Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54975 (KAR)

KRISHNA v. THE UNION OF INDIA

WP/203844/2025 · 2026-01-12

Pradeep Singh Yerur

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#! !" ' () ! " # " # # $% %&' % % % ' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ! ( # & " ) )" &'" % & &" * " ++ # & - 3 - $ && & ( # %* "", ""- "", . ""$ .& + # /012 3/014/2 56748/3 961 :;/ </:=:=64/1 1=/>10? 0@04A/1= 042 1=;04:=B;78;04 3/014/2 /<7:C 63=5=:61 /4/103 69 42=0 0364D E=:; 1=72;=1 =4D; =?0<713/014/2/<7:C63=5=:61/4/1036942=0961:;/ 1/8<642/4: 68%042 - 4 - " ;=8</:=:=64=89=3/2BC:;/</:=:=64/188:72/4:8 8//A=4D 0 E1=: 69 @0420@78 BC E0C 69 0 2=1/5:=64 :6 B/ =887/2 :6 :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 :6 </1@=: :;/ </:=:=64/18 :6 56@<3/:/ :;/ 0<<3=50:=648 042 @0A/ :;/ <0C@/4: 69 9// 042 :6 <01:=5=<0:/ =4 :;/ /F0@=40:=64 85;/273/2 :6 B/ 564275:/264G"", % ;/ B1=/9 905:8 01/ :;0: :;/ </:=:=64/18 01/ @=4615;=321/48:72C=4D=49=9:;8:04201208<=1=4D:60<</01 961:;/0=4=A5;6634:1045/F0@=40:=64 564275:/2 BC :;/ 0:=6403 /8:=4D D/45C 4 ""$ 1/8<642/4: 6%D6:=887/20<7B3=546:=5/=4>=:=4D643=4/0<<3=50:=648 961 3342=00=4=A5;66384:1045/F0@=40:=64 "",;/308:20:/96187B@=88=6469:;/0<<3=50:=64E08 9=F/264%""$ 7:30:/19615/1:0=41/08648=4:;/ =4:/1/8: 69 :;/ <7B3=5 =: E08 /F:/42/2 :6 '""$ :;167D; 0 7B3=5 6:=9=50:=64 20:/2 %""$ ;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 0<<3=/2 042 1/D=8:/1/2 :;/=1 0<<3=50:=648 :;167D; 643=4/ <61:03 64 "G""$ : =8 87B@=::/2 :;0: 27/ :6 305A 69 A46E3/2D/ 69 <7B3=5 - 5 - 6:=9=50:=64 :/5;4=503=:=/8 =4>63>/2 042 :;/ =4:1=505=/8 :;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 E/1/ 740B3/ :6 56@<3/:/ 042 87B@=: :;/=1 0<<3=50:=648 E=:;=4 :;/ 8:=<730:/2 :=@/ 33 :;/ 9671 8:72/4:8 01/ <7187=4D 5605;=4D :6D/: 02@=88=64=4:6 :;/ <1/@=/1=48:=:7:=64=/:;/0=4=A5;6638 8:;/<01/4:8 69:;/8:72/4:801/=33=:/10:/04246:90@=3=01E=:;:;/3/D03 =4:1=505=/8=4>63>/2=4:;/0<<3=50:=64<165/880429=3=4D69 :;/ 0<<3=50:=648 :;167D; 643=4/ @62/ :;/C 2=2 46: />/4 ;0>/ 055/88 :6 643=4/ 905=3=:=/8 961 9=33=4D 7< 69 :;/ 0<<3=50:=64961@8;/45/:;/C;020<<1605;/2:;/=1/5:61 69 :;/ 605;=4D /4:/1 042 8/4: 04 /@0=3 :6 1/8<642/4: 6%20:/2""$1/H7/8:=4D</1@=88=64:656@<3/:/ :;/87B@=88=6469643=4/0<<3=50:=6486E/>/1:;/1/E08 46 1/<3C 8/4: :6 :;/ /@0=3 8/4: BC :;/ 605;=4D 3088 =1/5:61/45/:;/</:=:=64/1801/8//A=4D=4273D/45/69 :;=8 671: :6 </1@=: :;/@ :6 @0A/ 4/5/8801C 0@/428 :6 