- 1 - !"!# $%" ! &%' !" # "" $ # "$ %& ' "( ) (( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( ( ) ( "( " ) "" * "" "" !" # " &+ , " )$ ) " & * & & " ) & " , " , , - - 3 - -& % ) "" & ) & " ) & & " % $ & & " ) " ) & & & " & ) .-" " /01234040560170839:;937369<645133=06>45134 <1093 4/3 0?2@>639 5A93A 9<439 , 2<1139 06 5 , , :; 4/3 3605A 0B08 -@9>3 <69 -& 5@A4 069/<6@A <69 C5613D@3648; 45 <885E 4/3 <2280C<405670839:;234040563A 937369<64545<CC3244/3 EA0443614<43?36457937369<645 /32<A4031454/32A5C33906>11/<88:3A373AA39 45<123A4/30A14<4@1:375A34/3A0<85@A4<128<064077<69 937369<641 - 4 - ( &<C41574/3C<13<A3<1@693A 1@04 C<?3 45 :3 70839 :; 4/3 28<064077 <><0614 4/3 937369<641 75A 4/3 A38037 57 93C8<A<4056 <69 06 4/3 <843A6<40B3074/35@A4/58914/<44/3A301652<A40405645 2<11 < 93CA33 75A 2<A404056 :; 2<A40405606> 4/3 2A523A4031 <6993C8<A06>4/328<06407745:33640483945< 4/1/<A306 C/39@83 <69 2A523A4031 <69 54/3A C5613D@3640<8 A380371 /3 1@04 E<1 70839 06 4/3 ;3<A , /3 937369<641 E3A3 65407039 :; 011@<6C3 57 1@??561 56 , , 37369<64 5 E<1 13AB39 56 ,, , <69455=40?3457083EA0443614<43?364:@4/5E3B3A7<0839 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 <69 4/3 1<?3 E<1 4<=36 <1 608 4 01 C56436939 :; 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 937369<64 5 4/<4 06 B03E 57 65670806> 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?3644/3?<443AC<?345:325143975A3B0936C357 4/3 28<064077 4 4/<4 14<>3 15?3 57 4/3 937369<641 70839 - 5 - <2280C<40561 45 23A?04 4/3? 45 7083 EA04436 14<43?3641 <856>E04/4/3EA0443614<43?3641E/0C/455E<15225139 :;4/328<064077/383<A639A0<8-@9>3<885E394/3EA04436 14<43?364 57 937369<64 5 45 :3 4<=36 56 A3C5A9 :; 5A93A 9<439 * ,F /3A3<743A 011@31 C<?3 45 :3 7A<?3956,, , ,401C56436939:;83<A639C5@6138 75A937369<6454/<4E/364/3?<443AE<113495E675A <99A31106> 706<8 <A>@?3641 4/3 2A31364 937369<64 5 70839<6<2280C<405606 5*@693AA93A@83, A3<9E04/3C4056574/3593570B08"A5C39@A345134 <10934/35A93A574/35@A44<=06>4/3EA0443614<43?364 <1 608 <69 23A?04 937369<64 5 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364/3EA0443614<43?364E<1<663G39<856>E04/ 4/3 <2280C<4056 /3 <2280C<4056 70839 :; 937369<64 5 E<1 13A05@18; 5:H3C439 45 :; 4/3 28<064077 256 C561093A<405657 4/3 1<09 <2280C<4056 56 ?3A041 4/3 1<?3 C<?3 45 :3 901?01139 :; 4/3 0?2@>639 5A93A 9<439 , 4014/015A93AE/0C/01D@31405639:375A34/01 5@A4 - 6 - 401<B3/3?364C5643640565783<A639C5@6138 75A937369<6454/<44/30?2@>6395A93A2<1139:;4/3 83<A639 A0<8 -@9>3 01 CA;240C 3AA5635@1 <69 C564A<A; 45 4/3?<43A0<8156A3C5A9<2<A47A5?:306>0883><836C3/3 133=145134<10934/31<095A93A401<815C56436939:; 4/383<A639C5@61384/<44/3<22A5<C/574/383<A639A0<8 -@9>3 01 A0>09 <69 239<640C 45E<A91 4/3 <2280C<4056 /3 1<?35@>/445/<B3:336C561093A3983603648;C561093A06> 4/3 7<C4 4/<4 4/3 1@04 01 70839 75A 2<A404056 <69 4/<4 4/3 93736C3 57 4/3 937369<641 654 :306> 4/3A3 /3 E5@89 654 /<B32A523A 1<;06 4/3?