- 1 - !!" #$%% $ & &'()* &( + ! ! ! " #! # $ ! % ! & ! $ ' ( # # % ! % )" Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! # ! !! !# ' (! %* "#+ % $)" % & ! """ ! " ! & ! "" %% # !% !& % , % !!"""%%% $ $" % ) "" % % % # !% !% !%! ! - !- .! /01 23404056 01 70839 :693; 3<4056 ") 57 /=;=40>= =?=;0@=:;=@1/==6/04=""45A:=1/4/32;5<33906?106 5 "" =;0106? 5:4 57 ;0B3 5 " 9=439 "" ;3?0143;39 C> 4/3 3B=8@/39 580<3 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1 =69 =654/3; 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/=C83 :693; - 3 - 3<40561$ =69$"57 236906?564/37083573605;0D08 :9?3=69!%:B6=C=9 " /3 7=<4:=8 B=4;0E 57 4/3 =13 01 4/=4 ;312569364 5"4/3 3<;34=;> 57 =;6=4=@= 5;93; ;3= 3D3852B364 :4/5;04> (/3;306=743; F4/3 :4/5;04>G+ 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364 5 580<3 4/=4 4/3 :4/5;04> /=9 1=6<405639 1 06 7=D5:; 57 ;0 /0;90 =0 =C= 9:<=4056=8=69:;=83D3852B364:84:;=8;:14(/3;306=743; F4/3;:14G+3B=8@/39#088=?3:B6=C=9=8:@09=;014;0<4 75; <5614;:<4056 57 = :84:;=8 /=D=6 4 01 =883?39 4/=4 56 """=69)""4/31=09=B5:64H=1 901C:;139 C> 4/3 :4/5;04> 06 7=D5:; 57 4/3 ;:14 H/0</ 01 /3=939 C> 563 #=0I06=4/ =<<:139 5 4 01 7:;4/3; =883?39 4/=4 56 " = I5064 06123<4056 H=1 <569:<439 C> ;312569364 5" =856? H04/ /01 43=B =69 =<<:139 5 H/3;306 04 H=1 ;3D3=839 4/=4 4/3 :84:;=8 /=D=6 H=1 <5614;:<439 06 4/3 70;14 7855; 57 = ;31093640=8 C:08906? C> 4/3 ;:144/5:?/4/3=B5:64H=11=6<40563945<5614;:<44/31=09 /=D=656=132=;=43104375;4/32:C80<:1311:</04<=B3 45 4/3 @65H839?3 57 ;312569364 5" 4/=4 4/3 =B5:64 57 - 4 - 1 1=6<405639 C> 4/3 :4/5;04> H=1 B01:139 C> 4/3 ;3109364 57 4/3 ;:14 H/3;306 4/313 234040563;1 =;3 4/3 1=6<405606? =:4/5;04031 1 1:</ 4/3 <5B28=06=64 859?39 4/3 <5B28=064 C375;3 ;312569364 5 580<3 =69 4/3 1=B3 H=1 ;3?0143;39 06 ;0B3 5 " :C13A:3648> ;312569364 5 580<3 <569:<439 4/3 06D3140?=4056=698=09</=;?31/334=?=06144/3 ;3109364574/3 ;:14 =69 =?=0614 4/313 234040563;1 C> =;;=>06? 4/3B =1 =<<:13951"=69H/3;306040114=4394/=44/313234040563;1 1=6<4056394/313<569=694/0;90614=88B3641H04/5:4D3;07>06? 4/3 H5;@ =139 56 4/3 ;3<3024 57 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 83=;639 !=?014;=43 455@ <5?60J=6<3 57 4/3 57736<31 ??;03D39 C> 4/3 1=B3 4/3 234040563;1 2;373;;39 4/01 23404056 45 A:=1/ 4/3 2;5<33906?1 3=;9 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 =69 83=;639 0?/ 5:;4 5D3;6B364 83=93; 75; 4/3 ;312569364 4=43 /5:?/ 6540<3 01 13;D39 45 ;312569364 5" /3 ;3B=0639=C1364 $ 3=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563;1 ;3043;=439 4/3 ?;5:691:;?39064/323404056=692;0B=;08><564369394/=44/3 - 5 - <5?60J=6<35;93;574/3!=?014;=4301C=;;39C>8=H75;H=6457 1=6<4056 <<5;906? 45 /0B 4/313 234040563;1 C306? 4/3 ?5D3;6B36413;D=6414/3=883?=4056=?=06144/3B014/=4H/083 901</=;?06? 4/30; 5770<0=8 9:4>4/3> <5BB04439 4/313 57736<31 =11:</4/31=6<405601D3;>B:</;3A:0;39452;513<:434/3B /5:?