Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 55015 (KAR)
RAMESH YADAV v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203912/2025 · 2026-01-21
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55015 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 55015 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#"$
%&#! !"
'&(
! "
#$
$$ %
&
$
$ $ $
!!! & $ ! & $ ! & '
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! $ & $! " #$'
%
(
& ) &
& ( & (#% #%
#% $ * (
!+)
( ! )!! $ #
,%
& (
-$'
&./01 23 045 /.15 .65 04.0 045 7508082956 81 . :;189511<.9 6518=89> 89 .8/4;6 810 .8/4;6 0 81 /29059=5= 04.0 04565 ?.1 756129.@ 59<80A :50?559 045 7508082956 .9=295 48<<.8.4 .9=204561 9 3;60456.9/5 23 045 .:2B5 59<80A 04565 56;705= . 38>40 :50?559 0?2 >62;71237527@5//26=89>@A:.15=29045/2<7@.890.9 & /.<5 02 :5 65>810565= .>.8910 7508082956 89 68<5 2! .9= ! ?80489 045 C;681=8/0829 23
- 3 -
50.C89.>.6 2@8/5 0.0829 .8/4;6 45 /4.6>5 14550 /.<5 02 :5 38@5= .>.8910 0481 7508082956 89 68<5 2! #7@#%
2+!!)% 29 045 38@5 23 ==80829.@ 5118291 ';=>5 .8/4;6 326 045 23359/51 7;9814.:@5;9=565/08291 + ) ! ! !) 23 .9= 5/0829 #% #!% 23 045 /45=;@5=.1051.9=045/45=;@5=68:51#65B59082923 062/80851% /0 ++ .9= 89 68<5
2! # 2)+ !%32604523359/57;9814.:@5;9=565/08291 ) !+65.=?8045/0829 + 23$.15=2904565>8106.082923045/68<5.9=38@89>23 045 /4.6>5 14550 651729=590
2 9175/026 23 2@8/5 65/2<<59=5= 02 2759 . 62?=A 14550 .>.8910 045 7508082956 456589 $.15= 29 ?48/4 045 651729=590
2 57;0A ;75689059=590 23 2@8/5 .8/4;6 26=565= 326 275989> ;7 23 045 62?=A 14550 ?8042;0 811;89> 045 762721.@9208/562?=A14550/.<502:527595=89045 9.<5237508082956=.05=)!!:A5905689>4819.<5 8904565>81056
- 4 -
0 81 /29059=5= :A @5.695= /2;915@ 326 045 750808295604.0045/.1512<.=52;0:A045651729=59089 68<5
2! .9= ! 045 7508082956 456589 /.<5 02 :5 ./D;8005= 29 ! ! .9= 29 !!! .3056 068.@ 45653265 80 81 /29059=5= 04.0 04565 81 92 /68<89.@ /.15 759=89> .1 .>.8910 045 7508082956 26 .9A /2<7@.890 65>810565= .>.8910 045 7508082956 :53265 045 72@8/510.08290813;60456/29059=5=04.029045:.18123 0452?=A45505>81056<.890.895=:A045651729=590 72@8/5 651729=590
2 4.1 :559 365D;590@A 1;<<2989> 04575080829560204572@8/510.0829.9=26=5689>48<02180 045590865=.A8904572@8/510.0829?8042;004565:589>.9A /2<7@.890&265B59.9.@@5>.0829.>.89100457508082956 =5178050453./004.0458192065D;865=89.9A/.15326.9A 89B5108>.0829?4.0125B56
0 81 3;60456 /29059=5= 04.0 045 7508082956 4.1 :559<590.@@A4.6.115=.9=920.:@502/;@08B.05481@.9= :A;08@8189>481B.@;.:@508<5?48/48192?1759089B818089> 045 72@8/5 10.0829 ?8042;0 04565 :589> .9A /2<7@.890
- 5 -
65>810565= 26 .9A :.181 ?48/4 81 89 020.@ B82@.0829 23 045 3;9=.<590.@68>40159146895=89045291080;0829239=8. 651068/089> .9= 65106.8989> 045 3655=2< 23 <2B5<590 .9= 045 3;9=.<590.@ 68>401 23 045 /808E59 9.<5@A 045 7508082956 456589 45653265 7508082956 1;:<8005= . 657651590.0829 29 !! ! 02 65B85?
