Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54962 (KAR)
D K MURALI YADHAV v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203976/2025 · 2026-01-28
Pradeep Singh Yerur
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54962 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54962 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$#%
&'$! !#
(')
! "
#$ $$ %
&
$
$$
$ '
! &
$
(
&
$
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
)
! $
& $
"
#$
$ %
*
&
!!' !! &
&
* &
+ *
((
*!' '!'
$ #,%
&
-$. *
/$ )
012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674= 244>17? 56 @AB20 504 6C:< 0445 4?1254=4: =:4=:1=4D5167 6(
6C:<!':B54:'!'EB175B174: ;<=42367:4756F1:4774GA=4
! 5 12 504 DB24 68 504 345151674= 50B5 04 12 B7 B:F6DB54 =421:17? 17 504 B1D0A= 04=4 CB2 B 34=267B9
- 3 -
47E15< ;45C447 504 345151674= B7: 674 01EEB1B0 B7: 6504=2 78A=504=B7D468504B;6F447E15<504=44=A354: B81?05;45C4475C6?=6A3268346394DD6=:17?9<;B24:
67 504 D6E39B175 B7 & DBE4 56 ;4 =4?1254=4: B?B1725 345151674= 17 =1E4 6!!' B7: !'!' C15017 504 HA=12:1D5167 68 45BH17B?B= 691D4 5B5167 B1D0A= 04 D0B=?4 20445 DBE4 56 ;4 8194: B?B1725 5012 345151674= 17 =1E4 6!!' #39#% 6!!% 67 504 8194 68
::15167B9 4221672 )A:?4 B1D0A= 86= 504 68847D42 3A7120B;94A7:4=4D51672(!(!( ( ' ( 68 B7: 4D5167 ( #% #% 68 504 D04:A94:B2542B7:504D04:A94:=1;42#=4F47516768 5=6D15142% D5 B7: 17 =1E4 6!'!' # 6!!(% 67 504 8194 68 ::15167B9 1F19 )A:?4 B7:
)& 6A=5( B1D0A= 86= 504 68847D4 3A7120B;94 A7:4= 4D51672 ( ((! ((' (( =4B: C150 4D516768 $B24:67504=4?125=B516768504D=1E4 B7:81917?68504D0B=?420445=42367:4756 7234D56= 68691D4=4D6EE47:4:566347B=6C:<20445B?B1725504
- 4 -
345151674= 04=417 $B24: 67 C01D0 =42367:475 6( 43A5< A34=17547:475 68 691D4 B1D0A= 6=:4=4: 86= 634717?A368504=6C:<20445C1506A5122A17?5047651D4 =6C:< 20445 DBE4 56 ;4 63474: 17 504 7BE4 68 345151674= :B54: '!' ;< 4754=17? 012 7BE4 17 504 =4?1254= (
5 12 D67547:4: ;< 94B=74: D6A7249 86= 504 345151674=50B5504DB2426EB:46A5;<504=42367:475217 =1E4 6!!' B7: !'!' 504 345151674= 04=417 DBE4 56 ;4 BD@A1554: 67 !! B7: 67 (!! B854= 5=1B9 04=486=4 15 12 D67547:4: 50B5 504=4 12 76 D=1E17B9 DB24 347:17? B2 B?B1725 504 345151674= 6= B7< D6E39B175 =4?1254=4: B?B1725 504 345151674= ;486=4 504 3691D425B5167 5128A=504=D67547:4:50B567504;B21268 5046C:<04454?1254=EB175B174:;<504=42367:475 3691D4 =42367:475 6 0B2 ;447 8=4@A4759< 2AEE6717? 504345151674=565043691D425B5167B7:6=:4=17?01E56215 5044751=4:B<175043691D425B5167C1506A5504=4;417?B7< D6E39B175& 6=4F47B7B994?B5167B?B1725504345151674=
- 5 -
:4231545048BD550B50412765=4@A1=4:17B7<DB2486=B7< 17F4251?B5167 C0B5264F4= 04=486=4 345151674= 2A;E1554: B=43=42475B516767(!!56=4F14CB7:=4E6F4012 7BE4 8=6E 504 6C:< 0445 4?1254= $A5 =42367:475 6!0B2765D6EEA71DB54:6=3B224:B7<6=:4=17=4234D5 68504=43=42475B5167262A;E1554:
5 12 D67547:4: 50B5 C047 504 345151674= EB:4 B7 B3391DB5167 6= =43=42475B5167 504 =42367:475 BA506=151426A?05560BF4BDD4354:504=43=42475B5167B7:
3=6F1:4: B7 6336=5A715< 56 504 345151674= 56 3A586=50 012 DB2468504=4;417?76B994?B516768D=1E17B9DB242347:17? B?B172501EB7:50B517D9A2167680127BE4B7:D67517A17?