/ 4/3 <56<3;639 =:4/5;04> =228039 75; 1=6<4056 4/;5:?/ 4/35D3;6B364:4/5;04>4/31=6<4056?;=643956)""" =?=0614 234040563; 5 01 H04/9;=H6 D093 5;93; 9=439 """ 8=<06? 4/3 1=B3 56 ;380=6<3 5D3;6B364 /=1 90;3<4394/30;3<45;=4357<565B0<1=694=40140<14506123<4 =69 4=@3 =<4056 =?=0614 234040563; 5" > 3B2/=10J06? 56 4/51395<:B3641/32;=>145=885H4/323404056 83=;639 5225139 4/3 2;=>3; 56 4/3 ?;5:69 4/=4 65H </=;?3 1/334 /=1 C336 70839 =69 H/083 1=6<405606? 4/3 =883?39 0614=88B3641 4/3 234040563;1 H3;3 654 901</=;?06? 4/30; 5770<0=8 9:4> =1 1:</ 4/3 =883?=4056 =?=0614 4/3234040563;19531654<5B3H04/064/32:;D03H575770<0=89:4> 574/3234040563;1 61:</<0;<:B14=6<31=6<4056B=>654C3 ;3A:0;39 45 2;513<:43 4/3 234040563;1 36<3 4/3 83=;639 - 6 - !=?014;=43 /=1 ;0?/48> 4=@36 <5?60J=6<3 57 4/3 57736<31 <<5;906?8>/32;=>145901B0114/323404056 /=D3?0D36B>=6E05:1<561093;=4056C54/564/3 1:CB0110561 B=93 C> 4/3 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 ;3123<40D3 2=;4031=6923;:1394/395<:B3641B=93=D=08=C8356;3<5;9 1<5:89C3?=4/3;397;5B;3<5;91=9B044398>4/3 <5B28=064H=1859?39C>3125693645"C>=883?06?4/=44/3 =B5:64571 H=11=6<40563975;4/3<5614;:<4056 57 :84:;=8 /=D=6 =4 3B=8@/39 =69 =<<:139 5 01 4/3 2;3109364571=09;:14/3=883?=4056=?=06144/313234040563;1 01 4/=4 4/3> C306? 4/3 3<;34=;> =69 3<4056 770<3;1 57 4/3 1=6<405606? :4/5;04> 1=6<405639 4/3 13<569 =69 4/0;9 0614=88B3641H04/5:4D3;07>06?4/3<5614;:<4056H5;@<569:<439 C> =<<:139 5 4 01 14=439 4/=4 4/3 :84:;=8 /=D=6 H=1 <5614;:<439064/3 70;147855;57=;31093640=8/5:1306143=957 <5614;:<406? 56 = 132=;=43 1043 =69 4/3 <5B28=064 =D3;B3641 901<8513 4/=4 =<<:139 5 01 ;3125610C83 75; 1:</ B0193391 5H3D3;9:;06?4/3<5:;135706D3140?=40560401=883?394/=4 4/313234040563;1=8157=083945901</=;?34/30;5770<0=89:4>H04/ ;3125610C0804> C> 3E=B0606? 4/3 H5;@ :693;?563 1 1:</ 04 - 7 - <5:89 C3 ?=4/3;39 4/=4 4/3 =<4 01 <5BB04439 C> 4/313 234040563;1 H/083 901</=;?06? 4/30; 5770<0=8 9:4> 36<3 45 2;513<:43 4/3B 06 = <;0B06=8 57736<3 1=6<4056 01 ;3A:0;39 =1 /389C>4/356.C8323E5:;4064/3<=1357 ;325;439 06 06 =;=?;=2/5/389=1:693;- ! ) 228>06? 4/3 706906?1 57 4/356GC83 23E 5:;4 06 4/3=C5D31=09<=13454/37=<41=69<0;<:B14=6<31574/01<=13 =69 =815 <561093;06? 4/3 =123<4 4/=4 65H =<<:139 5 /=1 ;30BC:;139 4/3 3640;3 =B5:64 57 1 45 4/3 =:4/5;04>=B574/3<561093;39D03H4/=44/3<56406:=405657 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 4/313 234040563;1 =B5:641 45 =C:13 57 2;5<311575:;4<<5;906?8>2;5<339452=114/375885H06?* - 8 - 0 /32340405601 00 /3 2;5<33906?1 =?=0614 234040563;1 =<<:139 51"=69065 ""=;0106?5:4 57 ;0B3 5 " 9=439 "" ;3?0143;39 C> 4/3 3B=8@/39 580<3 =?=0614 4/3 234040563;1 =69 =654/3; 75; 4/3 57736<31 2:601/=C83 :693; 3<40561 $ =69 $" 57 236906?564/37083573605;0D08:9?3 =69!%:B6=C=901/3;3C>A:=1/39 ,) &%( % ! 0145-85-) -