56@<3/:/:;/643=4/0<<3=50:=648042</1@=::;/@:6E1=:/ :;/ /4:1045/ /F0@=40:=64 961 :;/ 0=4=A 5;6638 : =8 971:;/1 564:/42/2 BC 3/014/2 56748/3 961 :;/ </:=:=64/18 - 6 - :;0:464&</1@=88=6461464&1/<3C:6:;//@0=38/4:BC:;/ 605;=4D 3088 =1/5:61 64 B/;039 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 =8 >=630:=>/ 69 :;/ <1=45=<3/8 69 40:7103 ?78:=5/ =33/D03 042 01B=:101C042;0>=4D46:56@@74=50:/2BCE0C691/<3C:6 :;/ </:=:=64/18 BC :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 =8 0D0=4 =33/D03 042 01B=:101C 042 :;/ 80@/ =8 46: /F</5:/2 916@ :;/ /4:103 F0@=40:=64 64275:=4D 7:;61=:C ;/1/961/ =4 >=/E 69 >=630:=6469 1:=53/8"042" 69:;/648:=:7:=6469 42=0 E;=3/ 2/4C=4D :;/ 6<<61:74=:C :6 <01:=5=<0:/ =4 /2750:=6403/4:1045//F0@=40:=64099/5:8:;/1=D;:869:;/ 8:72/4:8 :6<16</1 /2750:=64 0420 90=1 6<<61:74=:C:=8 0386 564:/4:/2 BC 3/014/2 56748/3 :;0: 1:=53/ %-# =8 0386 >=630:/2 6 0386 1:=53/ $ 69 :;/ 648:=:7:=64 69 42=0 /45/ </:=:=64/18 ;0>/ 0<<1605;/2 :;=8 671: 961 =4273D/45/=4:;=8@0::/1 3/014/2 /<7:C 63=5=:61 /4/10369 42=0 1=;04:=B;78;04 0<</01=4D 0364D E=:; 1=72;=1 =4D;=?0<713/014/2/<7:C63=5=:61/4/1036942=0 961 :;/ 4=64 69 42=0 87B@=:8 :;0: :;/ /4:1045/ - 7 - /F0@=40:=64 961 0=4=A 5;6638 051688 :;/ 5674:1C =8 564275:/2BCE0C6906@@644:1045//8:;/643=4/ <7B3=50:=64 69 46:=5/ E08 :0A/4 67: 64 ""$ 042 87B8/H7/4:3C 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 ;0>/ /F:/42/2 :;/ 308:20:/916@%""$:6'""$;/</:=:=64/18 =4:;=8508/;0>/87B@=::/2:;/=1643=4/0<<3=50:=648=4:;/ 643=4/ <61:03 64 "G""$ ;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 ;0>/<16>=2/2=4961@0:=64B733/:=40364DE=:;3=8:6920:/8 50:/D61=/8042:;/:/1@80425642=:=64896102;/1/45/:6 055/<:045/ 69 :;/ 643=4/ 0<<3=50:=648 961 :;/ /4:1045/ /F0@=40:=64 $ /014/2/<7:C63=5=:61/4/1036942=0<6=4:8 67: :6 :;=8 671: BC 9=3=4D 0 @/@6 0364D E=:; :;/ =4961@0:=64B733/:=4042B1=4D8:6:;/46:=5/69:;=8671: 3078/%69:;/4961@0:=64 733/:=4E;=5;1/02808742/1 ! - 8 - , 3078/&$ , G 042 " 0386 01/ 1/3/>04: 042 =@<61:04:E;=5;1/0208742/1 " # $ % & ' () ** # $ + , # * - ' $ * $ * . $ ' + $$ / ' - * - 9 - 0 12 ' %33* 242, - $ $ $- - - $ # $ '- + 56 $ # $ ' $ ) ! - /014/2 /<7:C 63=5=:61 /4/103 69 42=0 564:/428 :;0: E;/4 :;/ 6:=9=50:=64 E08 <7B3=8;/2 042 53/013C :;/ =4961@0:=64 B733/:=4 2/851=B/2 :;/ 4/5/8801C 961@03=:=/8 :6 B/ 02;/1/2 :6 042 /F/15=8/2 E=:; 7:@68: 501/ 042 507:=64 ;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 67D;: :6 ;0>/ 8;6E4 27/ 2=3=D/45/ 042 501/ E;=3/ 