Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54918 (KAR)

BASAVALAING NAYAK v. SMT ERAMMA

WA/200265/2025 · 2026-01-07

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $%!! $%! !& ## '( !"# $ % & ' " (# !" Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # & ()))" ")" ! * + !")" * !" ( !" , & *- !" $ % ". #. - 3 - ! (' ! ) ),#)# % )#)/#)#' & #))!!#)# %-' & & 0&& 123 0& & !% % 0&&' 45 166577128 419 :417752;53 12 <=35= 31853 ) ),#)# 619953 >? 751=253 @2;75 &A3;5 <B 84@9 <A=8 @2<#))!#)# # 45 B1:89 8418 :12 >5 ;1845=53 B=<C 845 D=@8 658@8@<21=58418=596<23528<"D1912575:853C5C>5= <B 81E12<<= =1C 12:41?18 123 D19 575:853 <2 )"##)#) A=@2; 845 "84 @212:@17 712 B<= 845 ?51= #)##-#)# :5=81@2 6A>7@: D<=E9 <B 845 612:41?18 D5=5 - 4 - 177<8853 8< =596<23528 <" 8 16651=9 8418 845=5 D5=5 :5=81@2@==5;A71=@8@59@2845"84@212:@17712B<=845?51= #)##-#)#1231:<C671@28@28418=5;1=3D197<3;53>? 84516657712845=5@2B<77<D@2;D4@:4=596<23528<4573 6=<:553@2;91239A>C@88531=56<=88<=596<23528<!<2 "/""#)## 8418 845=5 D5=5 95F5=17 @==5;A71=@8@59 45 12:41?18 5F57<6C528 BB@:5= D19 9A9652353 B=<C 95=F@:5 <2 # ""#)## 45 =596<23528 <! 8452 =5GA59853 =596<23528 < 8< 4<73 6=<:553@2;9 B<= 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 <B 845 166577128 A235= 5:8@<2 !%F' <B 845 12:41?18 1H :8 "// %45=5@21B85= =5B5==53 8< 19 I845 :8 "//J B<= >=5F@8?' B<77<D@2; D4@:4 52GA@=? 6=<:553@2;9 D5=5 4573 >? =596<23528 < 123 1 =56<=8 D19 9A>C@8853 8< =596<23528 <# 45 =596<23528 <# 65=A953845=56<=8123B<A2384188459<2<B=596<23528 <" D19 845 =5:@6@528 <B 1 9AC <B 9#! (( - 123 845=5B<=5 4573 8418 =596<23528 <" 413 @2:A==53 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 A235= 5:8@<2 !%F' <B 845 :8 "// 1953 A6<2 84@9 12 <=35= D19 619953 >? 845 33@8@<217 - 5 - 5:=581=? 8< 845 561=8C528 <B 12:41?18 1H 3@9GA17@B?@2; 845 =596<23528 <" 19 1 C5C>5= <B 845 12:41?184 B<= 1 65=@<3 <B 9@K ?51=9 A235= 5:8@<2 ! 123 ! %!' =513 D@84 5:8@<2 "#%7' <B 845 12:41?18 1H :8"// 5@2; 1;;=@5F53 >? 845 91@3 <=35= 845 =596<23528 <" B@753 <#))!!#)# 45 751=253 @2;75&A3;5<B84@9<A=84573- ! " ! # ! $ % " !& ! 45 751=253 @2;75 &A3;5 8452 6=<:55353 8< 6199 12 <=35= 9588@2; 19@35 845 <=35= <B 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 >A8 4573 8418 845 <=35= D<A73 2<8 :<C5 @2 845 D1? <B - 6 - @2@8@18@2;:=@C@2176=<:553@2;91;1@298=596<23528<"<= 12?<845=65=9<2 5@2;1;;=@5F53>?84591@3<=35=845166577128 @9>5B<=584@9<A=8 ( 45751=253:<A2957B<=8451665771289A>C@8853 8418 B<= 1 C5C>5= 8< @2:A= 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 A235= 5:8@<2 !%F' <B 845 :8 "// @8 @9 9ABB@:@528 @B @8 @9 5981>7@9453 >5?