- 1 - !"#"$ %&# # & ' '()* ' )) + !"##" $ % & ' ( ( !)!'# ) ( *!)!# $ % ( '+ & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !) ( %,) ( & #"#!% ( '##!& ( ( ( (( ",%&%& -, ''! '!' %& ! !'%& %!& ( *# .* ( ( / 01234515167128194:;7:4<4=5167!)68# 56 >;?20 504 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504 345151674<?==;24: 6 17 6#"#! ?<1217@ 6;5 68 <1A4 6'##!<4@1254<4:BC06<?3;<691=45?516786<504 68847=42 3;7120?B94 ;7:4< 4=5167 ",%&%A& ''!%& -, %=& ! !'%& <4?: D150 4=5167 %!& 68 # 3<424759C 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68 ::15167?9 125<1=5 ?7: 4221672;:@4215517@?506<?3;< # 04 8?=5;?9 A?5<1E 68 504 =?24 12 50?5 504 <42367:475 6 96:@4: 504 =6A39?175 B486<4 504 <42367:4756'*3691=4?994@17@50?520412504<421:475 - 3 - 68 4A?7;<; F199?@4 06<?3;< ?9;G ?7: 204 0?: # =019:<47 74 C4?< 3<16< 56 504 17=1:475 504 06;24 68 ?==;24: 6' 0?: 215;?54: 17 8<675 68 04< 06;24 ?5 4A?7;<; F199?@4 ?7: 04 ;24: 56 F1215 04< 06;24 6==?2167?99C ?7: 4E3<4224: 50?5 04 8499 17 96F4 D150 04< 047 504 =6A39?17?75 <4H4=54: 012 3<6362?9 04 50<4?5474: 04< ?7: =67517;4: 56 F1215 04< 06;24 017@2 2566:50;267'-#,#!?5?B6;5#'##3AD047204 D?2 ?9674 17 04<06;24 ?==;24: 6' 4754<4:504 06;24 ?7: =6AA1554: 86<=1B94 24E;?9 1754<=6;<24 67 04< ?7: 861254: 9184 50<4?5 56 04< 765 56 :12=9624 504 2?A4 56 ?7C6743672;=050<4?5675042;B24>;475:?C?92604 F12154:?7:0?:24E;?9?=5D15004<?7:67=4?@?17861254: 9184 50<4?5 56 04< ?54< 504 =6A39?17?75 1786<A4: 504 2?A4 56 04< 0;2B?7: 2 2;=0 67 #,#! ?5 ?B6;5 #)##?A5040;2B?7:68504F1=51AF12154:50406;2468 ?==;24:6'?7:47>;1<4:?7:?:F124:01A7655617:;9@4 17 2;=0 ?=5 ?7: 765 56 F1215 012 06;24 ?7: =?A4 B?=G 6D4F4< 67 504 2?A4 :?C ?5 ?B6;5 ### ?A 504 - 4 - ?==;24:6'?7:504345151674<14?==;24:6=?A456 50406;2468=6A39?17?75*F1=51A?7:?B;24:04<?7:04< 0;2B?7:1781950C9?7@;?@4?7:?9266;5<?@4:04<A6:425C 2 2;=0 67 !#,#! 504 <42367:475 6 96:@4: 504 =6A39?175 ?@?1725 ?==;24: 62' ?7: B486<4 504 <42367:475 6' * 691=4 7 504 25<47@50 68 2?1: =6A39?175 ( =?A4 56 B4 <4@1254<4: 17 <1A4 6'##!86<504?86<4A4751674:68847=42?@?1725504 345151674< ?7: ?76504< ;B24>;4759C <42367:475 6' * 3691=4 ?854< =67:;=517@ ?7 17F4251@?5167 9?1: =0?<@4*20445 ?@?1725504345151674<?7:?76504<86<504?86<4A4751674: 68847=42 BC ?<<?C17@ 504 345151674< ?2 ?==;24: 6 ?7: 67504<4=413568504=0?<@4*2044550494?<74:?@125<?54 566G =6@71I?7=4 68 504 68847=42 @@<14F4: BC 504 2?A4 504 345151674< 3<484<<4: 5012 34515167 56 >;?20 504 3<6=44:17@2?@?172501A # 4?<:50494?<74:=6;724986<504345151674<26 ?926 504 94?<74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7A475 94?:4< 86< - 5 - <42367:475 6'*5?54 423154 24<F1=4 68 7651=4 <42367:4756204<4A?174:?B2475 #, 3?<5 8<6A ;<@17@ 24F4<?9 =6754751672 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1A?<19C =6754754: 50?5 504 345151674< * ?