- 1 - ! "#$$ # %& %'() &%( * !! " # !! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ !! !! % &! '" ! ( ) ! ! !! ) * !! $ &! ' !)+ !! )( !))!'( ) '"( ! ! ! ,** ) ))! ) * !) ) ) * ! - 3 - ) ! ) ! ! ) " - - . /01 23404056 01 70839 :693; 3<4056 57 /=;=40>= =?=;0@:;=@1/==6/04=* 45A:=1/4/32;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1=<<:139 51 45 06 5,** =;0106? 5:4 57 ;0B3 5* ;3?0143;39C>=8=?=655;!580<3=0</:;75;4/357736<31 2:601/=C83 :693; 13<40561 =69 57 4/3 /=;=40>=>=>==6/04=* '75;1/5;4DE(236906? 564/37083570F08 :9?3=69 ) =1@0=0</:; /3 7=<4:=8 B=4;0G 57 4/3 <=13 01 4/=4 ;3125693645<5B28=06=64563 6=69C306?4/315<0=8 H5;@3; 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 56 *** C375;3 ;312569364 5%!580<3 =883?06? 4/=4 56 ,** =4 =C5:4$ *2B4/3;3H=1=<;0<@34B=4</C34H3364H5 43=B103!:6I=C06?1=695>=8/=8836?3;136?=8:;: - 4 - '(64/31=09B=4</4/343=BH564/3B=4</ =1 1:</ 45 <383C;=43 4/3 1=B3 =4 * * 2B 4/3 234040563;1 ?=4/3;39 06 4/3 C:1 1452 4 4/=4 40B3 ;312569364 5 H=1 2;31364 63=; 1=09 C:1 1452 /3 234040563;1C:;14<;=<@3;125:;39234;58064528=140< C=?1 =69 70;39 4/3B =69 4/3;3C> <=:139 5C14;:<4056 45 4/3 ;5=9 4;=6125;4=4056 C> 369=6?3;06? /:B=6 8073 /5:?/ ;3125693645=9F01394/3B65445069:8?3061:</=<4 H/0</369=6?3;4/3/:B=680734/3><56406:394/31=B3 C> 63?83<406? /01 =9F0<3 36<3 ;312569364 5 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364 5%!580<3 H/0</ ;3?0143;3906;0B35*9=439 ***75;4/3 =75;3B3640563957736<31:C13A:3648>;3125693645% !580<3 <569:<439 06F3140?=4056 =69 8=09 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1 75; 4/3 =75;3B36405639 57736<31 36<34/3234040563;1=;3C375;34/015:;445A:=1/4/3 2;5<33906?1=?=06144/3B - 5 - 3=;9 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 83=;639 0?/ 5:;4 5F3;6B364 !83=93; 75; ;312569364 5%4=43=6983=;639<5:613875;;3125693645 2=;4 7;5B :;?06? 13F3;=8 <5643640561 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 2;0B=;08> <56436439 4/=4 56 23;:1=8574/3<5B28=064=69</=;?3%1/334=F3;B364165 57736<31 /=F3 C336 B=93 5:4 :693; 4/3 2;5F010561 57 3<40561=69573<564364394/=44/3 234040563;1 =;3 14:93641 =69 4/3> =;3 2:;1:06? 4/30; ?;=9:=40563=815<564364394/=43G<32415B35B60C:1 =883?=40561 =?=0614 4/3B 06 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 65 54/3; 123<070< 5F3;4 =<41 /=F3 C336 ;325;439 304/3; 5C14;:<406? 4/32:C80<H=>5;=<43963?80?3648>06;3123<4573G28510F3 1:C14=6<34/3;3C><5BB04406?=6=<4369=6?3;06?807345 23;156=81=734>61:</<0;<:B14=6<31/32;=>145=885H 4/323404056 83=;639<5:613875;;3125693645 1:CB041 4/=4 4/3 06F3140?=4056 01 <5B283439 =69 </=;?3 1/334/=1C33670839/314=43B364573>3H046311=694/3 - 6 - =F3;B3641B=93064/3</=;?3%1/334;3F3=814/=44/3;301 <=13B=935:4=?=06144/3234040563;175;4/3 57736<314/3>/=F3C336</=;?31/33439 <<5;906?8>4/3 2;5<33906?1<=6654C3A:=1/39=?=06144/3234040563;1 # 3=;639 0?/ 5:;4 5F3;6B364 !83=93; 75; ;312569364 5%4=43 5225139 4/3 2;=>3; =69 2;=>1 45 901B0114/323404056 $ /=F3 ?0F36 B> =6G05:1 <561093;=4056 56 4/3 1:CB011056B=93C>4/383=;639<5:613875;4/3;3123<40F3 2=;4031=6995<:B3641=F=08=C8356;3<5;9 123;4/3<5B28=064=F3;B36414/3234040563;1 C306? 14:93641 H/083 <383C;=406? 