<23 3<A>8 8418 1 251=598 =5718@F5 <B 845 C5C>5= @9 528=A9853 D@84 D<=E >57<2;@2; 8< 845 12:41?18 5 9A>C@89 8418 B1:8 8418 845 9<2 <B =596<23528<"D1952;1;53B<=:5=81@26A>7@:D<=E9>? 845 12:41?18 A235= "84 @212:@17 712 3A=@2; 845 ?51= #)##-#)# @9 2<8 @2 3@96A85 5 845=5B<=5 :<285239 8418 845@C6A;253<=35=619953>?845751=253@2;75&A3;5@9 D@84<A8 =5B5=52:5 845 6A=6<95 <B 6=<F@9@<2 <B 71D 123 845=5B<=5 845 91C5 3595=F59 8< >5 958-19@35 5 @2F@853 845188528@<2<B845<A=88<F1=@<A9<>95=F18@<29C135>? 845 5;@<217 <CC@99@<25= 19 D577 19 845 33@8@<217 5:=581=?8<845561=8C528<B12:41?1841H8<:<28523 - 7 - 8418 =596<23528 <" 413 @2:A==53 845 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 A235=5:8@<2!%F'<B845:8"// , " 751=253:<A2957B<==596<23528<" :<285235384188459<2<B=596<23528<"D19=5;@985=53 19 1 :<28=1:8<= @2 845 ?51= #)"/ @8957B 5 :<285239 8418 =596<23528<"D192<8@298=AC52817@21D1=3@2;D<=E8< 45=9<219@8D19845:<775:8@F535:@9@<2<B84512:41?18 @2 528=A98@2; 845D<=E 8< 45= 9<2 5 845=5B<=5 :<285239 8418 =596<23528 <" :122<8 >5 6A8 8< 845 ;A@77<8@25 B<= 528=A98@2;845D<=E8<45=9<2 5179<:<2852398418=596<23528<">5:1C5 845 34?1E941 <B 845 12:41?18 <2 )) #)# 123 452:5 45 :122<8 >5 65217@L53 >? 12 <=35= <B 3@9GA17@B@:18@<25:<28523984185F5284561?C528C135 8<8459<2<B=596<23528<"@9>?84534?1E941123845 12:41?185F57<6C528 BB@:5=% '12384591C5@9@2 <=35=59@35984@945:<2852398418845=5@92<35B5:8@2 845 D<=E 5K5:A853 >? 845 9<2 <B =596<23528 <" 123 - 8 - 452:5845=5D192<2553B<=@2@8@18@2;6=<:553@2;9A235= 5:8@<2!<B845:8"// / 45 751=253 :<A2957 B<= =596<23528 <( 179< =5@85=1853 845 :<28528@<29 A=;53 >? 845 166577128 123 :<28523538418@8D198459<2<B=596<23528<"D4<413 5K5:A853 845 D<=E 3A=@2; 845 "84 @212:@17 712 3A=@2; 845?51=#)##-#D452=596<23528<"D1995=F@2;191 C5C>5=<B84512:41?18 ") 45 751=253 @;4 <A=8 <F5=2C528 75135= 179< =5@85=1853 845 1><F5 :<28528@<2 123 9A66<=853 845 <=35= 619953 >? 845 33@8@<217 5:=581=? 3@9GA17@B?@2; =596<23528<"191C5C>5=<B84512:41?18 "" 5 41F5 :<29@35=53 845 9A>C@99@<29 C135 >? 845 751=253 :<A2957 B<= 845 166577128 123 845 751=253 :<A2957 B<= =596<23528 <" 19 D577 19 845 751=253 @;4 <A=8 <F5=2C528 75135= 123 845 751=253 :<A2957 16651=@2;B<=84512:41?18 - 9 - "# 45 B1:89 8418 1=5 2<8 @2 3@96A85 1=5 8418 =596<23528<"D19845C5C>5=<B84512:41?18418 8459<2<B=596<23528<"1D1=353:5=81@2D<=E9<B845 12:41?183A=@2;845"84@212:@17712B<=845?51=#)##- #)# 45=5B<=5 =596<23528 <" D19 1 61=8? 8< 845 35:@9@<2<B84512:41?188<177<8845D<=E98<8459<2<B =596<23528<" " <= 845 91E5 <B :<2F52@52:5 5:8@<2 !%F' <B 84512:41?181H:8"//@95K8=1:853>57<D “[43A. Removal of members.