ?5 504 51-4 68 17=1:475 4C47 ?5 504 51-4 68 -?<<1?>42<1>059B=6754754:@B50494?<74:=6;724986< 504 345151674< 67 34<;2?9 68 504 =0?<>4 20445 -?54<1?92 504 -4:1=?9 <436<52 ?7: 6504< :6=;-4752 39?=4: @B 504 3<624=;5167 <4C4?92 50?5 ?2 67 504 :?54 68 81917> 504 =6-39?175504C1=51-D?2-?F6<;<504<5043<624=;5167 0?276539?=4:?7B:6=;-475256425?@912050?5504C1=51- D?2 -176< ?5 504 51-4 68 17=1:475 4E=435 39?=17> 504 2=0669=4<5181=?54 17=45043<624=;51670?28?194:5639?=4 ?7B ?;504751=?54: :6=;-475 91H4 @1<50 =4<5181=?54 6< ?7B 6504<=4<5181=?54122;4:@B504=6-345475?;506<15B26949B @?24: 67 504 2=0669 =4<5181=?54 504 ?>4 68 504 C1=51- =?7765 @4 :454<-174: 50?5 204 D?2 -176< ?5 504 51-4 68 17=1:475 :-1554:9B 504 345151674< ?7: 504 C1=51- D4<4 24E;?99B ?=51C4 86< -6<4 50?7 * I B4?<2 7 2;=0 - 8 - =1<=;-25?7=42 504 25?54-475 68 504 C1=51- ?@6;5 504 86<=1@94 24E;?9 1754<=6;<24 ?@6;5 5041< -?<<1?>4 ?7: 504 25?54-47550?5204D?2-176<?550451-46817=1:4750?2 56@454254:17?:45?194:5<1?9@B39?=17>504?;504751=?54: ?>4=4<5181=?54 ?>43<668 $ 7 C14D 68 504 ?@6C4 :12=;22167 D1506;5 4E3<42217> ?7B 6317167 67504 -4<152 68504=?242;881=4 56 069: 50?5 504 =;256:1?9 17=?<=4<?5167 68 504 345151674< :642765=?9986<217=450417C4251>?516712=6-39454:?7: =0?<>420445128194: + ==6<:17>9B 504 34515167 12 -../01 04 345151674< ?==;24:612:1<4=54:56@4479?<>4:67@?19 17 39 !6 &%&#347:17>@486<45046;<5 68::15167?9125<1=5?7: 4221672;:>4 " ! ?9?@;<?>1?<1217>6;568<1-46*, &%&#<4>1254<4:@B 504 4C66< 691=4 5?5167 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120?@94 ;7:4< 4=51672 ,*&!-! $# $+ #&! $+&! +! +&! #&! #& <4?: D150 4=5167 +% 68 - 9 - 0?<?51B? B?B? ?7015? 4=51672 ?7: * 68 6D<B <601@15167 =5 4=51672 + ?7: % 68 <601@15167 68 019: ?<<1?>4 =5 ?7: 4=51672 * ?7: , 68 504 <654=5167 68 019:<478<6- 4E;?98847=42=52;@F4=55650486996D17> =67:151672. ?!45151674<20?994E4=;54?34<267?9@67:86< ?2;-682%%%%% "D1505D62;<4514286< 504 91H42;- 56 504 2?5128?=5167 68 504 F;<12:1=5167?96;<5( @! 04345151674<20?99?334?<<4>;9?<9B67?99 504 :?542 68 04?<17> @486<4 504 <1?9 6;<5 ;79422504 <1?96;<54E4-352012?334?<?7=4 86<C?91:<4?2672( =! 04 345151674< 20?99 765 :1<4=59B 6< 17:1<4=59B 50<4?547 6< 5?-34< D150 504 3<624=;5167D15742242( :! 04 345151674< 20?99 765 17C69C4 17 21-19?< 68847=42178;5;<4( 4! 04 345151674< 20?99 765 94?C4 504 F;<12:1=5167 68 504 <1?9 6;<5 D1506;5 - 10 - 34<-122167 68 504 2?1: 6;<5 ;7519 504 =?24 <4>1254<4:?>?172501-12:123624:688 8! 04 345151674< 20?99 -?<H 012 ?5547:?7=4 @486<4 504 5?5167 6;24 881=4< 4C66< 691=4 5?51676781<25 ;7:?B684C4<B-6750 @45D447 %%% ?- ?7: %%% 3- 5199 504 =?24 <4>1254<4: ?>?1725 01- 12 :123624: 688 @486<4504 <1?96;<5 1+ %" * " 1256. 96.+