9=33=4D 7< :;/ 0<<3=50:=64961@4905::;/1/E08:=@/3=4/<1/851=B/2961 5611/5:=648=904C916@"""$:6""$271=4D :;=8 </1=62 46 56@@74=50:=64 ;08 B//4 8/4: :6 :;/ 5645/14/2 07:;61=:=/8 916@ :;/ 1/D=8:/1/2 /@0=3 61 :;/ <;64/47@B/1E=:;1/D012:68//A=4D04C5611/5:=648:=8 - 10 - 0386 564:/4:/2:;0::;//F0@=40:=64=846E85;/273/264 G"", 64 8517:=4=8=4D :;/ /4:=1/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@8 :;167D; 643=4/ <61:03 :;/ 02@=: 50128 ;0>/ 031/02C B//4 =887/2 :6 :;/ 8:72/4:8 051688 :;/ 5674:1C ;/ H7/8:=64 <0</18 ;0>/ 031/02C B//4 8/4: :6 >01=678 2=99/1/4: 3650:=648 051688 :;/ :0:/8 =4 :;/5674:1C ;/ !562/8 ;0>/031/02CB//4D/4/10:/2;/1/961/0::;=890D/42=: @0C 46: B/ <688=B3/ 961 :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 :6 1/6</4 :;/ E/B <61:03 961 :;/ 80A/ 69 :;/ 9671 </:=:=64/18 E;6 ;0>/ 46:96336E/2:;/=4961@0:=64B733/:=4042:;/D7=2/3=4/8=4 <16</1501/507:=640422=3=D/45/ G /014/2 /<7:C 63=5=:61 /4/103 69 42=0 87B@=:8 E=:; 0 ;/0>C ;/01: :;0: :;/ 8:72/4:8 :;67D; =4:/42=4D 50446: B/ ;/3</2 BC :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 08 =: E=33 6</4 7< :;/ 93662D0:/8 961 6:;/1 8:72/4:8 051688 :;/ 5674:1C042=:E=332/30C:;/02@=88=64<165/88042>01=678 6:;/1 =4:1=505=/8 =4>63>/2 =4 :;/ /F0@=40:=64 <165/88 /45/ ;/ 8//A8 2=8@=8803 69 :;=8 </:=:=64 08 :;/ 0<<3=50:=64961@89=33/2:;167D;643=4/<61:03=8=456@<3/:/ - 11 - 042;0846:B//41/5:=9=/2E/33E=:;=4:=@/08<1/851=B/2=4 :;/=4961@0:=64B733/:=4BC:;/1/8<642/4:8 ' ;0>/;/0123/014/256748/3961:;/</:=:=64/18 0423/014/256748/3961:;/1/8<642/4:8 : =8 04 74961:740:/ 508/ 69 :;/8/ 9671 C674D 8:72/4:8E;6=4:/42/2:6E1=:/:;//4:1045//F0@=40:=64 961 :;/ <1/@=/1 =48:=:7:=648 40@/3C :;/ 0=4=A 5;6638 051688 :;/ 5674:1C E;/1/ :;/ </:=:=64/18 E04:/2 :6 ?6=4 :;/ 0=4=A 5;663 =4 :;/ :0:/ 69 0140:0A0 7: 74961:740:/3C 27/ :6 =456@<3/:/ 87B@=88=64 69 :;/ 643=4/ /F0@=40:=640<<3=50:=648:;/C5673246:8/571/:;/02@=: 50128 =4 >=/E 69 =456@<3/:/ 87B@=88=64 69 0<<3=50:=64 961@8 :=846:=42=8<7:/:;0::;/</:=:=64/188:72/4:8 01/56@=4D916@46:0E/33&3=:/10:/90@=3CB05AD16742B7: ;02 :;/ =4:/4: :6 ?6=4 :;/ 0=4=A 5;663 BC E1=:=4D :;/ /F0@=40:=64/45/27/:6305A693=:/105C69:;/=1<01/4:8 042:;/2=D=:03A46E3/2D/:/5;4636D=503=4961@0:=64E/1/ 740B3/:69=337<:;/0<<3=50:=64961@8;/45/;02867D;: - 12 - :;/ 088=8:045/ 69 :;/ 605;=4D 3088 =1/5:61 :6 088=8: :;/@ =4 9=33=4D 7< :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@8 6E/>/1 :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@8 01/ 