- 1 - ! "#$$ # % %&'( %' ) ! !" "" ! #!" $ ! # ! !!" ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! !" $ & ! $ ! !" $ #! $ ! %! ! ' ( ) ! " *& - 3 - ! #!" $ ! ' ( "+ ) " &" ( !) & " () ! $ "! """ & # ! " ""() " " $ " ! , , - ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582: 2;3/45 & 46 .<:<3/=< <><:/? 9:<?0.< <5./3< 022?/5> 34 @9<0. 1:4;228/5>0<></5033.2123/3/452:0 <;;9028 4034/5 4% (<:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4 ) :2>/032:28B=3.2!4A2547/;2 <7<B9:<>/47/;23<3/45 64: 3.2 46625;2 195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 &() <58#: C2;3/45 461258/5>453.26/7246 88/3/45<7/D/798>2<58" <7<B9:<>/ - 4 - .2 6<;39<7 A<3:/E 46 3.2 ;<02 /0 3.<3 :201458253 4 A<::/28 123/3/452: 4 /2 <;;9028 4*9:=<?<53. /5 3.2 =2<: <58 89:/5> 3.2 A<::/<>20.21</884C:=/53.264:A46>:<A046>478 <58 43.2: .4902.478 <:3/;720 632: 3.2 A<::/<>2 0.2 :20/828 <745> C/3. .2: .90B<58 <58 /5*7<C0 <;;9028 12:0450 /5/3/<77= 64: < 12:/48 46 =2<:0 ;4:8/<77= .2:2<632: 3.2 123/3/452:0 03<:328 .<:<00/5> .2: <32: .2:.90B<58C253 3425><79:9 64: 7/D27/.448 /53.2 =2<: #9B02@92537=:201458253 4<704F4/528./A<58 03<:32834:20/82C/3../A/525><79:99:/5>3.<33/A2 <;;9028 4<88/;32864:B<8D/;20<58.2902834.<:<00 .2:B43.1.=0/;<77=<58A253<77= 5 3.2 =2<: 89:/5> 1<582A/; <;;9028 4;<A2B<;?34./0D/77<>28544:<5803<:328 34:20/82<745>C/3.43.2:123/3/452:0.49>.:201458253 4A<82<5<332A1334:2<;../A.252D2::20145828 34 .2: ;<77 "/5<77= 45 <3 <B493 % 1A C.25 :201458253 4 <745> C/3. .2: :27<3/D20 /2 ! - 5 - 34!C253343.2.490246<;;9028 4<38544:B= 3.<33/A2/3C<0;<A234.2:?54C728>23.<3.2:.90B<58 12:64:A283.202;458A<::/<>2!.250.2@9203/45283.2 0<A2 <77 <;;9028 12:0450 <B9028 .2: /5 6/73.= 7<5>9<>2 <58 <;;9028 40 <58 43.2:0 <00<97328 .2: <58 3.:4C5 .2: 493 46 3.2 .4902 25;2 0.2 748>28 < ;4A17</53 B264:2 :201458253 4*47/;2 45 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 C./;. ;<A2 34 B2 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4 64: 3.2 <64:2A253/4528 46625;20 9B02@92537= :201458253 4*47/;2 /5D203/><328 3.2 ;<02 <58 7</8 ;.<:>2 0.223 <></503 <77 3.2 123/3/452:0 <;;9028 .2 72<:528 <>/03:<32 344? ;4>5/G<5;2 46 3.2 46625;20 >>:/2D28 B= 3.2 0<A2 3.2 123/3/452:0 1:262::28 3./0 123/3/45 34 @9<0. 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58 72<:528 64: 3.2 :201458253 4*3<32 .49>. 543/;2/002:D2834:201458253 40.2:2A</528<B0253 - 6 - 1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02D2:<7 ;453253/450 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 .<0 ;45325828 3.<3 3.2 ;4A17</53 748>28 B= :201458253 4 952@9/D4;<77= /58/;<3203.<3:201458253 4C<0:20/8/5><745>C/3..2: .90B<58/525><79:9<58<35414/53463/A22/3.2:./A 4:43.2:<;;902812:0450.