.9= 65<2B5 481 9.<5 362< 045 2?=A 4550 5>81056 $;0 651729=590 24.1920/2<<;98/.05=267.115=.9A26=568965175/0 23 045 657651590.0829 12 1;:<8005= 59/5 @530 ?804 92 20456 .@0569.08B5 5338/./82;1 65<5=A 508082956 81 756326/5=02.7762./404812;6032689=;@>59/5
0 81 3;60456 /29059=5= :A @5.695= /2;915@ 326 045 7508082956 04.0 045 651729=590 .;042680851 768<.68@A 89B2F5=2627595=04562?=A14550.>.89100457508082956 ?8042;0 32@@2?89> 045 762B818291 23 045 .69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ + <265 175/838/.@@A 10.9=89> 26=56
2!+ .9= 045 762/5=;65 /2905<7@.05= 0456589 ?804 65>.6= 02 045 89068/./851 59;<56.05= 0456589 89/@;=89> 9.<89> 045 7508082956.1?450456.60.60$26.60.9=32@@2?89>
- 6 -
20456 762/5=;651 /2905<7@.05= 0456589 0 81 .@12 /29059=5= :A @5.695= /2;915@ 04.0 045 651729=5901 .65 45@@ :590 02 :6.9= 045 7508082956 .1 . 62?=A =517805 045 3./004.004575080829564.1:559./D;8005=890450?2/.151 04.0?56536.<5=.>.891048<.9=.@120453./004.004565 .6592/.151759=89>.>.891048<.9A<26589.9A72@8/5 10.0829 45653265 ?459 045 7508082956 <.=5 .9 .77@8/.0829 26 657651590.0829 045 651729=590 .;042680851 2;>40 02 4.B5 .//5705= 045 657651590.0829 .9= 762B8=5= .9 277260;980A 02 045 7508082956 02 7;032604 481 /.15 23 04565:589>92.@@5>.082926/68<89.@/.151759=89>.>.8910 48<.9=04.004589/@;1829234819.<5.9=/29089;89>481 9.<5 89 045 2?=A 4550 5>81056 81 B82@.08B5 045 7689/87@51 23 9.0;6.@ C;108/5 89/@;=89> 481 756129.@ @8:560A 0813;60456/29059=5=:A@5.695=/2;915@04.00456581.@@ 72118:8@8085104.00457508082956<.A:58<7@8/.05=8920456 ;995/511.6A /.151 .1 7508082956 81 B;@956.:@5 02 :5 =6.>>5=890204572@8/510.0829.9=36.<5=8912<5/.151
- 7 -
?456545819205B5989B2@B5=77.6590@A045658192/.15 759=89>.>.8910045750808295689.9A2304572@8/510.08291
0 81 3;60456 /29059=5= :A @5.695= /2;915@ 326 045 7508082956 04.0 045 7508082956 =251 920 3.@@ 8902 045 :6./F502310.9=89>26=56
2!+23045.69.0.F.2@8/5 .9;.@ .9= 45 2;>40 920 02 4.B5 :559 89/@;=5= 89 045 2?=A45505>81056:A045651729=590104565:A/;6:89> 0453;9=.<590.@68>4023045750808295689/@;=89>608/@5+ .9= 608/@5 23 045 291080;0829 23 9=8. 0 81 .@12 /29059=5= :A @5.695= /2;915@ 04.0 045 7508082956-1 9.<5 4.1:55989/@;=5=8904562?=A14550?8042;0/29=;/089> .9A 59D;86A 926 762B8=89> .9 277260;980A 23 45.689> 26 /.@@89> 326 .9A 5G7@.9.0829 26 32@@2?89> 045 762/5=;65 /2905<7@.05= ;9=56 045 .69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ <265 175/838/.@@A 10.9=89> 26=56
2!+ 0 81 .@12 /29059=5= 04.0 89 17805 23 045 7508082956 :589> ./D;8005= 89 045 0?2 /.15104.0?56538@5=.>.891048<=;502756129.@59<80A .9= =517805 045 657651590.0829 :589> <.=5 045 7508082956-1 9.<5 81 920 106;/F 233 362< 045 5906A 89 045
- 8 -
65>81056 23 62?=851 04565:A /.;189> ;902@= 4.6=1487 .9= B82@.0829 23 481 3;9=.<590.@ 68>40 23 3655 <2B5<590 .9= 481 @8:560A 45 651729=590
2 4.1 :559 ;995/511.68@A /.@@89>045750808295602045C;681=8/0829.@72@8/510.0829.9= F55789> 48< 326 92 65.129 ?4.0125B56 ?48/4 81 .>.8910 045 291080;0829.@ 3;9=.<590.@ 68>401 89 3.B2;6 23 045 7508082956 0 81 .@12 920 045 /.15 23 045 651729=590 04.0 04565.65.9A/.15165>810565=.>.8910045750808295602:5 /.@@5=02045C;681=8/0829.@72@8/510.0829.0045?48<1.9= 3.9/851 23 045 651729=5901 9=56 045 /86/;<10.9/51 @5.695=/2;915@155F102150.18=50458<7;>95=26=5623 :6.9=89>0457508082956.1.62?=A14550568904565>81056 <.890.895= :A 045 651729=590 .;042680A 9.<5@A 651729=590
2
56 /2906.