==;24: 6 D?2 741504< 3?<51=13?54: 17 504 17=1:475 76< 3<42475 ?5 504 2=474 68 6==;<<47=4 ?2 67 #,#!?2?994@4:17504=6A39?175==6<:17@5604< 504345151674<D?2?547@?9;<;217=40412D6<G17@?2? 6*6<:17?56< 68 ?205<650?7? ?<120?: ?5 47@?9;<; 6 2;B25?751?54 504 2?1: ?234=5 204 39?=4: 774E;<4* 14 504 =4<5181=?54 122;4: BC 504 6*6<:17?56< 68 504 ?205650?7? ?<120?: 504 ?5547:?7=4 <4@1254< 504 30656@<?302 ?7: 504 8665?@42 ?967@ D150 504 347 :<1F4C39?=17@<491?7=4675042?A42042;BA15250?5? 8?924 =6A39?175 0?2 B447 861254: ?@?1725 504 345151674<?==;24: 6 :;4 56 369151=?9 <1F?9<C ?7: F47@4?7=4 217=4 04 12 ?88191?54: D150 0?<?51C? ?7?5? ?<5C?7:676504<0?7:504=6A39?17?7512504D6<G4<68 - 6 - ?5167?9 67@<422 ?<5C ==6<:17@9C 204 3<?C2 56 ?996D 50434515167 #! 94?<74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7A475 94?:4< F404A4759C 633624: 504 34515167 ?7: 2;BA1554: 50?5 3<424759C =0?<@4*20445 0?2 B447 8194: ?7: - 56 '# ?<4 504 4C4D157422 56 504 17=1:475 04C 0?F4 =94?<9C 25?54:5043<4247=4685012345151674<67504?994@4:2365 68 17=1:475 67 #,#! ?7: 504 A?54<1?92 ?<4 39?=4: ?@?1725 5012 345151674< ==6<:17@9C 3<?C2 56 :12A12250434515167 #" 0?F4@1F47AC?7E16;2=6721:4<?5167B65067 504 2;BA122167 A?:4 BC 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51F4 3?<5142 ?7: ?926 34<;24: 504 =0?<@4*20445 A?54<1?92 #- 2 =6;9: B4 2447 8<6A 504 =6A39?175 504 3<1A?<C ?994@?5167 A?:4 ?@?1725 ?==;24: 6' 50?5 04 =6AA1554:24E;?91754<=6;<24D150504F1=51A*=6A39?17?75 67 24F4<?9 6==?21672 BC 8612517@ 9184 50<4?5 56 04< 217=4 - 7 - 01206;2412215;?54:178<6756804<06;2404<4?854<504 2?1:17=1:475D?21786<A4:BC504F1=51A5604<0;2B?7: 2 2;=0 04< 0;2B?7: >;4251674: 504 2?A4 D150 ?==;24: 6' 04<4?854< ?==;24: 6' ?967@ D150 5012 345151674< F12154: 504 06;24 ?7: A?70?7:94: 504 F1=51A ?7: 04< 0;2B?7:BC?B;217@504A1781950C9?7@;?@4 734<;2?968 504 25?54A475 68 2- 56 '# D06 ?<4 =9?1A2 56 B4 4C4D15742242 56 504 17=1:475 5012 345151674< 0?: ?926 3?<51=13?54:1750417=1:4756D4F4<94?<74:=6;724986< 504345151674<39?=4:=4<5181=?54122;4:BC6746@420504 6*6<:17?56<68?205<650?7??<120?:?5?7@?96<4:?54: #,##! D01=0 <4F4?92 50?5 504 345151674< B417@ 504 6*6<:17?56<D6<G17@175042?1:?<120?:D?23<42475?5 ?7@?96<4 8<6A '-#,#! 5199 #,#! 04 ?5547:?7=4 <4@1254< ?926 :12=96242 50?5 504 345151674< D?2 17 504 ?<120?: 67 50624 :?C2 4F4<5049422 504 8665?@42 :?54: '#,#! ?7: #,#! ?926 :431=52 50?5 504 345151674< D?2 ?5 ?205<650?7? ?<120?: ?7@?96<4 67 50?5 :?C 04 3<4247=4 68 504 345151674< 17 - 8 - 5048665?@42?<439?=4:?967@D150504347:<1F4?7: 504 6504< :6=;A4752 ?<4 765 24<16;29C :123;54: BC 504 94?<74: 1@0 6;<5 6F4<7A475 94?:4< 7 =?<48;9 68 50424 :6=;A4752 15 12 6BF16;2 50?5 504 345151674< =?7765 B4 3<42475 ?5 5D6 39?=42 ?5 ? 51A4 14 67 #,#! 6<46F4<504?994@?51672A?:4?@?1725504345151674<?