<:<0028.2:<0;7</A28B=.2: 2 <704 ;45325328 3.<3 64: < 12:/48 46 =2<:0 0.2 C<0 :20/828 ;4:8/<77= C/3. .2: .90B<58 <58 /5*7<C0 2 <704 ;453258283.<33.2:2<:25409;.A<32:/<7017<;28B=3.2 1:402;93/45 34 1:4D2 3.<3 3.2 123/3/452:0 12:64:A28 3.2 02;458A<::/<>246123/3/452: 4 <;;9028 4509;. ;/:;9A03<5;20.21:<=034@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 # 72<:528 4114028 3.2 1:<=2: B= ;453258/5> 3.<3 45 12:90<7 46 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<70 A4:2 1<:3/;97<:7= 3.2 03<32A2530 46 ! 34 ! <77 3.202 C/3520020 .<D2 ;<32>4:/;<77= 03<328 3.<3 <77 3.2 <;;9028 B= ;47798/5> C/3. 2<;. 43.2: .<:<0028 :201458253 4 1.=0/;<77= <58 A253<77= <58 <704 12:64:A283.202;458A<::/<>234123/3/452: 4 <;;9028 - 7 - 4 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.202123/3/452:0;<5543B2@9<0.28 % .<D2>/D25A=<5E/490;450/82:<3/45B43.45 3.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D2 1<:3/20 <58 12:9028 3.2 84;9A2530 A<82 <D</7<B7245:2;4:8 & 0;4978B2><3.2:286:4A:2;4:80/3/0543/5 8/01932 3.<3 3.2 :27<3/450./1 B23C225 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58 :201458253 4 /0 543 /5 8/01932 23/3/452: 4 /2 <;;9028 4 A<::/28 :201458253 4 /5 3.2 =2<: <583.2:2<632:0.2:20/828;4:8/<77=64:<12:/4846=2<:0 /5 3.2 A<3:/A45/<7 .4A2 9B02@92537= .2: .90B<58 0./6328 34 25><79:9 <58 0.2 <704 :20/828 C/3. ./A 64: 04A23/A2 <3 25><79:9 <32: <;;9028 4 7263 .2: <3 25><79:9 89:/5> 1<582A/; /5 3.2 =2<: <58 ;<A2 34 ./0 D/77<>2 <3 8544: <58 12:64:A28 02;458 A<::/<>2 ./0 <012;3 46 3.2 A<332: /0 ;72<:7= 03<328 B= !34! - 8 - 4523.27200 <;;9028 4 /0 3.2 .90B<58 <58 <;;9028 4/03.2B:43.2:46<;;9028 4<58<;;9028 4 /03.2 A43.2:46<;;9028 4 77 3.202123/3/452:0 C2:2 :20/828 34>23.2: /5 < 0.<:28 .4902 <3 8544: 4C2D2: 3.243.2: <;;9028 /2 <;;9028 40 <58 34 <:2;45;2:5283.2=<:23.20/032:0<583.2/:.90B<580 <953<5843.2::27<3/D2046<;;9028 4C.2:2/53.2=<:2 :20/8/5>021<:<327=<745>C/3.3.2/:6<A/7=009;.3.2:2 /05409;.1400/B/7/3=463.2=.<:<00/5>:201458253 4/5 3.2A<3:/A45/<7.4A2509;.;/:;9A03<5;20<A463.2 ;450/82:28D/2C3.<33.2:2<:2 <772><3/450<:2 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 <;;9028 40 <58 <58 3.2 1:4;228/5>0<></5033.2A;<5543B2@9<0.28<33./003<>2 4C2D2: :203 46 3.2 <;;9028 /2 <;;9028 40 34<:2;45;2:5282E;2134A5/B90<772><3/450 A<82 <></503 3.2A /5 3.2 ;4A17</53 <58 03<32A2530 46 43.2: C/3520020 3.2:2 <:2 54 09;. :27/<B72 4: 1<:3/;97<: <772><3/450 <:2 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 3.2A 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 3.2 45-B72 12E 49:3 /5 3.2 ;<02 46 - 9 - :214:328 /5 ! "#$ %& <3 1<:<>:<1. 4# .278 3.