1/42/1/2 =456@<3/:/ E=:;67: B/=4D <16>=2/2 :;/ 02@=: 50128 :6 :;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 /08648 01/ 46: 088=D4/2 BC :;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 :;67D; 04 /@0=3 ;08 B//4 E1=::/4 BC :;/ =1/5:61 69 :;/ 5605;=4D5308840@/3C 04D0361/605;=4D/4:/1 =201 64 ""$ 0: '"G : =8 8//4 :;0: :;/ <7B3=5 46:=5/<1/851=B/8:;/1/3/>04:20:/8042:=@/9619=3=4D69 :;/0<<3=50:=64961@042:;/@/:;62636DC96126=4D=:;/ =4961@0:=64 B733/:=4 <16>=2/2 BC :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 643=4/ ;08 <16>=2/2 033 :;/ 2/:0=38 08 :6 ;6E :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 1/H7=1/8:6B/9=33/27<042E;0:01/:;/5648/H7/45/869 464&9=33=4D 69 :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@ =4 0 <16</1 @044/1 E6732 1/42/1 =: =456@<3/:/ 042 =4/3=D=B3/ @0A=4D :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 :6 B/ 1/?/5:/2 042 464&56@<3=045/ 69 :;/ 1/H7=1/2 1/D730:=648 042 :;/ =48:175:=648 9714=8;/2 =4 :;/ =4961@0:=64 B733/:=4 E6732 1/42/1 :;/ 5042=20:/8 :6 B/ 2=8H703=9=/2 - 13 - " ;/ /4:=1/ @/:;62636DC 69 643=4/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@ ;08 B//4 53/013C 2/9=4/2 =4 3078/ 6- 69 :;/ 4961@0:=64 733/:=4 6 0386 3078/ 68% 042 $ 2/851=B/08:6;6E:;/0<<3=50:=64;08:6B/9=33/27<042 E;0:1/42/18=:=456@<3/:/0421/?/5:=6469:;/0<<3=50:=64 961@ 3078/ 6G 2/038 E=:; 9=403 87B@=88=64 69 643=4/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@ E;=5; <1/851=B/8 :;0: =9 8:/< 6% =/ 3078/ 6% =9 46: 96336E/2 61 56@<3/:/2 :;/ 961@8 E=33 8:042 1/?/5:/2 042 46 5611/8<642/45/ =4 :;=8 1/D012 E=33 B//4:/1:0=4/24:;/2=8530=@/15637@4:;/1/8<642/4:8 ;0>/53/013C8:0:/2:;0::;/08<=104:840@/3C:;/8:72/4:8 08<=1=4D :6 :0A/ 7< :;/ 643=4/ /F0@=40:=64 961 :;/0=4=A 5;663801/02>=8/2:6/F/15=8/7:@68:507:=64E;=3/9=33=4D 7< :;/ 5611/5: 2/:0=38 =4 :;/ 1/D=8:10:=64 8C8:/@ ;/1/961/:;/1/E080;/0>CB712/4508:64:;/8:72/4:8 E;=3/ 9=33=4D 7< :;/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@ :6 9=33 7< =4 0 <16</1 @044/1 507:=6783C 042 501/9733C E=:; 36: 69 2=3=D/45/ 961 :;/0<<3=50:=64961@:6B/56@<3/:/=403308</5:8 - 14 - % ;=8 671: 742/18:0428 :;/ 8=:70:=64 042 5642=:=64 69 :;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 56@=4D 916@ 04 =33=:/10:/ 90@=3C B05AD16742 E=:; 46: ;0>=4D 3=:/105C 64 56@<7:/1 A46E3/2D/ 61 :/5;4636D=503 02>045/@/4: 042 2=D=:03A46E3/2D/9619=33=4D7<69:;/0<<3=50:=64961@ 7: 033:;/8/2/:0=38E/1/<1/851=B/2=4:;/ 6:=9=50:=64042:;/ =4961@0:=64B733/:=4=:8/39/45/:;/6478E08;/0>C64 :;/8:72/4:8:6;0>/:0A/4501/042507:=64=946:E=:;=4 :;/=1 A46E3/2D/ 042 /F</1:=8/ 916@ 87=:0B3/ <16</1 </1864 61 5605;=4D 5/4:/1 ;0>=4D :;/ A46E3/2D/ :6 46: 56@@=:04C@=8:0A/83=D;:/8:=4:;/40:71/:61/42/1:;/=1 0<<3=50:=648 =456@<3/:/ :;/1/BC 9178:10:=4D 042 208;=4D :;/=1 ;6</8 69 />/4 E1=:=4D :;/ /4:1045/ /F0@=40:=64 ;67D;:;=8671:;0804/461@6780@674:698C@<0:;C 961:;/8:72/4:8E;601/=4:/1/8:/2=4?6=4=4D:;/<1/@=/1 =48:=:7:=64840@/3C0=4=A5;6638051688:;/5674:1C:;/ 3/D03=:=/8 E6732 <1/>0=3 =4 875; 8=:70:=648 E;/1/ 643=4/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@8 01/ 1/?/5:/2 27/ :6 =456@<3/:/ 961@8 042:;/5648/H7/45/8690336E=4D875;</:=:=648E6732B/ - 15 - @61/;01@9730422108:=5=4>=/E69301D/8503/6</4=4D7< 69 :;/ 042610I8 B6F 3/02=4D :6 @73:=<3/ 3=:=D0:=648 1/42/1=4D :;/ E;63/ /F0@=40:=64<165/88:604733=:C 042 210DD=4D69:;/:=@/3=4/8E;=5;:;/1/8<642/4:07:;61=:=/8 E6732 ;0>/ <16</13C 910@/2 042 2/5=2/2 961 :;/ 4/F: 0502/@=55711=5737@ />/1:;/3/88:;=8671:;085645/14 08 :6 E;C :;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 ;0>/ 46: />/4 B6:;/1/2:61/<3C:6:;//@0=356@@74=50:=648/4:BC:;/ 04D0361/ 605;=4D /4:/1 64 B/;039 69 :;/ 8:72/4:8 E;=5; E08 8/4: 64 ""$ 0: '"G ;/ 308: /F:/42/2 20:/ 961 643=4/ 9=3=4D 69 :;/ /F0@=40:=64 961@ E08 '""$ ;/1/961/ :;/ 308: 20:/ 69 <0C@/4: 69 /F0@=40:=64 9// :=@/ E08 D104:/2 :=33 $ 4 ""$:;/0<<3=50:=64;0>=4DB//49=3/2BCE0C6904 /@0=3 56@@74=50:=64 BC :;/ </:=:=64/188:72/4:8 64 ""$ 0: '"G E08 E/33 E=:;=4 :;/ :=@/ ;02 :;/1/B//401/<3CBC:;/1/8<642/4:8E=:;1/D012:6:;/ 1/08648 961 464&055/<:045/ 61 =456@<3/:/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@ :;/ </:=:=64/18 <16B0B3C 56732 ;0>/ @02/ 0@/428 - 16 - 042 5611/5:=648 61 1/5:=9=50:=64 =4 <0C@/4: 69 :;/ /F0@=40:=649//:;167D;<16</1B6012081/H7=1/2BC:;/ 1/8<642/4:8;/1/961/:605/1:0=4/F:/4::;/1/=886@/ 9073: 64 :;/ <01: 69 :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 08 E/33 961 46: 1/<3C=4D 042 <16>=2=4D :;/ 1/08648 961 :;/ =456@<3/:/ 0<<3=50:=64961@69:;/</:=:=64/18 /:;0:08=:@0C0::;=88:0D/:;=8/116169:;/ 1/8<642/4:8=:8/3950446:B/0D16742:60336E:;/</:=:=64 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 08 :;/ </:=:=64/18 67D;: :6 ;0>/ /F/15=8/227/2=3=D/45/<16</1501/042507:=640428/4: :;/ 1/H7=1/2 9// 042 9=33/2 7< :;/ 0<<3=50:=648 E=:;=4 <16</1:=@/=4:;/1/H7=8=:/961@@044/1042<165/271/ 0@/ ;0>=4D 46: B//4 264/ =8 1/42/1/2 =456@<3/:/ @0C B/ 0364D E=:; @04C 6:;/1 8:72/4:8 ;/1/ 01/ 30A;8 69 8:72/4:8 E;6 :0A/ 7< :;=8 /F0@=40:=64 =4 :;/ 5674:1C ;/1/961/6</4=4D7<69:;/E/B<61:03961:;/80A/69:;/ 9671 </:=:=64/18 =4 @C 6<=4=64 E6732 6</4 7< :;/ 93662D0:/8961 @73:=<3/ 3=:=D0:=648 051688 :;/ 5674:1C08 =: =8056@@64/4:1045/:/F:564275:/2051688:;/5674:1C - 17 - $ =:; 0 ;/0>C ;/01: :;=8 671: E6732 ;0>/ :6 1/?