- 1 - !" " #$%&#'()$*%#( + ! "# $ % # % % ## & "# $ ''' '''''" $ ( " % # ) # *$ + ! "# * #% , $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % &-% "$ & % # ")$ # " % %% # ("$ ("$".$&"$%# &%% # ( % $ #% * %* + % ) /# * * 012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4< 4=5167 & 68 #0><>51?> >@><1A ;<>A20> >7015> &86<@<>7568<4@;9><B>1917 <1.46 <4@1254<4:B?504;551691=4 5>516786< 50468847=423;7120>B94;7:4< 4=51672("$("$".$ &"$ 68 #0><>51?> ?>?> >7015> & C86< 206<5 D504 # &EF >7: 4=51672 >7: ( 68 504 <654=5167 68 019:<47 8<6. 4G;>9 8847=42 =5 C86< 206<5 D504 =5EF 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 ::15167>9 125<1=5 >7: 4221672 *;:@4 >5 >1=0;< 215517@ >5 17:0>7;< 17 34=1>9>246 - 3 - 04 8>=5;>9 .>5<1G 68 504 =>24 12 50>5 504 =6.39>17>75H1=51. I>2 >@4: >B6;5 ?4><2 & .67502 04 I>2 <421:17@ >967@ I150 04< 3><4752 >5 >1:6::1 H199>@4 04 345151674< >==;24: 12 504 741@0B6;< 68 504 H1=51.504<4B?504?B65084991796H42504?><4<49>51H42 504H1=51.@1<9;24:56H121550406;2468>==;24:>7:504? 0>:24G;>91754<=6;<2486<>34<16:68674?4><148<6. ( &56J - 04<4>854<504H1=51.B4=>.4 3<4@7>75>7:@>H4B1<5056>=019:>54<67 - 504H1=51.96:@4:>=6.39>175>@>1725504>==;24:>994@17@ 50>5504>==;24:0>:=6..1554:86<=1B9424G;>91754<=6;<24 6704<#>24:675042>1:=6.391>75504<42367:4753691=4 <4@1254<4:504=>24>@>1725504345151674<86<504>86<42>1: 68847=42 ;<17@ 504 =6;<24 68 17H4251@>5167 504 <42367:4753691=4><<4254:504>==;24:67 >7: 9>54< =67:;=54: 504 17H4251@>5167 >7: 9>1: =0><@4 20445 >@>1725 504 >==;24: 86< 504 >86<42>1: 68847=42 #417@ >@@<14H4: B? 504 2>.4 504 345151674< >33<6>=04: 504 94><74:::15167>9125<1=5>7: 4221672*;:@4 >1=0;< - 4 - 215517@>5 17:0>7;<17<912=6 86<@<>7568 B>19042>.4I>2<4K4=54:H1:46<:4<:>54:- #417@>@@<14H4:B?5042>.45043<4247534515167128194: & 4><:50494><74:=6;724986<504345151674<>7: 504 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6H4<7.475 94>:4< 86< 504 <42367:4752 3><5 8<6. ;<@17@ 24H4<>9 =6754751672 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1.><19? =67547:4: 50>5 504 3<624=;5167 0>2 8>194: 56 3<6:;=4 >7? >;504751=>54: :6=;.475 56 3<6H4 504 >@4 68 504 H1=51. 50>5 204 I>2 .176< >5 504 51.4 68 17=1:475 ==6<:17@ 56 01. B650 >==;24: >7: H1=51. B417@ 504 <49>51H42 >7: 741@0B6;<2 0>:96H4>88>1<>7:0>H4.><<14:72;=0=1<=;.25>7=42 504 68847=42 >994@4: 17 504 =0><@4 20445 :6 765 >55<>=5 >@>1725 504 >==;24: ==6<:17@9? 3<>?2 56 >996I 504 34515167 94><74: 1@0 6;<5 6H4<7.475 94>:4<6336242504B>1934515167 - 5 - ( 0>H4@1H47.?>7G16;2=6721:4<>5167B65067 504 2;B.1221672 .