012 7BE4 17 504 6C:< 0445 4?1254= 12 F169B51F4 68 504 3=17D13942687B5A=B9HA251D417D9A:17?01234=267B991;4=5<
5 12 B926 D67547:4: 50B5 17 23154 68 504 345151674=;417?BD@A1554:175045C6DB24250B5C4=48194:
B?B1725 01E :A4 56 34=267B9 47E15< B7: :423154 504 =43=42475B5167 ;417? EB:4 504 345151674=/2 7BE4 12 765 25=AD> 688 8=6E 504 =4?1254= 68 =6C:142 504=4;< DBA217? - 6 -
A7569: 0B=:2013 B7: F169B5167 68 012 8A7:BE475B9 =1?05 68 8=44E6F4E475B7:01291;4=5< '
512B926D67547:4:;<50494B=74:D6A724950B5 =42367:4752 0BF4 765 86996C4: 504 74D422B=< ?A1:491742 9B1::6C7;<50126A=517504DB2468
=436=54: 17 04=486=4 04 D67547:2 50B5 1E391DB517? 504 345151674= B7:=4?1254=17?012 7BE417 504=6C:<2044512 1994?B9B7:F169B51F4683=17D13942687B5A=B9HA251D4B7:504 ?A1:491742122A4:17504DB2468 #2A3=B% 47D45042BE4=4@A1=4256;4=4E6F4:B7:D6724@A4759< @AB204: 47D4 504 345151674= 12 34=86=D4: 56 B33=6BD0 50126A=517F6>17?504C=15HA=12:1D5167
94B=74: ::15167B9 6F4=7E475 :F6DB54=43=4247517?=42367:4755B54D67547:250B576 :6A;5 504 345151674= 0B2 ;447 BD@A1554: 17 504 B86=4E4751674:DB242;A55047BE468504345151674=CB2 17D9A:4:175046C:<04454?1254=3=16=56BD@A155B9B7: B926@A4251676886996C17?504?A1:4917429B1::6C7;<504
- 7 -
66=:17B54 $47D0 68 5012 6A=5 17 504 DB24 68
#2A3=B% C6A9: 765 B=124 86= 504 =4B267 50B5 17D9A2167685047BE468504345151674=175046C:<0445 4?1254= 12 3=16= 56 504 2B1: HA:?E475 47D4 504 2BE4 C199 765 47A=4 56 012 ;474815 DD6=:17?9< 04 244>2 56 :12E12250434515167
0BF404B=:94B=74:D6A724986=504345151674= B7:94B=74:::15167B96F4=7E475:F6DB5486=5045B54
5 12 B 8A7:BE475B9 =A94 68 9BC 50B5 C047 B 34=267 12 1E391DB54: B2 B =6C:< 204454= ;< 17D9A:17? 012 7BE417504912568=6C:<2044550467A212A3675045B54 56 86996C 504 :A4 3=6D4:A=4 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 504 =494FB75 =A942 B7: =4?A9B51672 7 504 3=42475 DB24 504 B=7B5B>B691D4B7AB9E6=4234D181DB99<5044?1254=68 6C:142 EB175B174: 17 6=:4= 6 C01D0 :4B92 C150 01256=< 204452 B7: =6C:< 204452 B7: 47=699E475 6= =4?125=B5167 68 34=2672 17 504 2B1: 20445 86= =4?1254= 86= D67517A6A2 E67156=17? ;< 504 3691D4 BA506=15142 12 765 86996C4: 5B7:17? =:4= 6 :4B92 C150 =4?125=B5167
- 8 -