4/3 F0<45;> 57 43=B 56 ,** 4/3> 5C14;:<439 4/3 ;5=9 =69 <383C;=439 C> C:;1406? <;=<@3;1 =69 =815 25:;39 234;58 0645 28=140< C=?1=691344/3B5670;3 , 6<=;37:823;:1=8574/306?;3903641573<4056 574/31=B3;3F3=814/=4H/53F3;9531=6>=<4 15;=1/8>5;63?80?3648>=145369=6?3;/:B=680735;4/3 - 7 - 23;156=8 1=734> 57 54/3;1 1/=88 C3 2:601/39 H04/ 0B2;0156B364 57 304/3; 931<;024056 75; = 43;B H/0</ B=> 3G4369454/;33B564/15;H04/7063H/0</B=>3G436945 4H54/5:1=6970F3/:69;39;:23315;H04/C54/C:4'=( H/3;3 4/3 /:;4 01 <=:139 1/=88 C3 2:601/39 H04/ 0B2;0156B364 57 304/3; 931<;024056 75; = 43;B H/0</ B=> 3G4369 45 10G B564/1 5; H04/ 7063 H/0</ B=> 3G4369 45 70F3 4/5:1=69 ;:2331 5; H04/ C54/+ 'C( H/3;3 ?;03F5:1 /:;4 01 <=:139 1/=88 C3 2:601/39 H04/ 0B2;0156B364 57 304/3; 931<;024056 75; = 43;B H/0</ B=> 3G4369 45 4/;33 >3=;1 5; H04/ 7063 H/0</ B=> 3G4369 45 436 4/5:1=69 ;:23315;H04/C54/5H3F3;5623;:1=857</=;?3%1/334 B=43;0=81651:</;=1/=6963?80?364=<41564/32=;457 4/3 234040563;1 =;3 75;4/<5B06? 06 4/3 <5B28=064 =69 4/3 </=;?3%1/334B=43;0=81 * 1 23; 54/3; 57736<31 =;3 <56<3;639 3<4056 57;3=914/=4H/53F3;C>9506?=6>=<45;C> 5B04406?454=@35;93;H04/=6>2;523;4>06/012511311056 5;:693;/01</=;?3<=:1319=6?3;5C14;:<40565;06I:;> - 8 - 45 =6> 23;156 06 =6> 2:C80< H=> 5; 2:C80< 8063 57 6=F0?=40561/=88C32:601/39H04/7063H/0</B=>3G4369 45 70F3 4/5:1=69 ;:2331 5H3F3; 06 4/3 <=13 56 /=69 4/3;301651:</<5B28=0644/=4234040563;15C14;:<4394/3 2:C80<H=>5;8063576=F0?=4056106<34/32:C80<5;5H63;1 57F3/0<8315;4/323;1561064/31=09;5=9/=F3654859?39 =6><5B28=064 3<4056 57 ;3=91 4/=4 H/53F3; 9531 H04/ =6> 3G28510F3 1:C14=6<3 =6> =<4 15 ;=1/8> 5; 63?80?3648> =1 45 369=6?3; /:B=6 8073 5; 45 C3 80@38> 45 <=:13/:;45;06I:;>45=6>54/3;23;1565;@65H06?8>5; 63?80?3648> 5B041 45 4=@3 1:</ 5;93; H04/ =6> 3G28510F3 1:C14=6<3 06 /01 2511311056 =1 01 1:770<0364 45 ?:=;9 =?=0614 =6> 2;5C=C83 9=6?3; 45 /:B=6 8073 7;5B 4/=4 1:C14=6<3 1/=88 C3 2:601/39 H04/ 0B2;0156B36457 304/3; 931<;02405675;=43;BH/0</B=>3G43694510GB564/15; H04/ 7063 H/0</ B=> 3G4369 45 70F3 4/5:1=69 ;:2331 5; H04/C54/ - 9 - 64/3<=1356/=694/5:?/0401=F3;;39064/3 <5B28=064 4/=4 4/3 =<<:139 H3;3 :106? 4/3 234;58 C5BC1 03C>25:;06?234;58064/328=140<C=?14/3>4/;5H64/3B C>834406?70;34/3</=;?31/334B=43;0=89531654901<8513 =6>1:</B=;@15;10?61064/328=<35706<093644/=4H=1 9563H04/234;58C5BC1 5;35F3;4/3;3=;365B=43;0=81 75; /=F06? 2:;</=139 4/3 234;58 5; 28=140< C=?1 1 1:</ 3<4056=8159531654=44;=<4=?=06144/3234040563;1 /3234040563;1C306?4/314:93641106<34/3;3 =;3568>5B60C:1=883?=4056175;4/<5B06?=?=06144/3B06 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 =B 57 4/3 <561093;39 F03H 4/=4 4/3 <56406:=4056 57 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/313 234040563;1=<<:139 51 45 01 654/06? C:4 =C:13 57 2;5<311575:;436<34/32;5<33906?1=?=06144/3B01 80=C8345C3A:=1/39 <<5;906?8>2=114/375885H06?- 0( /32340405601 00( /3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1% =<<:139 51 45 06 - 10 - 5,** =;0106? 5:4 57 ;0B3 5* ;3?0143;39 C> =8=?=655; !580<3 =0</:; 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/=C83 :693; 13<40561 =69 57 4/3 /=;=40>= >=>= =6/04= * '75; 1/5;4 DE( 236906? 56 4/3 7083 57 0F08 :9?3 =69 ) =1@0 =0</:;01/3;3C>A:=1/39 +) %$( $ 0145-85- -