@5.695= ==80829.@ 2B569<590 =B2/.0565765159089>045651729=5900.05/29059=104.0 29 045 :.181 23 045 /68<89.@ /.151 65>810565= .>.8910 045 7508082956.9=2045617508082956?.189/@;=5=890452?=A 45505>8105608192=2;:006;504.004575080829564.1
- 9 -
:559./D;8005=8904538610/.1589045A5.6!.9=89045 15/29=/.1589045A5.6!$;00453./065<.89104.045 4.=:559/4.6>5145505=89:204045/.151.9=;9=56?590 068.@ :;0 4.1 :559 ./D;8005= 45653265 04565 81 92 8@@5>.@80A /2<<8005= 26 762/5=;6.@ @.715 :A 045 651729=59018989/@;=89>0459.<523045750808295689045 62?=A 14550 <.890.895= :A 045 651729=5901 45653265 045 75080829 38@5= :A 045 7508082956 =5156B51 02 :5 =81<8115=.1045C;=><59065@85=:A045750808295689045 /.15 23
6572605=8981<;/4@.056 04.9 045 65>8106.0829 23 045 9.<5 23 7508082956 89 045 62?=A14550.9=80142;@=920599;6502481:595380 ) 4.B545.6=@5.695=/2;915@3260457508082956 .9= @5.695= ==80829.@ 2B569<590 =B2/.05 326 045 651729=5901
0 81 . 3;9=.<590.@ 6;@5 23 @.? 04.0 ?459 . 756129 81 8<7@8/.05= .1 . 62?=A 1455056 :A 89/@;=89> 481 9.<589045@8102362?=A1455004529;181;7290450.05
- 10 -
02 32@@2? 045 =;5 762/5=;65 /2905<7@.05= ;9=56 045 65@5B.90 6;@51 .9= 65>;@.08291 9 045 7651590 /.15 045 .69.0.F.2@8/5.9;.@<265175/838/.@@A0455>8105623 2?=851 <.890.895= 89 26=56
2!+ ?48/4 =5.@1 ?804 481026A 145501 .9= 62?=A 145501 .9= 5962@@<590 26 65>8106.0829 23 7561291 89 045 1.8= 14550 326 65>81056 326 /29089;2;1 <29802689> :A 045 72@8/5 .;042680851 81 920 32@@2?5= 0.9=89> 6=56
2!+ =5.@1 ?804 65>8106.0829 2362?=85145=538980829762B8=5=8104.0.62?=A<.A:5 =53895= .1 . >;9=. .9= 89/@;=51 . 422@8>.9 02;>4 B.>.:29=26.9A756129?4281=.9>562;1027;:@8/75./5 .9=06.9D;8@80A4565.65<.9A326<12362?=81< ?48/4 .65 =51/68:5= 0456589 .9= 045 762/511 .9= 762/5=;65 /2905<7@.05= 02:5 <.890.895= 89=833565907.601 9.<5@A .60.60$.9=.60?48/4>2B569045<.89059.9/5 23 . 65>81056 .9= 045 9.<51 23 045 62?=851 89 04586 65175/08B5 7.601 0 81 045 =;0A .9= 2:@8>.0829 /.10 ;729 045 651729=5901 ?48/4 81 920 270829.@ 02 32@@2? 045 =;5 762/5=;65/2905<7@.05=;9=5604510.9=89>26=56123045
- 11 -
.69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ ?48@5 5905689> 045 9.<5 23 . 756129 89 045 62?=A 14550 .9= 04565 .65 /560.89 762/5=;65102:5<.9=.0268@A32@@2?5=:532655905689>045 9.<511/29059=5=:A@5.695=/2;915@3260457508082956 045 762/511 .9= 762/5=;65 .1 /2905<7@.05= ;9=56 045 10.9=89> 6=56
