Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54992 (KAR)

SMT. JANAKI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WA/200295/2025 · 2026-01-28

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ #$ % "" &$' !"#$%& ' ( ) ) ) !"$%%%( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA S D Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"#$(%( ) !"#$(%( * + !"#$(%( " !"#$((& $ )) ) !"#$%, & , ) ( !"#$%& ' ) ( $- ) & ) * ) ) ($%,%" %%"%%%" ) ) - 3 - ) . /01 . $ . 234/556/734837619016:6;<3=0*=8<26 /:0/</>/ 3?2 =9:< ;< (,$( ;2/7760?30? <26 ;=::6;<0644 =8 /0 =:16:1/<61($%,%"30=%%"%%%" 26 8/;<4 <2/< ;/0 @6 ?/<26:61 8:=A <26 =%%"%%%" /:6 <2/< :645=0160< =& 26:630 ;2/7760?61/:643160<3/7;6:<383;/<6344961<=<26/55677/0< 26:630 =0 <26 ?:=901 <2/< 426 B/4 ?3C60 30 A/::3/?6 <= =06 (:/@2/>/: /77/DD/ /E6:3 =8 6C/:03A@/:?3 377/?6 =8 2/1;2/0 /79> 3E/D59:/ 34<:3;< /01 <2/< 426 2/1 4955:64461 26: A/::3/?6 /01 2/1/5573618=:3449/0;6=8/;6:<383;/<68:=A/1/>/;26:3 013 /79> < 34 ;7/3A61 <2/< <26 /24371/: 2/1 344961 / ;6:<383;/<6 1/<61 ((%%* /883:A30? <2/< (=::6;<61C316=:16:1/<61%%$ - 4 - 426 B/4 :643130? /< 30/?/03 377/?6 =8 013 /79> < 34 ;7/3A61<2/<=0;=A30?<=>0=B=849;259:5=:<617D8/>6 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 <26 294@/01 =8 :645=0160< =& 7=1?61 / ;=A57/30< =0 (%%(%* /461 =0 <26 ;=A57/30</060F93:DB/41=06/01<26;6:<383;/<6344961 <=<26/55677/0<B/4;/0;67761/456:<26:65=:<49@A3<<61 @D <26 2371 6C67=5A60< 883;6: <= <26 /24371/: =0 %(%%* 26 /24371/: <26:6/8<6: 5/4461 /0 =:16: ;/0;67730?<26:643160<3/7;6:<383;/<6344961308/C=9:=8<26 /55677/0< < 34 /74= ;7/3A61 <2/< <26 /55677/0< @630? / :643160< =8 6C/:/03A@/:?3 2/1 1673C6:61 / ;2371 /< <26 :3A/:D 6/7<2 60<6: /7/430?3 2/1;2/0 </79> < B/4 /776?61 <2/<<26 /55677/0< 4955:64430? <26 ;/0;677/<3=0=8 26::643160<3/7;6:<383;/<6344961@D<26/24371/:2/1/?/30 5:6C/376195=0<26659<D/24371/:;7/3A30?<2/<426B/4 / :643160< =8 30/?/03 377/?6 30 013 </79> /01 <2/< 426 B/4 :643130? 30 <26 4/31 C377/?6 8=: A=:6 <2/0 % D6/:4 26:6/8<6: <26 659<D /24371/: 344961 / :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6=0%%(%"/883:A30?<2/<<26/55677/0<B/4 - 5 - :643130?/<30/?/03377/?6=8 013/79>26:645=0160< =& <26:68=:6 @630? /??:36C61 @D <26 3449/0;6 =8 <26 :643160<3/7;6:<383;/<6308/C=9:=8<26/55677/0<;2/7760?61 3<@68=:6<234=9:<30=%%"%%%"=<3;6=8<26 B:3< 56<3<3=0 B/4 59:5=:<617D 46:C61 =0 <26 /55677/0< 26:630B2=1310=</556/: 26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 /8<6: 56:9430? <26 =:16: 5/4461 @D <26 /24371/: ;/0;67730? <26 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6344961308/C=9:=8<26/55677/0<2671<2/<G ! 630?