- 1 - ! ""# $%&! !" '%( !"#$% & ' ( ) * ) ) ) !"$$$ # ) * +!"$# , ) * !"#$% Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) * !"#$% ! ) * ) **' ( !"#$% & ' )( ) * ##" ## * ) * ( - )) *) ) ),$!#$$! ) ) ) ! .+ ( ) * ) #,$%#$## ) .+* ) * ) ) ) ) / ) 01234515167128194:;<504345151674=244>17?@A=15 68B@7:@BC2;<A@<68@:1=4D516756EC@200127@B417 504 6A:< 0445 4?1254= B@175@174: ;< 504 =42367:475 6! # 5 12 504 D@24 68 504 345151674= 50@5 04 12 @ =421:475 68 7:1 56A7 @7: 04 12 @ ;C217422B@7 @926 - 3 - 17F69F4:17369151D@9@D51F15142@7:D6BBC715<24=F1D4204 345151674= @926 @D51F49< 3@=51D13@542 17 504 96D@9 ;6:< 494D51672 @7: 3@=91@B475@=< 494D51672 )4 @926 4236C242 504 4D676B1D@99< A4@>4= 24D51672 68 504 26D145< 5 12 D67547:4: 50@5 :C4 56 012 3@=51D13@5167 17 369151D2 @7: 4236C217? 3C;91D D@C24 504=4 12 369151D@9 =1F@9=< 04 =1F@9 369151D1@720@F45@=?454:01B:C456A01D0345151674=0@2 ;447 1B391D@54: 17 D=1B17@9 D@242 )6A4F4= 15 12 D67547:4:50@56C568504D=1B17@9D@242345151674=0@2 ;447@DEC1554:1767468504D@242@7:504=4B@1717?$ D@2420@F4;447A150:=@A7;<504 5@546F4=7B475 , 012;417?50425@5468@88@1=2345151674=G27@B4 0@2 ;447 =4?1254=4: 17 504 6A:< 0445 4?1254= B@175@174: ;< 504 =42367:475 6! 5 12 8C=504= D67547:4: 50@5 504 345151674= 0@2 ;447 D67517C6C29< 3C5 67 2C=F4199@7D4 ;< 504 3691D4 @C506=15142 )12 8@B19< B4B;4=2@=4@926D67517C6C29<B67156=4:@7:06C7:4:;< 504 3691D4 @C506=15142 :C=17? 84251F@92 @7: 494D51672 7 F14A 68 @99 5012 345151674= B@:4 @ =43=42475@5167 56 504 - 4 - 3691D4@C506=1514267#,$%#$##56=4B6F40127@B48=6B 504 6A:< 0445 4?1254= 423154 504 345151674= 2C;B15517? 2CD0 @ =43=42475@5167 76 @D5167 0@2 ;447 5@>47;<504=42367:4752@7:5043691D4@C506=151420@F4 D67517C4: 504 7@B4 68 345151674= 17 504 6A:< 0445 4?1254=A1506C586996A17?3=634=?C1:4917429@1::6A7;< 50126C=5 5 12 8C=504= D67547:4: 50@5 67 #"##$# A047504345151674=@33914:86=0123@2236=556?656069< 319?=1B@?4C55043@2236=5@C506=15142>4355042@B467 069: D1517? 50@5 504 345151674=/2 7@B4 12 86C7: 17 504 6A:< 0445 4?1254= B@175@174: @?@1725 01B 5 12 D67547:4: ;< 94@=74: D6C7249 86= 504 345151674= 50@5 :423154@995012D6721:4=17?504D6BBC715<24=F1D4:;<504 345151674= 504 6F4=7B475 68 @=7@5@>@ 0@2 @3361754: 01B@2504B4B;4=68125=1D5@E8:F126=<6BB15544 1H@<@3C=@ 5 12 @926 D67547:4: 50@5 345151674= 12 @ 9@A+ @;1:17? D151I47 @7: C774D422@=19< 012 7@B4 0@2 ;447 17D9C:4: @5 504 1725@7D4 68 =1F@9 369151D@9 3@=5142 17 504 - 5 - 6A:< 0445 4?1254= A01D0 12 1994?@9 @7: D675=@=< 56 5@7:17? =:4= 6$!% 68 504 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9 %% @7: 6504= 3=6F121672 D675@174: 504=417 5 12 @926 D67547:4: ;< 94@=74: D6C7249 50@5 504 =42367:4752 0@F4 76586996A4:5043=17D1394217504 5@7:17?=:4= 6$!