- 1 - !!" #$%% $ & &'() &( * ! " # $" " % $" " " & & ! % $' # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $$!# $ ! (# ( $ )& $ $ % $ % $ $ $$ *+)$ $% $ ( , , - %%" ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/7289582: 2;3/45 46 .<:<3/=< <><:/?9:<?0.<<5./3<&*34@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 <></5033.2123/3/452:<;;9028/5 4)&<:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4)& :2>/032:28 B= %<7.<77/ 47/;2 </;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 *+) <58 46 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46 887 /03 58 200/450%98>2</;.9: .2 <B:/8>28 6<;30 46 3.2 ;<02 <:2 3.<3 :201458253 4 748>28 < ;4A17</53 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:<;;9028 45 && <772>/5> 3.<3 0.2 C<0 03<=/5>C/3..2:<953<3 4A<5<A<:<8/ D/77<>2 6:4A649: - 3 - =2<:0 1:/4: 34 3.2 /5;/8253 <58 .2: 1<:2530 1<0028 <C<= <580.290283484;447/2C4:?.2123/3/452:B2/5>3.2 :20/8253460<A2D/77<>2B2745>340<A2;<032<704?54C5 34 .2: 0/5;2 3.:22 =2<:0 3.2:2B= 2E1:20028 ./0 74D2 34 .2:;;4:8/5>7=3.2=B43.6277/574D2.2:2<632:.2.<8 >/D25 <009:<5;2 3.<3 .2 C4978 A<::= .2: 5 09;. 1:4A/023.2123/3/452:<58:201458253 4C2:202E9<77= <;3/D2 <32: 45 F&& <3 <B493 &,&& 1A C.25 0.2C<0<3.2:<953-0.49023.2123/3/452:3:201<0028/534 0</8 .4902 <58 253/;28 .2: C/3. < 1:4A/02 34 A<::= ;4AA/3328 02E9<7 /532:;49:02 45 .2: .2 .<0 543 :2D2<7283.20<A234<5=B48=0/5;2.21:4A/0283.<3.2 C4978A<::=.2: * 3 /0 69:3.2: <772>28 3.<3 3.2= C2:2 ?54C5 34 2<;.43.2:64:<12:/48463.:22=2<:0/5;23.2123/3/452: 6</728 34 A<::= .2: 0.2 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</53 B264:2 3.2 :20145825347/;2 45 && .2 0</8 ;4A17</53 ;<A2 34 B2 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4)& 64: 3.2 46625;20195/0.<B729582:2;3/45*+)46<582;3/450 - 4 - <58 ) 46 ;3 9B02@92537= :201458253 4 47/;2 /5D203/><328 3.2 ;<02 9:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5D203/><3/45 /3 C<0 :2D2<728 3.<3 :201458253 4 C<0 A<G4: <3 3.2 3/A2 46 /5;/8253 0 09;. 3.2 :201458253 47/;2 7</8 ;.<:>20.223 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 <58 *+) 46 <028453.2;4A17</533.272<:528200/450%98>2344? ;4>5/H<5;2463.246625;20 2/5><>>:/2D28B=3.20<A2 123/3/452:/0B264:23./049:3 2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: <58 72<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 64: :201458253 43<32.49>.543/;2/002:D2834:201458253 4 0.2:2A</528<B0253 1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02D2:<7 ;453253/450 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: 1:/A<:/7= ;45325328 3.<3 :201458253 4 B2/5> A<G4: 123/3/452: <58 0.2 C2:2 /5 74D2 C/3. 2<;. 43.2: <58 B43. C2:2 02E9<77= <;3/D2 64: 3.:22=2<:0<58<33.23/A246/5;/8253123/3/452:.<0543 ;4AA/3328 02E9<7 <;3 9145 09;. 1:4A/02 46 A<::/<>2 5 - 5 - 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;2 3.2 46625;2 9582: 2;3/45 *+) 46 8420543<33:<;3<></5033.2123/3/452:;;4:8/5>7=1:<=0 34<774C3.2123/3/45 ) 72<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 4114028 3.2 1:<=2: 45 3.2 >:4958 3.<3 ;.<:>2 0.223<772><3/45A4:21<:3/;97<:7=3.203<32A25346D/;3/A 9582: 2;3/45 ) 46 : 0.2 .<0 03<328 3.<3 3.2 <;;9028123/3/452:.<8;4AA/332864:;269702E9<7<;3C/3. .2: 582: 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 .2 1:<=0 34 8/0A/00 3.2 123/3/45 + .