- 1 - !"#"$ %&# # & '( ')*+ (' * , ! " ! ! # $%% " ! & #&& $ !" '&& ( &$ &) &&&% & & $&& & & ! & " $ "# $ ! ' & ( $ % * " ) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & $&&% &" %"!"#(&"% +#) & ) , & &"+!"!" #"" "!" & - % & %% & (") #" #(") #() % "!"# & % % & $% & * ) ,& & , & % &!""!" & &!!"!" $ "!" & & $ % & %% (") #" #(") #() % "!"#* ) & &&&&. & & & & % & ,& &&&$% $& $& $ /$ & &012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 " 68 0><>51?> >@><1A;<>A20>>7015>"!"#56B;>203<6=44:17@2>@>1725 504 345151674<2 >==;24: 62" 56 17 6#"" "!" (><1217@ 6;5 68 <1C4 6 "!") <4@1254<4: D? 504 6C47 691=41E>?3;<86<50468847=43;7120>D94;7:4<24=51672 - 3 - (")#"#(")<4>:F1504=5167#()680><>51?>?>?> >7015>()"!"#347:17@67504819468::15167>91G19 ;:@4>7:$%1E>?>3;< " &04 8>=5;>9 C>5<1H 68 504 =>24 12 50>5 <42367:475 6" C><<14: 56 >:1B >20A><1 14 >==;24: 6 67 !""!"#G4<217=4504:>5468C><<1>@4<42367:4756" 25><54: 56 <421:4 >967@ F150 04< 0;2D>7: >7: >==;24: 62" >7:#14345151674<62>7:">50>>91>@><1E>?>3;<> &04<4 F>2 > =6<:1>9 <49>51672013 F150 >==;24: 62 56 # >7: <42367:4756"86<>34<16:685F6C675028<6C 504:>5468 C><<1>@4 &04<4>854< >==;24: 62 56 # >967@ F150 >==;24: 6 25><54: 56 0><>22 <42367:475 6" D650 30?21=>99? >7: C475>99? D? 2;234=517@ 04< 81:4915? 99 68 504C 0>G4 1721254: <42367:475 6" 86< :1G6<=4 2 2;=0 504 2>1: >234=5 F>2 1786<C4:D?<42367:4756"5604<3><4752>54<04<3><4752 >7: 504 6504< 49:4<2 68 504 8>C19? =67:;=54: > 3>7=0>?>5 &06;@0175042>1:3>7=0>?>5504>==;24:>@<44:565>A4=><4 <42367:475 6" =6<:1>99? 504? 67=4 >@>17 25><54: 56 0><>22 04< D650 30?21=>99? >7: C475>99? >7: 817>99? 504? 50<6F7 04< 6;58<6C504C>5<1C671>906C422;=020425><54:56<421:4 1704<3><475>906;2447=420496:@4:504=6C39>175D486<4 - 4 - <42367:475 6I691=4 67 !""!" >@>1725 504 345151674<2 >7:>76504< # 7 504 25<47@50 68 =6C39>175 <42367:475 6I 691=4 <4@1254<4: 504 =>24 >@>1725 >==;24: 6 >7: 50424 345151674<2 86< 504 >86<4C4751674: 68847=42 17 <1C4 6 "!"&04<4>854<<42367:4756I691=4=67:;=54:504 17G4251@>5167>7:9>1:=0><@420445>@>1725504345151674<2>7: >76504< 86< 504 >86<4C4751674: 68847=42 D? ><<>?17@ 50424 345151674<2 >2 >==;24: 62" 56 ==6<:17@9? 504 94><74: $>@125<>54 566A =6@71J>7=4 68 504 68847=42 @@<14G4: D? 504 2>C4 504 345151674<2 14 >==;24: 6" 56 3<484<<4: 5012 3451516756B;>205043<6=44:17@2 4><: 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<2 >7: 94><74:86<<42367:4756&06;@07651=41224<G4:56 <42367:4756"204<4C>174:>D2475 3><58<6C;<@17@24G4<>9=675475167250494><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674<2 0>2 =67547:4: 50>5 67 34<;2>9 68 504 =6C39>175 >7: 6504< =0><@4 20445 C>54<1>92 4H=435 6C71D;2 >994@>5167 >@>1725 50424 345151674<2 >D269;549? 76 D4914G>D9425>54C47526<C>54<1>9239>=4:D?5043<624=;516717 - 5 - 504 =0><@4 20445 ==6<:17@ 56 01C 504<4 12 > :49>? 68 C67502 17 96:@17@ 504 =6C39>175 4 >926 =67547:4: 50>5 <42367:4756"25>?4:1704<C>5<1C671>906C486<84F:>?2 >7: 504<4>854< 204 G69;75><19? 