- 1 - ! "# #$ %&'%()*+&,%) - !" # $ %& ' ' !" " %( !% %% % !" ) %( % ! !" Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * % )% +,% !" % % +% !" # $ %' - %'"& ' *) **" ' .& !!"!" ( "!"" /& ) , ' 0 * ' 1 (( 2304563037895:3:37830;3<5=>8=545?:378*)45.=@3:2 5?:378 **" 7; "!") :7 05: .03=5 :25 74=54 =.:5= !!"!"9.005=/A==3:378.<30:43?:.8=5003780(>=B5 .<./>4.B3 38 5003780 .05 7 "!"" $254538.;:54 <5.485= 5003780 (>=B5& @2545/A :25 <5.485= 5003780 (>=B5 =30C3005= :25 .99<3?.:378 ;3<5= /A :25 95:3:37854 :247>B2 - 3 - 450978=58:7 0:.:5>8=545?:378) ,7;4:73C9<3?.:5 450978=58:70":7.8=:24557:2540.0.==3:378.<.??>05=38 7 "!""958=38B78:25;3<57;==3:378.<30:43?:.8= 5003780(>=B5 .<./>4.B3 " 25;.?:>.<C.:43D7;:25?.0530:2.:/.05=78:25 ?7C9<.38:<7=B5=/A:2595:3:37854.B.380:.??>05=70 :7* .8=7:2540'?.C5:7/545B30:545=.B.380:)!:7*!9540780 /A 8.C38B , 9540780 38?<>=38B 450978=58: 70" :7 38 :230 95:3:3783843C57* "! =.:5= *!)"! ;74:257;;58?50 9>8302./<5>8=545?:3780 *) * * *)"*))+)! !* *" 45.= @3:2 5?:378 *, 7; : 30 .<<5B5= 38 :25 ?7C9<.38::2.:78 *!)"! .:./7>:!*!!9C@23<5:25 ?7C9<.38.8: .8= 230 ;.C3<A C5C/540 @545 38 :2534 0>B.4?.85 0279 03:>.:5= 85.4 :25 2.4.8./.0.99. 5C9<5 )! :7 *! 9579<5 .9947.?25= :25 0279 .8= 4.80.?E5= :25 0.C5 .8= .C78B:25C.??>05=70 :7*.00.><:5=:25?7C9<.38.8:;74 45C76.< 7; :25 0279 ;:54 ?78=>?:38B 38650:3B.:378 . ?2.4B5 0255:2.0/558<.3=.B.380:.??>05=70 :7*;74:257;;58?50 9>8302./<5>8=545?:3780!*)!)"* *))+*"45.= @3:2 5?:378 )* 7; /A =479938B .<< 7:254 .??>05= 9540780 C58:3785=38:25'38?<>=38B450978=58:70":7 - 4 - ) >438B :25 ?7>405 7; :43.< :25 ?7C9<.38.8: @27 5D.C385=.0)0:.:5=:2.::25.??>05=38:25?2.4B50255: .8=:259479705=.??>05=3867<65=38:257;;58?57;4.80.?E38B :25 0279 .8= /.05= 78 :25 0.3= 563=58?5 :25 95:3:37854 35 :25?7C9<.38.8:;3<5=.8.99<3?.:378>8=545?:378) ,:247>B2 :2594705?>:378:73C9<3?.:5450978=58:70":7.0.==3:378.< .??>05= 25 43.< 7>4: 78 .00500C58: 7; :25 563=58?5 .8= 7:254=7?>C58:045F5?:5=:250.3=.99<3?.:37863=574=54=.:5= !!"!"58?5:250.C530?2.<<58B5=/5;745:2307>4: * 5.4= :25 <5.485= ?7>805< ;74 :25 95:3:37854 <5.485= ?7>805< ;74 :25 ?78:50:38B 450978=58:0 .8= .<07 :25 <5.485= 9.4:;47C>4B38B05654.<?78:58:3780:25<5.485= ?7>805< ;74 :25 95:3:37854 2.0 943C.43<A ?78:58=5= :2.: 563=58?57;)35:25?7C9<.38.8:?.:5B743?.