>:4 B? 504 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51H43><514226>92634<;24:5044751<4=0><@420445 .>54<1>92 J 2=6;9:B4@>504<4:8<6.504<4=6<:21512765 17:123;5450>5504345151674<>7:504=6.39>17>75H1=51. ><4 <49>51H42 >7: 504? B650 ><4 <421:17@ 56@4504< 17 >1:6::1 H199>@4 5 12 >926 765 17 :123;54 50>5 504? B650 I4<4 17 96H4 >7: 504 H1=51. ;24: 56 H1215 504 06;24 68 >==;24: 8<4L;4759? >7: 504<4>854< 504? 0>: 30?21=>9 <49>5167201386<>34<16:68674?4><:;4565042>.4504 H1=51.B4@65547>=019:04<4>854<504=6.39>175=>.456 B4<4@1254<4:B?504H1=51.2<1@059?361754:6;5B?504 94><74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 4G=435 39>=17@ 504 =4<5181=>54 122;4: B? 504 2=0669 4>:.>254< 76 6504< >;504751=>54: :6=;.475 12 39>=4: B? 504 3<624=;5167 56 3<6H4504>@468504H1=51.50>5204I>2.176<>550451.4 6850417=1:475%;<504<504.6504<68504H1=51.7>.49? ;<@>..>) 6#>2>H><>K123<42475B486<450126;<5>7: - 6 - 2;B.152 50>5 504 H1=51. >7: >==;24: ><4 .><<14: 4>=0 6504< >7: .125>A479? =6.39>175 I>2 96:@4: >@>1725 504 >==;24:B486<4504691=4>7:504H1=51.I>2.>K6<>5504 51.46817=1:475 ;=0B417@50436215167504H4<>=15?68 50425>54.47568504H1=51.>7:6504<I15742242>7:>926 504@47;174742268504>@4=4<5181=>540>256B454254:17> :45>194: 5<1>9 199 5047 504 =;256:1>9 17=><=4<>5167 68 504 345151674<1276574=422><?47=4I1506;54G3<42217@>7? 631716767504.4<15268504=>242;881=456069:50>5504 345151674< .>? B4 479><@4: 67 B>19 ==6<:17@9? 504 86996I17@ 04345151671204345151674<12:1<4=54:56 B4 479><@4: 67 B>19 17 396 J C% 6 3= F 347:17@ B486<4 504 6;<5 68 ::15167>9 125<1=5 >7: 4221672 *;:@4 >1=0;< 215517@ >5 17:0>7;< ><1217@ 6;5 68 <1.4 6 <4@1254<4: B? ;551 691=4 5>5167 86< 504 68847=42 3;7120>B94 ;7:4< 4=51672 ("$ ("$ ".$ &"$ 68 # & >7: - 7 - 4=51672 >7: ( 68 504 =5 2;BK4=5 56 504 86996I17@=67:151672 >$45151674<20>994G4=;54>34<267>9B67:86< >2;.68 2 I1505I62;<4514286< 504 91A42;. 56 504 2>5128>=5167 68 504 K;<12:1=5167>96;<5, B$04345151674<20>99>334><<4@;9><9?67>99 504 :>542 68 04><17@ B486<4 504 <1>9 6;<5 ;79422504<1>96;<54G4.352012>334><>7=4 86<H>91:<4>2672, =$ 04 345151674< 20>99 765 :1<4=59? 6< 17:1<4=59? 50<4>547 6< 5>.34< I150 504 3<624=;5167I15742242, :$ 04 345151674< 20>99 765 17H69H4 17 21.19>< 68847=42178;5;<4, 4$ 04 345151674< 20>99 765 94>H4 504 K;<12:1=5167 68 504 <1>9 6;<5 I1506;5 34<.122167 68 504 2>1: 6;<5 ;7519 504 =>24 <4@1254<4:>@>172501.12:123624:688 8$ 04 345151674< 20>99 .><A 012 >5547:>7=4 B486<4 504 5>5167 6;24 881=4<;551 691=4 5>5167 67 81<25 ;7:>? 68 4H4<? .6750 - 8 - B45I447 >. >7: 3. 5199 504 =>24 <4@1254<4: >@>1725 01. 12 :123624: 688 B486<4504<1>96;<5 ,) #( ) 1256 96 *