Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 55004 (KAR)

SHARNAPPA REDDY v. THE ASST COMMISSIONER

WP/203852/2025 · 2026-01-29

Pradeep Singh Yerur

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$#% &'$! !# (') !" # $ % ! && ' & & !"( ( ) !" # $ & % ) (( ((* ) ) ) & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '& ("!!("( &(("(( ' ! && & &)& +, & & -& ./01.2 34516.7 840 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 /12 7./01.2 22<9<41/74=.01>.192=43/9.8409:.0.6;412.199/9. /0.;0.6.19 ( :<6 ;.9<9<41 <6 8<7.2 ?@ 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 6..A<1B 9:.84774C<1B0.7<.86 !"#$ $% & " $" '( $ " ) *'$+&, ! -,' *'$+& . - 3 - ( /0', ) 1 9 <6 9:. 3419.19<41 48 ;.9<9<41.0 9:/9 :. <6 / ;.0>/1.190.6<2.19<1/A:/1/;50/=<77/B..C/0B</75A /7/?50/B< <690<39:.;.9<9<41.0C/6./07<.00.6<2.1948 0/> /13:/@/9: . <6 / <=<7 1B<1..0 ?@ ;048.66<41 :. ;.9<9<41.0 >/2. 34>;7/<19 94 9:. ;47<3. 2.;/09>.19 /B/<1699:./:6<72/0/1249:.04=.01>.19488<3</76C<9: 0.B/02 94 9:.<0 <77.B/7 /39<=<9<.6 25. 94 C:<3: 9:. 0.6;412.196 2.7<?.0/9.7@ 0.B<69.0.2 30<><1/7 3/6. /B/<169 9:.;.9<9<41.0840140./6416C:/964.=.0:..D9.01>.19 402.0 ;/66.2 ./07<.0 /B/<169 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 3/>. 94 ?. E5/6:.2<10<><1/7.=<6<41;.9<9<414("""F("(F F :<6?.<1B9:.69/9.48/88/<060.6;412.194! .D9.01.2 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 ?@ 9:. <>;5B1.2 402.0 2/9.2 ("!!("( 804> .C/0B< 94 47/0 512.0 .39<416 /12 489:./01/9/A/47<3.39!G$8406:409+9:. 39,% - 4 - 9 <6 / 3419.19<41 48 7./01.2 34516.7 840 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 9:/9 9:. .D9.01>.19 402.0 <>;5B1.2 :.0.<1 <6 <77.B/7 /0?<90/0@ /12 34190/0@ 94 9:. 39 /12 9:. ;04=<6<416 9:.0.<1 9 <6 3419.12.2 9:/9 9:. 8512/>.19/7 0.E5<0.>.1948<665/13.48149<3.:/6149?..13/56.241 9:.;.9<9<41.0 /12 14.1E5<0@<6 3412539.2512.0 .39<41 40.=.19:.;043.250./63419.>;7/9.2512.0.39<416 40489:.39/0.84774C.264/764.39<41 48 9:.3919:.6.B045126:.3419.1269:/99:.<>;5B1.2 402.0 48 .D9.01>.19 ;/66.2 C<9:459 84774C<1B 9:. ;04=<6<416 48 9:. /01/9/A/ 47<3. 39 <6 =<47/9<=. 48 9:. 8512/>.19/7 0<B:96 .16:0<1.2 <1 9:. 4169<959<41 :.0.840.:.6..A694/774C9:<6;.9<9<41 2 7./01.2 22<9<41/7 4=.01>.19 2=43/9.6569/<169:.<>;5B1.2402.0?59:.<651/?7.94 ;4<19459C:.9:.0149<3.C/6<665.2949:.;.9<9<41.0/12 34>;7</13.489:.;04=<6<41648.39<416/12 48 9:.39 - 5 - * :/=.:./027./01.234516.78409:.;.9<9<41.0 /12 7./01.2 22<9<41/7 4=.01>.19 2=43/9. 840 9:. 0.6;412.199/9. 1 9:. ;0.6.19 3/6. <9 <6 6..1 9:/9 14 149<3. :/6?..1<665.2/63419.>;7/9.2512.0.39<41 C:<3: <69:.;043.250.94?.84774C.294.D9.01/;.0641512.0 .39<41640489:.39/89.0<665/13.48149<3./ 0./641/?7. 4;;40951<9@ 45B:9 94 :/=. ?..1 B<=.1 1 9:. ;0.6.19 3/6. /2><99.27@ 14 149<3. <6 B<=.1 94 9:. ;.9<9<41.0 G 12.0 9:. 3<035>69/13.6 9:. ;04=<6<416 48 .39<41 48 9:. 39 :/=<1B 149 ?..1 84774C.2 9:. <1<9</9<41 48 9:. .D9.01>.19 ;043.66 /12 9:. <>;5B1.2 402.0 ;/66.2 <6 <77.B/7 ;.0=.06. /12 34190/0@ 94 9:. 39 !" :.0.840.;/669:.84774C<1B < :.C0<9;.9<9<41<6 - 6 - << :. D9.01>.19 02.0 2/9.2 ("!!("( ;/66.2 <1 3/6. 4 &(("( ( =<2. 11.D50. ;/66.2 ?@ 0.6;412.19 4!<6:.0.?@E5/6:.2 !*+ ( !#) $ F!