/??:36C61@D <26 4/31 =:16: <26/55677/0<34@68=:6<26=9:< * 2676/:061;=904678=:<26/55677/0<;=0<60161 <2/<<26/11:644=8<26/55677/0<B/4B:=0?7DA60<3=061 - 6 - 30 =%%"%%%"/4 / :643160< =8 6C/:/03A@/:?3 2/1;2/0 </79> <2=9?2 <26 /55677/0< 34 :643130? /< 30/?/03 377/?6 /01 <26:68=:6 <26 0=<3;6 B/4 0=< 46:C61 =0 <26 /55677/0< 6 ;=0<6014 <2/< /8<6: <26 /24371/: 5/4461 /0 =:16: ;/0;67730? <26 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 <26 /55677/0< ;2/7760?61 <26 4/A6 @68=:6 <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06:/01<2/<<26=:16:;/0;67730?<26:643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 B/4 46< /4316 @D <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06: B2=:6A3<<61<26;/468=::6;=04316:/<3=0/8<6:;=019;<30? / 8:642 30C64<3?/<3=0 6 ;=0<6014 <2/< <26 659<D /2/4371/:/8<6:C343<30?<26:643160;6=8<26/55677/0</01 /8<6: @630? 4/<348361 <2/< <26 /55677/0< 34 :643130? /< 30/?/03 </79> 344961 / 8:642 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 6 ;=0<6014<2/<<26468/;<4B6:60=<@:=9?2<<=<260=<3;6=8 <26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 /01 <26:68=:6 <26 3A59?061 =:16:5/4461@D<2676/:06130?7691?61646:C64<=@6 46< /4316 6 /74= ;=0<6014 <2/< :645=0160< =& /8<6: ;=A30? <= >0=B =8 <26 =:16: 5/4461 @D <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06: 2/1 ;2/7760?61 3< 30 =%%$%$ - 7 - B26:6 <26 /11:644 =8 <26 /55677/0< B/4 /?/30 42=B0 /4 6C/:/03A@/:?3 2/1;2/0 </79> 6 ;=0<6014 <2/< <26 4/31B:3<56<3<3=0B/41345=461=88=0(*%(%$/01<26 /55677/0< A=C61 <26 4/31 B:3< 56<3<3=0 8=: </>30? 95 <26 56<3<3=0G H/01<2676/:06130?7691?6 /8<6: @630? 4/<348361 <2/< <26 /55677/0< 34 0=< :643130? /< <26 /11:644 A60<3=061 30 <26 ;/946 <3<76 :6;/7761 <26 =:16: 1/<61 (*%(%$ 6 <294 ;=0<6014 <2/< :645=0160<=&342==1B30>30?<26=9:<4/4B677/4<26 /55677/0<30=@</3030?C/:3=94=:16:48:=A<26=9:<8:=A <3A6<=<3A66<26:68=:65:/D4<2/<<263A59?061=:16: 5/4461@D<2676/:061 30?76 91?6@6 46<I/4316 /01 <26 A/<<6: @6 :64<=:61 @68=:6 <26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 8=: 8:642;=04316:/<3=0 " 26 76/:061 113<3=0/7 =C6:0A60< 1C=;/<6 :65:6460<30? <26 =883;3/7 :645=0160< 49@A3<<61 <2/< <26 =:16: 5/4461 @D <26 /24371/: ;/0;67730? <26 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6344961308/C=9:=8<26/55677/0<B/4F964<3=061 @68=:6 <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06: B2= 5/4461 /0 =:16: - 8 - 46<<30? /4316 <26 =:16: 5/4461 @D <26 /24371/: /01 <26:6/8<6:/8:642;6:<383;/<634344961<=<26/55677/0<26 ;=0<6014<2/<<26468/;<4B6:60=<@:=9?2<<=<260=<3;6=8 <2676/:06130?7691?6 $ 6/:061 ;=90467 8=: :645=0160< =& =0 <26 =<26: 2/01 49@A3<4 <2/< <26 /55677/0< 34 :643130? /< 6C/:/03A@/:?3 2/1;2/0 </79> /01 <2/< 426 2/1 1673@6:/<67D4955:64461<26A/<6:3/78/;<4/012/18/7467D =@</3061 / :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 466A30? /4 38 426 B/4 :643130?