68=6C:14204:4817151673=6F1:4:1250B5B=6C:<EB<;4 :48174: B2 B ?A7:B B7: 17D9A:42 B 06691?B7 56A?0 FB?B;67:6=B7<34=267C0612:B7?4=6A2563A;91D34BD4 B7:5=B7@A1915<04=4B=4EB7<86=E268=6C:12E C01D0 B=4 :42D=1;4: 504=417 B7: 504 3=6D422 B7: 3=6D4:A=4 D6754E39B54: 56;4 EB175B174: 17:1884=4753B=52 7BE49< B=5B=5$B7:B=5C01D0?6F4=7504EB17547B7D4 68 B =4?1254= B7: 504 7BE42 68 504 =6C:142 17 5041= =4234D51F4 3B=52 5 12 504 :A5< B7: 6;91?B5167 DB25 A367 504 =42367:4752 C01D0 12 765 635167B9 56 86996C 504 :A4 3=6D4:A=4D6754E39B54:A7:4=50425B7:17?6=:4=268504 B=7B5B>B 691D4 B7AB9 C0194 4754=17? 504 7BE4 68 B 34=267 17 504 =6C:< 20445 B7: 504=4 B=4 D4=5B17 3=6D4:A=4256;4EB7:B56=19<86996C4:;486=44754=17?504 7BE422D67547:4:;<94B=74:D6A724986=504345151674= 504 3=6D422 B7: 3=6D4:A=4 B2 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 504 25B7:17?
=:4= 6 68 504 B=7B5B>B 691D4 B7AB9 0B2765;44786996C4:B7:766336=5A715<CB2?1F4756504 345151674=568194012=439<6=4G39B7B516786==4E6F17?012
- 9 -
7BE4175046C:<04454?1254=B7:E4=49<;4DBA2404 CB217F69F4:17D=1E17B9DB24217C01D0B926504345151674= 0B2;447BD@A1554:17504<4B=! B7:!! 512B926 D67547:4: 50B5 506A?0 504 345151674= 0B2 EB:4 B =43=42475B5167 56 504 =42367:475 BA506=15142 B854= 504 BD@A155B967(!!504=43=42475B51670B2765;447 D6721:4=4: B7: 4F47 B854= 504 BD@A155B9 04 0B2 ;447 2AEE674: 56 504 HA=12:1D5167B9 3691D4 25B5167 86= A774D422B=<1754==6?B5167C047504=41276DB24347:17? B?B172501E
5C6A9:;4=494FB75564G5=BD53B=B?=B306 68504HA:?E475681F12167$47D06850126A=517504DB24 68 !" " =436=54: 17 #$ %&& ' ( C04=417 504 1F12167 $47D0 :4B95 C150 21E19B= 2A;H4D5 EB554= C01D0 =4B:2 B2 A7:4=
- 10 -
! "# # $ %
&'( ) # $ $ %
&'( # ) *)
# + )
) ) ) # )) ) ) ) ) , )# ) - I
5B7:17? =:4= 6 68 B=7B5B>B 691D4 B7AB9 124G5=BD54:;496C
&'(
./0 # ) ) 1 .2/ 3+ / ! 45, / 6 )) # # 3 /),
- 11 -
/ !)1 + + ))))) , /*, /, / .7/ 6 # 8 8 %
&&) #9
0 : 4 ) ;
0#
.</. /% ) 848
0 ) ) ./ % ) 84 8
)
=
8"48 : ) #) ./ % ) >%#> 4 +
.'/ $ ) +*# $ #
.?/% ) )
0 : !6) ./ @ ) #
- 12 -
) 848 # ) 1 $
.A/ 4 # ) ) )
) ) ) 0
" * ) ) )
.(/$
" * ) # # # 8 8
: ) ) " *
4 6) *$
#
# .&/)#) # #)) ./ @ # + $ ! 8:8 )) $
! 808
- 13 -
.2/@ 8481 + 8488:8 @ 848 )
! $ 46) .7/ % ! 808 8:8 )
6
6)
)
+*# $ .</6)
+
) ) 6) 1 ! )
.'/ B C 3 ./ ) ! # ./
)))
2(< 4
. 9 /, ./ # ! (2./.)/.1/ ./D ! 0(?7 )# #C3
- 14 -
.#/0&A./ 4 , .#/0&4
4 .#/0&4
4 .#/ 0 )## , #/EC)'' '?D ! 0(?7, .C/ 0 '&( 6
4
#+ 3 .?/E# ) E " : ) + # )) # ++ )) !) + ./ @ # $
) )
" # # .A/)&?