<443A E04/5@4<6;283<906>1 3 <815 C56436939 4/<4 4/3 0?2@>639 5A93A 01 654 H@14070<:83 75A4/3A3<156 4/<4 563 57 4/3937369<641 03 937369<64 5 /<9<815 70839 <6 <2280C<4056<4 < :38<439 14<>3<69 4/3 1<?3 C<?3 45 :3 <CC32439 :; 0?25106> C514 6 4/3 2A31364 C<13 <815 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 5@>/4 45 /<B3 :336 <CC32439 :; 0?25106> C3A4<06 C5141 4 01 7@A4/3A C56436939 :; 83<A639 C5@6138 4/<4 4/3 A0<8 -@9>3 E<1 13A05@18; 2A3H@90C39 56 4/3 C5@64 57 938<; 06 70806> 4/3 - 7 - EA04436 14<43?364 :; 937369<64 5 3 <815 C56436939 4/<4 ?3A3 938<; E5@89 654 4<=3 <E<; 4/3 A0>/41 57 4/3 2<A4;6<?38;937369<645452@475A4//0114<69<69 93736C3<69C5643144/3?<443A56?3A041 * 4 01 <815 C56436939 4/<4 4/3 938<; E<1 5CC<105639 9@3 45 4/3 F 2<693?0C 104@<4056 <69 4/3C5@613875A937369<645654/<B06>1/5E69080>36C3 0670806>4/3EA0443614<43?364E388E04/0640?337369<64 5 E04/ 4/3 /382 57 4/3 C/<6>39 8<E;3A /<1 70839 4/3 2A31364 <2280C<4056 75A <CC324<6C3 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364E/0C/07<CC32439:;0?25106>C514E5@89654 C<@13<6;/<A91/025A06C56B36036C3454/328<0640775A<6; 2<A4;4 01 <815 B3/3?3648; C56436939 4/<44/32A5B01056 @693AA93A@83574/3"01568;90A3C45A;<69654 ?<69<45A; /3 1<?3 C5@89 /<B3 :336 <CC32439 :; 4/3 A0<8 -@9>3 /3 83<A639 C5@6138 /<1 A38039 @256 4/A33 H@9>?3641 57 4/3 56.:83 23G 5@A4 06 4/3 C<131 57 !"! - 8 - # "! !$ %% &'(( )*+ ), &- , <69 +.! % /0+ #*), 11 /3A375A3 56 4/313 >A5@691 /3 C56436939 4/<4 4/3 A3H3C4056 57 4/3 <2280C<4056 70839 :; 937369<64 54523A?04/0?4570834/3EA0443614<43?36401/0>/8; 3AA5635@1 0883><8 <69 <A:04A<A; <69 4/3 1<?3 A3D@0A31 45 :3134<1093<694/3EA0443614<43?36457937369<645 :3<CC3243907A3D@0A39:;0?25106>C514 83<A639 C5@6138 <223<A06> 75A 4/3 28<064077B3/3?3648;C564369394/<44/3A301650883><804;5A 23AB3A104; 06 4/3 0?2@>639 5A93A 2<1139 :; 4/3 83<A639 A0<8 -@9>3 <1 4/3 A0<8 5@A4 /<1 <22A3C0<439 4/3 C5643640561 57 4/3 2<A4031 A38039 @256 4/3 H@9>?3641 57 4/3 56.:83 23G 5@A4 <69 /<1 C<43>5A0C<88; C5?3 45 < C56C8@1056 4/<4 4/3A3 01 365A?5@1 <?5@64 57 938<; <69 /<1 A0>/48; A3H3C439 4/3 <2280C<4056 3<A639 C5@6138 1@14<061 4/3 0?2@>639 5A93A <69 C56436939 4/<4 4/3 937369<64 5 /<1 654 1/5E6 9080>36C3 65A /<1 /3 - 9 - :54/3A39 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 4 < 8<43A 25064 E/36 937369<64 5 B364@A39 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 E/0C/ C<?3 45 :3 <885E39 56 0?25106> C5141 B36 <4 4/<4 14<>3 /<9 4/01 937369<64 5 70839 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 ?