- 1 - !"#" $%# # % &'(&)*+'( & * , ! " #$$ #% & ' & ( ! " % & & " '% & " % ' # & )* & && ( Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * )"% "%)"%& * & " % ) "%"+%) & " # & % * & & # $ $& "$ % &$ & ' , , -$ $ .+/012+2+34+/5+617892.1:;;</17012+2+341=<471= 1;2+34 35.:=:2+9: :>:=+? <=:?/.: :4.+2: /11?+4> >=:42 35 :42+;+0:23=9 8:+6 +4 =+@1 3)* =1>+/21=17 89 <=<@+2?:6 36+;1 2:2+34 53= 2.1 35514;1/ 0<4+/.:861 <471= 1;2+34/ A ( 35 2.1 //142+:6 3@@37+2+1/;2* 1;2+34/)"% "%)"%35 2.1.:=:2+9: 9:9: :4.+2: 1;2+34/ A * 35 2.1 :=4:2:?: //142+:6 3@@37+2+1/ "<86+; +/2=+8<2+34 9/21@% <86+; 342=36 =71= ) :47 1;2+34/ "%"+% ) A 35 2.1 :=4:2:?: //142+:6 - 3 - 3@@37+2+1/ " 23=:>1 ;;3<42/ :+42:+4+4> #:6<1 32+5+;:2+34%=71=* .1 5:;2<:6 @:2=+B 35 2.1 ;:/1 +/ 2.:2 2.1 012+2+341=:;;</17 3 :634> C+2. 32.1= :;;</17 :661>17 23.:D1811453<47+403 p. 1 +3435=+;1C.+;.:;;3=7+4> 232.1;3@06:+4:42:<2.3=+29+//</01;2172381=+;1@1:42 53= 7+/2=+8<2+34 <471= 2.1 <86+; +/2=+8<2+34 9/21@ " % 2 +/ /36169 34 2.1 8:/+/ 35 2.+/ /</0+;+34 2.1 0=1/142 ;=+@1 .:/ 8114 =1>+/21=17 :661>+4> 2.:2 2.1 012+2+341=:4732.1=:;;</17.:70<=;.:/17 =+;15=3@ 86:;?@:=?12 1:=417;3<4/1653=2.1012+2+341=/<8@+2/2.:2 2.1 0=3/1;<2+34 ;:/1 =1/2/ 142+=169 34 : D:><1 ://1=2+34 2.:22.1 /1+E17=+;1 +/ =+;1 =:C+4> :22142+3423 2.1 =103=2/<8@+2217892.1355+;+:6/352.1&3373=03=:2+3435 47+: .1 /<8@+2/ 2.:2 1D14 2.1 ;34;1=417 :<2.3=+29 .:/ 432715+4+2+D169;1=2+5+172.:22.1=+;1/1+E17+/ =+;12 +/5<=2.1=;342147172.:21D14:/01=2.1;3@06:+422.1 012+2+341=+/3469:661>1723.:D10<=;.:/17=+;15=3@2.1 - 4 - 3014 @:=?12 :47 2.1=1 +/ 43 @:21=+:6 C.:2/31D1= 23 71@34/2=:21 7+D1=/+34 @+/:00=30=+:2+34 3= +661>:6 0=3;<=1@142 35 =+;1 .1 :8/14;1 35 ;34;6</+D1 @:21=+:6;3<0617C+2.2.15:;22.:22.1012+2+341=+/:6:C :8+7+4> :47 =1/01;2:861 +47+D+7<:6 +/ <=>17 :/ : >=3<47 53=>=:4235:42+;+0:23=98:+60:=2+;<6:=69/+4;12.1=1+/:4 +@@+4142 2.