Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54941 (KAR)
SYED AMIRUDDIN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201900/2025 · 2026-02-02
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54941 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54941 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""#
$%&!&! %
'( ')*+ '!!*
,
! "
#
$$
%
" #
& &
&'
(
& (
$ $ $
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)& &
* ( ' (&+
&&&,
& &
&&
& *
&
&,
&
+
&
"" -
(&,
! &
&
&'
#*+
$$
)
& *
(,. ,# (,+
&
& &
, , , & ! & && , , &
,&
&, ,
( ' ' , & *
& ,
,
& " + ,&,, $
" , , "
&
&
,
& &
& & &
,
&
" & -
-
/ '& '
- 3 -
&012 34515167 12 8194:;7:4< 4=5167 68 0><>51?> >@><1A ;<>A20> >7015> 244A17@ 56 B;>20 3<6=44:17@2>@>1725504345151674<2>==;24:
625617 6 ><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4
6 <4@1254<4: D? "6C47 691=4 5>5167 >9>D;<>@1 15? 86< 50468847=423;7120>D94 ;7:4< 4=51672 $ *+ >7:<4>:E1504=516768 >7:4=51672>7:
68 6E<? <601D15167 =5 $ 347:17@ 67 504 8194
::15167>91F19';:@4>7:' ,>9>D;<>@1
&04 >D<1:@4: 8>=52 68 504 =>24 ><4 50>5 15 12 >994@4: 17 504 =6C39>175 50>5 <42367:475
6 14 504 =6C39>17>75C><<14:>==;24:
6?4:D:;9">044:67 5 504 51C4 68 C><<1>@4 504 3><4752 68 <42367:475
6 0>: @1F47 569>2 68 @69: =>20 68 25E6E04494<C656<=?=94>7:6504<;5472192 >2 > :6E<? 56 >==;24:
6 7 504 74G5 :>? 68 504 C><<1>@415E>2<4F4>94:50>5>==;24:
612>:1F6<=44 >7: 012 81<25 E184 :1F6<=4: 01C 67 504 @<6;7: 50>5 04 12
- 4 -
2;884<17@ 8<6C C475>9 >7: 30?21=>9 1997422 ,;<504< 15 12 >926<4F4>94:50>504123><51>99?1C365475?2;33<42217@ 504 2>1: 8>=5 >99 504 >==;24: 34<2672 56@4504< =67231<4:
>7: 34<86<C4: 504 C><<1>@4 68 <42367:475
6 E150 >==;24:
6 >54< 504? 25><54: 56 0><>22 <42367:475 6D65030?21=>99?>7:C475>99?86<>::15167>9:6E<?68 2&04<4>854<67>5>D6;5 3CE047<42367:475
6>:F124:04<0;2D>7:>==;24:
6 56 5>A4 5<4>5C475 86< 012 1997422 04 86<=4: 04< 56 D<17@ 2 8<6C 04< 06;24 >7: B;><<494: E150 04<>7:>22>;954:04<550>551C4>==;24:
62>7: >926 >22>;954: 04< >7: >==;24:
62 >7: 17251@>54:
>==;24:
625656=6CC1504<C;<:4<D?3;2017@04< 8<6C<66856322;=020496:@4:504=6C39>175D486<4 <42367:475 6H691=4 >@>1725 504 345151674<2 >7:
>76504<&042>C4E>2<4@1254<4:17<1C4
6 ;D24B;4759? <42367:475 6H691=4 =67:;=54:
17F4251@>5167 >7: 9>1: =0><@4 20445 >@>1725 >==;24:
6 >7: 504 345151674<2 86< 504 >86<4C4751674: 68847=42 D? - 5 -
><<>?17@ 50424 345151674<2 >2 >==;24:
62 56 &04 94><74: >@125<>54 566A =6@71I>7=4 68 504 68847=42 47=4504345151674<23<484<<4:50123451516756B;>20504 3<6=44:17@2>@>1725504C
4><: 94><74: =6;7249 86< 345151674<2 94><74:
1@0 6;<5 6F4<7C475 94>:4< 86< <42367:475
6 H 5>54>7:94><74:=6;724986<<42367:475
6
3><5 8<6C ;<@17@ 24F4<>9 =6754751672 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<2 =67547:4: 50>5 345151674<2>==;24:
62 56 ><4 76 E>?