)
3+ /
% 2/% ) 7/5) )
- 15 -
</ % )
'/ ?/$F /% A/ ! .(/ 6 ) ) # ) 1 ) # ! )
-
! 0466=:17B54$47D06850126A=517504DB24 68 #2A3=B% 0B2 9B1: :6C7 ?A1:491742 C01D0 B=4 56 ;4 86996C4:C0194 =4?1254=17? 504 7BE468 B 34=267 17 504 6C:< 0445 4?1254= C01D0 4F47 3=16= 56 5042B1:HA:?E475CB2BEB7:B5486=504=42367:475256 0BF486996C4:25=1D59<17BDD6=:B7D45650425B7:17?6=:4= 6 68 504 B=7B5B>B 691D4 B7AB9 C01D0 17 E< 6317167 D6721:4=17? 504 8BD52 B7: D1=DAE25B7D4 68 504 3=42475 DB24 0B2 765 ;447 86996C4: B7: 4F47 B854= 504 BD@A155B9 68 504 345151674= 17 504 5C6 DB242 C01D0 DA9E17B54: 17 BD@A155B9 B854= :45B194: 5=1B9 B7: 4F47 B854=
- 16 -
504=43=42475B5167?1F47;<504345151674=86==4E6F17?012 7BE4 8=6E 504 6C:< 0445 4?1254= 504=4 12 76 =4236724 6= =439< 6= BD5167 ;< 504 =42367:4752 17 =4E6F17?0127BE4 (
7 F14C 68 767D6E391B7D4 68 504 3=6D4:A=4 D6754E39B54: A7:4= 25B7:17? 6=:4= 6 68 504 B=7B5B>B 691D4 B7AB9 B7: 767D6721:4=B5167 68 504 =43=42475B5167 ?1F47 ;< 504 345151674= 3A=2AB75 56 012 BD@A155B9 5012 6A=5 12 68 504 6317167 50B5 504 345151674= 0B2EB:46A5BFB91:DB2456D6721:4=8BF6A=B;9<
DD6=:17?9< 3B2250486996C17? 1 04C=153451516712)) 11 04 1E3A?74: 6=:4= 68 634717? 6C:< 04454?1254=175047BE468504345151674= ;4B=17?6(
*!':B54: '!' EB175B174: ;< =42367:475 61204=4;<@AB204:
- 17 -
111 04 =42367:4752 B=4 04=4;< :1=4D54: 56 =4E6F45047BE468504345151674=8=6E504 6C:<04454?1254=EB175B174:;<504E C15017B34=16:6886A=C44>28=6E504:B54 68=4D413568D4=51814:D63<685046=:4= 1F 1;4=5< 06C4F4= 12 =424=F4: 56 504 =42367:4755B54563=6D44: 17 BDD6=:B7D4 C1509BCB?B1725504345151674=18B5B99B7< DB2412EB:46A5B7:C0194:617?26504< 20B9925=1D59<86996C504?A1:4917429B1::6C7 ;< 5012 6A=5 17 504 DB24 68
=436=54:17
!*+ ( !#) $
J