- 1 - !"!# $%" " % &' &()* & ) + !"!#$ $ %& !"!%# % ' !"!%# # !"!#$ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ' !"!%$! ( ) * $ %" !"!%# ( ) + $ * !$" )* "$ )* $!$#$$ "$#$ %$% %$ %! %!! !# !#& % ! ! , , - - 3 - ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582: 2;3/45 !$" 46 .<:<3/=< <><:/? 9:<?0.< <5./3<$#$%34@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0<;;9028 40 34 ! /5 4$!$#$$ <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4"$#$ :2>/032:28 B= 2C<:>/ 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 %$% %$ %! %!! !# <58 !#& :C 2;3/45%46 1:202537=1258/5>453.26/7246 25/4: /D/798>2<58 <32C<:>/ $ .26<;39<7A<3:/E463.2;<02/03.<3123/3/452: 4%/2<;;90284%<0<D<:<F6/728<;49532:;7</A/5 <09/364:1<:3/3/456/728B=./00/032: 95<58<<></503./0 6<3.2:<5843.2:F4/53;41<:;252:/5 4$!$#&.2 0</8 ;49532: ;7</A 6/728 B= ./A ;<A2 34 B2 <774C28 .2 :2014582534$-0.90B<58<58.2:B:43.2:/57<C<58./0 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 C2:2 826258<530 /5 3.2 0</8 09/3 201458253 4$G0 .90B<58 C<0 < 1<:3= /5 3.2 0</8 4:/>/5<7 09/3 4$!$#& 0 09;. /3 /0 <772>28 3.<3 <;;9028 4% <745> C/3. ./0 C/62 @9<::27/5> C/3. - 4 - :2014582534$<58.2:6<A/7=A2AB2:03.<33.2/:0.<:2 .<034B2<7743328/53.2<5;203:<71:412:3= % 5 $#$#$ <3 <B493 ## <A C.25 :2014582534$G0.90B<5825><>28/53.2179AB/5>C4:? <3.2:.4902.2A<32:5<795;7246<;;90284$5<A27= <><55<3./2<;;90284<745>C/3.<;;902840<58 ! 3:201<0028 3.2 .4902 46 :201458253 4$ <58 <B9028 .2:/5<6/73.=7<5>9<>264:543>/D/5>3.21:412:0.<:2/5 3.2<5;203:<71:412:3=.2:2<632:<;;90284<00<97328 45 .2: 034A<;. <58 43.2: <;;9028 C2:2 493:<>28 .2: A48203= .25 .2: .90B<58 /532:62:28 34 1<;/6= 3.2 @9<::273.2=<704<00<97328./A<5864/03287/623.:2<334 B43. 46 3.2A 3 /0 03<328 3.<3 <3 3.2 3/A2 46 /5;/8253 :201458253 4$ C<0 ' A453.0 1:2>5<53 <32: <3 <B493 %#<A45;2<></53.2<;;902840$<58%;<A234 3.2 .4902 46 :201458253 4$ <58 <B9028 .2: <58 .2: .90B<58<58<704<00<97328C/3.<;79B453.2034A<;.46 :201458253 4$ 9:3.2: 3.2 <;;9028 <704 <00<97328 34 3.2 A43.2:/57<C 46 :201458253 4$ <58 892 34 3.2 - 5 - 0<A2 0.2 0903</528 B7228/5> /5F9:/20 45 .2: .2<8 25;2 0.2 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</53 B264:2 3.2 :201458253 4 47/;2 C./;. C<0 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4"$#$ 8<328 ##!$#$ 64: 3.2 46625;2 A<5<>2<B72 9582: 2;3/45%'"%$%%$%!!%!!#!#&C 2;3/45 46 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 9B02@92537= :201458253 4 47/;2 /5D203/><328 3.2 ;<02 <58 7</8 ;.<:>2 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/45 %$% %$ %! %!! !#<58!#&:C 2;3/45%46 B=<::<=/5>3.2A<0 <;;9028 40 34 ! <028 45 3.2 0<A2 3.2 72<:528 A<>/03:<32 344? ;4>5/H<5;2 46 3.2 46625;20 25;2 <>>:/2D28 B= 3.2 0<A2 3.2 123/3/452:0 1:262::28 3./0 123/3/4534@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 2<:8 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58 3.2 72<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 64: 3.2 :2014582534 3<32 ! 1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02D2:<7 ;453253/450 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 ;45325828 3.<3 3./0 - 6 - ;4A17</53 /0 6/728 B= :201458253 4$ 493 46 D25>2<5;2 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 0/5;2 3.2 09/3 <58 ;49532: ;7</A 6/728 B= <;;9028 4% <></503 3.2 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 46 :2014582534$C<082;:228<58<0.<:2C<0<774332834 .2: /5 3.2 <5;203:<7 1:412:3= 4 09B03<53/<32 3.2 0</8 <012;3 .2 17<;28 3.2 F98>A253 /5 4$!$#& 2 <704;453258283.<33.2<;;90284$6/728<0A<5=<0! ;4A17</530 <></503 :201458253 4$ <58 .2: 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 C./;. <:2 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4%$$#& $#$#" $&&$#" "!$#$ %$#$ ;;4:8/5> 34 ./AB264:23.28<3246/5;/8253<704<;4A17</53C<06/728 B= 3.2<;;9028 4$ <></503 :201458253 4$ <5843.2:0 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 C./;. C<0 :2>/032:28 /5 ;:/A2 4"!$#$.2:2<632:<0<;49532:B7<033./0;4A17</53 C<06/728B=:2014582534$509;.;/:;9A03<5;20.2 09BA/30 3.