– (1) The Government [or an Authority authorized by the Government] if it thinks fit, on the recommendation of the Gram Panchayat, or otherwise, may remove any member after giving him an opportunity of being heard and after such enquiry as it deems necessary, – (i) xxx, (ii) xxx (iii) xxx (iv) xxx (v) in the execution of any work of the panchayat, contractual or otherwise found involved directly with any person who is a nearest relative in the family or otherwise associated in any transaction related to such work as a partner, employee or a member on the Committee of such organisation, or otherwise. (vi) xxx Explanation: For the purpose of this section, nearest relative in the family means, - (a) the wife or husband of a person residing with her or him; (b) son or daughter or step-son or step-daughter; - 10 - (c) any other person related, whether by blood or marriage who is wholly dependent on such person; (2) xxx” "! 65=A917 <B 5:8@<2 ! <B 845 12:41?18 1H :8"//@23@:18598418845@28523C528<B84@96=<F@9@<2 <B 71D @9 8< =5;A7185 845 C@9:4@5B <B C5C>5=9 :<2B5==@2; 71=;5995<2845@=<D2B1C@7?C5C>5=9<=<265=9<29D@84 D4<C 845? 41F5 1 F59853 @285=598 45 6=<F@9@<2 @9 9< 359@;253 8418 @8 3585=9 12? C5C>5= B=<C 41F@2; 12? :<2B7@:8<B@285=598@2=5965:8<B5K5:A8@<2<BD<=E9<B845 12:41?18 8 @9 @2 <=35= 8< C558 9A:4 1 9@8A18@<2 8418 1 3=198@: 6A2@94C528 @9 6=<F@353 @2 845 6=<F@9@<2 >? 3@9GA17@B?@2;9A:41C5C>5=B<=165=@<3<B(?51=9 " 2 845 :195 <2 4123 845 9<2 <B =596<23528 <" D19 528=A9853 D@84 :5=81@2 D<=E9 <B 845 12:41?18 3A=@2;845"84@212:@17712B<=845?51=#)##-#)#123 845 9<2 <B =596<23528 <" 413 =5:5@F53 1 9AC <B 9#! (( - 596<23528 <" >5@2; 1 C5C>5= <B 845 12:41?18 @9 179< 1 9@;218<=? 8< 845 =59<7A8@<2 1D1=3@2; 845D<=E9 8< 45=9<2 4@9 @9 5F@3528 B=<C 845=59<7A8@<2 - 11 - 619953 18 845 965:@17 C558@2; <B 845 12:41?18 4573 <2 "))#)#)596<23528<":122<8B5@;2@;2<=12:58418 45= 9<2 D19 179< 1 85235=5= D4< D19 528=A9853 D@84 :5=81@2D<=E9<B84512:41?18B8418>59<@8@95F@3528 8418845251=598=5718@F5<B=596<23528<"D19@2F<7F53 @2 :5=81@2 D<=E9 <B 845 12:41?18 45=5B<=5 845 33@8@<217 5:=581=? 8< 845 561=8C528 <B 12:41?18 1H 1B85= ;<@2; @28< 84595 C185=@179 D19 <B 845 <6@2@<2 8418 =596<23528 <" 413 @2:A==53 845 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 A235= 5:8@<2 ! <B 845 :8 "// 45 751=253 @2;75 &A3;5 <A;48 2<8 8< 41F5 7@;487? @285=B5=53 D@84 9A:4 12 <=35= C<=5 61=8@:A71=7? D452 845=5 D19 C185=@17 <2 =5:<=3 8< 94<D84188459<2<B=596<23528<"D19;=12853:5=81@2 6A>7@: D<=E9 <B 845 12:41?18 123 D19 1 =5:@6@528 <B 1 9AC <B 9#! (( - 45=5B<=5 =596<23528 <" 413 @2:A==538453@9GA17@B@:18@<2A235=5:8@<2!<B845:8 "// "( 2 8418 F@5D <B 845 C1885= D5 958-19@35 845 <=35=619953>?845751=253@2;75&A3;5123845<=35=<B - 12 - 3@9GA17@B@:18@<2 <B =596<23528 <" 619953 >? =596<23528 <#@9=598<=53 ", 45 D=@8 166517 981239 <2 845 1><F585=C9 )* '!( ! )* ' !& ( ! @98<"7<##