- 1 - !"!# $%" " % &' &()* '& ) + ! " # $% % & ' ( ) %! % # $ * ) % & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ") $ & ) + ) + , "-" ))$ ) ))" ' & -$)& -$)&-$&)"$"&$&" - ) % %! ! ! . . / ! ! 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 ) 68 )) 56 >;?20 504 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504 345151674< ?==;24: 6 17 6"-" )) ?<1217@ 6;5 68<1A46) ))"<4@1254<4:BC5?5167?D?<691=4 ?9?B;<?@16;50;B1E1216786<50468847=423;7120?B94 ;7:4< 4=51672 -$)& -$)& -$& )"$"& $& " <4?: F150 4=5167 - 68 ))?7: 4=5167 )68 <4E475167 68 425<;=5167 ?7: 622 68 <634<5C =5 3<424759C 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 <17=13?9 1E19 !;:@4 ?7: !?5?9?B;<?@1 - 3 - ) 04 8?=5;?9 A?5<1G 68 504 =?24 12 50?5 674 ?2?E?<?H? ?55?7?I?< 14 <42367:475 6) 96:@4: ? =6A39?175B486<4<42367:47563691=467-)))" ?994@17@ 50?5 67 50?5 :?C ?5 ?B6;5 " 3A F047 04 F?2 3<6=44:17@ 74?< 504 6881=4 68 504 43;5C 6AA1221674< 17 012 ?;56 504 346394 68 ?7H?<? 26=145C F4<4 3<6542517@ ?7: ?5 50?5 51A4 26A4 A12=<4?752 8<6A 504@<6;3683<654254<2=?A4BC069:17@251=I2?7:256742 ?7: 015 012 ?;56 F150 504 2?A4 ?7: :?A?@4: 504 <4?< 17:1=?56< 68504 ?;56 ?7: ?92650421:4B6:C =6E4<68 504 ?;56 =?;217@ :?A?@4 F6<50 68 2 04<4?854< 504 A12=<4?752 ?926 015 504 =6A39?17?75 F150 ? 25674 67 504 <1@05 21:4 68 012 04?: ?54< 504 =6A39?17?75 =?A4 56 I76F 50?5 ? 84F :?C2 ?@6 ? 54?=04< 8<6A 504 ;291A =6AA;715C 0?: <?34: ? A176< @1<9 8<6A 504 ?7H?<? =6AA;715C 17 ?:<?A1 6F7 ?7: 504 2?1: 3<65425 F?2 @617@ 67 BC :4A?7:17@ 24E4<4 3;7120A475 86< 504 2?1: ?==;24: 2 2;=0 04 96:@4: 504 =6A39?175 B486<4 504 <42367:475 J 3691=4 F01=0 F?2 =?A4 56 B4 <4@1254<4: 17 - 4 - <1A4 6) ))" :?54: -)))" 86< 504 ?86<4A4751674:68847=42?@?172521G34<26726F4E4<?5 504 51A4 68 81917@ =0?<@420445 5012 345151674< F?2 1A391=?54:?2?==;24:6?994@17@50?50417251@?54:504 6504<?==;24: 7<4=413568=0?<@420445=6@71D?7=40?2 B447 5?I47 BC 504 94?<74: ?@125<?54 @@<14E4: BC 504 2?A4504345151674<12B486<450126;<5 4?<: 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< ?7: 94?<74:::986<<42367:47565?54 " 3?<5 8<6A ;<@17@ 24E4<?9 =6754751672 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1A?<19C =6754754: 50?5 504 345151674< 0?2 741504< 3?<51=13?54: 17 504 17=1:475 76< 3<42475 ?5 504 2365 68 17=1:475 6< 504 81<25 51A4 ?5 504 51A46881917@=0?<@42044504F?21A391=?54:17504=<1A4 67504?994@?516750?50417251@?54:?==;24:62)56(56 =6AA15 504 =<1A4 17=1:475 ==6<:17@ 56 01A 504<4 12 ? 369151=?9 <1E?9<C B45F447 504 345151674< ?7: 504 =6A39?17?7522;=0043<?C256?996F50434515167 - 5 - 94?<74: ::9 BC 6336217@ 504 34515167=67547:4:50?550417E4251@?51673?34<<4E4?92504 17E69E4A475685012345151674<1750417=1:475==6<:17@56 01AF1574225650417=1:475=94?<9C25?54:50?5:;456504 17251@?5167685012345151674<679C50417=1:475F?2=?;24: 22;=0043<?C256:12A12250434515167 0?E4@1E47AC?7G16;2=6721:4<?5167B65067 504 2;BA1221672 A?:4 BC 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51E43?