<4 6A71B;2?994@?516724F4717504=6A39?175?7:?92617504 25?54A4752 68 ?994@4: 4C4D157422 56 504 17=1:475 04 25?54A475 68 504 ?994@4: 4C4D157422 <4=6<:4: ?854< 9?324 68!:?C28<6A504:?5468<4@125<?516768(::15167?99C 504<4 12 ? :49?C 68 :?C2 17 96:@17@ 504 =6A39?175 BC <42367:475 6 ==6<:17@ 56 04< 504 81<25 17=1:475 D?2 6==;<<4:67'-#,#!?7:504=6A39?175D?296:@4:67 !#,#!72;=0=1<=;A25?7=42?:6;B5?<124217504 F4<2167 68 504 =6A39?17?75 ?7: ?926 17 504 25?54A4752 68 ?994@4:4C4D157422 #) 5 12 76D D499 245594: 50?5 =67517;?5167 68 504 =<1A17?93<6=44:17@2?@?1725?7C34<26767504B?21268? 8<1F696;26<F4E?516;2=6A39?1751226A45017@F4<C24<16;2 - 9 - 0?5D6;9:5?<71205041A?@46850434<267?@?1725D06A 8?9248<1F696;2?7:F4E?516;2?994@?51672?<494F494:04 67JB9434E6;<517504=?2468 <436<54: 17 049: 50?5 D0474F4< ?7 ?==;24: =6A42 B486<4 504 6;<5 17F6G17@41504<5041704<47536D4<2;7:4<4=5167,)68 < 6< 4E5<?6<:17?<C H;<12:1=5167 ;7:4< <51=94 " 68 =672515;5167 56 @45 504 ( 6< =<1A17?9 3<6=44:17@2 >;?204: 4224751?99C 67 504 @<6;7: 50?5 2;=0 3<6=44:17@2 ?<4A?7184259C8<1F696;26<F4E?516;26<172515;54:D150504 ;954<16< A651F4 86< D<4?G17@ F47@4?7=4 5047 17 2;=0 =1<=;A25?7=46;<56D42?:;5C56966G1756504(D150 =?<4?7:?915594A6<4=96249C5D199765B4H;25476;@086< 504 6;<5 56 966G 1756 504 ?F4<A4752 A?:4 17 504 (=6A39?175 ?9674 86< 504 3;<3624 68 ?2=4<5?1717@ D04504< 504 74=422?<C 17@<4:14752 56 =672515;54 504 ?994@4: 68847=4 ?<4 :12=9624: 6< 765 7 504 6504< 0?7: 5046;<56D42?:;5C56966G1756A?7C6504<?5547:17@ =1<=;A25?7=4 4A4<@17@ 8<6A 504 <4=6<: 68 504 =?24 6F4< - 10 - ?7: ?B6F4 504 ?F4<A4752 ?7: 18 744: B4 D150 :;4 =?<4 ?7: =1<=;A234=5167 5<C 56 <4?: 17 B45D447 504 91742 04 6;<5D01944E4<=1217@152H;<12:1=5167;7:4<4=5167,)68 <6<<51=94"68672515;5167744:765<425<1=5152498 679C5650425?@468?=?24B;5124A36D4<4:565?G41756 ? =6;75 504 6F4<?99 =1<=;A25?7=42 94?:17@ 56 504 17151?5167<4@125<?516768 504 =?24 ?2 D499 ?2504A?54<1?92 =6994=54:17504=6;<246817F4251@?5167 # 339C17@ 504 2?1: 3<17=13942 56 504 8?=52 ?7: =1<=;A25?7=42 68 504 =?24 ?A 68 504 =6721:4<4: F14D 50?5504(<4@1254<4:?@?1725504345151674<?==;24:6 B?24: 67 504 =6A39?175 12 8<1F696;2 F4E?516;2 ?7: 504 2?A4 12 <4@1254<4: D150 ?7 ;954<16< A651F4 04 4751<4 ?994@?5167A?:417504=0?<@420445A?54<1?92671528?=4 F?9;4?926:642765=672515;54?7C68847=4217504=0?<@4 20445 ?@?1725 504 345151674< 47=4 17 AC =6721:4<4: F14D 504 =67517;?5167 68 504 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504 345151674<?==;24: 6 12 ?B;24 68 3<6=422 68 6;<5 ==6<:17@9C3<6=44:563?2250486996D17@ - 11 - %?& 043451516712 %B& 04 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504 345151674<?==;24: 6 17 6#"#! ?<1217@ 6;5 68 <1A4 6'##! <4@1254<4: BC50406<?3;<691=45?516786<50468847=4 3;7120?B94 ;7:4< ",%&%A& -, ''! '!' %&!!'%&%!& (*#12 04<4BC>;?204: ,* '# ) # 1256'96