- 1 - !"!# $%" " % &' &()*' & ) + ! " # "$% & % # "' ! # (% # & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )*$# # ## *(#(*# ## ! # + # + # & , + + -./012.2.34./5.617847191:2.34(%35$% ;< 2-1 012.2.3419=::8/17 539 >9=42 35 ;=.6 .4 9.?1 3 $"$ 7=217 "% $) $ 91>./21917 ;< 4.@19/.2< 36.:1 2=2.34 =6=;89=>. 539 2-1 35514:1/ 084./-=;61 84719 1:2.34 *( 35 -=9=2.<= <=<= =4-.2= $% A539 ;91@.2< B2-1 $%CD =47 1:2.34/ ( * 35 2-1 9321:2.3435-.67914593?1E8=65514:1/:2$"A539 ;91@.2<B2-1:2CD091/1426<0147.4>342-15.6135 776 ./29.:2 =47 1//.34/ +87>1 F # 01:.=6 3892 539 =/1 =2 =6=;89=>. .4 ! 06 =/1 3 )*$ - 3 - -1 5=:28=6 ?=29.E 35 2-1 :=/1 ./ 2-=2 2-1 =::8/17 ./ 2-1 :38/.4 35 @.:2.? .4 2-./ :=/1 4 2-1 <1=9 $ G-14 2-1 @.:2.? G=/ =6341 .4 2-1 -38/1 -1 8/17 @./.2 -19 -38/1 =47 0912147 -19 23 63@1 -19 &-14 2-1 @.:2.?.4539?17-.?2-=2-1;1.4>2-1:38/.4:=443263@1 =47 ?=99< -.? 71/0.21 -1 .4/./217 -19 2-=2 -1 G3867 ?=99<-19 4/8:-093?./1-1-=7/1E8=6.4219:389/134 -19539=;382(232.?1/ =21934$ $* $=2=;382 "" $$0 ? G-142-1@.:2.?G=/.4-19-38/12-1=::8/17 :=?1 2-191 =47 34:1 =>=.4 91H81/217 -19 539 /1E8=6 5=@389G-.:-G=/9158/17;<-19 22-=22.?1-153./217 6.512-91=223-19;</2=2.4>2-=2-1:=?1593?I=.6.5/-1 7.7 432 :33019=21 -1 G3867 73 =G=< -19 6.51 / /8:- /-1 637>17 2-1 :3?06=.42 ;15391 2-1 91/0347142 F 36.:1 34"% $) $=472-191/0347142F36.:1:3478:2172-1 .4@1/2.>=2.34=476=.7:-=9>1/-112=>=.4/22-1012.2.3419 =::8/175392-1=5391?142.341735514:1/ >>9.1@17;<2-1 /=?1 2-1 012.2.3419 091519917 = ;=.6 012.2.34 ;15391 2-1 776 ./29.:2=471//.34/+87>1#01:.=63892539 - 4 - =/1/ =2 =6=;89=>. .4 ! 06 =/1 3 )*$ G-.:- G=/ 91I1:217 ;< 39719 7=217 J "$ $ 14:12-./012.2.34 % 1=97 61=9417 :384/16 539 2-1 012.2.3419 61=9417 539 91/0347142 3 "2=21 -38>- 432.:1 /19@172391/03471423 /-191?=.417=;/142 ( 0=92 593? 89>.4> /1@19=6 :342142.34/ 61=9417 :384/165392-1012.2.3419=::8/17-=/09.?=9.6<:34214717 2-=2 34 0198/=6 35 2-1 :3?06=.42 =@19?142/ 2-1 /=?1 :61=96< 91@1=6/ 2-=2 =::8/17 ./ 2-1 :38/.4 35 @.:2.? -1 =661>17/1E8=6=:2G=/:3??.2217G.2-=093?./123?=99< -19 ::397.4> 23 -.? 2-191 ./ = 716=< 35 % 7=</ .4 637>.4>2-1:3?06=.42 #892-192-1@.:2.?G=/")<1=9/"" ?342-/ =/ 019 2-1 093/1:82.34 =47 -19 =>1 G=/ G934>6< ?142.3417=47/-1G=/?=I39=22-12.?135.4:.7142 3 093@1 -19 =>1 1E:102 /:-336 :192.5.:=21 43 32-19 =82-142.:=217 73:8?142 ./ 06=:17 ;< 2-1 093/1:82.34 4 /8:-:.9:8?/2=4:1/-109=</23=663G2-1012.2.34 - 5 - 61=941753991/03471423 "F 2=21 ;< /800392.4> 2-1 .?08>417 39719 @1-1?1426< 3003/17 2-1 ;=.6 012.2.34 =47 /8;?.2217 2-=2 2-1 :=/1 ./ /128053929.