<5142?7:504:6=;A4752?E?19?B9467<4=6<: ( 2=6;9:B4@?504<4:8<6A<4=6<:2151276517 :123;5450?5504345151674<F?27653<42475?55042=47468 6==;<<47=4 67 504 :?54 68 17=1:475 04 =6A39?175 F?2 96:@4:?@?1725?==;24:62)56(50?5504C0?E417:;9@4: 17 504 ?=5 BC :?A?@17@ 504 ?;56 68 504 =6A39?17?75 ?7: ?926 BC ?22?;9517@ 01A 79C ?5 50451A4 68 81917@=0?<@4 20445 504 <42367:4753691=4 1A391=?54: 5012 345151674< ?2 ?==;24: 6 ?994@17@ 50?5 5012 345151674< 17251@?54: 504 6504< ?==;24: 56 =6AA15 504 =<1A4 04<4 12 76 2;=0 234=181=?994@?5167?@?17255012345151674< - 6 - 5 12 76F F499 245594: 50?5 504 =67517;?5167 68 504=<1A17?93<6=44:17@2?@?1725?7C34<26767504B?212 68 ? 8<1E696;2 ?7: E4G?516;2 =6A39?175 12 26A45017@ E4<C 24<16;2012F6;9:5?<71205041A?@468?34<267?@?1725 F06A 8?924 8<1E696;2 ?7: E4G?516;2 ?994@?51672 ?<4 94E4994: 04 67/B94 34G 6;<5 17 504 =?24 68 <436<54: 17 049: 50?5 F0474E4< ?7 ?==;24: =6A42 B486<4 504 6;<5 17E6I17@ 41504< 504 1704<475 36F4<2 ;7:4< 4=5167 ") 68 < 6< 4G5<?6<:17?<C H;<12:1=5167;7:4<<51=94)) 68=672515;516756@45504 6<=<1A17?93<6=44:17@2>;?204:4224751?99C67504@<6;7: 50?52;=03<6=44:17@2?<4A?7184259C8<1E696;26<E4G?516;2 6< 172515;54: F150 504 ;954<16< A651E4 86< F<4?I17@ E47@4?7=45047172;=0=1<=;A25?7=46;<56F42?:;5C 56966I1756504F150=?<4?7:?915594A6<4=96249C5 F199 765 B4 H;25 476;@0 86< 504 6;<5 56 966I 1756 504 ?E4<A4752 A?:4 17 504 =6A39?175 ?9674 86< 504 3;<362468?2=4<5?1717@F04504<50474=422?<C17@<4:14752 - 7 - 56=672515;54504?994@4:68847=4?<4:12=9624:6<765 7 5046504<0?7:5046;<56F42?:;5C56966I1756A?7C 6504<?5547:17@=1<=;A25?7=44A4<@17@8<6A504<4=6<:68 504 =?24 6E4< ?7: ?B6E4 504 ?E4<A4752 ?7: 18 744:B4 F150 :;4 =?<4 ?7: =1<=;A234=5167 5<C 56 <4?: 17 B45F447 50491742046;<5F01944G4<=1217@152H;<12:1=5167;7:4< 4=5167 ") 68 < 6< <51=94 )) 68 672515;5167 744: 765 <425<1=5 152498 679C 56 504 25?@4 68 ? =?24 B;5 12 4A36F4<4:565?I41756?=6;755046E4<?99=1<=;A25?7=42 94?:17@5650417151?5167 <4@125<?516768504=?24?2F499?2 504A?54<1?92=6994=54:17504=6;<246817E4251@?5167 - 339C17@504?B6E4817:17@26850467/B9434G 6;<5565048?=5?7:=1<=;A25?7=42685012=?24?A68 504 =6721:4<4: E14F 50?5 4E47 18 504 4751<4 ?994@?51672 17 504=0?<@4204455?I47671528?=4E?9;4504<412762;=0 =?24A?:46;5?@?17255012345151674<22;=0 =67517;?5167 68 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 5012 345151674< 12 765017@B;5?B;24683<6=422686;<5 ==6<:17@9C5043451516712 - 8 - 04 3<6=44:17@2 17 6"-" )) $<1A4 6) ))"685?5167?D?<691=4?9?B;<?@1&86<504 68847=42 3;7120?B94 ;7:4< 4=51672 -$)& -$)& -$&)"$"&$&"<4?:F1504=5167-68 ))?7:4=5167)68<4E47516768425<;=5167?7:622 68 <634<5C =5 - 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 <9 1E19 !;:@4K!?9?B;<?@1?@?17255012345151674< ?==;24: 61204<4BC ! ,* &" ) " . . .!