<<A50:./<30250 :2.: 450978=58: 70" :7 .45 3867<65= 38 :25 .<<5B5= ?43C5 .8=.<78B@3:2:25C.??>05=70 :7*58:545=:250>B.4?.85 0279 7; :25 ?7C9<.38.8: .8= 4.80.?E5= :25 0.C5 8 0>?2 ?34?>C0:.8?50 :25 43.< 7>4: 7>B2: :7 2.65 .<<7@5= :25 - 5 - .99<3?.:378;3<5=/A:2595:3:37854>8=545?:378) ,7;4 ??74=38B<A2594.A0:7.<<7@:254563037895:3:378 + :25<5.485=?7>805<;74:25450978=58: 70" :7 0>/C3:0 :2.: :25 43.< 7>4: .;:54 C5:3?><7>0<A 5D.C3838B:2558:345563=58?5.8=7:254=7?>C58:07845?74= 9.005= . @5<<45.0785= 74=54 .8= 3: =750 87: ?.<< ;74 .8A 38:54;5458?5.::252.8=07;:2307>4:'>4:254250>/C3:0:2.: :25 8650:3B.:378 ;;3?54 .;:54 ?78=>?:38B . =5:.3<5= 38650:3B.:378;3<5=.?2.4B50255:78<A.B.380:.??>05=70 :7 * /A =479938B .<< :25 7:254 .??>05= C58:3785= 38 :25 ' 38?<>=38B 450978=58: 70" :7 ??74=38B<A 25 94.A0 :7 =30C300:254563037895:3:378 2.65B3658CA.8D37>0?7803=54.:378/7:278:25 0>/C3003780 C.=5 /A :25 <5.485= ?7>805< ;74 :25 45095?:365 9.4:35007.<07954>05=:25=7?>C58:0C.=5.6.3<./<5/5;745 :2307>4: 0?7><=/5B.:2545=;47C45?74=0:27>B2:25' @.045B30:545=.B.380:)!:7*!9540780/A8.C38B,9540780 38?<>=38B450978=58:70":7.;:54.=5:.3<5=38650:3B.:378 :2538650:3B.:378;;3?54=47995=450978=58:70":7038?5 - 6 - :2538650:3B.:378=3=87:4565.<.8A9.4:3?39.:3787;450978=58: 70":738:25.<<5B5=?43C57@565438:25?7>4057;:43.< :25 ?7C9<.38.8:) =59705= .B.380: 450978=58: 70" :7 :2.::25A.453867<65=38:25?43C525563=58?57;)@.0 87:0>9974:5=/A.8A7:254@3:850050:3005::<5=9703:3787; <.@/A:2578G/<595D7>4:38.?.:58.7;F>=BC58:0:2.:. 954078?.8/50>CC785=.0.8.??>05=78<A@258:257>4: .;:54 .8.<AH38B :25 563=58?5 .6.3<./<5 78 45?74= 0:478B<A 0.:30;35=:2.::25455D30:00>;;3?358:.8=7654@25<C38B563=58?5 .B.380:0>?2 954078 :2.: 3:30 F>0: .8= 5D95=358: :7 0>CC78 23C.0.8.??>05=2545:25563=58?5306.B>5.8=7/0?>45 :25 7>4: 027><= 2503:.:5 ;47C 3C9<5.=38B :25 .==3:378.< .??>05= 25 781/<5 95D 7>4: 38 :25 45?58: F>=BC58: 7; 45974:5=38$"!")&)**38.4.7 !25<=.0 >8=54 ! " #$% #$% - 7 - & ' ! ( ! ) ! * , 8 ?.45;>< 5D.C38.:378 7; :25 3C9>B85= 74=54 563=58?57;).8=7:254?2.4B50255:C.:543.<0:2307>4: ;55<0:2.::255003780(>=B52.0=5.<::25C.::5438=5:.3<.8= 2.043B2:<A45F5?:5=:25.99<3?.:378.8=;38=87B77=B47>8=0 :738:54;545@3:2:253C9>B85=74=54 ! ??74=38B<A:254563037895:3:37830 = % ) 30:7 <7*+