=6=472-1@.:2.?-=7=691=7<;1141E=?.417 4/8:-:.9:8?/2=4:1-109=</237./?.//2-1012.2.34 * -=@1>.@14?<=4E.38/:34/.719=2.34;32-34 2-1 /8;?.//.34 ?=71 ;< 2-1 61=9417 :384/16 539 2-1 91/01:2.@10=92.1//3=6/30198/172-1?=219.=6/=@=.6=;61 3491:397 ) /:3867;1>=2-1917593?91:397/.2./432.4 7./08212-=2;32-=::8/17=472-1@.:2.?=91916=2.@1/=47 .4 2-1 :3?06=.42 .2 ./ =661>17 2-=2 34 2-1 093?./1 35 ?=99.=>1 2-1 =::8/17 :3??.2217 /1E8=6 =:2 G.2- 2-1 @.:2.?539(232.?1/=472-191./=716=<35%7=</.4 637>.4> 2-1 :3?06=.42 -38>- .2 ./ :6=.?17 ;< 2-1 093/1:82.34 2-=2 2-1 @.:2.? G=/ ?.439 =2 2-1 2.?1 35 .4:.7142=/0192-1/:-336:192.5.:=212-19=7.363><910392 06=:17;<2-13:239710.:2/2-=22-1=>1352-1@.:2.?./ - 6 - ") 23 " <1=9/ -1 /=.7 =/01:2 -=/ 23 ;1 21/217 .4 = 712=.617 29.=6 ;< 1E=?.4.4> 2-1 =82-39 35 2-1 ?17.:=6 91:397/ =47 =6/3 2-1 :-336 1=7?=/219 G-3 .//817 2-1 :192.5.:=21 3G 2-=2 2-1 @.:2.? -=7 =691=7< ;114 1E=?.417 2-191 ./ 43 /8:- 2-91=2 35 -=?019.4> 39 2=?019.4> 2-1 093/1:82.34 G.241//1/ -1 34C;61 01E 3892 .4 2-1 :=/1 35 91039217 .4 -167 =2 0=9= 3/ "=47"=/84719 ! " - 7 - # $ % & ' " ( ) $ *+ ( ) - 8 - 006<.4> 2-1 =;3@1 09.4:.061/ 23 2-1 :=/1 34 -=47G.2-3821E091//.4>=4<30.4.34342-1?19.2/352-1 :=/1/855.:123-3672-=22-1:8/237.=6.4:=9:19=2.34352-1 012.2.3419731/432:=66539=22-.//2=>1 J ::397.4>6<2-1012.2.34./ "$ -1 012.2.3419=::8/17 ./ 7.91:217 23 ;1 146=9>1734;=.6.4 !06 =/13 )*$=9./.4> 38235 9.?1 3 $"$ 91>./21917 ;< 4.@19/.2< 36.:1 2=2.34 =6=;89=>. 539 2-1 35514:1/ 084./-=;61 84719 1:2.34*(35$%=471:2.34/(=47*35 :2/8;I1:2232-153663G.4>:347.2.34/ =!12.2.3419/-=661E1:821=019/34=6;347539 =/8?35 / "$$$$$G.2-2G3/8912.1/539 2-1 6.K1/8? 23 2-1 /=2./5=:2.34 35 2-1 I89./7.:2.34=63892' ;!-1012.2.3419/-=66=001=991>86=96<34=66 2-1 7=21/ 35 -1=9.4> ;15391 2-1 9.=6 3892 8461//2-19.=638921E1?02/-./=001=9=4:1 539@=6.791=/34/' - 9 - :! -1 012.2.3419 /-=66 432 7.91:26< 39 .47.91:26< 2-91=214 39 2=?019 G.2- 2-1 093/1:82.34G.241//1/' 7! -1 012.2.3419 /-=66 432 .4@36@1 .4 /.?.6=9 35514:1/.4582891' 1! -1 012.2.3419 /-=66 432 61=@1 2-1 I89./7.:2.34 35 2-1 9.=6 3892 G.2-382 019?.//.34 35 2-1 /=.7 3892 842.6 2-1 :=/1 91>./21917=>=.4/2-.?./7./03/17355 5! -1 012.2.3419 /-=66 ?=9K -./ =22147=4:1 ;15391 2-1 2=2.34 38/1 55.:19 4.@19/.2< 36.:1 2=2.34 =6=;89=>. 34 5.9/2 847=< 35 1@19< ?342- ;12G114 "$ $$ = ? =47 $" $$ 0 ? 2.66 2-1 :=/1 91>./21917 =>=.4/2 -.? ./ 7./03/17355;153912-19.=63892 ,* &" ) " & ./23 "63 +