2!+ 23 045 .69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ 4.1920:55932@@2?5=.9=92277260;980A?.1>8B5902045 75080829560238@5481657@A265G7@.9.082932665<2B89>481 9.<5890452?=A45505>81056.9=<565@A:5/.;1545 ?.189B2@B5=89./68<89.@/.1529.756129.@59<80A23. 68B.@6A:50?5590?2>.9>1454.1:55936.<5=89?48/4 .@12 045 7508082956 4.1 :559 ./D;8005= 89 045 A5.61 ! .9=!081.@12/29059=5=04.0042;>40457508082956 4.1 <.=5 . 657651590.0829 02 045 651729=590 .;042680851 .3056045./D;800.@29!! !045657651590.08294.1 920 :559 /2918=565= .9= 5B59 .3056 045 ./D;800.@ 45 4.1 :559 1;<<295= 02 045 C;681=8/0829.@ 72@8/5 10.0829 326 ;995/511.6A8905662>.0829?459045658192/.15759=89> .>.891048<
- 12 -
+ 45226=89.05$59/423048129-:@52;6089 045 /.15 23 #1;76.% @.8= =2?9 /560.89 >;8=5@8951 45 >;8=5@8951 @.8= =2?9 :A 0481 2;60.65 .1 32@@2?1
!"!#$
%
&!%'
(#%!)$ *$) %$$ )$$) ! )$$
$
))
! **%$
%
+%%
, + **%$ ) %$$ + %
!"!#$ ))! %$! )" &
*
%#+ % *% & & &-% %
&. %
%#$! + %! %
&!. &"'
%
! ! *%$
/)*$ )%% ) . + !%*%! &
%%
+ )!! %
&!%
%
0$#% 123' ! 4526
7#$'
#*!
8$)
#+
"%$ 8$) ) %$$
))! **"$
!"!#$ ))! %
&!% &# )$$
)!% ! +()"$. )%! %
%$$ +$. - 13 -
)! % %%
))! **"$ ! -
)*. !"!#$ &' &
. *
8$) 0 *$% ,#.' %
%
"
(#%!)$ 8$) %$$ ) *#$%$. )
& .%' #!-
*!)
"&
%
%
&!% %# #' % *"!! #! 0$#% 193' ! 452:
7#$ &"'
% *
"!'
-
*%
. . %' %- !$
&!. %
+%%
)! ))# %)% %#) % )#!' ! )!#)' %)$) #. %")' )
;
*%
"& %$$ + )%!! +. (#%!)$ 8$)
$ $"$ &
*! <5 !.%' !# &) )%%. *#% . + +! #
"$+$ %#)% %
%
)$
) ! %$$ + %
(#%!)$ #*! 8$)
#+
"%$ 8$) )' & 42 !.% $ &
*% =
$ )$$)! #) ) ! $ &
%#$
)%! *% %$$ + ) #)! !"!#$ ))! & / 42 !.%
- 14 -
" ,. !"!#$
"! +. ()
% *%
)#
%
% . *
8$) 0 *$% ,#. !$. & <5 !.% &"'
*%$
%$$
"$
* %$$ + !%*%! +. )! %% &
# $
>5 !.%'
)%! $
)! % *#%
. + ?#%!' +. #. "
*)%%
&!.%. %
%%#)
**%$ ) % %*)! +"' #*
%%#)
!%
*
. 8$) 0 *$% ,#.' %$$ + ! $. %$! )" *)!# ! %$$ + !%)$%! ! "$+$
.' /)*
"!'
. 1
3 **$) %$$ + ! % ! "
"$
% #!$% %$$ )%#
( %)!#) ! !"% . *
%$$ + ! +. %)*$. ,#. ") %
)$
! )*. %$$ + -! ")
&!. %%. ' &# +- . !$. - 15 -
/
" #!$%
+" $! !& %$$ + **$)+$
)%
%. % % &$$' #% #!% ! %#+()
*"%%
@- 8$) 7#$' 46>2A
! 45 C;=><590 23 045 29-:@5 8>4 2;60 23 '.<<; .9= .14<86 .9= .=.F4 .0 '.<<; 89 2)!)=5.@0?804811;523=53.<.082965@A89>;729 045893.<2;1/.1523 !