% 68 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9 @7: B4D0@71D@99< 504< 0@F4 3@224:@76=:4==4?1254=17?5047@B468504345151674=17 504=6A:<20445A01D012F169@51F468=51D942%@7:#68 504672515C5167687:1@04=486=404244>256@996A504 34515167 @7: D6724EC4759< =4B6F4 012 7@B4 8=6B 504 6A:< 04454?1254=04D6C7249@926D67547:250@5504 =42367:475 3691D4 0@F4 765 86996A4: 504 ?C1:491742 9@1: :6A7 ;< 5012 6C=5 17 504 D@24 68 =436=54: 17 ! 94@=74: ::15167@9 6F4=7B475 :F6D@54 =43=4247517? 504 5@54 2C25@172 504 1B3C?74: 6=:4= @7: D67547:2 50@5 217D4 24F4=@9 D@242 A4=4 =4?1254=4:@?@1725504345151674=@7:04A@2:45=1B475@956 - 6 - 5041754=4256850434@D4@7:5=@7EC1915<6850426D145<012 7@B4A@2=4?1254=4:175046A:< 04454?1254=@7:17 @DD6=:@7D4565043691D4B@7C@9504345151674=A@2;417? B67156=4: 9@A8C99< 04=4 12 76 1994?@915< D6BB1554: @7: 504=41276F169@516768@7<=C949@A@D56=3=6D4:C=426 @926 504 ;=4@D0 68 @7< D672515C5167@9 3=6F121672 )4 @926 D67547:250@5504HC:?B475=4914:;<504345151674=17504 D@2468 '2C3=@(12BCD09@54=50@7504 =4?125=@5167 68 504 7@B4 68 345151674= 17 504 =6A:< 20445 @7:15A6C9:765D6B456012;47481504=486=404244>2 :12B122@968501234515167 " 0@F404@=:94@=74:D6C724986=504345151674= @7: 94@=74: ::15167@9 6F4=7B475 :F6D@54 86= 504 5@54 5 12 @ 8C7:@B475@9 =C94 68 9@A 50@5 A047 @ 34=267 12 1B391D@54: @2 @ =6A:< 204454= ;< 17D9C:17? 012 7@B417504912568=6A:<2044550467C212C367504 5@54 56 86996A 504 :C4 3=6D4:C=4 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 504 =494F@75 =C942 @7: =4?C9@51672 7 504 3=42475 D@24 504 - 7 - @=7@5@>@691D4@7C@9B6=4234D181D@99<5044?1254=68 6A:142 B@175@174: 17 6=:4= 6$!% A01D0 :4@92 A150 01256=< 204452 @7: =6A:< 204452 @7: 47=699B475 6= =4?125=@5167 68 34=2672 17 504 2@1: 20445 86= =4?1254= 86= D67517C6C2 B67156=17? ;< 504 3691D4 @C506=15142 12 765 86996A4: 5@7:17? =:4= 6$!% :4@92 A150 =4?125=@5167 68=6A:14204:4817151673=6F1:4:1250@5@=6A:<B@<;4 :48174: @2 @ ?C7:@ @7: 17D9C:42 @ 06691?@7 56C?0 F@?@;67:6=@7<34=267A0612:@7?4=6C2563C;91D34@D4 @7:5=@7EC1915<04=4@=4B@7<86=B268=6A:12B A01D0 @=4 :42D=1;4: 504=417 @7: 504 3=6D422 @7: 3=6D4:C=4 D6754B39@54: 56;4 B@175@174: 17:1884=4753@=52 7@B49< @=5@=5@7:@=5A01D0?6F4=7504B@17547@7D4 68 @ =4?1254= @7: 504 7@B42 68 504 =6A:142 17 5041= =4234D51F4 3@=52 5 12 504 :C5< @7: 6;91?@5167 D@25 C367 504 =42367:4752 A01D0 12 765 635167@9 56 86996A 504 :C4 3=6D4:C=4D6754B39@54:C7:4=50425@7:17?6=:4=268504 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9 A0194 4754=17? 504 7@B4 68 @ 34=267 17 504 =6A:< 20445 @7: 504=4 @=4 D4=5@17 - 8 - 3=6D4:C=4256;4B@7:@56=19<86996A4:;486=44754=17?504 7@B422D67547:4:;<94@=74:D6C724986=504345151674= 504 3=6D422 @7: 3=6D4:C=4 @2 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 504 25@7:17? =:4= 6$!