- 1 - ! " #$ #$ % "" &$' !" # $ % & "!' ( & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "!' & & (!!! ' "! " & ) "! * + "! ( ,(, -. //!!" 0,( ( "! # $ 1 "1 - 3 - 1 (% & " !! & !(,/! !(!,! !!,!* & & & 2 2 $ $ 2 % 0 !34536789:;<7=>>766=?;477@3?A67=B7;0 >C757C=?=>>7=6=A=3?4;;<70C87C8=;78 !!>=44783? &0!(,/! - 4 - <7 =>>63D=?; D0?;7?84 ;<=; C74>0?87?; 0 C74>0?87?; 0( =?8 3; E7C7 ;7?87C7C4 =A=3?4; = ?0;353D=;30?8=;78"!(!50C4F>>6:055008AC=3?4=?8 0;<7C =C;3D674 ;0 C G978@=C C77;C3D =?8 04; 7;C3D 0:4 =?8 3C64 04;764 50C ;<7 :7=C4 !( =?8 !(/ ;=640=>>7=C4;<=;;<793805;<7=>>63D=?;E=4 C7H7D;78=;;<74;=A7050>7?3?A05;<753?=?D3=69384<7 =>>63D=?; D<=667?A78 ;<7 4=G7 9750C7 ;<7 =>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;:=?8;<74=G734>7?83?A ?;<7G7=?E<367;<7 938 4F9G3;;78 9: C74>0?87?; 0 E=4 ;C7=;78 =4 ;<7 60E74;=?83;E=487D38783?>C3?D3>67;0344F7=E0C@0C87C 3? ;7CG4 05 =? 0C87C 8=;78 !"!,! =;7C ;<7 C7406F;30? =DD7>;3?A ;<7 C74>0?87?; 0 =4 ;<7 60E74; 93887C E=4 @7>; 3? =97:=?D7 3? ;7CG4 05 =? 0C87C 8=;78 !(!,!=?8;<7C7=5;7C3;E=4D=?D766780?!!,! <7C74>0?87?; 0 ;<7C750C7 D<=667?A78 ;<7 =D;30? =?8 40FA<; 50C = 83C7D;30? ;0 344F7 = E0C@ 0C87C 3? & 0!(,/! <7 67=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 <768 ;<=; C74>0?87?; 0 973?A D0?4387C78 =4 ;<7 60E74; 93887C - 5 - ;<7C7E=4?0HF4;353D=;30?50C?0;344F3?A=E0C@0C87C=?8 D0?47IF7?;6: 83C7D;78 ;<7 =F;<0C3;374 ;0 344F7 = E0C@ 0C87C 73?A =AAC37B78 9: ;<7 4=38 0C87C ;<7 =>>63D=?; 477@4 6397C;: ;0 5367 =? =>>7=6 0? ;<7 AC0F?8 ;<=; 3; E=4 ?0;=CC=:78=4=>=C;:3?;<7EC3;>7;3;30?=?8;<=;3;E=4 ?0;<7=C8 ' >>63D=?;D0?;7?84;<=;;<7=>>7=6536789:;<7 =>>63D=?;9750C7;<7=>>766=;7=F;<0C3;:34?0EH70>=C83J78 3? B37E 05 ;<7 0C87C>=44789:;<767=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 ;34;<7C750C7>C=:78;<=;;<7=>>63D=?;97AC=?;7867=B7 ;05367=?=>>7=6=A=3?4;;<70C87C>=44789:;<767=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 7 =640 D0?;7?84 ;<=; C74>0?87?; 0 GF4;<=B7D<=667?A78;<70C87C>=44789:;<7=F;<0C3;374 D=?D763?A ;<7 =DD7>;=?D7 05 <34 938 9750C7 ;<7 =>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;374 " ;<7 67=C?78 D0F?476 50C C74>0?87?; 0 4F9G3;4 ;<=; ;<7 67=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 <=4 G7C76: 83C7D;78 ;<7 C74>0?87?; =F;<0C3;374 ;0 ;=@7 ;<7 ;7?87C ;0 3;4 60A3D=6 7?8 9: 83C7D;3?A ;<7G ;0 344F7 = E0C@ 0C87C - 6 - 43?D7 C74>0?87?; 0 E=4 ;C7=;78 =4 ;<7 60E74; 93887C 7 D0?;7?84 ;<=; ;<34 D=??0; =557D; ;<7 =>>63D=?; 3? =?: G=??7C =4 <7 <=4 D<=667?A78 ;<7 C7H7D;30? 05 <34 938 9750C7 ;<7 =>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;: 7 D0?;7?84 ;<=; ;<7 =>>63D=?; E0F68 A7;= ;0 D<=667?A7;<70C87C >=4478 9: ;<7 67=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 0?6: 35 <34 938 34 C74;0C787;<7C750C7D0?;7?84;<=;;<7=>>63D=?;D=??0; =44=36 0C 47; =; ?=FA<; ;<7 0C87C >=4478 9: ;<7 67=C?78 3?A67F8A7 <7 67=C?78 883;30?=6 0B7C?G7?; 8B0D=;7 C7>C747?;3?A;<70553D3=6C74>0?87?;40;0"4F9G3;;78 ;<=; 3? B37E 05 ;<7 0C87C >=4478 9: ;<7 67=C?78 3?A67 F8A7=E0C@0C87C34?0E344F78;0C74>0?87?;0 0? 8=;7!"!,! ( &7<=B7D0?4387C784F9G34430?405;<767=C?78 D0F?47650C;<7=>>63D=?;=4E766=4;<767=C?78D0F?47650C ;<7 C74>0?87?; 0 =?8 ;<7 67=C?78 883;30?=6 0B7C?G7?;8B0D=;750C;<70553D3=6C74>0?87?;4 - 7 - / <7B=6383;:05C7H7D;30?05;<79384F9G3;;789: ;<7=>>63D=?;34:7;;097D0?4387C789750C7;<7=>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;:<70C87C>=44789:;<767=C?783?A67F8A734 3?;<7?=;FC=6D0FC47057B7?;4=4;<767=C?783?A67F8A7 <=8 <768 ;<=; C74>0?87?; 0 973?A ;<7 60E74; 93887C D0F68 ?0; 97 87>C3B78 05 ;<7 97?753; 5 = E0C@ 0C87C 34 344F78>FC4F=?;;0;<70C87C>=44789:;<767=C?783?A67 F8A7 ;<7 4=G7 E0F68 =6E=:4 97 4F9H7D; ;0 ;<7 =>>7=6 53678 9: ;<7 =>>63D=?; 9750C7 ;<7 =>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;: <7C750C7 ;34?0;=>>C0>C3=;750C;<34 0FC;;0F>47;;<7 0C87C >=4478 9: ;<7 67=C?78 3?A67 F8A7 0E7B7C E7 D0?4387C3;=>>C0>C3=;7;0<068;<=;;<7E0C@0C87C35=?: 344F789:;<70553D3=6C74>0?87?;4;0;<7C74>0?87?;0 4<=66=6E=:4974F9H7D;;0;<70F;D0G705;<7=>>7=653678 9: ;<7 =>>63D=?; 9750C7 ;<7 =>>766=;7 =F;<0C3;: 7?D7 ;<7C734?0?778;0AC=?;=?:67=B7;0;<7=>>63D=?;;05367 ;<34 =>>7=6 DD0C83?A6: 0 ! 34 C7H7D;78 9F; 4F9H7D;;0;<70947CB=;30?4G=873?=90B7 - 8 - ?B37E05;<70C87C>=44780? 0 ! ;<7&0!!' !!=6404;=?84834G34478 () & ' () & %' 34;0 60,