- 1 - ! " # $%!! $%! !& &%## '( (## )* ' ( ! !"#$% & ' ( )!! ) ! #%%% & ) Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ! #%%% )!! & ' ( ) ) ) *+ ) ) ) , -%$%. %-% %- '( )) ) ), ) ) ), %%. %.') ) '( ##$% %. ) ) *%$%# '($##$ %$ ) ) ( ' ( )!! ) ! "#%%% ) - 3 - "#%%%* - ) ! '!( ! !"#$% . ! '!( ! !"#$% # ! '!( !"#$% !"#$% + ! '!( !"#$% ' ( - 4 - ! ! . / !"#$% ' ) ( ) . ) !! ) ) !! ! ! -%$%. %-% %- / ) 0 123 0 - 5 - ' 0( 45617781956:5983;<=48=1=8>419982?52?12@A38A 31=83 -%$%. 716683 ;< =48 981A283 52?98 B3?8 52 @%-% %- A58:9<6=1=83=48:1>=61A8=41=A867@2382=C16 177@52=831612B26D59983E1F3@@A'>@@958(@23159<C1?86 C5=48::8>=@2%*$-12348C@AD83>@2=52B@B69<=599 %*$+ @2 C45>4 31< 48 C16 =8AE521=83 C5=4@B= A816@248A867@2382=413A8238A83E@A8=412.%31<6 @: 68AG5>8 52 =48 916= :@BA <81A6 7A5@A =@ 456 =8AE521=5@2 48 A867@2382= 177A@1>483 =48 17789912=6 123 458: 2?5288A ! 566B83 12 823@A68E82= 31=83 -%**% 35A8>=52? 45E =@ 177A@1>4 =48 17789912=6 :@A A8526=1=8E82= 4@B?4 =48 A867@2382= 177A@1>483 =48 1B=4@A5=586 >@2>8A283 =48< 353 2@= A8526=1=8 45E 52=@ 68AG5>88=48A8:@A8A1568313567B=8C45>4C16A8:8AA83 =@ =48 1;@A @BA= 52 ) @$ **# < @A38A 31=83 %** =48 1;@A @BA= 199@C83 =48 A8:8A82>8 123 - 6 - 35A8>=83 =48 A8526=1=8E82= @: =48 A867@2382= C5=4 #%H ;1>D C1?86 >@2=52B5=< @: 68AG5>8 123 >@268IB82=519 ;828:5=6 48 17789912=6 >419982?83 =48 6153 @A38A 52 @$+ **$ 48 @A38A @: =48 1;@BA @BA= C16 E@35:583 @29< =@ =48 8J=82= @: ?A12=52? >@2=52B5=< @: 68AG5>8 :A@E %%+**- 123 =41= 48 56 2@= 82=5=983 =@ ;1>DC1?86@A>@2=52B5=<@:68AG5>8:@A=4878A5@37A5@A=@ %%+**- 456 C16 >419982?83 ;< =48 17789912=6 52 @## **$C16356E56683@2=48?A@B23@:3891< 16 C899 16 @2 E8A5=6 48 A867@2382= =48A8:@A8 >915E83 =41= =48 @A38A @: =48 981A283 52?98 B3?8 413 1==15283 :52195=< 8 C16 =482 A8526=1=83 52=@ 68AG5>8 123 48 A8238A8368AG5>8@23159<C1?8;16568>915E6=41==48A8 C8A868G8A19481G<E1F3@@A6C4@C8A8177@52=83@23159< C1?8652 G1A5@B6 3871A=E82=6@:=48@G8A2E82=52 5991 12>41<1=4 123 @>19 B=4@A5=586 123 =48< C8A8 A8?B91A56838>915E83=41=48C16>@2=52B83=59931=8@2 3159<C1?868G82=4@B?448413>@E798=83=4A8838>1386 @: 68AG5>8 8 >915E6 =41= 48 C16 ?A12=83 =48 ;828:5= - 7 - B238A =48 !1A21=1D1 159< 1?8 E79@<886 89:1A8 >= % 526=813 @: A8?B91A5652? 456 68AG5>8 @2 >@E798=5@2 @: % <81A6 @:68AG5>8 8 >915E6 =41= 48413 E138 68G8A19 A87A8682=1=5@26A8IB86=52?A8?B91A561=5@2@:45668AG5>8 A8>@EE8231=5@2C16E138;<17789912=@-=@17789912= @. :@A A8?B91A5F1=5@2 @: =48 68AG5>8 @: =48 A867@2382= @C8G8A =48 61E8 C16 2@= 3@28 123 =48A8:@A8 =48 A867@2382=177A@1>483=456@BA=52 @%-% %- :@A 1 35A8>=5@2 =@ >@26538A =48 A8>@EE8231=5@2 @: 17789912=@-=@17789912=@.48981A28352?98B3?8 52=8AE6@:12@A38A31=83-%$%.4893=41=652>8=48 A867@2382= 413 A8238A83 A8IB565=8 <81A6 @: 68AG5>8 123 =48 1B=4@A5=586 413 A8>@EE82383 456 >168 :@A A8?B91A5F1=5@25=C@B93;8177A@7A51=8=@35A8>==48=1=8 @G8A2E82= =@ >@26538A =48 >168 @: =48 A867@2382= :@A A8?B91A5F1=5@21237166177A@7A51=8@A38A6C5=452178A5@3 @: =C@ E@2=46 :A@E =48 31=8 @: A8>857= @: >@7< @: =48 @A38A 852? 