% 68 504 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9 0@2 765 ;447 86996A4: @7: B4=49< ;4D@C24 04 A@2 17F69F4:17D=1B17@9D@242040@2;4478=@B4:6C568 A01D0 17 674 68 504 D@242 345151674= 12 @DEC1554: @7: 6504=2 @=4 A150:=@A7 ;< 504 5@54 5 12 @926 D67547:4: 50@5 506C?0 504 345151674= 0@2 B@:4 @ =43=42475@5167 56 504 =42367:475 @C506=15142 @854= 504 @DEC155@9 67 #,$%#$## 504 =43=42475@5167 0@2 765 ;447 D6721:4=4: @7: 4F47 @854= 504 @DEC155@9 04 0@2 ;447 2CBB674: 56 504 HC=12:1D5167@9 3691D4 25@5167 86= C774D422@=< 1754==6?@5167A047504=41276D@24347:17?@?@172501B 5A6C9:;4=494F@75564J5=@D53@=@?=@30 6 68504HC:?B475681F1216747D06850126C=517504D@24 68 !" " =436=54: 17 #$ %&& ' ( A04=417 504 1F12167 - 9 - 47D0 :4@95 A150 21B19@= 2C;H4D5 B@554= A01D0 =4@:2 @2 C7:4= ! "# # $ % &'( ) # $ $ % &'( # ) *) # + ) ) ) ) # )) ) ) ) ) , )# ) - % 5@7:17? 6=:4= 6$!% 68 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9%%124J5=@D54:;496A &'( ./0 # ) ) 1 .2/ 3+ / ! 45, - 10 - / 6 )) # # 3 /), / !)1 + + ))))) , /*, /, / .7/ 6 # 8 8 % &&) #9 0 : 4 ) ; 0# .</. /% ) 848 0 ) ) ./ % ) 84 8 ) = 8"48 : ) #) ./ % ) >%#> 4 + .'/ $ ) +*# $ # .?/% ) ) - 11 - 0 : !6) ./ @ ) # ) 848 # ) 1 $ .A/ 4 # ) ) ) ) ) ) 0 " * ) ) ) .(/$ " * ) # # # 8 8 : ) ) " * 4 6) *$ # # .&/)#) # #)) ./ @ # + $ ! 8:8 )) $ - 12 - ! 808 .2/@ 8481 + 8488:8 @ 848 ) ! $ 46) .7/ % ! 808 8:8 ) 6 6) ) +*# $ .</6) + ) ) 6) 1 ! ) .'/ B C 3 ./ ) ! # ./ ))) 2(< 4 . 9 /, ./ # ! - 13 - (2./.)/.1/ ./D ! 0(?7 )# #C3 .#/0&A./ 4 , .#/0&4 4 .#/0&4 4 .#/ 0 )## , #/EC)'' '?D ! 0(?7, .C/ 0 '&( 6 4 #+ 3 .?/E# ) E " : ) + # )) # ++ )) !) + ./ @ # $ ) ) " # # .A/)&? ) 3+ / % 2/% ) - 14 - 7/5) ) </ % ) '/ ?/$F /% A/ ! .(/ 6 ) ) # ) 1 ) # ! ) - $ 7F14A68504767+D6B391@7D4685043=6D4:C=4 D6754B39@54: C7:4= 5@7:17? =:4= 6$!% 68 504 @=7@5@>@ 691D4 @7C@9 @7: 767+D6721:4=@5167 68 504 =43=42475@5167 ?1F47 ;< 504 345151674= 3C=2C@75 56 012 @DEC155@9 5012 6C=5 12 68 504 6317167 50@5 504 345151674= 0@2 B@:4 6C5 @ F@91: D@24 56 D6721:4= 8@F6C=@;9< DD6=:17?9<3@2250486996A17? 1 04A=153451516712)) - 15 - 11 04 1B3C?74: 6=:4= 68 634717? 6A:< 04454?1254=175047@B468504345151674= :@54: ,$!#$$! B@175@174: ;< 504 =42367:475 6!1204=4;<EC@204: 111 04 =42367:4752 @=4 04=4;< :1=4D54: 56 =4B6F45047@B468504345151674=8=6B504 6A:< 04454?1254=B@175@174:;<504B A15017@34=16:68A44>28=6B504:@5468 =4D413568D4=51814:D63<685046=:4= 1F 1;4=5< 06A4F4= 12 =424=F4: 56 504 =42367:475 5@54563=6D44: 17 @DD6=:@7D4 A1509@A@?@1725504345151674=18@5@99@7< D@2412B@:46C5@7:A0194:617?26504< 20@9925=1D59<86996A504?C1:4917429@1::6A7 ;< 5012 6C=5 17 504 D@24 68 =436=54:17 !)* ' !"( & 125 6 9 6)