"#$%
& .9= 45@= 04.0.H>22=657;0.0829I81.95@5<59023756129.@15/;680A .9=8176205/05=:A045291080;08295D;.@@A?804.68>4002 59C2A<59023@835@8:560A.9=7627560A2804.102:545@= 02:55115908.@/2<729590B81.B8168>4002@83523./808E59 ;9=56608/@523045291080;0829239=8.90569.0829.@ 2B59.90 29 8B8@ .9= 2@808/.@ 8>401 + 65/2>98E51 045 68>40 02 4.B5 27898291 .9= 045 68>40 23 3655=2< 23 5G76511829;9=56608/@5+23045291080;0829239=8.81 1;:C5/00268>4002657;0.08292320456157;0.082981H920
1 ++)
- 16 -
29@A . 1.@0 23 @835 :;0 045 7;6510 065.1;65 .9= 045 <210 765/82;1 7563;<5 23 @835I 45 226=89.05 $59/4 23 0481 2;60 89 045 /.15 23 #1;76.% 4.1 @.8= =2?9>;8=5@8951?48/4.6502:532@@2?5=?48@565>8105689> 0459.<523.756129890452?=A45505>81056?48/4 5B59 76826 02 045 1.8= C;=><590 ?.1 . <.9=.05 326 045 651729=5901024.B532@@2?5=1068/0@A89.//26=.9/502045 10.9=89> 26=56
2!+ 23 045 .69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ ?48/4 89 <A 2789829 /2918=5689> 045 3./01 .9= /86/;<10.9/5 23 045 7651590 /.15 4.1 920 :559 32@@2?5= .9= 5B59 .3056 045 ./D;800.@ 23 045 7508082956 89 045 0?2 /.151?48/4/;@<89.05=89./D;800.@.3056=50.8@5=068.@.9= 5B59 .3056 045 657651590.0829 >8B59 :A 045 7508082956 326 65<2B89>4819.<5362<0452?=A45505>8105604565 81 92 65172915 26 657@A 26 ./0829 :A 045 651729=5901 89 65<2B89> 481 9.<5 45 /29089;.0829 23 045 9.<5 23 . 756129 89 . 62?=A 14550 ?8042;0 04565 :589> .9A /2>590 65.129 =251 920 .;>;6 ?5@@ ?804 045 0.05 .1 . 7.6591 7.068.5?48/481.>;.6=8.923045/808E591230481/2;906A
- 17 -
&26 045 65.129 04.0 ?459 04565 81 92 /.15 759=89> 92 .@@5>.0829 <.=5 92 /2<7@.890 65>810565= .9= =517805 ./D;800.@26=567.115=.>.891004575080829560450.054.1 02762B8=5.9277260;980A02045/808E590265326<48<15@3 02@5.=.926<.@@835.9=<8G?80404512/850A02@5.=.@835 23 . 926<.@ /808E59 $6.9=89> 48< 02 :5 . 62?=A :A 275989>62?=A145508192004512@;0829.9=80.==102045 762:@5<23/65.082923<89=15023.62?=A./68<89.@.9= @5.=89> 02 C28989> 23 >.9>1 .9= /65.0829 23 >.9> ?.61 ?48/481=5068<590.@0204512/850A
9B85?23045929/2<7@8.9/523045762/5=;65 /2905<7@.05= ;9=56 10.9=89> 26=56
2!+ 23 045 .69.0.F. 2@8/5 .9;.@ .9= 929/2918=56.0829 23 045 657651590.0829 >8B59 :A 045 7508082956 7;61;.90 02 481 ./D;800.@890450?2/.15104812;608123045278982904.0 045 7508082956 4.1 <.=5 2;0 . B.@8= /.15 02 /2918=56 3.B2;6.:@A//26=89>@A7.1104532@@2?89>
- 18 -
8 45?6807508082981''( 88 45 8<7;>95= 26=56 =.05= )!! 65>8105689>0459.<5230457508082956890452?=A4550 5>81056 <.890.895= :A 045 651729=590
2 81 4565:A D;.145= 888 45 651729=5901 .65 4565:A =865/05= 02 65<2B50459.<5230457508082956362<0452?=A4550 5>81056 <.890.895=:A045< ?80489 . 75682=23 ?55F1 362<045=.052365/587023/5608385=/27A2304526=56 8B 8:560A 42?5B56 81 65156B5= 02 045 651729=5900.05 02 762/55= 89 .//26=.9/5 ?804 @.?
.>.8910045 7508082956 83.0 .@@ .9A /.15 81 <.=52;0 .9= ?48@5=289>12045A14.@@1068/0@A32@@2?045>;8=5@8951@.8= =2?9 :A 0481 2;60 89 045 /.15 23
6572605= 89
!)* ' !"( #
' 810
2@
2 !