=1:2 35 :==1/2 ;;3=7+4>69 .1 0=:9/ 23 :663C 2.1012+2+34 61:=417 77+2+34:6 2:21 <86+; =3/1;<23= 3003/1/ 2.1 012+2+34 :47 06:;17 =16+:4;1 34 ;1=2:+4 73;<@142/ 23 ;342147 2.:2 2.1 012+2+341= .:/ ;=+@+4:6 :421;17142/ :47 34 2.:2 8:/+/ .1 /<8@+2/ 2.:2 2.1 012+2+341= +/ 432 142+2617 23 2.1 7+/;=12+34:=9 =16+15 35 :42+;+0:23=98:+6 .:D1 >+D14 @9 :4B+3</ ;34/+71=:2+34 23 2.1 /<8@+//+34/ @:71 89 2.1 61:=417 ;3<4/16 53= 2.1 =1/01;2+D10:=2+1/:4773;<@142/:D:+6:86134=1;3=7 - 5 - ) 4: : p. 1 @142352.1;3@06:+42 /1+E<=1 :47 32.1= 73;<@142/ 06:;17 34 =1;3=7 +2 +/ 1D+7142 2.:2 2.1 4D1/2+>:2+4> 55+;1= +/ 912 23 /1;<=1 ;34;6</+D1@:21=+:623/<8/2:42+:212.1:661>:2+342.:22.1 /1+E17=+;1+/ =+;13=2.:22.1=1.:/8114:497+D1=/+34 35 1//142+:6 ;3@@37+2+1/ .3<>. 2.1 61:=417 77+2+34:6 2:21 <86+; =3/1;<23= ;342147/ 2.:2 2.1 012+2+341= .:/ :421;17142/ :2 2.+/ /2:>1 2.1 3<=2 +/ ;345+417 23 1B:@+412.1@:21=+:60=1/14269:D:+6:861+42.1=1;3=7 ( .1 ;342142+34 35 2.1 61:=417 ;3<4/16 53= 2.1 012+2+341= +/ 2.:2 @1=1 0<=;.:/1 35 =+;1 5=3@ 2.1 3014 @:=?12 731/ 432 :<23@:2+;:669 :22=:;2 2.1 0=3D+/+34/ 35 1;2+34/:47(352.1//142+:63@@37+2+1/;2* 1;2+34/ )"% "% )"% 35 2.1 .:=:2+9: 9:9: :4.+2: 1;2+34/ :47 * 35 2.1 :=4:2:?: //142+:6 3@@37+2+1/ "<86+; +/2=+8<2+34 9/21@%<86+;342=36=71=)3= 1;2+34/"%"+% ):47 352.1:=4:2:?://142+:63@@37+2+1/" 23=:>1 - 6 - ;;3<42/:+42:+4+4>#:6<1 32+5+;:2+34%=71=* +/: @:221=2.:2=1F<+=1/:712:+617+4D1/2+>:2+34 .1 :661>17 +4;+7142 01=2:+4/ 23 )* :47 2.1 4D1/2+>:2+4> 55+;1= +/ 912 23 +421==3>:21 2.1 012+2+341= 151==+4> 23 2.1 =103=2 /<8@+2217 89 2.1 355+;+:6/352.1&3373=03=:2+343547+:61:=417;3<4/16 53= 2.1 012+2+341= 03+42/ 3<2 2.:2 1D14 2.1 ;3@012142 :<2.3=+29.:/432>+D14:49715+4+2+D130+4+342.:22.1=+;1 /1+E17+/ =+;1.1=103=2342.1;342=:=94321/2.1 :8/14;1 35 7+/2+4><+/.+4> ;.:=:;21=+/2+;/ /<55+;+142 23 ;34;6</+D169 +7142+59 2.1 /1+E17 /23;? :/ =+;1 @1:42 53= 7+/2=+8<2+34<471=2.1<86+; +/2=+8<2+34 9/21@ * 2 2.