<; :3 4/3 1<?3 C5@89 /<B3 :336 <885E39 <69 654 5:H3C439 45 :@4 937369<64 5 /<B06> =324 D@034 75A ?5A3 4/<6 30>/4 ;3<A1 /<B06> 70839 4/3 <2280C<4056 56 , , <743A <CC324<6C3 57 6540C3 06 4/3;3<A ,0401<6365A?5@1<?5@6457938<; F /3 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 4/3 28<064077 /<1 A38039 @256 < H@9>?364 57 4/3 56.:83 23G 5@A4 06 ! 2 *& 0 3& & !4 & !I#1(,--5J061@225A457/01C<134 01 <815 C56436939 :; 4/3 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 4/3 28<064077 4/<43B36064/3<2280C<405670839:;937369<6454/3A3 <A365>559>A5@6915AC5>364A3<15615A<6;3G28<6<4056 E04/ A3><A9 45 938<; 5A 75A 4/<4 ?<443A <6; 4A@4/ 06 4/3 1<09 3G28<6<4056 <69 65 95C@?364<A; 3B0936C3 01 2A59@C39451@:14<640<434/31<?3/3A375A34/3A3<1561 - 10 - <110>639<A3<815B<>@3E/0C/95654C<8875A0643A73A36C3 57 4/3 E388A3<15639 5A93A 2<1139 :; 4/3 A0<8 5@A4 CC5A906>8;/3133=1901?011<8574/0123404056 , /<B3 /3<A9 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 4/3 234040563A 937369<64 5 <69 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 4/3 A3125693645 28<064077 /32506414/<4<A01375AC561093A<4056<A3 0$ )/34/3A 4/3A3 01 <6; 0883><804; 5A 23AB3A104; 06 4/3 5A93A 2<1139 :; 4/3 83<A639 A0<8 -@9>3 C<8806> 75A 0643A73A36C3 :; 4/01 5@A4 @693A A40C83 *574/3561404@405657690<K 00$ )/<45A93AK 22<A3648; 04 01 1336 4/<4 4/3A3 01 65 9012@43 E04/A3><A9454/37<C41574/31@04/<B06>:33670839064/3 ;3<A , /3 937369<641 E3A3 13AB39 E04/ 6540C3 37369<64 5 <223<A39 :375A3 4/3 5@A4 4/A5@>/ /01 C5@6138 56 ,, , /3A375A3 04 01 1336 4/<4 937369<645E<1B3A;?@C/<E<A3574/31@04<13<A8; - 11 - <1 ,, , E/36 /3 <223<A39 :375A3 4/3 5@A4 4/A5@>/ /01 C5@6138 4 01 <815 654 06 9012@43 4/<4 4/3 937369<645 70839<EA0443614<43?364064/3;3<A ,F /5@>/4/3EA0443614<43?36470839:;937369<645 E<1 <815 :<AA39 :; 4/3 40?3 70G39 @693A 4/3 593 57 0B08 "A5C39@A3 /5E3B3A /3 70839 <2280C<40561 45 C569563 4/3 938<;<6923A?04/0?457083EA0443614<43?3644/31<?3 E<1C5695639<694/3EA0443614<43?364E<1<CC32439:; 4/3 83<A639 A0<8 -@9>3 :; 0?25106> C514 57 1,,, 3<C/ ( 6 4/3 54/3A /<69 937369<64 5 =324 D@034 E<4C/06>4/32A5C33906>19312043:306>A32A3136439:;< C5@6138 <69 70839 <6 <2280C<4056 75A C56956<4056 57 938<; <69 23A?011056 45 <CC324 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 56 , , E/0C/01?5A34/<630>/4;3<A17A5?4/39<43 57A3C3024571@??561<694/3=65E839>35770806>574/3 C<13401<815A383B<644565434/<47A5?4/39<435770806> 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 57 937369<64 5 E/0C/ E<1 <CC32439 06 ,F 011@31 E3A3 7A<?39 4/3 28<064077 /<1 - 12 - <99@C393B0936C3<69E<1CA5113G<?06394/3C56431406> 937369<641 /<B3 <99@C39 3B0936C3 <69 E3A3 CA511 3G<?0639 <69 4/3 ?<443A E<1 134 95E6 75A <99A31106> <A>@?3641564/3?<061@04/3?<06?