=6774=54: 56 504>994@4:17=1:475==;24:
62>7:><45048>504< 179>E>7:C6504<179>E68<42367:475
6<4234=51F49? ==;24:
62>7:><4504D<6504<179>E>7:21254<17 9>E68<42367:475
6<4234=51F49?48;<504<=67547:4:
50>5504345151674<
6>==;24:
612C><<14:>7:204 12 <421:17@ 17 04< C>5<1C671>9 06C4 ==6<:17@ 56 01C 4G=435 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 C>:4 >@>1725 50424 345151674<2 >D269;549? 76 2;=0 C>54<1>92
- 6 -
39>=4:562;D25>751>5450>5504?>=51F49?3><51=13>54:17504 >994@4: 68847=4 ==6<:17@9? 04 3<>?2 56 >996E 504 34515167
94><74:=6;724986<<42367:475
6 =67547:4:50>5>==;24:
625614504345151674<
62 56 E4<4 <421:17@ >967@ E150 >==;24:
6 >7: <42367:475
6==;24:
62560><>224:<42367:475 6 D650 30?21=>99? >7: C475>99? 86< >::15167>9 :6E<? ==6<:17@5601C>7>554C35E>2C>:4D?>==;24:
62 5656=6CC15504C;<:4<68<42367:475
647=404 3<>?256:12C12250434515167
4><74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7C475 94>:4< >334><17@86<<42367:475
65>54633624:50434515167 >7:3<>?256:12C1225042>C4
0>F4@1F47C?>7G16;2=6721:4<>5167D65067 504 2;DC1221672 C>:4 D? 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51F4 3><5142 >7: 34<;24: 504 :6=;C4752 C>:4 >F>19>D9467<4=6<:
- 7 -
2 =6;9: D4 @>504<4: 8<6C <4=6<:2 504 =6C39>175 >F4<C4752 :12=9624 50>5 >==;24:
6 C><<14:
<42367:475
6 D? 2;33<42217@ 012 4><914< C><<1>@4 >7: 01230?21=>9>7:C475>91997422&042>1:>234=5E>2E499 E15017 504 A76E94:@4 68 345151674<
62 >7: 14 >==;24:
62>7:E06><45043><475268>==;24:
6 854<504C><<1>@4<42367:475
625><54:<421:17@>967@ E15004<0;2D>7:>==;24:
6>967@E150>==;24:
62 >7:86<84E:>?2 512>994@4:50>5:;<17@04<25>?504? 1721254:86<>::15167>9:6E<?>7:>926C>:4>7>554C3556 :6>E>?E15004<9184&0425>54C47568E15742242:12=9624 =>24>@>1725>==;24:
6>7:345151674<
62 >7:6E4F4<6734<;2>968504=0><@420445C>54<1>92 4G=435 26C4 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 >@>1725 >==;24:
62 >7: 14 345151674<
62 >7: 76 6504< C>54<1>92 ><4 86<50=6C17@ >@>1725 504C 45151674< 6>==;24:
6 12 504 C><<14: :>;@054< <421:17@ 243><>549? 74>< 5 '62430 67F475 =0669 (1:?>
>@>< >9>D;<>@1 &04 679? >994@>5167 17 504 =0><@4 20445
- 8 -
>@>1725 >==;24:
62 >7: 12 50>5 504? 17251@>54:
>==;24:
625656:6>E>?504918468<42367:475
6
$
72;=0=1<=;C25>7=4250467/D9434G6;<5 17 504 =>24 68
<436<54: 17 ! "#$ %& >5 3><>@<>30 6 049: 50>5 504 6;<5 206;9: D4 =><48;9 17 3<6=44:17@ >@>1725 504 :125>75 <49>51F42 17 =<1C42 34<5>1717@ 56 C>5<1C671>9 :123;542 >7: :6E<? :4>502 &04 <49>51F42 68 504 0;2D>7: 206;9: 765 D4 <634:17 67 504 D>212 68 6C71D;2 >994@>51672 ;79422 234=181= 1725>7=4 68 5041< 17F69F4C475 17 504 =<1C4 ><4 C>:4 6;5 5 12 >926245594: 36215167689>E50>518>34<26712C>:4568>=4>=<1C17>9 5<1>9 67 26C4 @474<>9 >7: 2E44317@ >994@>51672 E1506;5 D<17@17@ 67 <4=6<: >7? 234=181= 1725>7=42 68 =<1C17>9 =67:;=5 15 12 765017@ D;5 >D;24 68 3<6=422 68 504 6;<5 &046;<523624>:;5?562;DJ4=5504>994@>516794F4994:17 504=6C39>17556>506<6;@02=<;517?56817:6;5E04504< 504<4 12 >7? @>17 68 5<;50 17 504 >994@>51672 6< E04504<
- 9 -
504? ><4 C>:4 679?