/5::;/</:=:=6469:;/</:=:=64/1896146:B/=4D2=3=D/4: 04256@<3C=4DE=:;:;/1/H7=1/@/4:808<1/851=B/2=4:;/ 7B3=5 6:=5/042:;/4961@0:=64 733/:=4 , ;/ 3/014/2 /<7:C 63=5=:61 /4/103 69 42=0 1/3=/2 7<64 04 612/1 69 :;=8 671: =4 1=: /:=:=64 6%,$""$ E;/1/=4 =4 04 /4:1045/ /F0@=40:=64 69 :;/ 8:72/4:8 0<</01=4D 961 :;/ /F0@=40:=64 :;/ 0<<3=50:=648 69 :;/ 8:72/4:8 :;/1/=4 961 6</4=4D 69 :;/ <61:0350@/:6B/1/?/5:/2;/1/961/=4:;/<1/8/4:508/ 08 E/33 :;/ </:=:=64 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 50446: B/ /4:/1:0=4/208:;/C;0>/46:02;/1/2:604296336E/2:;/ 8:1=5: =48:175:=648 =4 9=33=4D 7< 69 :;/ 643=4/ 0<<3=50:=64 961@8E/33E=:;=4:=@/=4:;/@044/1=:E08088=D4/2042 <1/851=B/2 =4 :;/ 643=4/ <7B3=5 46:=5/ 08 E/33 08 :;/ =4961@0:=64 B733/:=4 <16>=2/2 :6 :;/ 8:72/4:8 86 0386 961 :;/1/0864:;0::;/02@=:50128;0>/031/02CB//4=887/2 :6 8/>/103 8:72/4:8 051688 :;/ 5674:1C :;/ H7/8:=64 <0</18 ;0>/ 031/02C B//4 8/: 042 8/4: :6 :;/ 5645/14/2 - 18 - :0:/8051688:;/5674:1C042:;/!562/8;0>/031/02C B//4D/4/10:/242/1:;/5=157@8:045/80::;=890D/42 /4:/1:0=4=4D :;=8 </:=:=64 E6732 B/ 3/02=4D :6 @61/ 20@0D/042@73:=<3=5=:C693=:=D0:=648<16B0B3C:6:;/6:;/1 8:72/4:8 3/02=4D :6 <68:<64/@/4: 69 :;/ /F0@=40:=64 E;=5; =8 46E 867D;: :6 B/ 564275:/2 :;167D; 643=4/ <165/88051688:;/5674:1CE67323/02:68/>/1/046@03=/8 10:;/1:;04B/4/9=: - 80E61269507:=64042D662D6>/14045/042 08 0 1/8<648=B3/ 07:;61=:C =: =8 1/H7=1/2 961 /=:;/1 :;/ 4=6461:;/:0:/742/1875;5=157@8:045/80::;/3/08: :61/<3C:6:;//@0=388/4:BC:;/8:72/4:861:;/5605;=4D 5/4:/18 64 B/;039 69 :;/ 8:72/4:8 :6 0: 3/08: A46E 08 :6 E;0: =8 :;/=1 9073: 042 E;/1/ :;/C ;0>/ D64/ E164D :6 1/5:=9C :;/ 80@/ E/33 E=:;=4 :;/ :=@/ <1/851=B/2 ;=8 08</5:=8<6=4:/267:BC:;=8671:643C961:;/<71<68/69 =@<16>=4D :;/ /2750:=64 8C8:/@ :;/ <165/271/ 026<:/2 042 :6 6E4 :;/1/8<648=B=3=:C:6 905=3=:0:/ :;/ 8:72/4:869 :;/ 5674:1C E;6 01/ =4:/42=4D :6 ?6=4 875; <1/@=/1 - 19 - =48:=:7:=648 042 E;/1/ 6<<61:74=:=/8 26 46: 56@/ 645/ 0D0=4B/5078/:;/1/=8468/56425;045/ G /45/ :;=8 671: =8 46: =453=4/2 :6 055/<: :;=8 </:=:=64 55612=4D3C:;/1=: /:=:=648:04282=8@=88/2 !*+ ' !") # =8: 63 6