/<30/?/03377/?630 013/79>6;=0<6014<2/< /8<6:<26=:16:5/4461@D<264434</0<=AA3443=06:<26 /55677/0< 2/1 /?/30 83761 /0=<26: /5573;/<3=0 @68=:6 <26 659<D /24371/: B26:630 426 ;7/3A61 <2/< 426 34 / :643160< =8 30?/03 377/?6 =8 8J/759: /79> /7/@9:/?3 34<:3;< 6 <26:68=:6 ;=0<6014 <2/< <26 /55677/0< 34 0=< 49:6 /@=9< <26 57/;6 =8 26: :643160;6 /01 <2/< 426 2/4 @660;7/3A30?<2/<42634:643130?/<C/:3=94/11:644646 <26:68=:6;=0<6014<2/<0=30197?60;6;/0@642=B0<=<26 /55677/0< - 9 - & 6 2/C6 ;=04316:61 <26 49@A3443=04 A/16 @D <26 76/:061 ;=90467 8=: <26 /55677/0< /4 B677 /4 76/:061 113<3=0/7 =C6:0A60< 1C=;/<6 8=: <26 =883;3/7 :645=0160<4/01<2676/:061;=904678=::645=0160<=& # < /556/:4 8:=A <26 /113<3=0/7 1=;9A60<4 83761 @D<26/55677/0</7=0?B3<2<26B:3</556/7<2/<<26=:16: 5/4461 @D <26 /24371/: ;/0;67730? <26 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 B/4 ;2/7760?61 @D 26: @68=:6 <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06: /01 <2/< <26 4434</0< =AA3443=06: 30 <6:A4 =8 <26 =:16: 1/<61 %"(%* 2/1 46< /4316 <26 =:16: =8 <26 /24371/: /01 :6A3<<61 <26 ;/46 8=: :6;=04316:/<3=0 < /74= /556/:4 <2/< <26:6/8<6: <26 :6C6096=883;3/742/1C343<61<262=946=8<26/55677/0</01 1:/B0I95/A/2/J/:/01<26:6/8<6:<26659<D/24371/: 2/1 344961 / :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 16;7/:30? <2/< <26 /55677/0<34:643130?/<30/?/03377/?626468/;<4B6:6 0=< 57/;61 @68=:6 <26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 5:=;66161 =0 <26 8==<30? <2/< =0;6 <26 :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 B/4 ;/0;67761 @D <26 /24371/: / - 10 - 659<D /24371/: B2= B/4 7=B6: 30 :/0> ;=971 0=< 2/C6 344961 /0=<26: :643160<3/7 ;6:<383;/<6 26:68=:6 <26 ;/46 576/161@D:645=0160<=&B/40=<;=04316:61=0A6:3<4 /8<6: </>30? 30<= ;=04316:/<3=0 <26 ;=0<60<3=04 =8 <26 /55677/0<26:63026:68=:6B6;=04316:3</55:=5:3/<6<= 46<I/4316 <26 =:16: 5/4461 @D <26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 /01 :64<=:6 <26 B:3< 56<3<3=0 @68=:6 <26 76/:061 30?76 91?6 , 60;6<26B:3</556/734 /01 <26 =:16: 1/<61 ($%,%" 5/4461 30 =%%"%%%" 34 46<I/4316 =046F960<7D <26 =%%"%%%" 34 :64<=:61 < 34 =560 8=: <26 /55677/0< <= 8376 4</<6A60< =8 =@E6;<3=04 /01 ;=0<64< <26 B:3<56<3<3=0234342=B6C6:49@E6;<<=5/DA60<=8;=4<=8 4(%%%%I 5/D/@76 <= <26 3?2 =9:< 6?/7 6:C3;64 =AA3<<66B3<230/56:3=1=8=06B66> - 11 - (% 0 C36B =8 1345=4/7 =8 <234 /556/7 560130? 30<6:7=;9<=:D /5573;/<3=04 38 /0D 1= 0=< 49:C3C6 8=: ;=04316:/<3=0;;=:130?7D<26D/:6134A34461 )* & ' )* & %' 34<=(7=(,