E150 504 2694 6DJ4=5 68 17F69F17@ =4<5>17 17:1F1:;>92 17 > =<1C17>9 =0><@4 C6<4 3><51=;9><9? E047>3<624=;5167><1248<6C>C>5<1C671>9:123;54
,;<504<50467KD94 34G6;<5 17 504 =>2468 '( #
<436<54:17 )*$$+*)049:173><>
62>7: >2;7:4<- )
! "
#
$%
& $'
$'
$% (
- 10 -
,) ! *+, #
! (
- . ! *+, #
/. "
0 ! . . ! *+, # . # -
#
1
7 504 1725>75 =>24 > D><4 34<;2>9 68 , >7:
=0><@4 20445 C>54<1>92 =94><9? 206E2 50>5 504 >994@>51672 C>:4 D? <42367:475
6 >@>1725 345151674<
62 >7:
>==;24:
62>7:><4F>@;4>7:6C71D;2&04<486<4
- 11 -
504 =0><@4 20445 9>=A2 =67=<454 >7: 3<4=124 >994@>51672 >@>1725345151674<
62>7:
512245594:36215167689>E50>56;<520>F456 D4=><48;9>7:=>;516;217:4>917@E150=6C39>175>7:C;25 5>A4 3<>@C>51= <4>915142 1756 =6721:4<>5167 E0194 :4>917@ E150 C>5<1C671>9 :123;542 E04<4 504 >994@>51672 0>F4 56 D42=<;5171I4:E150@<4>5=><4>7:=1<=;C234=5167176<:4< 563<4F475C12=><<1>@468J;251=4>7:>D;24683<6=42268 6;<5
2 2;=0 >C 68 504 =6721:4<4: F14E 50>5 504 =67517;>516768504=<1C17>93<6=44:17@2>@>1725345151674< 62>7:>==;24:
62>7:12=94><>D;24683<6=422 68 6;<5 2 2;=0 504 2>C4 12 91>D94 56 D4 B;>204:
6E4F4< 217=4 =>24 12 C>:4 6;5 >@>1725 345151674<
62 >7: >==;24:
62 >7: 504 3<6=44:17@2 =>7765 D4 B;>204: >@>1725 504C ==6<:17@9? 3<6=44:563>2250486996E17@-
1 &043451516712 -
- 12 -
11 &043<6=44:17@2>@>1725504345151674<
62 >7: 14 >==;24:
62 >7: 20>99 =67517;4 111 &043<6=44:17@2>@>1725345151674<
62>7: >==;24:
62>7:17
6 ><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4
6 <4@1254<4: D?"6C47691=45>5167>9>D;<>@115?86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>D94 ;7:4< 4=51672 $ *+>7:<4>:E1504=5167 68 >7: 4=51672 >7: 68 6E<? <601D15167 =5 $ 347:17@ 67 504 8194
::15167>91F19';:@4>7:' ,>9>D;<>@112 04<4D?B;>204:
!-+ '&!* &
" 125
6-9
6- &-'