<3 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 543./5> B93 <B902 46 1:4;200 46 ;49:3 ;;4:8/5>7= .2 1:<=034<774C3.2123/3/45 - 7 - & 3.272<:528 />.49:34D2:5A253 72<82:41140283.2123/3/45<58;453258283.<33.2:2<:2 ;<02 <58 ;49532: ;<02 <></503 <;;9028 40$ I % <58 :2014582534$49532:;<02.<06/728B=<;;90284$ <></5033.2;4A17</5<53<58.2:.90B<58<58.2:/57<C0 /5:/A24"!$#$009;./3/0;72<:3.<33.2/5;/8253 C<0 ;<9028 45 $#$#$ 4:24D2: 3.2:2 <:2 6/D2 ;4A17</530 748>28 B= <;;9028 4$ <></503 3.2 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 46 :201458253 4$ ;;4:8/5> 34 3.2 72<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 45 12:90<7 46 3.2 ;4A17</53<D2:A25303.2/5/3/<7/5;/8253.<03<?2517<;2/5 3.2.490246:2014582534$<3<B493##<A<33.<3 3/A2 <;;9028 4 <58 ! C2:2 <772>287= 1:20253 <58 7<32: <3 <B493 %# <A 3.2 <;;9028 40$ <58 % 3:201<0028 /534 3.2 .4902 46 :201458253 4$ <58 <00<97328 .2: <33.<3 3/A2 3.2 <;;902840 <58 ! C2:2543/53.20;2524646625;2 2<704;453253283.<3 54C 3.2 :201458253 4 47/;2 .<0 ;4A172328 3.2 - 8 - /5D203/><3/45 <58 7</8 ;.<:>2 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 25;2.21:<=0348/0A/003.2123/3/45 ' .<D2>/D25A=<5E/490;450/82:<3/45B43.45 3.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D2 1<:3/20 <58 12:9028 3.2 84;9A2530 A<82 <D</7<B7245:2;4:8 " 0 ;4978 B2 ><3.2:28 6:4A ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<70 <8A/33287= 3.2:2 /0 < ;/D/7 8/01932 1258/5> B23C225 <;;9028 4$ % <58 3.2 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 46 :201458253 4$ /5 4$!$#& 0 09;. A973/172 ;4A17</530 748>28 B= <;;9028 4$ <></503 3.2 6<A/7= A2AB2:046:2014582534$<58.2:6<A/7=A2AB2:05 3.2 8<32 46 <772>28 /5;/8253 <704 < ;4A17</53 .<0 B225 748>28B=<;;90284$<></503:2014582534$<583.2/: 6<A/7= A2AB2:0 0 09;. <0 :/>.37= ;45325328 B= 3.2 72<:528 />. 49:3 4D2:5A253 72<82: 3.2 /5;/8253 ;<5543 B2 825/28 4C2D2: 3.2 1<:3/;/1<3/45 46 <;;9028 4<58!<112<:034B2849B369764:3.2:2<0453.<3 3.2= <:2 3.2 :20/8253 46 <><5>2:< D/77<>2 /2 6<: <C<= - 9 - 6:4A3.217<;246/5;/8253;;4:8/5>34:2014582534$ 3.2 /5/3/<7 /5;/8253 C<0 ;<9028 <3 ## <A <58 09B02@92537= <3 %# <A 3.2 <;;9028 4$ <58 % 3:201<0028/534.2:.4902<33.<33/A23.2<;;902840 <58!C2:2543/53.20;2524646625;2 .2C4958;2:3/6/;<3217<;28B=3.2:201458253 4$<70484205438/0;7402<5=B7228/5>/5F9:/20<583.2 <772><3/450 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: 4 <58 ! <:2 4A5/B9054 A<32:/<70<:217<;28<></5033.2A <B4933.2/:/5D47D2A253/53.2<772>2846625;2 # 5;<:269712:90<7463.2;.<:>20.223A<32:/<70 0/5;2 3.2:2 <:2 A973/172 7/3/><3/45 B43. ;/D/7 <58 ;:/A/5<7 1258/5><></503<;;90284$%<583.26<A/7=A2AB2:0 46:2014582534$3.2/A17/;<3/45463.2123/3/452:40 <58 ! <112<:0 34 B2 493 46 D25>2<5;2 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20 45 4D2:<77 12:90<7 46 3.2 A<32:/<70 45 :2;4:8<A463.2;450/82:28D/2C3.<33.2;453/59<3/45 463.2;:/A/5<71:4;228/5>0<></5033.2123/3/452:40 <58!/2<;;90284<58!/0<5<B902461:4;20046 - 10 - 49:3 0/5;2 3.2 0<A2 /0 A<5/62037= 6:/D47490 4: D2E<3/490 4: /503/39328 C/3. 3.2 9732:/4: A43/D2 64: C:2<?/5> D25>2<5;2 .2 253/:2 <772><3/45 /5 3.2 <58 ;.<:>2 0.223 <;;21328 45 /30 6<;2 D<792 2D25 3.25 3.2 0<A2 ;4978 543 ;4503/3932 <5 46625;20 ;.<:>2 0.22328<></5033.2<;;90284<58! 2: ;453:< 45 12:90<7 46 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<7 3.2:2 <:2 <772><3/450 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 <;;9028 40$ <58 % ;;4:8/5>7= 1:4;228 34 1<003.264774C/5>, / .2123/3/45/0 / .2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: 40$ <58 % /2 <;;9028 40$ <58 % 0.<77 ;453/592 .2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452: 40 <58 ! /2 <;;9028 40 <58 ! /5 - 11 - 4$!$#$$ <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4"$#$ :2>/032:28 B= 2C<:>/ 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 %$% %$%!%!!!#<58!#&:C 2;3/45%46 1:202537=1258/5>453.26/7246 25/4:/D/7 98>2<58 <32C<:>//0.2:2B=@9<0.28 ,* &" ) " /034, 74,$# ,