<443AE<1251439 75A <99A31106> <A>@?3641 56 ,* , :@4 75A 563 A3<156 5A 4/3 <654/3A 4/3 937369<641 /<B3 :336 2A54A<C406> <69 9A<>>06> 56 4/3 2A5C33906>1 4 01 3G4A<C439 06 4/3 5A93A 57 4/3 83<A639 A0<8 -@9>3 4/<4 <8?5144/A33<69</<87;3<A1/<B32<1139106C34/39<43 57 4/3 1@04 :306> 251439 75A 706<8 <A>@?3641 312043 4/3 ?<443A :306> 251439 75A <A>@?3641 56 ,* , 937369<64 5 909 654 ?5B3 /01 804483 706>3A 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 5E3B3A 937369<64 5 ?<93 < :38<439 <443?24 56 , , 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364<69<6<2280C<405645A3C<884/35A93A574<=06> 4/3EA0443614<43?364 <1608 /3 83<A639A0<8 -@9>3 /<1 <9B3A439 45 <88 4/313 7<C41 <69 9<431 57 /3<A06> <69 901?011394/3<2280C<405657937369<645/359357 0B08"A5C39@A3C<?345:3<?36939<69<40?380?04E<1 - 13 - 70G39 75A 70806> 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 5E3B3A 4/3 2A5B015 23A?04439 4/3 5@A41 45 3G3AC013 901CA34056 45 <CC324 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 07 2A523A A3<1561 <69 9@3 9080>36C3011/5E6:;4/3937369<641/5@>/<40?380?04 E<12A31CA0:39:;4/3<?369?364E/0C/C<?306453773C4 7A5? ,,* ,, 4/3 56.:83 23G 5@A4 06 C<436< 57 H@9>?3641 /389 4/<4 4/3 1<09 <?369?364 E<1 654 ?<69<45A; :@4 04 E<1 90A3C45A; /3 E388 =65E6 <69 7<?5@1H@9>?364574/356.:83 23G5@A4064/3C<1357 #1@2A<$ 93<81 E04/ 4/3 70806> 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 /3 5@A4 /<1 :336 2A5B0939 4/3 901CA34056 45 2A565@6C3 5A 654 2A565@6C3 < H@9>?364 <><0614 4/3 937369<64 3B36 07 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 01 654 70839 4/3 5@A4 E5@89 C3A4<068; /<B3 4/3 901CA34056 45 304/3A <CC324 5A A3H3C4 < :38<439 EA0443614<43?364:<139560415E67<C41<694/3A3<1561 <110>639<69123C070CC<@131/5E675A4/3:38<43970806>57 4/3EA0443614<43?364 - 14 - 5?06>:<C=454/32A31364C<1356/<694/3 937369<64 5 E/5 E<1 B3A; ?@C/ <E<A3 57 4/3 =65E839>3574/31@04/<B06>3643A39<223<A<6C34/A5@>/ /01 C5@6138 56 ,, , <69 :306> <E<A3 57 4/3 7<C4 4/<4937369<645 708394/3EA0443614<43?364064/3;3<A ,F909654:54/3A4570834/3EA0443614<43?364<6;40?3 <13<A8;<125110:83A<4/3AE<043940884/38<14?5?3644088 4/3?<443AE<125143975A<A>@?3641/5@>/04E<1801439 56 ,* , 75A<A>@?3641564/3?<06?<443A/3909 654 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 5A <2280C<4056 :@4 70831 <6 <2280C<405656, , <743A4/A33;3<A1574/3?<443A :306> 801439 75A 706<8 <A>@?3641 <743A C56C8@1056 57 4A0<8 22<A3648; 04 01 1336 4/<4 04 /<1 :336 ?5A3 4/<6 30>/4 ;3<A1 106C3 4/3 A3C3024 57 1@??561 :; 937369<64 5 4/<4 4/3 2A31364 <2280C<4056 01 70839 45 <CC324 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364/356.:83 23G5@A4064/3C<1357 ! 