9485 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 >7: 25><54:56<421:41704<3><475>906;2472;=0=1<=;C25>7=42 504>994@>5167=>7765D4D4914G4:>7:>==6<:17@9?043<>?256 B;>205043<6=44:17@2 94><74: 633624: 504 3<>?4< D? =67547:17@50>5<42367:4756I691=40>G417G4251@>54:504 C>554< >7: 9>1: =0><@4 >@>1725 504 345151674<2 >7: >76504< %;<504< 04 =67547:4: 50>5 504 25>54C4752 68 504 C>54<1>9 F15742242 =94><9? :12=9624 504 >=51G4 3><51=13>5167 68 >==;24: 62 56 # 17 504 =6CC122167 68 =<1C4 6F4G4< 04 8>1<9? 2;DC1554:50>5>==;24:614345151674<6#04<417F0612 50421254<I17I9>FF>2<421:17@243><>549?8<6C504C>5<1C671>9 06C4==6<:17@9?043<>?256:12C12250434515167 0>G4@1G47C?>7H16;2=6721:4<>5167D65067504 2;DC1221672 C>:4 D? 504 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51G4 3><5142>7:34<;24:504:6=;C4752C>:4>G>19>D9467<4=6<: - 6 - 2=6;9:D4@>504<4:8<6C<4=6<:2504<49>51672013 D45F447 <42367:475 6" >7: 50424 345151674<2 ><4 765 17 :123;54 45151674< 62 >7: " ><4 8>504<I17I9>F >7: C6504<I17I9>F<4234=51G49?>7:345151674<6#1250421254<I17I 9>F68<42367:4756"512>92676517:123;5450>5345151674< 62 >7: " 14 17I9>F2 ><4 <421:17@ 17 504 20><4: 06;24 F04<4>==;24:62>7:<42367:4756"F4<4<421:4: + 7 34<;2>9 68 504 =6C39>175 >G4<C4752 504 2>C4 :431=5250>5>854<"C675028<6C504:>5468C><<1>@4>==;24: 6256#25><54:560><>2204<D65030?21=>99?>7:C475>99? D?2;234=517@04<81:4915?5 12>92625>54:50>5504?;24:56 >22>;9504<30?21=>99?>7:5650>54884=5>>7=0>?>50F>2>926 =67:;=54: >5 504 1725>7=4 68 04< 8>504< 423154 504 >==;24: =67517;4: 5041< 0><>22C475 %17>99? :;4 56 175694<>D94 0><>22C475 204 9485 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 >7: 25><54: 56 <421:41704<3><475>906;24&0425>54C47568F1574224214 56 =94><9?:12=9624250>5679?>==;24:6256 # ><4 4B;>99? 3><51=13>54: 17 504 >994@4: =<1C4 6F4G4< 17 <4234=568345151674<6#14>==;24:612=67=4<74:204 12 <421:17@ 243><>549? 8<6C 504 C>5<1C671>9 06C4 >967@ F150 04<8>C19?&06;@05046C71D;2>994@>5167C>:4>@>172504<17 - 7 - 504=6C39>175=0><@420445>7:1750425>54C47568F15742242 504 2>C4 =>7765 D4 D4914G4: 86< 504 <4>267 50>5 F047 204 F>2 <421:17@ 243><>549? 8<6C 04< 3><475>9 06;24 (C>5<1C671>906C468<42367:4756")>967@F15004<8>C19? 504<4 12 76 2;=0 36221D1915? 68 204 G121517@ 504 C>5<1C671>9 06;2468<42367:4756">7:0><>2204< ! 72;=0=1<=;C25>7=42>339?17@504817:17@268504 67.D9434H6;<517504=>2468 <436<54: 17 ! "#$%& 565048>=52>7:=1<=;C25>7=42685012=>24>C68 504 =6721:4<4: G14F 50>5 =67517;>5167 68 3<6=44:17@2 >@>1725 345151674< 6# >==;24: 6 12 765017@ D;5 >7 >D;24 68 3<6=422 68 6;<5 2 2;=0 504 2>C4 0>2 56 D4 B;>204: 6F4G4< >2 :12=;224: 504<4 ><4 C>54<1>92 ><486<50=6C17@>@>1725345151674<62>7:" >==;24:62" >7:#047=45041<3<>?4<86<B;>2017@5043<6=44:17@2=>7765 D4@<>754:==6<:17@9?3<6=44:563>2250486996F17@* 1 &04<1C17>93451516712 ' - 8 - 11 &04 34515167 17 <4234=5 68 345151674< 62 >7: " >==;24: 62" >7: # 12 04<4D? ( 111 &04 34515167 17 <4234=5 68 345151674< 6# >==;24: 6 17 6#"" "!" (><1217@6;568<1C46 "!")<4@1254<4: D? 504 6C47 691=4 1E>?3;< 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>D94 ;7:4< 4=51672 (")#"#(")<4>:F1504=5167#() 68 0><>51?> ?>?> >7015> () "!"# 3<424759?347:17@67504819468::15167>9 1G19 ;:@4 >7: $% 1E>?>3;< 12 04<4D? ) -+ '# * # &$ 1256"96