<D2>/D25A=<5E/490;450/82:<3/45B43.45 3.2 09BA/00/45 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D21<:3/20<583.284;9A2530<D</7<B7245:2;4:8 0 ;4978 B2 ><3.2:28 6:4A :2;4:80 /5/3/<77= ;4A17</53 C<0 748>28 45 && <772>/5> 3.<3 :201458253 4 <58 3.2 123/3/452: C2:2 ?54C5 34 2<;. 43.2: 64: 3.:22 =2<:0 <58 3.2= B43. B2745>0 34 0<A2 D/77<>2 <58 B43. C2:2 /5 74D2 <58 02E9<77= <;3/D2 - 6 - ;;4:8/5> 34 .2: 0.2 C<0 543 /564:A28 3.2 0<A2 34 <5=B48= 0/5;2 3.2 <;;9028 1:4A/028 .2: 3.<3 .2 C4978 A<::= .2: .49>. /5 3.2 ;4A17</53 0.2 .<0 03<328 3.<3 0.2 C<0 <>28 <B493 + =2<:0 <3 3.2 3/A2 46 /5;/8253 89:/5>3.2;49:0246/5D203/><3/45/3C<0:2D2<7283.<30.2 C<0 A<G4: 0 09;. 3.2 :20145825347/;2 7</8 ;.<:>2 0.223457=64:3.246625;20195/0.<B729582:2;3/450*+) <58 46 B= 72<D/5> 3.2 1:4D/0/450 46 ;3 8A/33287= 3.2:2 /0 <5 /54:8/5<32 827<= /5 748>/5> 3.2 ;4A17</53 F 4:24D2: /3 /0 3.2 012;/6/; ;<02 46 3.2 ;4A17</5<533.<3B43.0.2<58123/3/452:C2:2/574D23/0 543 03<328 /5 3.2 ;4A17</53 4: /5 .2:) 03<32A253 3.<3 0.2C<0>/D25;450253B=A/0;45;213/45466<;3<58B264:2 .<D/5> 09;. 02E9<7 <;3 .2 .<8 1:4A/028 3.<3 .2 C4978 A<::=.2: & 509;.;/:;9A03<5;23.245IB7212E49:3/5 3.2 ;<02 46 - 7 - :214:328 /5 .278 /5 1<:< 40<58<09582:, ! " # $ % & ' " - 8 - ( ) $ *+ ( ) $9:3.2:3.245IB72 12E49:3 /5 3.2 ;<0246 !"! #$:214:328/5%&'( ).2783.<3C.25<C4A25C.4C/77/5>7=25><>20 /5<745>32:A02E9<7:27<3/450./1C/3.<A<56977=<C<:2 46/305<39:2<58C/3.493<5=;4>2532D/825;2340.4C3.<3 09;.:27<3/450./1C<0/589;28B=A/0;45;213/45466<;304: 6<702 1:4A/02 46 A<::/<>2 A<82 /5 B<8 6</3. 6:4A 3.2 /5;213/45 3.2 A<5 ;<5543 B2 .278 >9/73= 46 :<12 9582: 2;3/45 *+) 46 .90 /3 /0 ;72<: 3.<3 <;;9028 ;<5 B2 ;45D/;328 64: :<12 457= /6 3.2 49:3 :2<;.20 < ;45;790/45 - 9 - 3.<3 3.2 /53253/45 46 3.2 <;;9028 C<0 A<7<6/82 <58 3.<3 .2.<8;7<58203/52A43/D20 $9:3.2:3.245IB72 12E49:3 /5 3.2 ;<0246 $*+ ,! $ -! ! +. !/5:7 4)&F<:/0/5>4934612;/<7 2<D2 23/3/45 !:/A/5<7# 4+ 46 &F .278 /5 1<:< 40)+<58<09582:, / , ) - ) . ) $ /01 ) ( 2 3 4 & 5 ! - 10 - " $ 5 &6 ' " ( ) ) $ *+ ( ) - 11 - 78 9 ) ( : $ ; & ( - - - $ - - 4 &1 ( $ *+ ( < $ " , $ - 12 - " " . ( ( & = ( 5) 78 9 0 ) $ /01 ) ) - 13 - - * .2 A<32:/<70 17<;28 /5 3.2 ;<02 <:2 0966/;/253 34 :2G2;3 <58 4D2::972 3.2 6<;39<7 <002:3/45 ;453</528 /5 3.2;4A17</53<58;.<:>20.2233.<3<;;90<3/450<:26<702 0 09;. ;453/59<3/45 46 1:4;228/5>03:/<7 C4978 :20973 /5 <B902 46 1:4;200 46 3.2 49:3 <58 C4978 543 02:D2 3.2 2580 46 G903/;2 012;/<77= C.25 /3 /0 ;72<: 3.<3 3.2 0<A2 C4978543;45;7982/53.2;45D/;3/4546<;;9028 5 D/2C 46 3.2 <B4D2 <A 46 3.2 ;450/82:28 D/2C 3.<3 0/5;2 3.2 D/;3/A C<0 < ;450253/5> 1<:3= <58 B43. 3.2 123/3/452: <58 :201458253 4 C2:2 02E9<77= <;3/D2 64: ;450/82:<B72 12:/48 <58 3.2= C2:2 /5 74D2 .2:264:23.246625;209582:2;3/45<58*+)46 84 543 <33:<;3 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:<;;9028 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;2 ;453/59<3/45 46 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:<;;9028 /0 543./5> B93 <B902 46 1:4;200 46 49:3 - 14 - ;;4:8/5>7=3.2123/3/45/0 + ) .21:4;228/5>0<></5033.2123/3/452:<;;9028 /5 4)& <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4)& :2>/032:28 B= %<7.<77/ 47/;2 </;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B729582:2;3/450*+)<58461258/5>45 3.2 6/72 46 887 /03 58 200/450 %98>2 </;.9: /0 .2:2B=@9<0.28 +) &%( % , ,* ,%