2 *& #1@2A<$<4 2<A<>A<2/ 51 <69 /<1/389<1@693A - 15 - 16& ! " " # # $ %# # $ & $ 7 $'( " # # " & " " " # # " # # # "!" # # $ 1$ ( $ ) " * # # * + " #" - 16 - " # "$ , % # % # $-"+"! & .,)/01023043& 5436 7 1 822& 1&$$$ ( %## # ! $ ( " " 9 + + 9$ # ! # " #$: ! "" + %! " $ ( %#% # $-%! ! % ' # $ ( % - 17 - ;# # % #%#$< /3 56.:83 23G 5@A4 /<1 A38039 @256 4/3 H@9>?364 57 4/3 #1@2A<$ <69 3G4A<C439 4/3 2<A<>A<2/ 57 4/3 1<09 H@9>?364 "<A<>A<2/ 5 01 7@A4/3A 3G4A<C439 75A:3443A@693A14<6906> 81-& ! ! # ! " " # # $- ; ! # 3# " # 4 # - 1 " 4=< 401<815A383B<64453G4A<C42<A<>A<2/5*57 4/3H@9>?364E/0C/A3<91<1@693A 81'& - " + !!#:! ! # # ! ! - 18 - $( :! #" *# !! ; * # ! " " ! >$ " # % #$ ( :! # " $ ) ? $:" " ! + " ! " " !! ! ! # :! #$ " " @ # 4 43 " # " " " " ?%' $ $$1)$884 ). +! # " ? ! + % $ ! " + # " - 19 - " " + ! #$< * <B06> >563 4/A5@>/ 4/3 H@9>?3641 57 4/3 56.:83 23G5@A456E/0C/4/3A380<6C30128<C39:;4/3 83<A639 C5@61381 4/3 25064 4/<4 <A0131 <><06 01 E/34/3A 4/3 :38<439 <2280C<4056 70839 :; 937369<64 5 75A <CC324<6C3 57 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 9312043 /<B06> 4/3 =65E839>3 57 4/3 1@04 70839 06 4/3 ;3<A , <69 4/3A3 :306>652A523A3G28<6<40565AC56B06C06>C5>364A3<1561 5A 1<4017<C45A; 3G28<6<4056 75A 4/3 938<; E/34/3A 938<; C5@89:3<CC32439 6 ?; /@?:83 5206056 3B3A; C<13 E5@89 /<B3 45:34<=36564/37<C41<69C0AC@?14<6C31570415E66 4/32A31364C<1356/<69<22<A3648;937369<645/<1 183245B3A4/3?<443A)/34/3A04014/37<@84574/3C5@6138 5A937369<645/0?1387040175A937369<64545/<B3 A3<80L39<483<14E/36/3C/<6>39/01<9B5C<4307/3E<1 654 2A523A8; <9B0139 45 7083 4/3 EA04436 14<43?364 E388 E04/06 40?3 <1 2A31CA0:39 @693A 4/3 593 57 0B08 - 20 - "A5C39@A3 <69 3B36 07 /3 E<1 654 <:83 45 95 15 E04/06 < A3<156<:83 40?3 57 /<B06> @693A14559 4/<4 4/3A3 E<1 < 938<;0670806>4/3EA0443614<43?364<B06>654956315 04 E5@89 654 803 45 937369<64 5 45 C564369 4/<4 C514 C5@89:30?2513975A<CC324<6C3574/3EA0443614<43?364 /01B3A;436936C;574/35@A410?25106>C51445<CC324 EA04436 14<43?364 <><06 1/5@89 :3 A3C561093A39 :; 4/3 A0<85@A41<690>/5@A4<12<;?36457C514E5@89654 A3693AH@140C3454/354/3A109375A4/3365A?5@1<?5@64 57938<;<8A3<9;C<@139 1E3/<B313360613B3A<8C<131 >363A<40561 2<1139 :; 83><8 A32A31364<40B31 C5?3 56 A3C5A9 :@4 14088 4/3 7A@041 57 4/3 93CA33 <A3 654 1336 5A 36H5;39:;4/32<A4031/3A375A34/35@A41E088/<B345 4<=3</<A9143206C@A:06>1@C/:38<439<22A5<C/31?<93 :; 304/3A 57 4/3 2<A4031 06 2A54A<C406> <69 2A5856>06> 2A5C33906>1 83<906> 45 /@>3 236936C; <69 :<C=85> 57 C<131 &@A4/3A 04 01 1336 4/<4 <1 <:158@438; 65 2A523A 3G28<6<4056 01 2A5B0939 06 4/3 <7709<B04 75A 4/3 938<; 3GC32475A<?3A314<43?36457652A523A<9B0C3>0B36:; - 21 - 4/3C5@6138<69F<1<63GC@134/31<?3C<6654 :3<CC32439<104017<A734C/39693A4/3C0AC@?14<6C31 956547069<6;>559>A5@695AC5>364A3<15645<CC324 4/3 C5643640561 57 4/3 83<A639 C5@6138 75A 234040563A 937369<64 5 <815 95 654 7069 <6; 23AB3A104; 5A 0883><804; 06 4/3 E388A3<15639 5A93A 2<1139 :;4/383<A639A0<8-@9>3 F CC5A906>8;2<114/375885E06> "340405601 () & !' " " - 014585 ,