Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55020 (KAR)
THE MANAGER HDFC ERGO GEN INS CO LTD v. NINGAPPA
WP/203739/2025 · 2026-01-28
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55020 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55020 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!
" #$#%
&'$! !#
(')
!"#
!
$%#"&
'
!"' !
$( $)*
$%#"&
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
''+ '')
, &+&''&'%
- - ' %
++*
'&( ** '&''
. $
!
! / -
0123 4012503 6785904 :72 ;<0 =0;>;>7502$59821560 7?=15@ ' 7;>60 ;7 209=75305;9 A<7 120 ;<0 641>?15;
153 7A502 7: ;<0 7::053>5B C0<>640 209=06;>C04@ >9 3>9=05903:72;<0201975;<1;5713C029072302>9=19903 1B1>59;;<0209=75305;919;<>9
782;>9>564>503;720?>;
;<0?1;;02;7;<005>72
>C>4-83B0153- >53<1582 :729<72; D;<02>E8514F >5
7** '&'* * <0=0;>;>7502$59821560
7?=15@<19614403>5 G809;>75 ;<0 72302 31;03 &+&''&'% =19903 E@ ;<0
- 3 -
2>E8514 >5
7** '&'* A<020>5 ;<0 2>E8514 3>9?>9903 7' :>403 E@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502$59821560 7?=15@ 900H>5B 20I06;>75 7: ;<0 641>? =0;>;>75 :>403 E@ 209=75305; 7$641>?15;
75 ;<0 B27853 ;<1; ;<0 641>?
=0;>;>75 >9 57; :>403 A>;<>5 9>J ?75;<9 :27? ;<0 31;0 7:
7668220560 7: ;<0 166>305; >;<78; 13C02;>5B ;7 ;<0 ?02>;9 7: ;<0 ?1;;02 >; >9 9005 ;<1; >5 C>0A 7: ;<0 641>?
=0;>;>75 <1C>5B E005 :>403 A>;< 1 3041@ ;<0 =0;>;>7502$ 59821560
7?=15@:>403151==4>61;>75:7220I06;>757:;<0 641>? =0;>;>75 85302 2302 840 2013 A>;< 06;>75 %7:
15306;>75++*7:7;720<>64096; 75 ;<0B27853;<1;;<0641>?=0;>;>75A19E12203E@;<041A7: 4>?>;1;>75>5C>0A7:;<01?053037;720<>64096;
" 2>E8514 20I06;03 ;<0 1==4>61;>75 :>403 E@ ;<0 59821560
7?=15@ 85302 2302 840 2013 A>;< 06;>75%7:
15306;>75++*7:7;720<>6409 6; A<>6<>9614403>5G809;>75E@;<0=0;>;>7502$59821560 7?=15@>5;<>9A2>;=0;>;>75
- 4 -
% <02012090C0214?1;;029:27?3>::0205;
782;9 162799 ;<0 6785;2@ A<>6< <1C0 1==2716<03 ;<0 75/E40 8=20?0
782;
E0>5B 1BB2>0C03 E@ ;<0 20I06;>75 7: ;<0 1==4>61;>75153E@;<03041@E0>5B67537503E@;<0641>?9 2>E8514 ;<020E@=02?>;;>5B;<0675;>581;>757:;<0641>?
=0;>;>75>52>;0;>;>75
>C>47++ '&'">5;<061907:
A<>6< >9=053>5BE0:720;<075/E408=20?0
782;>5C74C>5B;<0 G809;>75 7: 4>?>;1;>75 =20962>E03 E@ ;<0 1?05303 7;72 0<>64096;<075/E408=20?0
782; C>307230231;03 +''&'% =19903;<0:7447A>5B72302!
!
+ <>9E0>5B;<09;1;07:1::1>29 ;<075/E40=0J 782;<19>5:16;<043;<1;;<0641>?=0;>;>75967843=276003
- 5 -
0J60=;:>514>9>5B;<0I83B?05;9<020:720 >;A7843E0>5 ;<0 >5;0209; 7: E7;< ;<0 =12;>09 153 =2830560 30?1539 ;<1; >5 C>0A 7: 90C0214 =053056@ 7: ?1;;029 ;<0 641>?
=0;>;>759E0:720;<0209=06;>C0
782;99<144=276003:82;<02 0J60=; :>514>9>5B ;<0 I83B?05;9 >5 016< 7: ;<0 ?1;;029 66723>5B4@ ;<0A2>;=0;>;>75>9
230203166723>5B4@
!*+ ( !#) $
!"!* ,