1??A58G83 ;< =48 6153 @A38A =48 =1=8 123 @=48A1B=4@A5=5861A852177819 - 8 - - 48 981A283 335=5@219 @G8A2E82= 3G@>1=8 6B;E5==83=41==48A867@2382=5619A813<13E5==83=@=48 ;828:5=6 B238A =48 !1A21=1D1 159< 1?8 E79@<886 89:1A8 >= % 123 =48A8:@A8 48 56 2@= 82=5=983 =@ A8?B91A5F1=5@248196@>@2=8236=41==48A867@2382=C16 177@52=831?1526=12@2612>=5@2837@6=48A8:@A84856 2@=82=5=983:@AA8?B91A561=5@2164893;<=4878J@BA=52 =48>168@: G6") * . 981A283 >@B2689 :@A =48 A867@2382= 6B;E5=6 =41= =48 A867@2382= 416 >@E798=83 % <81A6 @: 68AG5>812348C16177@52=837A5@A=@%%+*$.123=48 78J @BA= 52 =48 >168 @: ! " # $ % &'$ G6 " )* 413 35A8>=83 =48 A8?B91A561=5@2 @: 8E79@<886 @2 3159< C1?86 C4@ 1A8 177@52=83 7A5@A =@ %%+*$. 8 =48A8:@A8 >@2=8236=41==48A867@2382=5682=5=983=@;8A8?B91A5683 865386 =456 48 >@2=8236 =41= =48 177@52=E82= @: =48 - 9 - A867@2382=161A@B7 8E79@<8852=48<81A*$-562@= 3567B=83;<=4817789912=612348416>@2=52B83@2 ;1656 =48A81:=8A 123 =48A8:@A8 52 G58C @: =48 A8>82= KB3?E82= @: =48 78J @BA= 52 =48 >168 @: (%% G6 ) " * +# , =48 A867@2382=5682=5=983=@;8A8?B91A56835268AG5>8 # 8 41G8 >@26538A83 =48 6B;E5665@26 @: =48 981A283335=5@219@G8A2E82=3G@>1=8:@A=4817789912=6 16C89916=48981A283>@B2689:@A=48A867@2382= 48 :1>= =41= =48 A867@2382= C16 177@52=83 7A5@A =@ %%+*$. 56 2@= 52 3567B=8 = 56 196@ 2@= 52 3567B=8 =41= :@99@C52? =48 @A38A6 716683 ;< =456 @BA= 52 @$+ **$ =48 A867@2382= 56 A8526=1=83 52=@ 68AG5>8 48A8:@A8 456 68AG5>8 416 =@ ;8 A8526=1=83 C5=4 ;828:5= @: >@2=52B5=< @: 68AG5>8 :A@E %%+**- 48 A867@2382= 416 7B= >@2=52B@B6 68AG5>8 @: E@A8 =412 % <81A6 123 52 G58C @: =48 KB3?E82= @: =48 78J @BA= 52 (%%,6>168A8:8AA83=@6B7A1=48A867@2382=5682=5=983 =@;8A8?B91A56835268AG5>8 - 10 - + 2=41=G58C@:=48E1==8A=48A8562@2883=@ 52=8A:8A8 C5=4 =48 @A38A 31=83 -%$%. 716683 52 @%-% %- ;< =48 981A283 52?98 B3?8 @C8G8A C8 >@26538A 5= 177A@7A51=8 =@ 35A8>= =48 17789912=6 =@ :@A=4C5=4 A8?B91A568 =48 68AG5>86 @: =48 A867@2382=123 ?A12=45E 199;828:5=6 52 1>>@A312>8C5=4 91C $ 45664199 ;8 >@E79583 C5=452 1 78A5@3 @: =4A88 E@2=46 :A@E =48 31=8 @: A8>857= @: >@7< @: =456 @A38A >>@A352?9<CA5=17781956 * 2 G58C @: =48 @A38A 716683 ;< =456 @BA= 52 @%%%%- % ?A12=52? =4A88 E@2=46 =5E8 =@ =48 17789912=6 =@ >@E79< C5=4 =48 35A8>=5@26 566B83 ;< =456 @BA=@%%-.* %#56'' +' )!* ! +' ) !& * ! 56=@9@+