+/ /2:>1 2.1=153=1 2.1 53<47:2+34:6 :661>:2+342.:22.1012+2+341=C:/+403 p. 1 +34357+D1=217 =+;1 =1@:+4/ <4/<8/2:42+:217 '.14 2.1 D1=9 4:2<=1 35 2.1 /1+E17 ;3@@37+29 +/ 912 23 81 ;34;6</+D169 7121=@+417 2.1 0=3/1;<2+34G/ ;:/1 +/ :2 81/2 <471= 0=16+@+4:=9 /;=<2+49 4 /<;. ;+=;<@/2:4;1/ ;</237+:6 +421==3>:2+34 35 2.1 012+2+341= +/ 432 /.3C4 23 81 - 7 - 41;1//:=9 :47 2.1 +4;34;6</+D1 4:2<=1 35 2.1 & =103=2 C1+>./ +4 5:D3<= 35 >=:42+4> :42+;+0:23=9 8:+6 7<=+4> 2.1 014714;9352.1+4D1/2+>:2+34 4D+1C352.1:8/14;1351D+714;1:22.+//2:>1 :47;34/+71=+4>2.1411753=;</237+:6+421==3>:2+3481+4> 41+2.1= 71@34/2=:217 43= /<8/2:42+:217 :47 /+4;1 2.1 012+2+341= :6/3 /2:47/ 34 2.1 /+@+6:= 5332+4> 23 2.:2 35 32.1= :;;</17C.3.:D1:6=1:79>=:42178:+6.1+/142+261753=>=:42 35 :42+;+0:23=9 8:+6 34 2.1 >=3<47 35 0:=+29 14;1 C+2.3<2 1B0=1//+4> :49 30+4+34 342.1 @1=+2/ 352.1;:/1/<55+;1 23.3672.:22.1012+2+341=+/142+261753=:42+;+0:23=98:+6 /<8H1;2 23 .+/ 5<66 ;3301=:2+34 C+2. 2.1 +4D1/2+>:2+34 14;12.153663C+4>, .1012+2+34+/ .1 =1/0347142I36+;1 :=1 7+=1;217 23 =161:/1 2.1 012+2+341=:;;</17 3+42.11D14235.+/:==1/2+4=+@1 3)* =1>+/21=17 89 <=<@+2?:6 36+;1 2:2+34 - 8 - +/2=+;2:7>+=+53=2.135514;1/0<4+/.:861<471= 1;2+34/ :47(352.1//142+:63@@37+2+1/;2* 1;2+34/ )"% "% )"% 35 2.1 .:=:2+9: 9:9: :4.+2: 1;2+34/ :47 * 35 2.1 :=4:2:?: //142+:6 3@@37+2+1/ "<86+; +/2=+8<2+34 9/21@%<86+; 342=36 =71= ) :47 1;2+34/ "%"+% ) :47 35 2.1 :=4:2:?: //142+:6 3@@37+2+1/ " 23=:>1 ;;3<42/ :+42:+4+4>#:6<1 32+5+;:2+34%=71=* /<8H1;2232.1 53663C+4>;347+2+34/, .1 12+2+341= /.:66 :001:= 8153=1 2.1 4D1/2+>:2+4> 55+;1= C+2.+4 7:9/ 5=3@ 2.1 7:21 35 =1;1+02 35 2.1 ;309 35 2.+/ 3=71= :47 /.:66 1B1;<21 : 01=/34:6 8347 53= : /<@ 35 / "<011/ 41 :?. 3469% C+2. 2C3 /<=12+1/ 53= 2.1 6+?1/<@ 23 2.1 /:2+/5:;2+34 35 2.1 +4D1/2+>:2+4>355+;1= - 9 - 12+2+341=/.:66=1><6:=69:001:=8153=12.1 =+:63<=2C+2.3<25:+6<461//1B1@021789 2.1=+:63<=253=D:6+7=1:/34/ 12+2+341= /.:66 432 2:@01= C+2. 2.1 0=3/1;<2+34 C+241// :47 .1 /.:66 ;3 301=:21 C+2. 2.1 036+;1 53= +4D1/2+>:2+34 :47 :001:= 8153=1 2.1@ C.141D1= ;:6617 <034 .1 012+2+341= /.:66 432 +4D36D1 +4 /+@+6:= 35514;1/+45<2<=1 -+ &# * # , , ,$