<3 3.2 49:3 0.4978 B2 ;<:2697 /5 1:4;228/5> <></503 3.2 8/03<53 :27<3/D20/5;:/A2012:3</5/5>34A<3:/A45/<78/019320<58 84C:=82<3.0.2:27<3/D20463.2.90B<580.4978543B2 :4128*/5 45 3.2 B<0/0 46 4A5/B90 <772><3/450 957200 012;/6/; /503<5;2 46 3.2/: /5D47D2A253 /5 3.2 ;:/A2 <:2 A<824933/0<7040233728140/3/45467<C3.<3/6<12:045 /0 A<82 34 6<;2 < ;:/A/5<7 3:/<7 45 04A2 >252:<7 <58 0C221/5> <772><3/450 C/3.493 B:/5>/5> 45 :2;4:8 <5= 012;/6/; /503<5;20 46 ;:/A/5<7 ;4589;3 /3 /0 543./5> B93 <B902461:4;200463.249:3.249:301402<893=34 09BF2;3 3.2 <772><3/45 72D27728 /5 3.2 ;4A17</53 34 < 3.4:49>.0;:93/5=346/58493C.23.2:3.2:2/0<5=></546 3:93. /5 3.2 <772><3/450 4: C.23.2: 3.2= <:2 A<82 457= C/3. 3.2 0472 4BF2;3 46 /5D47D/5> ;2:3</5 /58/D/89<70 /5 < ;:/A/5<7 ;.<:>2 A4:2 1<:3/;97<:7= C.25 < 1:402;93/45 <:/026:4A<A<3:/A45/<78/01932 - 10 - 5 3.2 /503<53 ;<02 < B<:2 12:90<7 46 ;.<:>2 0.223A<32:/<70;72<:7=0.4C03.<33.2<772><3/450A<82B= :201458253 4 <:2 D<>92 <58 4A5/B90 1<:3 6:4A ;7</A/5> 3.<3 3.2 .90B<58 /2 <;;9028 4 <58 ./0 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 1.=0/;<77= <58 A253<77= .<:<0028 .2: :201458253 4 .<0 543 1:4D/828 <5= 012;/6/; 823</70 4: 820;:/B28<5=1<:3/;97<:/503<5;246.<:<00A253.2.<0 543A253/45283.23/A28<3217<;24:<A<552:/5C./;. 3.2 <772>28 .<:<00A253 4;;9::28 .2:264:2 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 7<;?0 ;45;:232 <58 1:2;/02 <772><3/450 .2 32:A H;:9273=I ;<5543 B2 203<B7/0.28 C/3.493 012;/6/; /503<5;2 .20<A2C2<?2503.2;<02463.21:402;93/45<58;<030 02:/490 849B3 45 3.2 1:4B<B/7/3= 46 3.2 D2:0/45 46 3.2 ;4A17</5<53.2A2:2>252:<7<772><3/45046.<:<00A253 C/3.493 14/53/5> 493 3.2 012;/6/; 823</70 C4978 543 B2 0966/;/253 34 ;453/592 ;:/A/5<7 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 <5= 12:045 3/00233728140/3/45467<C3.<349:30.<D234 B2;<:2697<58;<93/490/582<7/5>C/3.;4A17</53<58A903 - 11 - 3<?2 1:<>A<3/; :2<7/3/20 /534 ;450/82:<3/45 C./72 82<7/5> C/3. A<3:/A45/<7 8/019320 C.2:2 3.2 <772><3/450 .<D2 34 B20;:93/5/G28C/3.>:2<3;<:2<58;/:;9A012;3/45/54:82: 341:2D253A/0;<::/<>246F903/;2<58<B902461:4;20046 49:3 25;2 ;4774;<3/5> 3.2 6/58/5>0 46 3.2 45-B72 12E49:3/53.2<B4D2F98>A253343.2;<0245.<58 <A463.2;450/82:28D/2C3.<3A2:2>252:<7<772><3/450 46 .<:<00A253 C/3.493 14/53/5> 493 012;/6/; 823</70 C4978 543B20966/;/25334 ;453/592;:/A/5<71:4;228/5>0<></503 123/3/452: 40 34 <;;9028 40 34 ;;4:8/5>7=1:4;228341<003.264774C/5>+ / .2123/3/45/0 ' // .21:4;228/5>0<></503123/3/452: 40 <58 <;;9028 40<580.<77>445 /// .21:4;228/5>0<></503123/3/452: 40 34 <;;9028 40 34 /5 4% <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 - 12 - 4 :2>/032:28 B= !4A25 47/;2 <7<B9:<>/ 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 46 &() <58 #: C2;3/45 461258/5>453.2 6/72 46 88/3/45<7 /D/7 98>2 <58 " <7<B9:<>//0.2:2B=@9<0.28 *( %$' $ /03 4,7 4,